John Crawford was the unfortunate black man holding a BB gun in the toy section of a Walmart Store in Beavercreek, OH, when police, in response to several 911 calls, shot and killed him on August 5, 2014.
Police have maintained that Crawford was waving the BB gun around in a threatening manner when they arrived and refused their commands to drop the “weapon” (even though Ohio is an “open carry” state), thus requiring his execution style death by cop.
However, Ohio Attorney General Mike Dewine, who assigned the case investigating the police homicide of Mr. Crawford to a special prosecutor, recently allowed family members and their attorneys to view the surveillance tape from the store that shows the moments up to and including John Crawford’s shooting death by police. After viewing that tape, the family’s attorneys and Crawford’s father dispute the police account of this incident in no uncertain terms:
Attorney Michael Wright said: “We need Mike DeWine to refer this case to the Department of Justice. Not to a special prosecutor.”
Wright said Crawford did nothing wrong in Walmart. “Nothing more, nothing less than shopping.”
Wright, who has seen store surveillance video of the shooting incident, said Crawford was shot while talking on the phone, holding the butt of the gun with the barrel pointed at the floor.
He said Crawford was “shot on sight” in a “militaristic” response.
This is extremely troubling news. Much like the case of Michael Brown, the family has been complaining that leaks about the investigation have benefited the police shooters and denigrated John Crawford’s character.
“Everything released is one-sided. There is nothing favorable to John Crawford. You can’t show different pieces, show it all, don’t trickle pieces to gain favor of the public, “said Michael Wright, Crawford family attorney. Wright wants to see the release of events in chronological order.
Wright says the video shows Crawford standing in the direction of some shelves. He say Crawford was talking on his cell phone and probably did not see or hear the police officer sent to the store to investigate. He said in one frame you see Crawford on the phone, the next you see him on the floor.
Crawford’s father questions the timing of the state’s investigation.
“My main concern is the delay. What’s taking so long? I understand it’s a process, but frankly, I see stall tactics,” said John Crawford II [the decedent’s father].
According to the family and its lawyers, the video supports their claim that John Crawford was on his cell phone talking to his girlfriend and doing nothing else when the police entered the store and shot him down for the crime of being Black and holding a toy gun in a Walmart.
Crawford was speaking by cell phone to his girlfriend, who was with his parents, when he was shot.
“He said he was at the video games playing videos, and he went over there by the toy section where the toy guns were,” said LeeCee Johnson, the mother of his two children. “The next thing I know, he said, ‘It’s not real,’ and the police start shooting, and they said ‘Get on the ground,’ but he was already on the ground because they had shot him.”
Johnson put the phone on speaker mode, and she and Crawford’s parents heard him die.
“I could hear him just crying and screaming,” Johnson said. “I feel like they shot him down like he was not even human.”
The Grand Jury is set to begin hearing evidence regarding the Crawford shooting on September 22, 2014, assuming no further delays. Meanwhile, one of the police officers who shot Crawford is already back on the job, while the other one remains on administrative leave with pay.
It should be remembered that Mr. Crawford was not the only victim of this “incident.” Another shopper, 37 year old Angela Williams “collapsed and died as she scrambled to get away after police fired at Crawford.” All because of the claims made by 911 callers such as this one:
In one of those calls, which was released by police, a Wal-Mart shopper told emergency dispatchers that it looked like the man — later identified as Crawford — was trying to load the rifle and that he had pointed it at two children, WHIO reported.
The 911 caller’s wife said that Crawford was on the phone and that he was messing with the gun. She said that after police ordered Crawford to put down the unidentified weapon, “I heard two shots after I saw him turn. He still had the weapon in his hand.”
Considering the content of the video, and the fact that Crawford was a father of two children with his girlfriend (with the couple expecting a third child), I find that story a little hard to swallow. Sounds like panic by white shoppers and an unwarranted response by the police who shot a harmless man while he was talking on his phone. All because he was a scary black man. But what do I know.
This incident essentially happened in my back yard, and it has been interesting that there has been so little outcry or publicity about this. From what I have heard, the circumstances seem to be every bit as egregious as the Michael Brown case. When this was first reported, there were things that just didn’t seem to make much sense. Of course, being that it happened in a Walmart, cameras are ubiquitous, so there was little doubt that virtually every second of the event was recorded, and from multiple angles. Zero information related to what was on the video has been released, however.
Attorney General Mike Dewine did announce today that a special prosecutor, Mark Piepmeier, had been appointed to investigate and present details to the grand jury. Piepmeier oversaw the grand jury investigation that returned a charge of negligent homicide against Cincinnati Police Officer Stephen Roach, in an incident in which Timothy Thomas, an unarmed 19 year old black man, was shot while fleeing as police tried to execute an arrest warrant for a handful of non-violent misdemeanor offenses. He rounded a corner in a dark alley and surprised Officer Roach, who later said he thought Thomas was reaching for a gun, when he was actually trying to pull up his pants.
Officer Roach was later acquitted at trial on the charge of negligent homicide. The riots in Cincinnati that resulted from this incident were the worst in the the country since 1992.
Ohio is an Open Carry state. That means anyone can carry a visible gun anywhere. Ohio is a traditional open-carry state. The open-carry of firearms by those who legally possess the firearm is a legal activity in Ohio with or without a license.
The Walmart video has finally released. John was talking on the phone, leaning on the still wrapped toy gun package, in the Toys aisle with his back to the 2 policeman. One police man has already returned to work.
You are correct on the open carry. Though it is not really very common in urban areas. I can’t recall ever seeing anyone open-carrying around here, though I’m sure it has happened. Though it is likely to result in a call to police.
I know that the family’s lawyer and the man’s father had seen a portion of the video, but I have not heard that it has been released publicly.
Mike, as far as I’ve seen the tape has not been released publically, nor has the full extent of the tape been shown the father. I’m sorry iI left that impression. It has been reported John’s mother chose not to view it.
Mark E. Piepmeier, an attorney in the Hamilton County Prosecuting Attorney’s office, has been appointed to lead the Grand Jury team which won’t convene until Sept. 22.
After watching the nonchalance of Wilson in Ferguson, the full length of the aftermath should be important here. The entire tape should reveal much about the training and humanity of the Beavercreek PD.
There is also this additional death: “Another person in the Wal-Mart also died after the situation. Angela Williams, a customer in the store, collapsed after running from the chaotic scene and was later pronounced dead. The autopsy results showing the cause of her death are not available yet.”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2014/08/26/ohio-attorney-general-appoints-special-
prosecutor-to-investigate-wal-mart-shooting/
“seem to be every bit as egregious as the Michael Brown case”
Much more egregious. Michael Brown was illegally walking down the middle of the road and maybe was giving lip to the cop (a felony in Illinois). That doesn’t justify shooting him, of course, but he did do some very minor (IMHO) illegal stuff. This man did absolutely NOTHING illegal apparently EVEN if he had been carrying a real gun! Maybe the tape shows a hesitation when they screamed at him to “drop the weapon”. I can see myself in that situation, being dumbfounded and saying “Huh?”, then being blasted. Most egregious police behavior I’ve even heard of.
So sad. Will we ever become a nation where a man is judged by the content of his character rather than the color of his skin?
Did you see this, yet?
I hate to start my day with tears. That was heart-wrenching.
But when I think about those kids’ families, I’m pretty sure they start every day with tears, and I’m stupidly selfish about my sadness. I can cry for them, but that doesn’t help.
I have three sons, but I never had to tell them not to pick up a BB gun in a department store for fear of being gunned down by cops. I never had to tell them to only ride with a few kids at a time when they went out, and to keep the music turned down in the car to keep from being harassed. My sons are white, see.
And while they might be viewed with some suspicion by cops, they don’t have targets painted on their backs automatically.
We’ve not come very far. I think we’ve gone backwards.
Hey, Mike! I’m fifteen minutes from this store. Beavercreek is a suburb of Dayton, 85% white, and the Walmart is in the vicinity of a shopping mall where residents have repeatedly voted against allowing the RTA bus line from downtown being connected. The citizens don’t want a “criminal element” being brought into their lily white area.
Some letters to the editor of the local paper have all but said that Crawford’s death proves that “this kind of people” will cause problems. It’s sickening to see this overt racism, and to see a town split into separate sides. It’s exactly what happened in Ferguson. White cops overreacted to a black citizen, panicked, and shot an innocent man to death.
God, when does it end?
Unfortunately, donnah, it never ends.
Yeah, Donnah. I’ve seen some of those letters in the Dayton Daily News. And there has been bitching for years about the RTA line running to any of the suburbs around the city. The same attitudes exist all over this general area. I hear it all the damn time. I am gobsmacked on a daily basis, though I really should not be so surprised. After all, I have lived in this area for over 50 years. It seems to just be baked into the cake.
yeah, it’s kinda baked into the fabric of the city…
I was born in Dayton and lived there until I moved to Beavercreek in 1980, then California in 1982. Segregation and discrimination had been part of society (albeit at low levels, almost subconsciously) all my life there. Not to run down the state of life there–it was just a fact of life…something you lived with.
I recall my NCR-retiree grandfather telling me that Old River pool would be open Tues-Sat for Whites, Sunday for Blacks, then closed Monday while they drained both pools, cleaned them, and refilled them for Tuesday–one reason the water was so bloody cold.
I think that may be one reason the pool’s not there any more…
Jeff Wiltse wrote a book called Contested Waters about the racial prejudice that ended a most “public” municipal pools.
For the same reason, dancing platforms in city parks across the US were destroyed. Dayton once had at least one very active “public” dancing pavilon.
Segregation or total prohibition meant it is not public, what ever the white town fathers say.
God, when does it end?
2030 thereabouts, when we simultaneously have demographic turnover and a significantly less racist generation of Americans replaces their parents in leadership positions.
Not to say that the current generation of Traditional America can’t fix themselves before then. They were able to make astounding progress on gay rights. But if they don’t, well, they can feel free to join the Jim Crow southerners and anti-Catholic northeasterners in the annals of history’s villains. Most of them will live long enough to feel the spiteful spit on their cheeks via their children and grandchildren. If that makes you feel any better.
See a pattern yet?
A number of West Coast progressives think that it’s time to bust police unions for their tactics of obstruction of justice.
It seems that the authorities are using secrecy and confidential showing to try to shut up the victims’ families.
Which isn’t the answer…
Cops TV crew member and suspect killed by Omaha police during gunfight. Not exactly a gunfight:
With US cops trigger happy, maybe toy assault weapons aren’t such a good thing. Shooting of Andy Lopez
So sad. These questions need answers.
url=Merchant Cash Advance[/url]