[From the diaries by susanhu. Don’t miss the stats below on % of Nat’l Guard in Iraq — I heard the same on CNN today.] I get most of my news via various net sources, but my impression is that there are various parts of the Hurricane Katrina story that aren’t being covered.
Coincidentally enough, many of those things make the Bush Administration look bad.
I’ll give the condensed version after the jump, but American Progress has a good report here.
As a couple of folks here have mentioned, rescue and recovery efforts are no doubt being hampered by the fact that many members of the National Guard are thousands of miles away from where they’re needed, fighting a war started for — to put it politely — dubious reasons. According to an article in the Shrevesport Times:
Louisiana has 65 percent of its troops available for state missions; Mississippi, 60 percent; Alabama, 77 percent; and Florida, 74 percent, Guard officials said.
But that’s only the most blatant issue.
There an old britishism about being “penny-wise and pound-foolish”. Given the damages of this storm, perhaps we should update it to “million-wise and billion-foolish”:
Two months ago, President Bush took an ax to budget funds that would have helped New Orleans prepare for such a disaster. The New Orleans branch of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers suffered a “record $71.2 million” reduction in federal funding, a 44.2 percent reduction from its 2001 levels.
Sometimes I miss George the Elder. Well, not very often and not much, but compared to his kid, he seems positively wise:
The Gulf Coast wetlands form a “natural buffer that helps protect New Orleans from storms,” slowing hurricanes down as they approach from sea. When he came into office, President Bush pledged to uphold the “no net loss” wetland policy his father initiated. He didn’t keep his word. Bush rolled back tough wetland policies set by the Clinton administration, ordering federal agencies “to stop protecting as many as 20 million acres of wetlands and an untold number of waterways nationwide.”
And then there’s the whole climate change issue. While it doesn’t make sense to point at a specific bit of weather and say that it was “caused by global warming”, most scientists who’ve studied the issues agree that (a) humans are having a significant effect on the atmosphere, (b) global temperatures seemed to be slowly rising, (c) it’s very likely that (a) is causally related to (b), and (d) those rising temperatures will likely contribute to more dramatic (read: more destructive) weather.
AP reported recently on a Massachusetts Institute of Technology analysis that shows that “major storms spinning in both the Atlantic and the Pacific … have increased in duration and intensity by about 50 percent” since the 1970s, trends that are “closely linked to increases in the average temperatures of the ocean surface and also correspond to increases in global average atmospheric temperatures during the same period.” Yet just last week, as Katrina was gathering steam and looming over the Gulf, the Bush administration released new CAFE standards that actually encourage automakers to produce bigger, less fuel-efficient vehicles, while preventing states from taking strong, progressive action to reverse global warming.
As a side note, I hesitated before writing this diary, as I was reluctant to “politicize” the tragedy. But unfortunately, the tragedy was politicized even before it occurred. Thanks to the triumph of power over reason, everyone’s future has been politicized.
There’s another factor in this that’s rarely mentioned. While it’s not the fault of the Bush League, they’re damned unlikely to help us get ourselves out of the situation.
See, even when the waters recede, they’re going to leave behind a friggin’ mess. And I’m not just talking about the ruined buildings, downed trees, destroyed infrastructure, etc. There’s also the pollution.
This would be bad enough in any case, but in and around New Orleans it may be devastating. See, because of the groundwater conditions in that area, storage tanks have to be kept above ground. Normally, that’s safer, but a Class 4 hurricaine ain’t normal. Some of these tanks may have been (or will be) broken by flying and falling debris or by rising waters. There are likely to be hazardous chemical spills that can’t be properly contained due to the after-storm conditions. Gods only know how bad that may be. But so far, it’s the ugly possibility that damn few people seem to be mentioning.
If the chemical plants start loosing containment you can forget New Orleans, the delta parishes, and damn near the whole Gulf Coast. It’s been a while but when I lived in Algiers, across the river from New Orleans, there was some pretty nasty chemicals being used and produced: petro-chemicals, solvents, herbicides, pesticides, and etc in and around New Orleans.
I wonder if the monitoring stations are still operating.
Don’t forget the sewer system: it’s toast, and the waste is classified as a biohazard. Problem is, you can’t flush a house.
that for me makes Olberman about the only news show to watch. That stat on slashing funds and the Army of Engineers was how he started his show last night…good for him.
I don’t think it’s particularly ‘politizing’ a major disaster like this to cover the story but also show how some effects could be avoided so this doesn’t happen again ..or at least with less devastation. How many disaster plans are in place and how much money is allotted for programs like that. That’s not politics but logic and common sense..when bush fucked over the funding that made it his political problem but also a fucken human problem for the rest of the people in areas where funding was slashed.
The whole environmental disaster that is going to be effecting everyone there really has been ignored and I don’t know if that’s intentional or not.
I doubt it’s being intentionally ignored with the intent of obscuring it; I suspect most coverage now is aimed primarily at giving the best picture possible of the short-term, disaster-relief, situation. Longer-term effects are in the back seat, because they don’t make for really compelling footage while the disaster is still ongoing.
Now, if in three, four days we’re not having that conversation, THEN I’m going to start wondering…
As was mentioned in another diary, Bush also directed a lot of federal aid towards Florida, presumably to shore up his brother’s support.
As for politicizing this, I don’t believe it can be avoided. Bush’s policies didn’t create the disaster, but they did do away with almost everything that could have mitigated it.
Water rising at 17th St. canal
Tuesday, 6:30 p.m.
Mayor Ray Nagin has announced that the attempt to plug a breach in the 17th Street canal at the Hammond Highway bridge has failed and the rising water is about to overwhelm the pumps on that canal.
The result is that water will begin rising rapidly again, and could reach as high as 3 feet above sea level. In New Orleans and Jefferson Parish, that means floodwaters could rise as high as 15 feet in the next
few hours. Nagin urged residents to try to find higher ground as soon as possible.
Trouble is, almost every new report reminds me of another one of Bush’s failures. In this case, slashed funds. I keep bouncing between feeling heartache and sadness for the victims to outrage and anger at Bush. I can’t help myself. This is from NOLA.com Times-Picayune Breaking News
And all Hannity can ask about and show is the looting. They showed people taking food from grocery stores. It’s call survival Sean you asswipe!
I saw the looting headlines and I was thinking ‘who cares about that now? Then the reporter came on after a flourish from the anchor and he said that the looting had actually gone down since people are realizing that they have more important things to worry about. The same could be said for the authorities and news stations. There were images of police taking the looted goods from people and throwing them in the water. People up to their knees in rising flood water where being searched by police. It was absurd. The looters are absurd for weighing themselves down with anything but food & water and the police for trying to save goods that will soon be underwater.
NBC’s take was more focused on the dire straights, and the fact the people had nothing – no food, water, shelter….nothing. Fairly non-judgemental.
Rita Cosby showed the Wal-Mart looting clip over and over. Won’t Wal-Mart write the whole store off as a loss? Shouldn’t we be more focused on how much farther the water is going to rise in New Orleans? My heart isn’t exactly breaking for Wal-Mart right now.
Always Ready , is the USCG motto. As many of you know, Spouse is a retired CG officer (20 years) who commented today while watching video of a USCG orange & white plucking people to safety, “They’re not going to keep being able to perform those rescues. It’s not for lack of manpower. You can only keep the ‘copters in the air so many hours before mandatory maintenance has to be done. And that means down-time”
With the budget cuts to this branch of the service, it is not alarmist to be worried that some future casualties of Katrina may come from the ranks of the rescuers themselves. It would not be the first time.
Read what’s being considered for fiscal year 2006.
Even last year, you may recall, the Bush Admin., when Ridge headed the so-called Dept. of Homeland Security, called for a 30% government-wide cut in funding to the Nation’s first responders. In spite of that cut, the Coast Guard was slated to receive an 8% increase over the previous (2003) year’s allocation.
At that time, bi-partisan concern from Sens. Lieberman (D-Conn) and Collins (R-Maine) were raised with Ridge over the same issue of concern that still exists regarding upgrading and updating of USCG hardware.
Currently, it’s the House and its Republican membership that wants to eviscerate the USCG budget over political bickering, a move that could “jeopardize the mission,” according to GovExec.com
We’re not talking pork chop projects that these funding requests are being made for. These moneys would be spent on the very equipment currently appearing in so many of the rescue photos gracing MSM news sites and appearing in print.
“Homeland Security,” we plainly see, has never been a sincere priority with this president, although it is the primary responsibility of his office.
safer? Of course he only promised us a never ending war, not really “homeland security”!
Hurricane George: Nation Destroyer
Newsflash: Hurricane Central has just announced that it has added a new category to comprehend the devastating impact of Hurricane George. Up until now the most powerful hurricane was category 5, catastrophic.
But category 5 storms only destroy geographic areas, whereas category 6 storms, like Hurricane George, can devastate the entire infrastructure of a major industrialized nation.
This is accomplished though ignoring and/or contradicting all of the established and recognized wisdom of experts — such as scientists, meterologists, physicians, members of the intelligence community, military strategists, etc. — in favor starting illegal wars to enrich yourself and your friends, dismantling all environmental protections also to enrich yourself and your fellow corporate mobster pals, dismantling public education, abridging civil liberaties on behalf of so-called homeland security, rigging elections, winning public office by smearing your opponents, giving great big fat tax breaks to the wealthiest one percent, bankrupting the government, allowing corporate mobsters like Halliburton to plunder the national treasury, pretending myths like creationism are facts and facts like global warming are myths, underfunding and/or eliminating all social services, sending young men and women to fight, kill, and die on foreign soil for no reason, and going on two-hour bike rides every day to have fun and look fit and bronzed while the rest of the nation goes to hell in a hand cart.
Category 6 storms are formed when diva sockpuppets like George Bush come under the influence of evil suckcurrents like Karl Rove.
Bearpaw, this is NOT politicizing.
This is telling the truth,
stating the facts,
pointing out the obvious,
opening people’s eyes,
WAKING PEOPLE THE F— UP!
While doing all we can to help the victims, we can and SHOULD be doing exactly this. Tell the truth, as far and wide as possible.
The climate crisis, the logistical nightmare caused by Iraq and Bushhead anti-environmental policies…but the major cause of problems now and to come is that Bush has squandered the federal budget away, the surpluses he inherited, and put the government in such deep deficit that the kinds of major things that will need to be done to respond to this crisis, can’t even be contemplated.
And this is just the beginning. They may be able to throw enough resources into this to mitigate the disasters in the making in the short term resulting from this storm, though even that is not certain, but if there’s anything else like it somewhere else soon, we’ll see chaos and suffering like we’ve never seen.
People are unprepared for this because their leaders haven’t prepared them. And the government is unable to do what needs to be done even in this case, because they’ve squandered the national treasure.
If the Bush regime fails to deal effectively with this catastrophe, such a failure may be the thing that finally destroys their credibility in the eyes of those diehard members of the public who still think Bush is doing the right things. For many people, his catastrophic failures in Iraq are still so distant and still so “foreign” that they’re able to keep from getting as outraged as they should. (After all, most of those who suffer in Iraq are “foreigners”, and many people just don’t care much about their fate.) But with over a million Americans disposessed by this storm, if the government fails on this it will resonate all across the country.
(In no way am I “hoping” for such failure; I just want to make the point that people will be more outraged by failure here in the US than failure in Iraq.)
In view of the reduction of funding for levee upgrades, maybe the other British saying is more appropriate “spoiling the ship for a ha’pence worth of tar”