First is was Tim Russert’s son Luke, then it was George W. Bush’s daughter Jenna, and now it is Chelsea Clinton who will be working for NBC. Here’s a description of what she’ll be doing:
Ms. Clinton will show up at the news division offices on Monday morning, said Steve Capus, president of NBC News, and will begin work on stories that NBC expects to use as part of its “Making a Difference” series, which runs on “NBC Nightly News.”
…
“What we talked about was if she were to come on board that’s the kind of thing she would be interested in doing. We knew she wasn’t going to do the lead story. But having somebody who was going to do really captivating feature assignments for the ‘Making a Difference’ franchise really kind of synced up,” Mr. Capus said.
Those feature reports, which have become popular on NBC’s evening newscast — and which may be added to NBC’s new prime-time newsmagazine program, “Rock Center With Brian Williams” — spotlight people who are making volunteer commitments to improve the lives of others in their community.
Mr. Capus said Ms. Clinton had said to him, “That’s the kind of thing, if this were to happen, that I would really like to do.” He added, “It’s not about Chelsea Clinton saying, ‘Here I am; I want to be a TV star.’ ”
Okay, I think it’s a worthy news segment. By all means, go out and find ordinary Americans who are donating their time and energy to worthy causes and give them some props and maybe it will inspire some others to be better people. I am sure that there are countless broadcasting majors who could do this adequately. Chelsea Clinton, on the other hand, has a B.A. in History from Stanford, a M.Phil. in International Relations from University College, Oxford, a Master of Public Health degree at Columbia Mailman School of Public Health, and is working on a doctorate degree at the Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service, New York University. She’s a tad bit overqualified to be working full-time on bit segments for NBC News.
It’s not my place to tell her what to do, but I hope she isn’t committed to being a glorified Jenna Bush. As for NBC, they continue to hire the sons and daughters of the elite of the elite instead of hiring on hard work and merit. Luke Russert, Chelsea Clinton, and even Jenna Bush Hager are all accomplished people, but they wouldn’t have received their broadcasting jobs on merit alone. With people in the streets complaining about how the 1% are only looking out for themselves, NBC is badly off message.
I don’t know if Ms. Clinton is doing this to boost her profile for a future political career or if she’s doing it for a fat paycheck. It has nothing to do with history or international relations, and is only tangentially related to public health and public service.
If she is serious about a career in broadcasting, she probably should have studied broadcasting. And I’d rather see her cut her chops as a foreign corespondent, although security concerns probably make that impossible.
Above all, I’m tired of seeing NBC hand people plum jobs for who they are rather than what they’ve done.
The only thing I disagree with is the notion that you need to study broadcasting to be in broadcasting.
Rachel Maddow earned a degree in public policy and a a Doctor of Philosophy (DPhil) in politics.
Chris Hayes who just got his own show on MSNBC has a Bachelor of Arts degree in Philosophy.
Chuck Todd majored in political science and minored in music, but never graduated.
I agree that a degree in broadcasting should not be a hard-and-fast prerequisite. If you’re covering politics, or business, or public policy then degrees in those areas are more of a plus than a degree in broadcasting. However, majoring in being the son or daughter of a president doesn’t seem like the right preparation. Majoring in being the son of Tim Russert seems like nepotism.
There are a lot of people who have worked very hard to get these positions, and they just passed over.
Very few people who work in broadcasting got broadcast degrees; what they did do was find entry level work in broadcasting, and work their way up. Glenn Beck, for example, got his start in high school by taking the bus every weekend to do a radio overnight gig 70 miles away. Even Maddow, whose rise was meteoric, worked in small market radio before her MSNBC gig.
The issue isn’t so much that Clinton’s academic background is a mismatch as that a network TV reporting slot is her first gig. That is because of who her parents are, and it’s an insult to people who have worked their asses off paying dues and who could do that job in their sleep.
I’m annoyed, more so, at the Fox folks hiring the well publicized failures and giving them an oversized mic to continue their failures.
Given the emerging crowd I’m just glad MSNBC chose Luke & Chelsea and most specifically Chris Hayes rather than give a new show to Pat and Babe Buchanan.
Actually, if she hopes to finish her doctorate at Wagner, she’d really better not be working on anything more trying than pieces about volunteering. The PhD there is a full time commitment.
Boo:
Is this an effort to try and get younger people to watch NBC? If so, it will be a spectacular failure. And 20%(hardcore GOPers) of the country will never watch anyway.
I dunno. It reminds me of tuning in to some channel in the 80s to a Ron Reagan Jr. newmagazine-type show and wondering wtf he was and wtf he was important enough to have his own show. Maybe it was unwarranted at the time but he managed to take that sliver of media attention and eventually carve out a meaningful role for himself in the public forum.
I don’t know how we can get around it: some folks are just going to be born on third base. If they throw that advantage away and decide not to turn it to the advantage of the people at large, then where exactly is the moral high ground in that?
Yeah, OK, it isn’t fair or perfect, but then again neither is it fair that some people are born with any other advantage like intelligence or musical aptitude or even just an infallible sense of humor.
Some people are born in the public eye and are expected to have something meaningful to say, even when they don’t. But if they don’t, before too long the spotlight shifts onto another subject. Ron Jr isn’t a celebrity by any means but he’s a public figure who does good with what he’s carved out from an advantageous origin. Bristol Palin may turn out to be a force for good in about 60-80 years, who knows.
Chelsea is getting an early shot at the limelight, and she’s opted to take it. It’s not right or wrong, it’s how it is. It may turn out to be a good or bad decision based on a number of factors, but it’s just possible that she’s a capable and well-intentioned person who can get things done starting at a young age that 98% of the rest of us don’t get the opportunity to do.
Fair? No. But the opportunity is an obligation of sorts, imho.
Every time I see Luke Russert I think of a talented, ambitious and hard-working local NBC reporter who didn’t get that job.
Don’t forget Megan McCain.
The nepotism would probably bother me more if NBC (or any of the rest of the networks) actually, you know, DID NEWS. As it is, actual news content has been limited to cable networks for (nearly? over?) a decade now, and even that has been limited to less than 3 hours a night on one network. The Ferengi are already there, and they ain’t going anywhere.
We have two many news stories and news shows.Just keep our favorite shows on the air and not cancel them.
Casey Mahoney Brad P
Wow. The right wing blogs hate this just because she is Chelsea Clinton. 😉
Wow. The right wing blogs hate this just because she is Chelsea Clinton. 😉
Who you know has always trumped what you know in the real world, but I don’t think that anybody can say that Chelsea is a girl that doesn’t know anything. I’m happy for her. If she’s serious about this as a career, look for her to emulate the Maddow model.
What makes you think Chelsea would adopt the persona of an unabashed progressive? Nothing in her resume particularly indicates that she is one. She worked for McKinsey and is married to an investment banker, for goodness sakes. Not to mention who her parents are.
Tim Russert was a sham and an apologist for the economic royalists at the top. The others are more of the same doing more of the same. In a more sane world… both Bush’s, both Clinton’s and McCain would be in prison for their many crimes against humanity and the American people. Unfortunately it looks as if their progeny are continuing on the same path…