Jonah Goldberg, the son of l’affaire Lewinsky superheroine Lucianne Goldberg, has a job writing columns for the Los Angeles Times. He is probably the stupidest person in the entire country to have one of these plum positions with a major distribution paper. I mean that. He’s practically an idiot. Other conservative columnists make bad arguments all the time, but they know they’re doing it and most of them are quite effective in spewing their lies. Goldberg isn’t effective at all. His arguments are laughable and of the kind you hear from uninformed neighbors at block parties. Take today’s offering for example:
There’s a weird irony at work when Sen. Barack Obama, the black presidential candidate who will allegedly scrub the stain of racism from the nation, vows to run afoul of the constitutional amendment that abolished slavery.
For those who don’t remember, the 13th Amendment says: “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime … shall exist within the United States.”
I guess in Obama’s mind it must be a crime to be born or to go to college.
In his speech on national service Wednesday at the University of Colorado, Obama promised that as president he would “set a goal for all American middle and high school students to perform 50 hours of service a year, and for all college students to perform 100 hours of service a year.”
He would see that these goals are met by, among other things, attaching strings to federal education dollars. If you don’t make the kids report for duty, he’s essentially telling schools and college kids, you’ll lose money you can’t afford to lose. In short, he’ll make service compulsory by merely compelling schools to make it compulsory.
The rest of his column isn’t any better. Nowhere in his column does he mention that we had a draft in this country for a good part of the 20th-Century, not to mention during the Civil War. Comparing the draft to slavery is insulting but it would make more sense than comparing government-compensated volunteerism to slavery. You can read about Barack Obama’s actual service proposals here. I can tell you one proposal that is going to be very popular with parents.
Require 100 Hours of Service in College: Obama will establish a new American Opportunity Tax Credit that is worth $4,000 a year in exchange for 100 hours of public service a year.
If you want that $16,000 discount on a four-year university education, you’ll need to volunteer 400 hours. You will be getting paid $40/hour for ‘volunteering’. In Jonah Goldberg’s universe, this is slavery. Can the Los Angeles Times hire Digby or something? This is just embarrassing.
Golberg also thinks fascism is a left-wing thing. He’s just bizarre. But knowing he’s the son of oh-so-socially connected Lucianne makes his employment there understandable. We need to give citizens a “Government Shill 101” course so they can laugh these people off the oped pages.
Also of note. If you work 50 weeks a year for 40 hours a week and you get paid $40/hour, you will bring in $80,000. If you get a paid two-week vacation on top of it, you’ll earn more.
I don’t know what the LA Times pays Goldberg to write his crap, but it must be a lot for him to compare $80,000/year to slavery.
Goldberg and neocons in general are facts deficient. They care not. When Goldberg and his neo-con colleagues define slavery, slavery is what it is..
To volunteer in service to your country is slavery….perhaps that’s why Goldberg didn’t volunteer for Iraq?
Goldberg should know. The US has a few hundred thousand slaves – slaves to the war in Iraq and Afghanistan…continued tours of duty, treated as slaves PTSD. The Pentagon’s recruiting teams fanned out into countries with struggling economies, whose peoples have a certain skin tone. “Commie, commie here.. we’ve some uncle Sam devalued bucks for you…if you live to see it.”
Vets are slaves. The U.S. embassy in Iraq built by slaves.
Mama was a right-wing intel asset.
The apple didn’t roll far from the tree.
In the rotten orchard of the mass media.
Why even read his shit?
Wjhy even read the LA Times?
Just another asset.
NY Times Jr.
Bet on it.
AG
Not just right wing – NANA – the North American Newspaper Alliance, fronted people for the CIA as well, notably Priscilla Johnnson McMillan, who interviewed Oswald pre-assassination in the USSR and then wrote a book about his wife after that Marina called a pack of lies.
Priscilla also claimed an affair – with President Kennedy – in the National Enquirer or one of those rags. She was not exactly a looker. Please. JFK had his pick, and it would never have been HER.
Priscilla’s CIA file lists her as a “witting” asset (as opposed to their unwitting assets who don’t even know they’re being manipulated by the CIA).
I have always objected to the ‘witting” term when used in this way.
First of all…anyone who still possess the wit with we we are almost all born would not work for the CIA in any capacity as it stands today and as ithas stood since the late ’40s.
Secondly, if they do not know they are being used by the secret police…because that is what the CIA and other intel ops really are when acting domestically, let’s call a spade a spade here…then they are witless out front.
The system is rotted almost all the way through now. Like a giant tree in its last days, it totters and is about to fall.
Call the Tree Whisperer!!!
QUICK!!!
AG
This is one apple that is a lot less intelligent than the tree it came from.
you could call it ‘involuntary servitude’ but it wasn’t slavery. Those two terms are not synonymous.
but my Jonah’s logic….
Jonah jumped the shark at least 6 months ago.
Then what was Reagan with his “Thousand Points of Light”? Wasn’t that a call to volunteerism? IOKIYAR?
that was Poppy, not Ray-gun.
Oops. To quote LOLcats, “I can’t brain today. I haz teh dumb.”
Why is it that the right is DOMINATED right now by those who obtained their status by nepotism?
Goldberg
William Kristol
Kagan
Kagan
Inevitably, since these princes of right-wing nuttery gained their status by dad/mom shoving aside others for them, we get 2nd rate intellects.
What’s the deal there?
Why?
They’re aliens.
It’s genetic.
Alien to human love, at the very least.
Maybe worse.
MUCH worse.
They live. And they reproduce. BEEN doing so from the dawn of human history.
It’s genetic.
Bet on it.
Later…
AG
As I recall, slavery wasn’t voluntary. Does he think everyone should get the tuition credit for doing nothing? Who knew Jonah would grow up to be a socialist? Hooray!! Now he can atone for the sins of his parents.