When early reports said 50 people joined Cindy Sheehan at her protest near Bush’s Crawford ranch, my heart sank because, usually, body count marks success or failure for a protest.
I didn’t take into account the power of this protest by a singular grieving mother of a son killed in Iraqi fighting an unnecessary war that also — as she always remembers to note — kills countless Iraqi civilians.
I knew she’d succeeded when local TV news, far away in Seattle, ran her story. Google has tracked over 600 stories on Cindy’s vow “to camp out on the spot until Mr. Bush agrees to meet with her, even if it means spending all of August under a broiling sun by the dusty road.”
A reporter from The Associated Press had just finished interviewing her. CBS was taping a segment on her. She had already appeared on CNN, and was scheduled to appear live on ABC on Monday morning. Reporters from across the country were calling her cellphone.
“It’s just snowballed,” Ms. Sheehan said beside a small stand of trees and a patch of shade that contained a sleeping bag, some candles, a jar of nuts and a few other supplies. “We have opened up a debate in the country.” (NYT)
ABC’s The Note‘s balls up the NYT story this way:
The [NYT] attributes the media attention Cindy Sheehan has attracted to a “confluence” of forces: last week’s deaths of 20 Marines from a single battalion, slipping poll support, and a White House press corps camped in Crawford, Tex. without much to do.
Baloney, Note writers. You ignored us when millions and millions of us marched before the Iraq war. Don’t you dare try to minimize a protest of one who proves it’s not numbers — but a big heart and a heart-breaking story — that matter.
As philinmaine’s diary says, “Symbols change reality.” (Updates below the fold.)
Update [2005-8-8 10:48:47 by susanhu]: Crooks & Liars has video of Cindy Sheehan from her protest near Crawford. She’s interviewed by Wolf Blitzer on CNN’s Late Edition.
And Howie Martin just sent this report:
CNN: “By popular demand ( many requests ) Cindy was on with Wolf and talked about her son, her first visit with President Bush, and her trek to Crawford in an effort to see President Bush again. She was highly critical of her first meeting with President Bush about her son’s death and talked a little bit about yesterday’s events. Crooks and Liars has the video.
New York Times (via Dem Bloggers): “President Bush draws antiwar protesters just about wherever he goes, but few generate the kind of attention that Cindy Sheehan has since she drove down the winding road toward his ranch here this weekend and sought to tell him face to face that he must pull all Americans troops out of Iraq now.
Ms. Sheehan’s son, Casey, was killed last year in Iraq, after which she became an antiwar activist. She says she and her family met with the president two months later at Fort Lewis in Washington State.But when she was blocked by the police a few miles from Mr. Bush’s 1,600-acre spread on Saturday, the 48-year-old Ms. Sheehan of Vacaville, Calif., was transformed into a news media phenomenon, the new face of opposition to the Iraq conflict at a moment when public opinion is in flux and the politics of the war have grown more complicated for the president and the Republican Party.”
I cut this paragraph from the story because it didn’t fit, but I love Sheehan’s plain talkin’:
SusanHu,
See Atrios, apparently “The Dark Side” has started in the sniping against Cindy Sheehan, in the form of Matt Drudge grumbling about politics of it all.
I think that’s obscene, but alas, I am not Karl, for whom foul deeds seem fair.
Thank you Susan for doing this story. I strongly feel it is up to us to make sure this story does not lose steam. I wrote to Preznut this morning, I am contributing to a fund for Cindy and those that want to be with her as soon as their paypal account is up, I wrote Keith Olberman, I wrote to Senators Boxer and Feinstink, I will continue anyway I can to support this True Patriot. She is doing what all of us want to do. She is holding the Crime Family accountable. The Today show just gave the story about one minute. Bush is leaving for New Mexico this morning to sign the energy bill but will not be traveling the road that Cindy is camped on but take the helicoptor instead. Fucking Chickenshit!
NBC’s First Read says:
Cool 🙂
http://www.MeetWithCindy.org
Lots of contact info and updates, how we can help a true “Noble” cause.
THANKS! She’s just great…. loved her at Conyers’ DSM hearing. That took guts, testifying alongside a longtime CIA analyst (Ray McGovern) and a former ambassador (Wilson). Her son would be so proud.
Well, this site is no longer opening up. Anyone else try and get an error message? It worked just fine this morning.
I cannot even begin to express my disgust with the Today Show. They gave Cindy about 60 seconds(typical soundbite)but my God people they just did a story about some cheerleaders, all pretty blue eyed blonds rescuing someone(very admirable) about three minutes and even had them do a cheer for all of us sheeple. Fuck that! We have a brave woman that is confronting the Chimpmaster puppetjead and that doesn’t warrent as much time? Maybe if a bunch of big boobed, scantily clothes gals show up in Crawford in bikinis the media wil cover this better. Sorry for the rant…I AM PISSED!!!!
“. . . and a White House press corps camped in Crawford, Tex. without much to do.”
I mean, it’s not like a woman grieving for her dead son and trying to spare other parents the same grief is a real story, or that thousands of parents and children and brothers and sisters – both American and Iraqi – are suffering the same grief for a stupid pointless war is a real story. it’s just a bored press corps with nothing much to do . . .
What you said, Susan. How dare they.
.
~ Cross-posted in diary by philinmaine and @dKos ~
Invasion at Normandy and Liberation of Europe: The GI’s did it FOR THEIR BUDDIES!
<click to enlarge>
Words spoken by JP —
Mr. President,
Bobby Rasmus, a nineteen-year-old American soldier who fought here more than sixty years ago, had a chance to tell his story after the war.
He said, “The reason you storm the beaches is not patriotism or bravery. It’s that sense of not wanting to fail your buddies.”
It was that spirit – “not wanting to fail your buddies”– that was the basis of the liberation of our country. In times of war, in times of danger, solidarity inspires people to make enormous personal sacrifices.
~~~
Related Diaries/Comments @BooMan ◊ by Oui
~~~
Drudge is attacking Cindy on his page right now. He’s got her photo up, along with this headline:
PROTESTING SOLDIER MOM CHANGED STORY ON BUSH
A quick google to find the source/article he was pulling the quotes from led me to this site:
Sheehans meet President Bush / By David Henson/Staff Writer
I’m sure this is the source he is using, as I couldn’t find any other links to the quotes. I did get this:
Gold Star mom hits roadblock,
which also has a snippet from the David Henson/angelfire piece.
Not sure exactly what this means, but I guess if they set drudge on you, you’ve definitely made the news…
Hmmm …
we could return fire!
Something like, “Drudge attacks grieving mother,” “bloggers’ vicious attacks…”
However. Ouch. Maybe we should wait for her to reply to that. If she said those things a year ago — Drudge is quoting a legit news article — that’d fairly call into question what she’s saying now about how cold Bush was, etc.
We could check the original article and see if he quoted her out of context, etc….
It costs $2.95 to retrieve articles older than 31 days … The Reporter.
However, I searched Google and could not find a single reference to that article anywhere…. I’ll try different combos of search terms and see if I can get it.
I searched the old archives and got zero results. I also searched via Yahoo and got zero results.
does not seem to be a conservative paper, at least editorially. I saw an editorial titled “Time for disclosure” which calls on the WH to release all documents on Judge Roberts. If the Drudge reference is incorrect one would think the paper itself would deny it.
Yes Ed – that’s what started me down this road. I saw the headline on his site, clicked through, saw no link to an article and wondered where he was getting his reporter quotes from. I googled some of the quotes … and could only find the angelfire site that has posted the Henson piece. I don’t trust Drudge, in fact fully expect him to find some obscure craziness to further his sensational reports etc.
I’ll do some checking too…
I called the newsroom for the paper. They’re going to check it out and send me an e-mail.
I said, ‘Drudge is quoting one of your stories.” He replied, “Oh really.” I told him I couldn’t find a reference to that story anywhere, so far.
Susan! You da woman! Won’t it be something if it turns out there is no such article. Even if there is and even if he quotes it accurately, good on you for going directly to the source to check it out.
Way to go Susan!
If it turns out to be bogus, I would be more than happy… actually estatic to lay a verbal smackdown on that slime…
I noticed that both Wolf and the newsmodel on CNN this morning kept referring to Ms. Sheehan as “that woman” or “the grieving mother.” A deliberate attempt to avoid humanizing her and her cause. She doesn’t fit into the story they like to tell; the devout parents who “move on” and know their baby “died for a good cause.”
Just another product to sell … no negative product reviews welcome.
It’s like the way Bush only called her “Mom,” instead of using her name. (I used to HATE it when the pediatrician’s nurses did that to me. I wish now that I had reminded them that my son is the only person on earth who gets to call me that.) The choice of adjectives is interesting, too. “Grieving,” which she is, but she’s also, “determined,” “angry,” “brave,” etc. “Grieving,” while true, lets them appear to be both sympathetic and dismissive of her. “Oh, she’s just a grieving mother, what can you expect?”
Some of Sheehan’s recent statements I have found very inspiring because she has such a grasp of how our society (ie America) cannot move forward UNTIL we grieve. This is a piercing process which the powers that be want to suppress any way they can. I have some essays on the subject at http://wbrueggemann.blogspot.com, including the original one posted last fall at Daily Kos.
There’s a reason why Cindy Sheehan has to be ignored, minimized, ridiculed or even silenced. Her grieving and encouragement of others to grieve over these bad and horrible things our country has done, threatens the very foundations of Bush’s administration, which seeks to numb the American people. It’s the only way they can stay in power (and by “they,” I mean the whole military-corporate establishment, whether it’s headed by George Bush or a Republican-lite Dem).
Excellent points.
Whoops, wrong link: here it is.
Please, let’s don’t get into a screaming match with Drudge. He’s just doing his job, which is being a ” major-league a**hole” and distracting us from having any real effect on the public discourse, and denigrating everyone with a real message. We must help Cindy as much as we can and keep our eyes on the prize.
Alice – I agree that Drudge is, well a cybergossip, who loves sensationalism. And that it takes absolutely nothing away from what Cindy, and all those standing with her, are working towards. I do think it’s worthwhile to keep aware of what the opposition is crafting in response … sort of a metric of how successful or pervasive Cindy’s campaign is, if you will. They’re willing to broadcast her message (albeit with a negative slant) on their right wing / conservative blogs and boards, so it interests me to see how they posit it in a negative way.
Millions of people will read Drudge’s headline and possibly his inaccurate story today.
We need to counter such material. That’s why, for example, David Brock’s Media Matters is so very important. As is FAIR.
But actually, the Note is correct:
It isn’t minimizing Sheehan’s guts to acknowledge that the news vacuum has a lot to do with the coverage. The media has discovered this important story precisely because they are stuck there in Crawford with nothing else to report on. It appears to be the right time, the right place, the right message, delivered by the right messenger.
If she can stay there and attract actual bodies to her cause, she can make Bush’s excessive vacation time work AGAINST him. She’s creating a genuine “scene,” and both protesters and reporters love scenes. Especially when they are unpredictable and promise a good, long story to fill up the 24 hours of news.
Someone over at the Orange Place suggested Cindy Sheehan should be nominated for the Nobel Peace Przie. So I did some research and wrote a diary about how to do it, in case anyone wanted to follow up.
I shouldda known better. It is in the process of sinking like a stone, with so far only one rather snide comment, from Frank in the Netherlands.
Now I know how Welshman felt. <sigh>
I was thinking about this, myself, this morning. My feeling is that it’s too early yet, but that what she’s doing is exactly the kind of thing that can eventually lead to Nobel Peace Prizes. Like those two women in Ireland.
Me, too. I wasn’t suggesting it be done so much as putting the information out there if anyone wanted to follow up on it. And, who knows? Perhaps the information will be useful to someone else for a different nomination.
But that’ll larn me, not to post information where people think inside small literal boxes and make snide comments.
Yes, my goodness, what were you thinking?
You should crosspost it here.
Frank is an ass. Try to ignore him.
You know, I have been reading all the diaries both here and at dkos and all the comments and this weird thought came to me. “They” have us right where “they”want us. Hear me out ok? Here is this courageous woman confronting THE president of the United States. Here are all of us on these blogs, at home, at work, at the library saying how if only we could be there with her but for the money or jobs or kids. Because of our economy and so few real jobs available we are all fearful of taking time off or sacrificing a few bucks to be there with her. Please undersatnd I am including myself in this. I am a single 53 year old grandmother that just tweaks by as it is with no reserves so it really goes back to we are somewhat helpless is supporting Cindy Sheehan. I am taking three days vacation time next week to help my sister move. God, if I had not already committed to do that I would take that time to join Cindy. I feel so torn. Am I losing it or is this guilt feeling normal?
They have a reporter on the scene, and she has posted twice today (noon and about 2;30). The’ll do daily coverage, apparently.
It’s raining a LOT here in Dallas – – radar shows possible showers in McLennan county. Hope Cindy et al are dry or prepared.
http://www.iconoclast-texas.com/
I love this site and all of archive!
You are a great webmaster
成人用品 伟哥 阴茎增大 成人用品 伟哥 阴茎增大 成人用品 伟哥 阴茎增大 注册上海公司 虚拟空间 域名申请 条形码 条形码 注册商标 商标注册 商标 安利 培训系统 考试系统 学习系统 电话营销 企业名录 市场营销 手机查询 电话查询 性病 尖锐湿疣 服装进销存 海南旅游 三亚旅游 海南酒店 三亚酒店 条码打印机 销售管理 客户关系管理 crm软件 安利 成人用品