Update [2009-12-21 1:23:56 by BooMan]: Senate invokes cloture on Reid’s manager’s amendment by a 60-40 vote. I will remind you that we needed every single victory from 2006 and 2008 to achieve this. We needed Tester and Webb and McCaskill and Whitehouse and Klobuchar and Franken and Begich and Merkley and Sanders and the two Udalls and Brown and Cardin and Hagan and Casey and Hagan and Shaheen and Warner. We needed to seat Bennet and Burris and Gillibrand. We needed to replace Kennedy with Kirk. With had to flip Arlen Specter to the Democratic Party. If we lost any single one of those battles, health care reform would be dead. Instead, it lives. And you have yourselves to thank for that. Your activism made the difference.
———————————————-
If you are like me, you spent today watching some football, and maybe checking your Fantasy Football stats in this first week of Fantasy playoffs. I won by just over a point, when Brett Favre threw an interception instead of a completion at the end of the Panthers-Vikings game. I think Steven needs Hakeem Nicks to have a monster game on Monday night to survive.
But, believe it or not, the Senate is about to convene after midnight and have the key cloture vote of the whole health care reform shebang. The vote should begin at approximately 1am. They will have to wheel Robert Byrd in again in the middle of the night to cast the deciding sixtieth vote. Once they reach 60 votes, the Democrats and probably the chambers will erupt in applause. I’m not sure if all the Republicans will even show up. They don’t need to be there. The way cloture works, all that is required is 3/5’s of seated senators, not of those actually present. So, technically, no Republicans need to show up. Some of them will probably opt to get some sleep. Once cloture is invoked on Reid’s manager’s amendment, the clock will start on 30 hours of post-cloture time. Then, sometime Tuesday they will hold another cloture note on the substitute bill. And on Wednesday, a vote on that. And on Christmas Eve, a vote on final passage.
But the big vote is tonight, starting at around 1am. This is the vote that we had no way of winning so long a triggerless public option was part of the bill. We could, however, have won over Snowe’s vote for a trigger if we had so chose. To win over all 60 members of the Democratic caucus in the Senate, Reid had to add a lot of goodies, especially for Landrieu and Ben Nelson, but also for others, like Bernie Sanders. Now that these senators have won concessions, they will be very reluctant to blow up the Conference Report with the House, even if the bill moves to the left. There are definitely limitations to how far the bill can move to the left without losing the support of at least one Democrat. But the bill can now be improved for the first time since the HELP Committee completed its work in July.
There may be some temptation in the interest of time and simplicity to doing what is called a ping-pong maneuver. This is a move where the House votes to pass a bill that is identical to the Senate version, thereby obviating the need to go to a Conference Committee to reconcile the differences. That would be a travesty. We’ve made too many compromises to win over the support of people like Joe Lieberman and Blanche Lincoln. We need to take the Senate bill and make some improvements so that the bill is better from both a policy and a political point of view. We can’t win a public option of any kind. But we can make some tweaks to improve the subsidies, strengthen the regulations, and the phase in the exchanges quicker.
The chaplain is giving the opening prayer to an empty Senate chamber. He’s praying that the senators will lead a life of integrity and remember that they are servants of the people, and not succumb to cynicism.
Ha.
Ironic on so many levels…
I’ll be watching c span tonight.
Senator Mark Udall of Colorado is presiding as president of the Senate. Lamar Alexander opens for the GOP.
Also I think it’s interesting that this senate is actually working and working late. During the Bush era I don’t remember the house or the senate working very much
This senate doesn’t work much either. The GOP simply delays things so that we have half as many legislative days as we should to do some work.
Does anyone get the feeling that Jane Hamsher is going to go the way of Orly Taitz before this is all over?
Maybe they’ll form a third-party together.
Maybe Jane is Orly’s long lost sister. I think they favor.
Along with Lady Lynn Forester de Rothschild?
Then why did Jane tape and post that PUMA going out of her mind(back when they decided what to do about Michigan and Florida)?
I think one thing we’ve figured out during all of this is that some people are concerned about actual governing and effective policy making, and others more about hysteria, chest-beating, throwing tantrums, and shout-downs of critics. One of these actually gets things done; the other generates lots of media buzz.
what? You haven’t seen me on your teevee or on syndicated radio?
Remember, the two simplest ways to get invited to speak in the media.
Lol, every time I see the word syndicated I think of David Sirota.
And that’s why some of us prefer THIS blog 🙂
blah blah blah blah blah blah Naval Academy blah blah blah blah blah blah POW blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah
thanks, I dozed off and missed what McCain had to say.
You might not have heard his comments but trust me, you didn’t miss anything.
your recap was helpful.
I aim to please.
Harkin’s outfit is so Christmas-y.
How long are thses revolting repubs gonna talk. Isn’t it past their bedtimes?
I’m watching Survivor until 10pm (West Coast time) – then switching to C-SPAN for “the vote.” I haven’t slept much in the past few days – catching all the coverage I could. This is a good/bad/wonderful/horrible bill. I hope and pray it really is an improvement. I truly don’t know what to think, not having read the bill myself. But I am captivated by the arguments on both sides and can’t wait to see what comes of all of this. I’m just tired – I can’t fight every battle.
That’s about where I am. I am hoping this is actually an improvement for common people, even if it’s a massive wet kiss to the insurance companies. But I hope they turn right around and start inching the camel further into the tent.
I’ve actually read about 200 pages of the bill. Now that school is out I will actually finish it along with the amendments and such. I work in the healthcare field and I see many ways that this bill is going to help a lot of people
Geez, I hate listening to Mitch McConnell. I have to wipe the slime off the speakers every time he’s done speaking.
it’s turtle slime.
You gave me a good morning laugh here in Amsterdam.
I aim to please. ;-D
If you’re playing the Talking Point Drinking Game, take a drink now for “overwhelming opposed by the American people” and one for “never before has a bill like this passed without bipartisan support.” Hope you’re taking small drinks.
also any reference to the number of pages in the bill and/or amendment.
Do these guys have a speech impediment that makes them repeat everything? That makes? Them? Repeat? Everything?
Harry Reid is so boring and uninspiring.
no doubt.
If it weren’t for him pulling together the 60 votes, I’d insult him right now, but his voice is lulling me to sleep at this late hour. It’s kind of comforting. He’s the kind of guy I’d hire to read me books at my bedside or on Mr. Rogers.
Maybe the Star Trek mirror universe version of Mr. Rogers
what? I dozed off again.
Get your sleep while you can.
I told CG that this morning when she kept waking me up every 30 minutes. I was like, “You know this might be the last morning for years that I can get some sleep, right?”
You might get lucky and get one of those who sleeps through the night from the start. But it’s not likely. My oldest son is 33 and he’s never yet slept all the way through the night.
Yeah but I’d rather listen to him than McConnell or McCain or most of the other Republibots.
Harry Reid insists on the rule, never normally enforced, that members vote from their desks. This makes the vote go quicker. It also gives it a sense of history.
He should also insist that if senators want to filibuster they should talk rather than just stand up and say they filibuster. Just my 2 cents.
Hard to do. They can just go up there and not the absence of a quorum and the clerk has to call the roll, which takes 15 minutes, and them another one can do the same thing. Only way to prevent that is to keep a quorum present at all times.
I didn’t say it’d be easy, but that means the Republicans have to keep their part of the quorum as well.
They look like a bunch of schoolchildren. I’ve never seen them all sit down at once before.
Mr. Byrd. Mr. Byrd ‘aye.’
Lieberman votes “aye.” Thanks a lot, bub. We’ll remember this.
i’d note at this point that every effort we made to elect Begich, McCaskill, Franken, Webb, Merkley, etc., over the last four years is paying off now. Without any of them, we’d have bupkis.
Great point.
Watching history, and hopeful.
are there any senators wanting to vote or change their vote?
Why are they calling the roll again?
Booman, congratulations. It’s not the end, or the beginning of the end, but at least its the end of the beginning.
Bittersweet.
I am a morning person and this AM I feel just great. Go for it all you Senate guys and gals with a heart. (NRNA) No Republicans Need Apply!
Sorry I missed all this. Waves to Omir.
Hey Boran, nice to see you.