Well, they stop short of actually calling it that, but they might as well with the absolute nonsense that is on the “Ten Facts About Guantanamo” list that was issued earlier in the week (word document at the top of the web site).
Is it me, or have things now just flown past obscene and vile and disgusting and shameful and disgraceful to bizarre and pathetic? Because when you see the items on this list, including (get this) high top sneakers, denim jean jackets, blue jeans and ping pong.
I swear, I kid you not.
Now, I must give a hat tip to the good folks at ThinkProgress for pointing out the lunacy. But in reality, I just don’t know how to react to this, so I think that snark is the best answer here – not to minimize the fact that Gitmo is a symbol of the torture and complete disrespect for the Constitution, or that there are numerous detainees who have committed suicide while there, or have been released with no charges brought – but I just can’t believe that this is something that anyone actually took the time to write, and then have approved for release by higher-ups at the Pentagon.
I’ll provide the points on this list, just because I wouldn’t have believed it unless I read them for myself, and you will see just how stupid, pathetic and just flat out wrong (no surprise there) these items are:
1) The detainees at the Guantanamo Bay detention facility include bin Laden’s bodyguards, bomb makers, terrorist trainers and facilitators, and other suspected terrorists.
2) More money is spent on meals for detainees than on the U.S. troops stationed there. Detainees are offered up to 4,200 calories a day. The average weight gain per detainee is 20 pounds.
3) The Muslim call to prayer sounds five times a day. Arrows point detainees toward the holy city of Mecca.
4) Detainees receive medical, dental, psychiatric, and optometric care at U.S. taxpayers’ expense. In 2005, there were 35 teeth cleanings, 91 cavities filled, and 174 pairs of glasses issued.
5) The International Committee of the Red Cross visits detainees at the facility every few months. More than 20,000 messages between detainees and their families have been exchanged.
6) Recreation activities include basketball, volleyball, soccer, pingpong, and board games. High-top sneakers are provided.
7) Departing detainees receive a Koran, a jean jacket, a white T-shirt, a pair of blue jeans, high-top sneakers, a gym bag of toiletries, and a pillow and blanket for the flight home.
8) Entertainment includes Arabic language TV shows, including World Cup soccer games. The library has 3,500 volumes available in 13 languages — the most requested book is “Harry Potter.”
9) Guantanamo is the most transparent detention facility in the history of warfare. The Joint Task Force has hosted more than 1,000 journalists from more than 40 countries.
10) In 2005, Amnesty International stated that “the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay has become the gulag of our times.”
OK, take a moment to stop laughing, crying, shouting or screaming at the computer screen.
Now, correct me if I am wrong, but if these are “the worst of the worst Islamofascists” who only focus on bringing death and destruction to `Murka – and they are this way because they “hate our freedoms”, then please answer these questions:
Why would they be interested in high top sneakers, blue jeans, denim jackets and other “symbols of `Murka”? Shouldn’t we just give them an American flag lapel pin while we are at it?
There are approximately 460 detainees at Guantanamo. Are 35 teeth cleanings in nearly four years something to be bragging about? Are less than 100 fillings something anyone should be impressed with?
Was any of this dental work done after the prisoners were tortured and their teeth were knocked out? Were any of those pairs of glasses issued to people whose faces were kicked in?
Isn’t the World Cup on once every four years? Isn’t that like saying that the Olympics are broadcast? And wouldn’t anyone that is only interested in killing `Murkins not interested in this?
About that transparency – didn’t the military block the media’s access entirely? And while the media did have access, didn’t the following occur:
Journalists could not talk to detainees, they had to be accompanied by a military escort and their photos were censored.
What about that 4,200 calorie diet? Not to mention the fact that that is more than twice what is a normal diet, didn’t we hear about hunger strikes? What about the following little nugget (and I don’t mean chicken Mcnugget either):
There also has been a hunger strike since August. The number of inmates refusing food dropped to 18 by last weekend from a high of 131. The military has at times used force-feeding methods, including a restraint chair.
I guess when you force feed people, they gain weight.
What about those Red Cross visits? Well, it is nice to say that they visit often, but what does the Red Cross actually say about the “facilities”?
Christophe Girod – the senior Red Cross official in Washington – said it was unacceptable that the 600 detainees should be held indefinitely at Guantanamo Bay without legal safeguards.
—snip—
Mr Girod said the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) was making the unusually blunt public statement because of a lack of action after previous private contacts with American officials.
“One cannot keep these detainees in this pattern, this situation, indefinitely,” he said during a visit to the US naval base where the Taliban and al-Qaeda suspects are being held.
As for the last point, why would any “fun fact” sheet want to point out that Amnesty International called Guantanamo a gulag? Doesn’t that seem like something that the Pentagon would want to gloss over?
Just like all of the other facts about Guantanamo, torture, rendition, secret CIA prison camps and well, pretty much everything else that these liars and war criminals have done over the past six years.
also in orange
I’m at a loss for words-almost..are you sure this didn’t come from Letterman or The Onion? And how did number 10 slip in there or do they think gulag is a good thing?
it is from defenselink.mil
I was trying to be very snarky but maybe it came across as being a serious question.
nah – I figured it was snarky, but it very well could have come from Letterman or the Onion.
That is how farcical the list looked to me….
Wow, that makes it editable! Hmmmm….
7) Departing detainees receive a Koran, a jean jacket, a white T-shirt, a pair of blue jeans, high-top sneakers, a gym bag of toiletries, and a pillow and blanket for the flight home.
Am I the only one here who looked at this and mentally added, “And a copy of the Guantanamo Home Game from Parker Brothers”?
No, I don’t even want to think about what would be in the box.
Eh, reminds me of the Japanese internment era, when the Defense Dept took great pains to show how the Americans of Japanese descent had “voluntarily” gone into the camps…
Ironically, there was a time when we thought the Japanese internment camps was the worst thing that our Govt could do. Boy, were we wrong!
Gee whiz… this is so surreal that I almost don’t know what to say. I even had to download it myself to believe it was real (and it is).
I guess uh I have to ask, if bin Laden’s “bodyguards” are in there, how did they get caught and not bin Laden? Why werent they guarding him? And exactly how is it a crime anyway to guard bin Laden?
And why are they allegedly spending more on food per detainee than for the Americans? What’s the point of that? If the food is so good or generous why not just serve the same stuff to everyone?
And thanks for the healthcare stats but uh, why are the American taxpayers paying for that? I guess what I mean is why not just give them a trial and put them in the prison system, why are the American taxpayers paying INDEFINITELY for an unconvicted person who might be let go one day?
Speaking of which, where is this budget even coming from, the dental and 4,200 calories per diem budget? The military? Is it the Army or the Navy? The CIA? Who?
And what’s up with the sneaks and the blue jeans? Is the modest dress of Afghanistan not sufficient?
And why are there shows in Arabic and not Pashto or Dari? Are all the prisoners Arabic speakers? I dont think they are.
And if the detainees are passing twenty thousands messages to their families, then why can’t we get a simple list of the detainees’ NAMES? Why did the government fight so hard to censor that? I dont need to know the secret intel that implicates them in terrorism, I just want to know their NAMES. If they’re really sending so many messages to their families, why havent the families come forward with their names?
#9 is a crock because there have been MUCH more “transparent” POW camps run by the United States in the past. And is it a POW camp? If so then the Geneva conventions apply right? Oh wait, so it’s the most transparent POW camp that’s holding exempt POW’s? Ahhh…
And #10, wow, that’s just weird. Inexplicable. Who knows how this whole thing got on the DOD website AND in WORD format. Someone’s sloppy on the sysop side of things I guess.
Weird weird weird…
Pax
I’m struck by how the last comment sounds like they are bragging about being the gulag of our times. Did someone at the Pentagon think this was a good thing to say?
It’s up there with saying “accredited by Amnesty International as the the gold standard for torture”.