[From the diaries by susanhu, a finely written diary by Spiderleaf. FP’d with prayers and hope. I’ve been heartened that so many Muslim leaders — including one in the UK who’s in prison for his Al Qaeda connections — are calling for the hostages’ release. Please keep us posted, Spiderleaf.]
I have refrained from posting about the four hostages being held in Iraq as it not only hurts me to the core, but I have held out hope they will be released soon. But time is running out. The deadline is now hours away.
The hostages are members of the Christian Peacemakers Team and are two Canadians, an American and a Brit. They were in Iraq to document human rights abuses and to help the Iraqis. They were all adamently opposed to the occupation.
I apologize if this post focuses mainly on the Canadians, but hey, that’s where I live and who I am and it’s the news I’ve been following. Unfortunately, it appears at this point that their nationality may be what saves them vs. the American and Brit. The most recent videos released by the kidnappers showed the Brit and American bound and blindfolded and the Canadians were not shown at all. According to journalists following the story, that does not bode well for the non-Canadians. My heart hurts for that. I know we stayed out of the war but these people were all just there to help.
The international outcry has been inspiring. From the streets of Palestine to the mosques of Canada and Iraq people of good conscience have been asking for their release.
The Canadian hostages – James Loney, 41, of Toronto and Harmeet Sooden, 32, who has lived in Montreal – are not seen in the video, which was broadcast on the Arabic satellite channel Al-Jazeera.
BBC correspondent Caroline Hawley said it was “pretty disturbing” that only two of the four men, all members of a Christian Peacemaker group, were shown.
“I think the hostage takers are clearly trying to differentiate between them because Canada doesn’t have troops here in Iraq and Britain and America do,” she said.
“I stress on the necessity to release the four kidnapped foreigners who have helped the residents of Azamiyah,” cleric Ahmed Hassan Taha said.
“We ask those who have authority and power to do their best to release the four.”
Outside the mosque, similar sentiments were expressed by residents holding signs and banners.
“We demand the release of the abducted peacemakers,” one sign read.
Also in Baghdad on Friday, an envoy from the Canadian Islamic Congress continued his attempts to free the hostages.
Lotayef, a Canadian of Egyptian origin, is said to be trying to enlist local support and to get his message through to the hostage takers.
Moazzam Begg told BBC Newsnight that seeing Mr Kember in an orange jumpsuit reminded him and his fellow ex-inmates of their ordeal at the US base in Cuba.
…
Mr Begg said seeing these orange jumpsuits had prompted him to make the appeal.
He said: “When we were first granted release by Allah’s mercy we came home to find that there were people who opposed the government in their brutal war waged against Afghanistan and Iraq and stood on the side of justice, and they were not Muslims.
“It is our sincerest belief that Norman Kember, the 74-year-old Briton and those with him are amongst those people, the many people who opposed this war from the beginning and were only in Iraq to promote human rights for the oppressed.”
He added that he hoped these words would encourage the hostage-takers to show mercy to the men and set them free.
Mr Begg was held for almost three years by the US at its naval base in Cuba.
He was eventually released without charge and sent back to the UK with his fellow inmates in January.
This story has cut to the core of so many in Canada. We oppose this war. We oppose Bush. We stand for peace and freedom for all. But we understand why these men were there and we do not want better treatment for them than for the British and American peacemakers. We just want the madness to stop.
I can only hope that the pleas reach the kidnappers and they find it in thier hearts to release them unharmed.
This war needs to end. The Iraqi people deserve their country back. And the families of these men deserve them back too… although the family of James Loney said recently that he would probably be back in Iraq within weeks of being released because that is his calling. Peace & stopping injustice is his life.
Please light a candle today for these men and for all around the world who live with death and destruction around them.
Namaste.
It’s a very tense situation, and worrisome w/ all of our political squabblings on-going (d/t election). Sometimes I think they can’t kill the Cdns; we’re not part of this war. But then I think of all the other innocents that have died — like those waiting in lines or shopping or sitting on a bus. They didn’t ask for their fate either. And in the end, I really don’t know what to think.
me too, I’ve been going back and forth on this all week about how I feel. Last night when my Yank husband said “there’s no way they’d kill the Canucks” I made up my mind that I just couldn’t stand it if they killed the other two and let the Canadians go… they are all opposed to the war and nationality be damned.
as a protest group against occupation and will not necessarily CARE about the politics of those they kidnap. They may only be trying to outrage the citizenry of other countries as they apparently feed on that outrage in some fashion. It is not that they don’t have a coherent motivation, it is just that, like Bush, their motivation is not what ours would be in the same situation.
Apparently there’s been some speculation that this is a kidnap for ransom gang as oppposed to a group with any real political motivations.
is that if the hostages are killed, Bush and his ilk will use the killings to committ even more atrocities in the Middle East…which is just what the four were trying to prevent. A never-ending cycle… 🙁
Moazzam Begg … how are he and his dad doing these days? Anyone know?
I remember his dad so well… and had a photo of him standing next to Vanessa Redgrave in London, demonstrating for his son’s release
I saw the clip from the BBC today and he appeared to be doing well… seemed, not happy, but at least somewhat at peace with the fact he was back… but he looked so pained at the orange jumpsuits that it probably brought back a lot of unpleasant memories for him.
but he looked so pained at the orange jumpsuits that it probably brought back a lot of unpleasant memories for him.
Which makes his request for mercy and the release of all the hostages even more amazing.
Thanks for follwoing this story so well, spiderleaf.
He and his dad are remarkable people. They have earned our respect.
And then to find out, as we have, that Guantanamo was just “window dressing” while unknown numbers were held in secret gulags and being treat horribly….
it’s all too much.
I find I can only read about this stuff for a little while and I have to take a break. My mind cannot comprehend how much sorrow we are creating and how much we will reap.
I heard today that in addition to everyone else, prominent spokespeople from Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad and even Al Qaeda have called for the release of these peace advocates.
It seems the only people who favor their capture are the disconnected nuts who are holding them.
The outpouring of support has been truly amazing and unprecedented.
I knew nothing of the “Christian Peacemaking Team” and actually assumed when their name was first mentioned that they would be there trying to convert as well as help… boy was I wrong. Evidently these people do not try to spread Christianity, that’s just their faith and how they conduct themselves.
On the CBC today they interviewed residents of the Grassy Narrow Native reservation in Northern Ontario who knew Loney from his days helping them keep loggers off their land… and they said he was so respectful of their beliefs and culture. They are all smoking pipes, singing songs and praying to the Great Spirit for his and the others safe return. It just breaks my heart.
It’s a sad commentary on the state of modern religious activity that we so easily assume actions taken by religious groups are generally either over;ly aggressive or self-serving.
Like you, when I heard thr name of this group, my first thought was that they must have an agenda designed to elevate their own stature rather than one truly devoted to helping others and fostering peace with no strings attached.
I’m very happy to have been wrong about this group, and while I do not practise a particular religious scheme myself, I’m pleased there are people such as these active within the broader religious arena.
It was just a passing thought … and please regard it as such … but what if Bushco wanted them to stop their research on Abu Ghraib?
And what has become of their materials and documents? (Or are there enough other members left free in Baghdad who have control of the research?)
I’ve been thinking the same thing all week… no one had heard of this group before these guys were taken, they’d been to Fallujah and the pleas from around the world seem to be falling on deaf ears at this point…
I don’t want to believe.
(in terms of other members, it doesn’t sound like their were a whole lot of them in Iraq at this point so I have no clue if they had access to the documents or can continue their work.. I’ll see what I can dig up)
I would put nothing past the Bush regime. There’s no atrocity I regard them incapable of committing if it would advance their insane agenda.
In the Cult of Neoconservativism, there are no ethical or moral boundaries.
I have taken it for granted since the announcement that they had been seized.
We started it at 4 p.m. our time, which was the stroke of midnight, the beginning of December 10, in Iraq.
We had a good turnout for a little college town on the first Friday of exam week. At least 20, maybe 25 people came and went for two hours.
Three of them had been merely passing by, saw our signs, and were moved to join our vigil. That felt pretty good.
Two different crews came from local TV stations, filmed us, interviewed me and some others. That was also encouraging.
Like spiderleaf, I have more hope for the two Canadian peacemakers than for Tom Fox, the American, or Norman Kember, the Briton. My rational self understands this. My spiritual self is holding out for a miracle.
But, no matter whether these kidnappings end in joy or tragedy — the global outpouring of support and admiration has been unprecedented and remarkable. When’s the last time a pacifist made headlines? If we work on this as a teachable moment, we may be able to change the public discourse on pacifism. I made a sign for today’s vigil that read, “Pacifism Isn’t Passive.” I know that is terrible framing, but it’s the best I could do on short notice!
I’m almost afraid to go to sleep and wake up tomorrow morning and listen to the news. I can’t imagine how the families and friends of the four men feel. My heart goes out to them, and I am trying SO HARD to heed CPT’s call to feel equal compassion and empathy and concern for the people who are holding these four men. I guess there’s a reason Christianity has so thoroughly warped Jesus’s central messages: they are damned hard to live.
Like you I just wish they would stop this stupid war.
“The four men have been gathering evidence about people being treated poorly while “detained by occupation forces,” Edward Loney said.”
So is this perhaps a CIA or Iraqi black op’s thing.
They kill one of more hostages, blame it on the terrorists and keep nosey foreighners from looking into abuse by “occupation forces” which would include the Iraqi army essientially.
It’s a win win situartion.
Now it doesn’t make sense that the kidnappers would kidnap them if they thought these foreigners were working to expose occupation force abuse does it?
Yes to opposing of war and Bush. I hope that the day of freedom and peace would come soon. It’s really heartwrenching to make innconent people suffer like that. They deserves to be back with their family more than anything else. I hope we’ll all be able to see the day of light some day.