Gonzales v Oregon: The Right to Die With Dignity
Newly confirmed US Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts begins his tenure today with one of the most controversial issues of the day: the right to die with dignity as determined by individual states. During his confirmation hearings, he posited himself as a person who had the skill necessary to sway the court from closely decided decisions in order to reach a clear consensus. This will be his first test. We will also have the opportunity to discover if he is, indeed, a justice who refuses to be a right-wing activist. The stakes in this case are enormous.
Here’s some background courtesy of the Christian Science Monitor:
WASHINGTON – Oregon is the only state in the nation where an individual diagnosed as terminally ill can ask a physician to prescribe a lethal dose of drugs.
Since 1997, when the Oregon Death With Dignity Act took effect, more than 200 individuals have requested medical help to end their lives.
Supporters of the law call the process physician-assisted death. Opponents, including former Attorney General John Ashcroft, view it as state- sanctioned killing, and say it is incompatible with a physician’s role as healer.
Wednesday, after four years of litigation, the issue arrives at the US Supreme Court where the justices must decide whether Mr. Ashcroft’s efforts to undermine the Oregon law were a valid exercise of federal power.
At issue is a clash between the power of the federal government to reinterpret and enforce the nation’s drug laws versus the power of the states to regulate the practice of medicine in ways supported by elected state officials and twice approved by Oregon voters.
[PLEASE WELCOME CATNIP as a new front-pager! She’ll do a fabulous job, and we are so honored that she agreed to take this on. She’ll also cover for BooMan on Sundays since the Boo has wanted a day off for a long time. — I didn’t want to post this welcome at the top because I didn’t want to spoil Catnip’s first story being picked up by the RSS FEED ! — Susan (susanhu)]
more…