My hope for this essay is that you will come away with an understanding of how the American Government and the Religious institutions that were in fact a significant part of the Government in the late 19th century and early 20th century were able to systematically work toward the elimination of the Native Peoples culture, language and heritage. These schools were little more than indoctrination camps for the religious teaching of the evangelical Christian and Catholic religions. They provided increased funding and national spotlighting in their crusade to assimilate the Native Peoples into the American mainstream. That more money flowed into the church coffers than flowed into the schools that it was designed to support is an atrocity. One school, Haskell in Lawrence, KS was so under funded that in its first several years of existence, more than 20 Indian children died in the bitter plains winters because of inadequate heating.
I have been honored in meeting with some of those children that were taken from their homes in the early 20th century. They had realigned themselves with their tribes and had become elders of their communities. I listened with heartfelt gratitude that I was not born in the era when being an Indian meant you had no civil rights, you were a ward of the federal government and were consistently lied to, cheated and told that you were less human than the white person that was sent there to teach you how to become an American.
Many of you will be shocked, many will be remorseful and many more of you will want to know what can I do today to help mitigate this great injustice that was perpetuated upon an entire culture. The answer is simple, support Native American rights, write letters to the editor concerning Native American issues, tell you Congress people that you support the full accounting of the Native American trust account. Visit a reservation, talk to an Indian, and find out what needs they are lacking and ask them what you can do today to help them fulfill their needs.
“”””””””””””””””””””””More below the fold””””””””””””””””””””””
Crossposted at European Tribune and My Left Wing
Perhaps the most fundamental conclusion that emerges from boarding school histories is the profound complexity of their historical legacy for Indian people’s lives. The diversity among boarding school students in terms of age, personality, family situation, and cultural background created a range of experiences, attitudes, and responses. Boarding schools embodied both victimization and agency for Native people, and they served as sites of both cultural loss and cultural persistence. These institutions, intended to assimilate Native people into mainstream society and eradicate Native cultures, became integral components of American Indian identities and eventually fueled the drive for political and cultural self-determination in the late twentieth century.
One must first understand that the boarding schools in my estimation, based upon the research that I have done, is this: these schools were designed with one purpose, the cultural, psychological and intellectual waging of war upon Native students. This war had one end, to achieve the enculturation of Native children into the American mainstream. In effect turn them into Americans. How this change started was first to take these children from their families and place them into the boarding schools. Upon arrival this is what happened.
The children were met by school administrators and teachers and told this is your new name. Then they were taken to have their hair cut, their clothing removed and in many cases, subjected to delousing and physical examinations that were dehumanizing to say the least. Most native cultures adhered to a highly developed sense of hygiene. Their entire diet and concept of time and spatial relationships were then dissolved and they were told this is how you will live. Their language was suppressed, if spoken aloud they were punished severely for speaking it. They were subjected to a militaristic regime that place English, Christianity and the ritualistic use of American cultural practices to further them into a place of Patriotism and Citizenship. For many they were indoctrinated into the narrow gender roles provided by the Fundamentalist of the time. Manual labor and Domestic skills were the primary educational opportunities provided by the schools. The sad fact for these children was this assault upon their culture caused bewilderment, estrangement, melancholy and hostility toward not only the school, but also their families, for having allowed this to happen to them.
That this institutional attack upon an entire race of people was allowed to happen in the US, to me is reprehensible. Taking into consideration the mores and values of the American culture in that time, I can understand how and why it was allowed to happen. I find today that many on the religious right, those Christians that feel that their way is the only way and therefore they are going to institutionalize their beliefs into our society by taking over our entire governmental structures, suggest to me that this injustice can occur again. These injustices will not only happen to the Native peoples, but any group of people that is deemed unworthy or not sufficiently pious enough in their subjugation to the Christian God. Listening to the stories of these elders and what happened to them and how they strived to keep and maintain their cultural identities were amazing and made me hope that I too could summon the courage and integrity to hold onto my own identity. Here are just a few of the ways these people who were under attack strived to protect themselves and their cultures.
Unfortunately many students acquiesced to the demands placed upon them, but for many they resisted the assaults upon their very character as a human being. Some used covert methods such as insulting names for members of the staff or administration. Others used letter writing to try and manipulate the authority of the school. Others continued to practice their traditions in secret through the use of stories, dances and gamesmanship. There were others who were more covert in their practices of resistance to this authority. They would start fights with other students, staff or faculty. Others would become more destructive, setting fires or destroying books, desks or even their clothing. On the other side, there were the parents who helped facilitate resistance, by not sending their children to the schools, or sending orphaned or less desirable children in place of their own children. There were constant complaints filed to Indian agents, school administrators about the quality of their children’s education and its lack of emphasis on tribal relationships and the cultural values of the tribes when they were allowed home visits.
Here is a link to a conversation between an Indian Commissioner and Chief Joseph concerning Indian Schools. There is also some wonderful information concerning Sitting Bull and the Dawes Commission
Here is a link that provides some positive influences of the Indian Schools, though I still find it less than positive that children were forcibly removed from their parents custody.
This essay brings to light not only despair but also hope. It is my fervent hope that the Christian right is not allowed to fulfill its call of Manifest Destiny or Dominion of the Earth dogma. For if they are able to capture the United States of America again, it will not only be the Native Peoples who are told they are going to be Assimilated, it will be all who do not hold dear to the Extreme rights Christian philosophy. I hope and pray that those who hold that the Constitution is a living breathing document, that its truths, that all men are created equal will continue to be upheld. I have read some truly interesting diaries over the last weeks and I for one have great fear for my country and many of the peoples who live in my country. The writing I have given you today, I hope gives you an idea of what can happen to human beings, when others believe their virtues are greater and have more significance than your own. That they can and will strip you of your own culture, your religion or non religion, your principles and values, to further their own cause in the name of their God is transparently available, when you see what happened to the Native Peoples of the America’s.
I was at a presentation by some Onondaga women a few weeks ago where the topic of boarding schools came up. There isn’t anyone on their reservation who hasn’t been affected by the legacy of boarding schools in some way, directly or indirectly. Because the kids at these schools were treated in such a cold, dysfunctional way, they learned to treat their own kids that way. The parents or grandparents grew up in these schools and passed the emotional problems on down to the kids. Only just in the last decade, they said, are they coming to terms with the emotional damage that was transmitted down through two or three generations.
though many of the elders that I had contact with, that came out of the schools, stated they too had some of those difficulties. It was with the support of members of the tribe that they were able to facilitate changes that mitigated the damage done by the schools. Not everyone was able to do that and I am sure many of these elders displayed behaviors that when looking back, they wish had not become a part of their lives.
…piece, ghostdancers way.
My grandmother was forced to attend a boarding school. When she returned home at age 17 in 1920, she vowed never again to speak English and, to my knowledge, she never did until the day she died in 1954.
Americans cannot hear too often about things like this.
ghostdancers way, do you know quite a bit about Haskell College? Every time I drive by there I wonder about it. Is it a good thing? A bad thing? A mixed blessing? What about the funding? Is it solvent or struggling? Would it be better for those kids to go to KU, if they could, or is Haskell important to them in cultural ways that KU could not supply? Just driving by, it seems like such an anachronism and my first instinct is to think that a college for Native Americans shouldn’t even have to exist, but maybe I’m wrong about that?
You may have heard me say that my son goes to KU. I’ve asked him about whether or not KU and Haskell mix and he doesn’t seem to think they do much at all. When I drive east of Mass St., Lawrence looks like a segregated town, much like KC, Mo. is. Is that true, in your experience, or do you think that minority populations are more mixed throughout than I think they are?
Apologies for deluging you with questions. Answer one or all or none! I’m just always so curious about Haskell.
has come a long long way from its earliest history.
Haskell Indian
Haskell archive
These are just a few links that might help you understand the history of Haskell.
I know several people who are graduates of Haskell and someone I used to work with is also a member of the advisory board for Haskell, a very wise old indian who has taught me significantly about what it means to be a Indian.
Thanks gdw. I’ll be reading your links.
My grandmother (an Omaha and direct descendant of Chief Big Elk) was sent to Haskell as a girl. I heard first hand some of the very same things you are posting about here. I sure never thought I’d see it diaried about on Booman Tribune!
-Alan
Well, what about that teen who’s been packed off to de-gaying camp? Some white American kids are already experiencing this.
I was thinking about this, too. Makes my heart hurt.
if you see this tactic that the christian right uses to indoctrinate those who’s beliefs are in conflict with their own, then you can well see they are not above doing this to others who are not that far out of their so called mainstream.
The conflict between the beliefs these schools instill in their students and what happens in their daily lives sometimes creates a tremendous amount of pain and misery.
It’s bad enough when a nice Christian girl we’ll call Madison, well-schooled as to the hellbound sinfulness of premarital fornication but kept woefully ignorant of the functioning of her own body, becomes pregnant at 16.
But it’s hell on earth when her own parents–who have relied on Sunday school and abstinence-only sex ed to keep their precious daughter “pure”–find out, and flatly inform her that she’s going to have an abortion. No ifs, ands or buts. Call the clinic.
These brazen hypocrites have spent years making double-damned sure that this girl believes unquestioningly that “abortion is murder.” And now, when she’s already afraid that God might not even forgive her for having sex before marriage, mom and dad tell her that she has to kill her baby. (Well, to tell the absolute truth, in a good many cases it’s only mom, because it’s amazing how many lies of omission are told in good Christian homes.)
Mom, already on the verge of a full-blown anxiety attack in her fear that someone will find out, is absolutely traumatized when, after speaking with her daughter in private, our counselor deliver even more bad news: “pro-choice” means just what it says, and we provide abortion care only to women who want it. Since Madison clearly states that she definitely doesn’t want an abortion, she’s not going to have one–not at our clinic, and not at anybody else’s.
Upright Christian ladies invariably feel angry and defrauded when we “abortionists” don’t live up to their expectations: “Well, you’ll just have to talk her into it! Isn’t that what y’all do?”
As if we could undo 15 years of rockribbed fundamentalist indoctrination in 15 minutes–or would, even if we could. As one of our counselors told a furious East Texas cheerleader mom (yes, that’s what we call them) only a few months ago, “I have to hand it to you, ma’am, you’re just a whole lot better at brainwashing than we are.”
But there have been times when I’ve wept for the chidren–both of them.
Good Morning America covered this story this morning. It’s currently their “headline” story.
http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/
so much I want to share…
Yesterday I recieved the packet from the Southern Poverty Law Center about our schools and what the Right want to do with them. How hate crimes are committed mostly in the schools due to race, disability, religion and sexuality.
I will support Native American rights. I will support human rights. Disability rights.
It’s all about human beings. Not human doings.
Human carings… wouldn’t that be great if that’s what we could be? Human carings.
Thank you for this diary Ghostdancer
These schools are the saddest schools I have ever seen. The Victory Academy in Ava,MO uses these programmed texts for everything. It is all rote learning. They sit in small classrooms and get “factory education”drummed into them. All memorization. They recently advertised for a math teacher. They do not demand a college education “because the materials do the teaching”. It must be incredibly boring to be a teacher there let alone be a student.
Another one I saw when I went to the church polling station in Seymour MO to vote for Kerry. I walked in the door and saw booths in a room,and,thinking they were polling booths,opened the door and went in. The women teachers were Menenites,the kids were sitting in these isolation booths working on workbooks. The walls of each were high enough to block any view of the child next to them. They wee sprawled across their desks,droopy,bored and learning how to be dumb. I said to the teachers,”This is the saddest classroom I have ever seen in my life.” They just smiled back at me. I went to another church that was the polling place.
and if these people get vouchers,then it is really all over for masses of students to get any kind of education except brainwashing.
the mind has a troubling excess capacity. It benefits them to have the mind closed up.
The economy overall is passing a threshold of efficiency such that it’s joining more backward cultural forces in needing the mind more constrained than liberated.
Society itself is becoming the people’s adversary. But I think the Native viewpoint on that would be roughly “do tell.”
and then I Will speak,
The kind of christian extremists who did this to Native American kids are same kind of people who now are trying to inflitrate and take over American society. They were the people in charge of the 1950’s world in which I was born and raised Liberating myself from that horrendous conditioning has taken me most of a lifetime.
I understand we’re not in a “War of Terror” anymore, but instead, it’s a war on “Islamic Extremists.”
Pretty effective way to divert attetion from the fact that all out war was declared some time back, by Christian Extremists right here at home. To underestimate the potential effects of this war on all of us, would be a tragic error.Keep telling it like it is, Ghostdancer..and so will I. Maybe if more of us who have been drectly affected by life under extremist christian rule spoke up, we’ll be believed.
But they weren’t Christian extremists. What you call “Christian extremism” used to be mainstream America. Also, these schools were run by a wide variety of Christian and Christian-influenced groups, including the Quakers, who had a very good track record otherwise of standing up for the rights and culture of Native Americans.
We ought to be pondering ways that the mainstream of American society today suppresses people who are different (be they Indians or non-Indians). The mainstream is a mishmash of pseudo-Christian piety and materialism and it is practiced by people on both the right and the left. When I think about fundie Christians sending gay teens off to boot camp, I also think about “progressive” Democrats who think that it’s OK to boot people off their property in the name of eminent domain for economic development, because everything can theoretically be boiled down to monetary value, including a home that somebody loves and doesn’t want to sell. This reasoning, too, was used against the Indians.
(What you call “Christian extremism” used to be mainstream America.}
Exactly. A mainstream America where men of one religious idealogy set all the rules, roles and norms for all, according to their interpretation of the Bible.
When any religion presuumes to control a society, that is religious extremism to me, and in this case, Christian Extremism. It was considered “mainstream America” back in my day and if they get their way, it will be “mainstream America” again. One in which those who embrace materialism and accumulation of power at the top will benefit greatly from.
And so we see the marriage of Christian extremisn and materialistic greed being consumated right in front of our eyes.
(Well, some eyes.)
I am new to this forum (indeed, the 1st time I have ever joined such a thing), and I have a few opinions to voice on this matter. I am a middle-aged white fellow, and so pardon me if I rattle on a bit (is digression the better part of middle-age?).
Recently (Jan. 2005), a dear friend attempted to convert me to Xtianity, but this had a reverse effect: I am now a professed skeptic, a humanist, and (possibly) an atheist. Being a left-brainer, I began researching not only the Bible, but the Declaration of Independence, the Bill of Rights, the Constitution. I have come to the conclusion that we are INDEED a secular government (my research and investigation is available upon request). A spirited discussion w/said friend about school prayer (I have no children, but I believe in doing the research) has uncovered a HUGE and invidious effort (no, not a conspiracy theorist, just facts, ‘Ipsa race loquitor’)to reconstruct (read: return to ‘Traditional values’, such as they were, geared solely for the white man) our precious nation as a ‘supposedly’ Xtian nation. I am afraid. The RR is slowly but surely trying to ‘convert’ our entire nation. People like Rushdooney, Falwell, Robertson, Barton (he’s the propagandist w/all these alleged ‘examples of Xtian persecution’), all of them w/fingers in the political pie, it is a frightening reality that we are at risk here, that life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are to be stripped away once the RR (religious right) are in control.
Discussion of these items is good, but some form of action is imperative. Non-violent civil dissent, a core value of this country, is, IMHO, becoming fast a necessity. I propose this: that every non-Xtian, from Native American to Hindi, Jew to Muslim, Atheist to Wiccan, everyone that can, all these people that are marginalized by Scalia and Rehnquist, that are impugned by the Moral Majority, that are victimized and persecuted by this religion that proclaims ‘Love thy neighbor’ and ‘God is just and loving’, I say we march. ‘Deeds, not words, shall speak me’ – John Fletcher, English dramatist (1579 – 1625)
insights and suggestions and welcome to Booman Tribune. I would suggest you get to know some of the more vocal members of our community by stopping by the Froggy Bottom Cafe and introducing yourself.
Again thanks for reading and commenting on my diary.
is one of the absolute low points in American history. It’s repercussions are felt today and ever forward sadly.
In regard to the link about Carlisle… there is a line that says:
“Athletics were also an important part of the education. Jim Thorpe, Chief Bender (a Philadelphia baseball pitcher), Louis Tewanima (1908 and 1912 Olympics star), and Coach Glenn “Pop” Warner were all Carlisle students.”
Let me correct the impression given here that Glenn “Pop” Warner was a student there. he was not. And the implication that he would therefore have been Native American. He was not.
Glenn Scoby “Pop” Warner was my 1st Cousin, three generations removed. It saddens me that he would have been involved in anyway in the atrocious behavior of our government… and European American forebears… towards Native American people’s. What I know of him in family research (and a couple letters between he and my grandfather) is that he was a good man. I do not know, beyond his role as football coach, what other role he may have played at Carlisle during his years there. Any information people more familiar with Carlisle and it’s history, or descendants of students there, can give me would be greatly appreciated… even if it tells a less than flattering tale about Cousin Pop.