In 1975 my maternal grandmother died. I was only 5 or 6 years old. I don’t really remember her, although I remember the road trip we took to attend her funeral.
Before long my grandfather who was already 73 years old was remarried to a woman that he had known for many years, and whom had lost her husband a few years earlier. She became known in our family as ‘Grandmary’.
My Grandfather died at the age of 98, but Grandmary is still alive today, still going strong into her 90’s. Last year she visited me and I took her to see the brand new Constitution Center here in Philadelphia.
:::flip:::
As we walked around the center we came to a display that asked us to vote for our favorite American president. It didn’t offer a list of all the presidents and it was heavily biased toward 20th-century selections. I chose FDR. Grandmary chose Eisenhower.
I raised my eyebrow. Grandmary could remember every President since Taft; she lived through two world wars, the Great Depression, the Korean War, JFK’s assassination, Vietnam, Watergate, Iran-Contra, l’affair Lewinsky.
She never struck me as a conservative. But she didn’t see Eisenhower as a conservative. She saw him as a man who led this country with honor. He didn’t leave us with a legacy of deception, there was no war, there were no second term humiliations.
A close examination of Eisenhower’s two-terms will bring up plenty to criticize, including some pretty big whoppers, including McCarthyism, including the U2 plane incident. But he gave us seven years of peace and prosperity, and he left the country stronger than he found it.
More importantly, Eisenhower led the GOP back to some degree of respectability. When Lyndon Johnson wanted to pass the Civil Rights Act, he found a higher percentage of allies in the GOP than he found in the Democratic Party.
* Democratic Party: 46-22
* Republican Party: 27-6
The Original House Version:
* Democratic Party: 153-96
* Republican Party: 138-34
Goldwater famously voted against it and began the long downward slide of the GOP into the moral morass we see today.
Today’s modern GOP is built on the ashes of the 1964 election and the resentment of the Civil Rights Act. It’s built on hostility to the Warren Court that brought us desegregated schools, an end to mandatory school prayer, and our Miranda rights.
The GOP combined its traditional pro-business, anti-communist stance, with a new emphasis on racist and xenophobic and evangelical populism. Take a look at the modern Air Force Academy and you can see all the evils of the GOP condensed into one relatively small campus.
This modern GOP is born of opposition to all of the things we are most proud of in the post-war era: Brown vs. the Board of Education, the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act, the environmental movement, the women’s movement, the gay rights movement, multilateralism and the United Nations, an emphasis on human rights in foreign policy.
And now we are witnessing a GOP that tolerates torture, indefinite detainment of American citizens, rampant graft and corruption in its leaders, and even the travesty of Plamegate.
After 37 years of predominately Republican rule we are wondering whether Roe v. Wade might be overturned.
Our 20th-Century leaders were almost uniformly disappointments. Looking back, perhaps only Eisenhower and the two Roosevelts can be considered great Presidents that did little to dishonor our nation. We need the GOP to honor the legacies of Teddy Roosevelt and Dwight Eisenhower. We need two viable, moral, ethical parties.
The rank and file members of the GOP need to stand up and be counted. They need to say ‘no’ to this administration, before it is too late.
Grandmary deserves that.
Grandmary was right to choose Ike. He could have run on either ticket (Truman asked – he declined to run Democrat). From an earlier diary:
“In addition to asking ourselves what would happen in the coming election, we should consider especially what might happen to the nation and the world in the next hundred years.” [Ike, ’56]
The unique aspect of the campaigns of both Roosevelt & Ike were that both were totally in charge, and both believed strongly that the President must represent all the people.
Change based on principle is progress; constant change without principle becomes chaos. [Dwight D. Eisenhower].
You raise an excellent point – our nation needs TWO (or more?) “viable, moral, ethical parties.” You should consider submitting this as an essay to the press.
My only comment would be to insist that at least one of the parties represent the interests of the “common man” as opposed to that of giant corporations.
Was a true conservative. Goldwater was a radical. The people who run the Part today? Dave Neiwert calls them pseudo fascists (mostly because they haven’t employed storm troopers yet, I think). For me, they are simply the lowest uncommon denominator, a party that appeals to the darkest side of our collective personality as a Nation: xenophobia, bigotry, paranoia, greed, moral hypocrisy and an unfettered exceptionalism.
I long for a Republican like Ike.
I used to be a moderate independent until the GOP radicalized ALL of my moderate positions into left/progressive ones.
Thank you so very much for sharing this anecdote and your analysis. I like your Grandmary a lot.
TR would be tossed out of the GOP faster than you can say “Guckert” if he were alive today.
He and Eisenhower would be labeled RINOs, and they would lose in their respective primary races before their careers even got of the ground.
The modern GOP has all the hallmarks of a budding fascist movement. Now we have the Minuteman Project (straight out of Sinclair Lewis, ironically) popping up all over the country, which would give the GOP the brownshirt brigade (thanks, Lou Dobbs, you flaming asshole) they need to keep us uppity liberals in line. All they need is another “galvanizing event” and all the pieces will be in place.
Folks, it can happen here. It is happening here. We need to wake up and smell the coffee. This is the “wrapped-in-the-American-flag” fascism Huey Long warned us about.
I hope to god I’m wrong; god help us if I’m right.
Oh, and read David Neiwert if you think I’m off the deep-end. He has his finger on the pulse of this issue better than anyone else out there.
I’m with dinK, publish it far and wide.
This is exceptional writing, Martin. And wonderful story-telling.
Do spread it far and wide.
Looks like Little Ricky is going to skip his impersonation of John the Baptist in ’08.
Mon Jul 25, 4:59 PM ET
WASHINGTON – Republican Sen. Rick Santorum (news, bio, voting record) said Monday he has no intention to seek the presidency in 2008.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Pennsylvania conservative, who recently wrote a book titled “It Takes a Family,” said he couldn’t imagine putting his family through another campaign after his re-election bid in 2006. Recent state polls show Democrat Bob Casey Jr. leading the two-term incumbent.
more . . .
What will we tell the children?
Hat tip to a different John at Americablog.
Just think about this one small but illustrative difference between then and now. TR set up the national park system, today’s GOP wants drilling in ANWR, logging in the national forests and potentially a private administration of the parks. There is no conservatism now, proceeding cautiously, smaller government, less expenditures. Now there is only radicalism and moderates beware.
I’ve been thinking about posting on this for awhile. I’m a registered republican; coming from a long line of Southern republicans. People of color did not register as democrats in my mother’s time, and I’ve continued in that tradition. Those democrats are the ones who wouldn’t let her teach in public schools in 1961.
But I’ve stayed a republican for a variety of reason. First, because I really do believe in true conservative traditions: don’t spend money you don’t have, fewer laws for small business, and personal responsibility (as in, “I don’t need laws to tell me what to do with my body or my adult relationships”).
There are other reasons. Not enough republicans sign up to work elections around here, so changing parties would make the Clerk’s job more difficult. Because as much as I hate to listen to what the republicans are saying, I’ve enamored with the way they so consistently say it.
On evenings at town meetings when the republican crew extolls the “wonderful” work of the current administration it’s very clear to me how different I am compared to them. But my heart isn’t ready to let me switch parties.
Though times have changed.
generational thing. The parties have changed a lot since the early 60’s, that’s for sure.