Update [2005-4-17 20:23:35 by susanhbu]: WaPo story, with wonderful quotes from Sen. Leahy and staff, below the fold.
Cross-posted at DailyKos. UPDATES below fold, including “What Hostages?” As I perused this important new story from The Independent …
By Patrick Cockburn in Mosul
… The upsurge in violence across Iraq in the past four days has left claims made by the Pentagon that the tide is turning in Iraq and there are hopeful signs of a return to normality in tatters.
At least 17 Iraqis were killed during the day and two US soldiers were reported dead …
Ironically, one reason why Washington can persuade the outside world that its venture in Iraq is finally coming right is that it is too dangerous for reporters to travel outside Baghdad or stray far from their hotels in the capital. The threat to all foreigners was underlined last week when an American contractor was snatched by kidnappers.
… I heard, by chance, the news that an extraordinary 29-year-old American aid worker named Marla Ruzicka was killed by a suicide bomber yesterday, enroute to the Baghdad airport.
: : : More below : : :
Update [2005-4-17 20:23:35 by susanhbu]:
By Ellen Knickmeyer, Washington Post Foreign Service
Monday, April 18, 2005; Page A13
BAGHDAD, April 17 — In a one-woman battle for the victims of war, 28-year-old Marla Ruzicka won over Congress and the U.S. military, persuading the United States to free a precedent-setting $20 million for civilians it injured by mistake in Afghanistan and Iraq. …
The [suicide bomber’s] blast also killed Ruzicka’s longtime Iraqi aide and driver, Faiz Ali Salim, 43, as they drove the road to a U.S. military base by the airport, where foreigners travel for flights out of the country and where Iraqis go to ask for help from the American forces.
A security guard for the convoy was also killed.
“What she wanted to do was eminently sensible,” Sen. Patrick J. Leahy (D-Vt.), who pushed through the compensation package after Ruzicka proposed it, said by telephone from the United States. “Unfortunately, things that are eminently sensible sometimes get lost in bureaucracy without a champion. She was a champion I would follow anywhere.”
“It’s rare anybody in a lifetime can accomplish what she did, and she did it in just a couple years,” Leahy said.
Ruzicka came from the isolated, hilly town of Lakeport, Calif. What started out as anti-war fervor during college took her to Washington, then to Afghanistan and Iraq.
“The amazing thing is she came here as an anti-war activist, really,” said Tim Rieser, an aide to Leahy who worked closely with Ruzicka on compensating Afghan and Iraq families. But she “quickly saw that wasn’t the way to accomplish what she felt strongest about, which was to help innocent people who were wounded — to get Congress, get the U.S. military to do that.”
“In that sense, she accomplished what frankly nobody has ever accomplished,” Rieser said. “Programs were created for Afghanistan and for Iraq to provide assistance to victims of U.S. military mistakes.”
Ruzicka would lose her cell phone every other day, Rieser recalled, but she could get Bianca Jagger to a party in Kabul, win millions in public and private funds for war victims, and change the way the United States handled war, colleagues said.
Blonde, with hair variously in dreadlocks or extensions, Ruzicka could “talk, smile and bust her way into all the meetings she needed — with Afghans, Iraqis, U.S. military and U.S. Embassy people,” said Quil Lawrence, a journalist who had met her in Kabul. …
Full story: WaPo
Update [2005-4-17 12:42:59 by susanhbu]: This has to crack me up (laughing), otherwise …
By ROBERT F. WORTH
NYTimes
Published: April 17, 2005
BAGHDAD, Iraq, April 17 – Anyone in Baghdad this morning could have been forgiven for thinking the country was on the verge of civil war.
Three Iraqi Army battalions had surrounded the town of Madaen, just south of the capital, where Sunni kidnappers were said to be threatening to kill hundreds of Shiite hostages unless all Shiites left the town. As the national assembly met, Iraq’s top political figures warned of a grave sectarian crisis. Iraq’s most revered Shiite cleric issued a plea for restraint. Even the outgoing prime minister released a statement decrying the “savage, filthy, and dirty atrocities” in Madaen.
But as the army battalions arrived in Madaen, they saw streets full of people calmly sipping tea in cafés and going about their business. There were no armed Sunni mobs, no cowering Shiite victims. After hours of careful searches, the soldiers assisted by air surveillance found no evidence of any kidnappings or refugees at all. …
Update [2005-4-17 9:38:51 by susanhbu]: From Reuters:
Sun Apr 17, 2005 12:15 PM ET
BAGHDAD (Reuters) – An American humanitarian worker was among three people killed in a suicide car bomb attack on a convoy traveling on Baghdad’s airport road, the U.S. embassy said Sunday.
Marla Ruzicka, 27, the founder of the Campaign for Innocent Victims in Conflict, was driving behind a private security convoy when the car bomb exploded Saturday …
The identities of the others killed were not immediately known. Five people were wounded in the explosion and taken to a U.S. military hospital inside Baghdad’s Green Zone, a U.S. embassy spokesman said.
Ruzicka, who grew up in California, had worked frequently in Iraq and Afghanistan trying to uncover details on the number of civilian casualties in the wars and secure compensation for the families of victims.
She also spent time cataloguing the impact of war on communities, often running great risks to do so.
She is one of at least half a dozen humanitarian workers who have been killed in Iraq. Four American Baptists were shot dead in a drive-by shooting near [Mosul].
And Margaret Hassan, a British-born aid worker who ran the Care International group in Iraq, was killed …
The road to Baghdad’s international airport is one of the most dangerous in the country, with almost daily suicide bomb blasts and ambushes.
Ruzicka was shortly due to leave Iraq to return to the United States to work on securing more funding for her group.
The story of Marla’s death is so new — I heard it by chance on CNN just now — that there isn’t a single wire story or newspaper report, or any story yet at CNN. Or is it because the news just isn’t picking up her story, and the only reason CNN mentioned her death was that the reporter in Baghdad knew Marla? See below for more on news coverage of violence in Iraq. First, more about Marla:
U.S. Senator Patrick Leahy (D-VT), with information provided by CIVIC, sponsored legislation that authorizes assistance to innocent Iraqis who need housing and medical care.
Marla Ruzicka, a former protege of Medea Benjamin –according to Alternet — “has been working tirelessly in Iraq to help the many innocent victims of the U.S. invasion.”
The site for Marla’s work is CIVIC, where you can sign up for Marla’s journals from Iraq. The “About Us” page explains that “CIVIC seeks to mitigate the impact of the conflict and its aftermath on the people of Iraq by ensuring that timely and effective life-saving assistance is provided to those in need.”
The site offers no news yet of Marla’s death.
Alternet, which notes that Marla’s work is well-known to its readers, provides this brief history in a preface to a letter from Marla describing her work in Iraq:
Her work seemed to have been all about individual people in Iraq:
Marla’s site describes this scene from a photo at Commondreams.org: “CIVIC founder Marla Ruzicka visiting Ahmad, 15 and Inas 17, who lost their mother when a cluster bomb struck their home, leaving their eleven year-old brother Hasin blind, and Karwar, their 18 year old brother and breadwinner, handicapped forever. The conditions in the hospitals during the war caused the children to suffer permanent burn damage, with a high risk of developing skin cancer. CIVIC is working to get them long-term medical care and plastic surgery. Ahmad doesn’t play with his friends anymore, embarrassed by his wounds, and Inas’s dream of having a husband and family in the future is a far off dream.”
_______________________________
Perhaps the reason there is not a single wire story about Marla’s death is that we are not getting an accurate picture of the violence in Iraq, reports today’s The Independent:
US casualties have fallen to about one dead a day in March compared with four a day in January and five a day in November. But this is the result of a switch in American strategy rather than a sign of a collapse in the insurgency. US military spokesmen make plain that America’s military priority has changed from offensive operations to training Iraqi troops and police. More than 2,000 US military advisers are working with Iraqi forces.
With US networks largely confined to their hotels in Baghdad by fear of kidnapping, it is possible to sell the American public the idea that no news is good news. General George Casey, the top US commander in Iraq, said recently that if all goes well “we shall make fairly substantial reductions in the size of our forces”. Other senior US officers say this will be of the order of four brigades, from 17 to 13, or a fall in the number of US troops in Iraq from 142,000 to 105,000 by next year.
Marla, thank you for all you did and for the legacy you leave us. I do not know about the future of Marla’s program, CIVIC, but donations may be made at any time.
Update [2005-4-17 11:43:40 by susanhbu]:: Contact information for CIVIC. We can send them e-mails with our condolences:
Write to us at: info@civicworldwide.org
CIVIC’s Mailing address:
Campaign for Innocent Victims in Conflict
1630 Connecticut Ave. NW, Suite 500
Washington, DC 20009
Marla wrote this letter to the editor of The New York Times:
Marla’s Letter to the Editor
Feb 5 , 2005
The New York Times
To the Editor:
Lt. Gen. James N. Mattis’s comments during a speech in San Diego, remarking that “it’s fun to shoot some people,” in reference to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, are appalling. At a time when the United States military is trying to win hearts and minds in both countries, and when Iraqis think that American forces are trigger-happy, his words are counterproductive. For our troops who are dying every day, making war sound like a sport is beyond distasteful.
General Mattis was defended by Gen. Michael W. Hagee, who said that “he intended to reflect the unfortunate and harsh realities of war.” From living in Afghanistan and Iraq for much of the last three years, assisting noncombatants harmed in the crossfire, I find that General Mattis’s comments do not represent what it is like to lose a loved one or a home. For a parent in the United States who lost a brave young son or daughter, his words are far from comforting.
I have worked with many of our servicemen who have helped me assist innocent civilians injured accidentally by American forces. It is not fair that their acts of kindness and care are misrepresented by General Mattis’s undignified remarks.
Marla Ruzicka
New York, Feb. 4, 2005
The writer is founder, Campaign for Innocent Victims in Conflict.
This is very sad. It upsets me.
You are the best Susan. With my sinus infection I am not up to creating content, and here you are blowing my mind. Thank you.
Ohhh … I’m rushing over with a big bottle of that Naked juice my daughter drinks all the time. She’s always making me drink that stuff. Not bad, really.
I’m sure the alternative media will be all over this story and Marla’s wonderful work. I wrote to Lisa, who knows some of the folks in Code Pink and other such groups, to see if she had any more news.
Marla Ruzicka, may her soul rest in peace.
This is too sad. Will we ever know who killed her, was it a check point?
I am so burdened by the tragedy of Iraq I can’t find words anymore.
Thank you Susan for this tribute to her.
suicide bomber killed, I’m sorry I missed that part.
If I understand what you’re saying … I’m slow sometimes … it was Marla who died, along with the suicide bomber, of course.
And who knows .. maybe some Iraqis died too in that particular suicide bombing.
See The Independent above. The reporter mentions two suicide bombings that weren’t even reported. .. he’s in Mosul. The Independent surely has someone in Baghdad too … maybe they’ll find out what happened and how many died.
Sorry, I was up late last night.
I meant to print ‘suicide bomber killed her’
I can’t help it. After Sgrena, etc., I have my doubts. Especially since we only have CNN reporting the story, and only on TV (so far).
And she was killed on the infamous route to the Baghdad airport (not sure if she was on the same road that Sgrena took).
Perhaps her colleagues will be able to find out more, and tell us. IF ANY OF YOU see more stories, please share them. Thanks.
http://tinyurl.com/bsg27
U.S. Aid Worker Killed in Baghdad Car Bomb Blast
Sun Apr 17, 2005 12:15 PM ET
BAGHDAD (Reuters) – An American humanitarian worker was among three people killed in a suicide car bomb attack on a convoy traveling on Baghdad’s airport road, the U.S. embassy said Sunday.
Marla Ruzicka, 27, the founder of the Campaign for Innocent Victims in Conflict, was driving behind a private security convoy when the car bomb exploded Saturday, security officials said.
The identities of the others killed were not immediately known. Five people were wounded in the explosion and taken to a U.S. military hospital inside Baghdad’s Green Zone, a U.S. embassy
———–
It’s still vague.
Since there are survivors, there will be witnesses.
http://raedinthemiddle.blogspot.com/ says he received and email from Justin Alexander saying that, without any details as to how.
I saw this on the blog linked above, was AFK for a few minutes, and when I returned to post the quote from it here, the blog was down.
OMG. My worst fears … Hate to say it because it’s considered so tin-foil-hat, but it would not surprise me. I wonder what Sgrena will say about this.
How does a military convoy get attacked by a car bomber?
Do these cars just appear from out of the landscape beside the road to the Baghdad airport – the new highway of death?
The site is still down.
— I also just posted this in the comments section of the Kos diary — and I called my daughter, who hangs out at NGO forums and asked her to see what she can dig up from the NGO community.
Marla Ruzicka Killed in Baghdad
I got a phone call from the US after midnight telling me that Marla Ruzika was killed in Baghdad yesterday. I got an email later from my friend Justin Alexander in Baghdad:
Dear friends & collegues of Marla,
Sometime between 3-6pm Baghdad time Marla died in a car crash. My current information is poor, but the accident may have happened on the Baghdad Airport road as she travelled to visit an Iraqi kid injured by a bomb, part of her daily work of identifying and supporting innocent victims of this conflict.
A US military convoy was involved in the event, but it is not clear at this stage in what way precisely.
I have no information on the whereabouts or health of her collegue Faiz who I believe was with her in the car.
I believe it is important that Marla be commemorated and that her work continue. In the short term I hope her friends will be able to identify and help those Iraqis she was in the process of assisting.
[…]
Marla was one innocent victim of conflict among millions, but I believe her work over the last two years has made a unique impact in highlighting and helping these people often forgotten as “collatoral damage”.
Marla was my partner in the CIVIC survey project in Iraq. Someone took the above picture of me and her in the background more than a year ago in Nasiriyya. I published the results of the work on http://civilians.info.
Posted by: Raed Jarrar / 10:15 AM (17) comments
“private security” convoy, “military” convoy, it is unlikely that the circumstances of her death will ever be known.
What is known is that while she lived, she actively and openly opposed US policies and implementation of same.
Though it will be little comfort to her family and friends at this time, whatever recording of history continues past the next few years will count her as a martyr and a hero.
http://dailywarnews.blogspot.com/ Marla is mentioned on this link which I post periodically. The US saying that this supposed upsurge in attacks is such propaganda when a daily reading of this link shows how many bombings/killings/hostages are taking place daily. There is no slowing down of insurgency from my daily reading of this site. If anything attacks are becoming more sophisticated and coordinated. Does the military really think that one day the insurgents are just going to say ok I guess that’s it, let’s quit?
Dailywarnews also has link to Civic. As usual I doubt we will get the real story for sometime. No matter what the real story is this is another tragedy that is a daily occurrence for everyone in Iraq and people from all over the world who have loved ones there.
wrote an article about the hatred that the US Military has for people who calculate civilian deaths. She was attacked of course but she recounted how the first targets in Fallujah were medics and doctors who do the body counts.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,3604,1366278,00.html
Here’s one paragraph:
She goes on to lay out the case for deliberate attacks on the three groups who do the body counts.
Fantastic … sybil, please post this at Kos. And there’s some nutsack making some strange arguments on the thread.
If this is not civil war, what is?
http://tinyurl.com/a77nh
this is what I found on the french press online:
Translation:
how could we? It’s too dangerous for reporters to leave their hotels.
There were 50 killings on election day in Iraq as reported by Mark Danner much later. Did we hear about those attacks and killings on that day? No, all cameras were controlled by the US military.
Tuesday, 8 July, 2003, 11:24 GMT 12:24 UK
Human cost of the war
This is an excellent article. Please read.
.
Yahoo News Search on Marla Ruzicka
Franz Ruzicka - artist
Oui – Liberté – Egalité – Fraternité
A US convoy being involved could just mean it was in the vicinity. When I’ve read stories about taking the airport road, people are always debating whether it’s better to travel with the protection of a military convoy – to protect against kidnapppings – or worse, because military convoys are primary targets of bombers.
The road to the Bagdhad airport is supposed to be the most dangerous, most frequently attacked route in Iraq.
Here’s the latest from Reuters – on Yahoo:
“Marla Ruzicka, 27, the founder of the Campaign for Innocent Victims in Conflict, was driving behind a private security convoy when the car bomb exploded Saturday, security officials said.”
They are calling it a “private security convoy.” Could mean anything.
Where is the media coverage? In “Hotel Baghdad” in the May Atlantic [mag. subscription required], William Langewiesche describes how different news services gather information inside Iraq.
How the “majors” – print and networks – are all virtual prisoners inside the Green Zone, and rarely venture out without a military escort. How a very few print reporters manage to get out – rarely – using local contacts. And that the only group of reporters operating in-country using locals are the young, hungry independents – stringers and freelancers. Explains alot about the depth of reportage coming out. A mile wide and an inch deep.
Who’s fighting [other than military units]? In Senate testimony Gen. Meyers listed disaffected Baathists; “fence-sitters” (work for both sides); splinter groups of Sunni, Shi’a, and Kurds; individuals/small groups engaged in revenge killings; a large group of common criminals; and of course, Al Queda. To prove to obvious, the U.S. has redirected billions from reconstruction contracts to training Iraqi troops. The message is clear: There is no safe area. No one in their right mind should venture into the middle of that war zone unarmed.
Most NGOs have pulled their people out, declaring the environment too dangerous [a serious understatement]. Yet she went there. Another humanitarian gone, joining the perhaps 100 other people who died in Iraq yesterday. “Civilians”. Innocent women and children, doctors, teachers, shopkeepers, clerks – the list is long. Eventually their names will be written on stone somewhere, recorded in a book, and their families will remember and pass their stories down to each succeeding generation. But we won’t read about them until much later, in an “official abstract of statistics” compiled after the war.
We will read about the humanitarian. And in the end, maybe that will be her legacy: that she provided a glimpse into the daily horror of living in a war zone. That maybe she put a face to those names. If we’re very lucky, her death may spark a renewed call to end the fighting. But that judgement won’t come until much later when this fiasco is recorded by historians.
Today, it’s more than likely that half the people reading about her will say she paid the price of entry, that knew what she was getting into, and the other half will treat her as a martyr. I suspect the truth, as always, lies somewhere in the middle.
update up on yahoo
http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/ap/20050418/ap_on_re_mi_ea/us_iraq_activist_killed
In an e-mail message to a friend, Marla Ruzicka
described the girl sitting on her lap in a Baghdad
photo: “This is Harah, she was 3 mts old when her
mom threw her out of the window of the car and all
her family members died when a US rocket hit the car –
now she is big and healthy – we help her – thought
you would like to see the photos.”
New York Times
She was aware when she died. Her last words were “I’m alive” spoken to a medic on the scene. American Officer Brig. Gen. Karl Horst arrived at the scene shortly after and reported that Ms. Ruzicka’s car was engulfed in flames and she sufferred burns over 90 percent of her body.
“A suicide bomber attacked a convoy of security contractors that was passing near her car on the airport road in Baghdad, killing her and her Iraqi driver, United States Embassy officials in Baghdad said.”
Troops find car bomb factory
By Ned Parker in Salman Pak, near Baghdad
April 18, 2005
IRAQI commandos combing an area on the outskirts of Baghdad where Shiite residents were allegedly taken hostage have found a car bomb-making factory.
One Iraqi official also said “execution chambers” had been uncovered in the region, where US-backed Iraqi forces mounted an operation after reports of Shiite residents being held by Sunni gunmen.
Mortar rounds and artillery shells were stocked in several outbuildings surrounded by palm groves in an abandoned farm, while two cars bombs stood ready for use, a reporter embedded with the military said.
Two rusty 250lb (110kg) bombs lay next to an orange and white taxi while an artillery shell, rigged with explosives and caked in cement, was hidden in a grey van.
Both vehicles were loaded with cartons of potato chips.[…]
http://tinyurl.com/85uun