Second, writing and posting rants has always served to inspire me to take action. Parenthetically, I would hope that you and the others who have criticised this particular rant would take note of the fact that the “Vichy Dems” receive this rant treatment perhaps once every 10 rants. I do aim most of my verbal vitriol at the opposition. I won’t get into why I feel it necessary at times to turn the hose on my own party — if it isn’t obvious by now, no amount of explication will suffice. For the moment, let us focus solely on the charge made by you and a few others that writing and posting such screeds serves no purpose.
Crossposted at my new Community Blog, My Left Wing
The expectation I have in composing and posting rants like this, voicing my complaints and frustration (to say the least) with my own Party members, is twofold.
1. To be heard by those people. Now, I do my fair share of civil, eloquent, succinct letter writing to the Democrats with whom I have severe problems. I also put my money where my keyboard is, so to speak. But at times, after receiving the standard form letter from one more politician thanking me for my opinion, my frustration reaches a boiling point. At such times, I feel the urge to throw up my hands in despair and give up the fight.
Instead, I write these little missives. They give vent to my overwhelming feelings of impotence — and in a forum such as this, they also serve to gather together a group of people who share my feelings. Thus, my feelings of isolation and despair are ameliorated and replaced with a sense of community and connection. And, considering the widely read status of a blog like this, I improve my chances of being heard by the objects of my complaints.
2. The other purpose in writing a rant like this is to spur myself (and, hopefully, others) to action. be it a letter written to one’s representative or a commitment to a Democratic primary opponent, whatever action one is inspired to take surely must be better than mere inchoate rage.
What a rant like this is NOT supposed to do: Actually affect change, all by itself. I do not expect the Democrats in question to read my rants and see the skies open up, struck by the epiphanous realization that they have been going at it all wrong and, by god, resolve to change their errant ways.
I understand your complaints. When Kerry was in the midst of his campaign, I was one of the more vociferous in the insistence on unity and solidarity and “Thou shalt speak no evil of thy Candidate.” Believe me, I got a lot of shit for that, and some here will never forgive me for it.
But it is 2005. Next year we see the chance to elect or re-elect worthy Democrats in the hope of affecting change. If we cannot voice our opinions and complaints, our demands and desires… NOW… when can we?
I no longer subscribe to the “Speak no evil of thy fellow Democrats” line. If we do not speak up, they will not change. If we do not make our demands heard, we will continue to receive the sort of treatment from our representatives that bothers us so. If we keep letting them do what they do, we will keep getting what we’re getting.
If nothing changes… nothing changes.
I am interested to hear YOUR suggestions regarding the sort of complaints voiced in these rants — and in the volumes of similar responses they garner.
of a comment I wrote in the aforementioned rant, in the discussion at DKos, in response to a direct question as to what purpose I think posting rants like that one serves.
I hope this clarifies my position.
I think we’re on the same page, but are handling it in a different way.
So tell us what you really mean! I am seeing ‘insanity’ on both sides now. NOTHING is working.
I love to read Maryscott, so whatever she is inspired to post online serves the purpose of pleasing ME. One might as well ask what is the purpose of going online to attack a private individual? It strikes me like painting swastikas on her house. This lady has become known to us who read the web – she is in no government position and therefore not answerable to the public. You know what Jesus said – judge not, lest you be judged. Read it and agree, or shake your head saying “what a fool.” Don’t attack, insisting that we justify our existence to you.
My complaint is that someone complained about your complaining about the lack of complaints by the Vichy Dems and yet no one complained about my complaining about the lack of complaints… actually except for you who mentioned that I should be complaining about the opposition instead of the Vichy Dems…
Damn. My head hurts. I’m going back to bed. Wake me when Hillary is President.
🙂
I think the problem lies in my failure to fully explain that it is NOT the last straw about which I am ranting — not really. It is ALL the straws. That which prompts me to rant is MERELY another straw.
Do you see what I mean? It’s not CAFTA, it’s not the Energy Bill, it’s not the Bankruptcy BIll, it’s not the flaccid, tepid approach to the filibuster — it is all these things and more — IN TOTO.
I see where you are going completely. Yes, all of the above are bad in and of themselves, but in and of themselves they can be ignored… taken as a whole they make you want to tell someone to go fuck themselves… for real.
yup, totally on the same page. 😉
I’m a bit puzzled by people who insist or imply that opinions not be uttered unless they are absolutely 100 percent vetted, cross vetted, accurate, topical, and universally applicable in each and every case.
I love reading what you have to say.. and even if I didn’t I sure wouldn’t be wasting my energy trying to drain your energy away.
You’re entitled to your opinions – rant on!
I guess I’m really just saying that you’ve got my support, for what it’s worth grins
Yeesh, I wish my solid, well thought out, tried and tested, opinions sounded as reasonable as some of your “rants.”
I’ve never been comfortable with the “we” that refers to the Democratic Party–not here, not on dKos, not only any blog. Though I have never voted for a Republican, I do not consider myself part of the Democratic Party–and don’t want to see myself that way.
Why?
When I was a kid, my family lived in Thailand. We were there during the 1964 election. My family supported LBJ–quite strongly, and I remember following the election–right through election day–at the USIS library. Even in 8th grade, I was quite excited–and happy when Johnson won.
Then came Christmas. And the bombings of Hanoi. Suddenly, the conflict in Vietnam was a full-scale war. My school doubled in size as civilians were evacuated from Saigon. The air-force officers who lived in our building in Bangkok started disappearing for days at a time–while this president I had supported so strongly said no bombing missions were being flown from Thailand.
The peacekeeper I had whole-heartedly backed against that “loose cannon” Goldwater had turned out to be incredibly destructive.
Sure, there’s lots that Johnson did that was good. Does that mean I should have supported him when he did wrong?
No. And I give the same answer to Democrats today. Don’t count on me, when you betray the trust with us.
I am not going to become like the Republicans and their chant, “My party, right or wrong.”
No, I am not going to vote for Republicans… but I can fight the Democrats, as well.
If I have to.
I am a citizen and a voter first. My loyalty is to my values. The “team” thing is contrived…its a method by which Party framers on both sides of the major parties discourage voters from going third party.
Call it the fear vote “The most important thing is that THEY don’t win…don’t vote your position, vote against them.”
There’s no romance in it. I want a party with a dream that goes beyond this silliness.
Voting out of fear solves nothing.
Short answer is that I don’t see why you have to apologize for your rant. It may have been a rant but it had a point and as I as I’m concerned was constructive. And if we can’t do a goddam rant here where in the hell can we? Where are we supposed to let off steam?
Democrats are not going to get a spine or wise up if we as their constituents don’t let them know we are unhappy with continued unwillingness to stand up and be counted-fight for democratic ideas/principles and be the goddam loyal opposition. Republican lite is not the fucken way to go. What the hell does that get us but a bigger fucken morass and stagnant country than we already have.
Democrats need to make the platform a real platform again and not some wishy-washy sorta kinda well we’ll go along this time and play nice kind of bullshit pandering to get elected.
Democratic leaders and politicians need to know that we will hold their feet to the fire for votes that sell us out and when they sell them selves out like Biden did as have many other Dems with their chickenshit votes.
At this juncture especially since bush was installed in office it makes no sense for democrats to even attempt to make themselves believe that the republicans are or will even honor any supposed compromises. Playing nice with crooks and liars has never been an option in any area of life. If you do you only get pulverized and lose your dignity to boot.
How we get a hundred more Boxers I don’t know.
An apologia is NOT an apology. It is a verbal (usually written) explanation and/or DEFENSE of its object.
I am not apologising for ranting.
Ok, I’m still trying to rub sleep out of my eyes and get a few buckets of coffee in me and just read title wrong..
To paraphrase P.G.Wodehouse:
Rant on MSOC…clarify/explain/defend as required.
I’m with you all the way-got your back, so to speak,-on this.
Peace
People Against Virtually Everything is what some have called me anda few others. One guy calls me “negative” and that I should see the positive side of things…
Like how the fuck am I supposed to see the positive in maimed children? These asshats trying to control my vagina and my sexlife? Fuck that.
Silent women never accomplished anything. Pollyanna never did shit.
I rant and I vent because it helps me focus on what to do. It helps me pick my battles. Reading your completley brilliant articles confirms to me that not everybody in this country drank the kool aid.
Now… if it was just bitching and no action… that would be different. But Silence is not golden and ranting and raging keeps one active – then HOORAY!
If one isn’t outraged, they aren’t paying attention. (some quote that I can’t remember who did)
When do we start screaming? When they carry us away? When they start using tactical nuclear weapons?
I’m a bit riled up. Saw A vision shared, the Guthrie and Leadbelly DVD. Seeing all those activist songwriters who have carried on the counterculture who also sang to children…
This land is your land…
I don’t scream.I get lowdown dirty mean.That means’Watch your back ,cause I will stab you in it ,when you aren’t looking’.This is not because I am a
mean person,it’s because you have to use whatever power you have,not the power you are GIVEN.
The nicey little crumbs that women are offered nowadays by the Vichy Dems, do not cut it. It’s full equality or nothin at all ,TYVM.
Breaks my heart that these tactics are even necessary–going backwards,it looks like to me.
Men kissin up to men and betraying the other half of the population, is what it looks like.
Of course ,those are the tactics every insurgency uses against power. So be it.
Rant on, MSOC… the only people that are going to be offended by it are likely the people that most need to hear it in the first place.
And to parapharse Aaron’s quoting of Emma Goldman above:
If I can’t rant, I don’t want to be part of your revolution.
OR
Never doubt that a small group of ranters can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has. – Margaret Mead
Might just malke it my MLW sig.
and agree 100% with it.
I’ve been active in D politics since at least ’70, and have never been as pissed with their actions (or inaction) as I am now.
Last winter at a town hall style meeting here in Fargo, I told our lone Representative that if Howard Dean was not elected chairman of the DNC then many life long democrats that I knew were going to quit the party. And there was a rumble of support from the crowd. (Although we all recognized that was just a good start.)
There are no end of us who are FED UP with “business as usual” with our D politicians.
Obviously we have an unusual situation with the R control of our government. So it would seem to require an unusual intensity of action to counter it.
RANT ON MSOC
Whose the Babe?
Looks to me like a very flattering pic of Angelina Jolie (not that there are many unflattering ones).
When I get all wild and try to rant I start to babbel. Maryscott, your rants are exercises in rage coupled with the fact that you are never at a loss for words… you can’t help it that you’re so articulate. I usually finish them with a resounding “Yeah! God Damn it!!” Keep right on ranting, dear, and I (and a lot of others) will keep right on reading them.