Of course, if you don’t want a cola — or any kind of sugared, carbonated beverage — this kind of question doesn’t help.
It seems that the same kind of thing is happening in politics, where people increasingly are seeing the two main brands, Democrat and Republican, offering two slightly different variations on the same basic treacly, gassy content.
You’d think that the disruptive nature of the internet would mean that bloggers, who ostensibly are not constrained by the mainstreaming pressures of mainstream political cultures, would be pushing for real progressive policies, or, for that matter, real conservative policies.
Strangely, when it comes to the mainstream bloggers, that does not seem to be the case. (Or maybe it’s not so strange, considering how some bloggers are now in bed with political PACs.)
Cross-posted on mediagirl.org and dKos … More after the jump….
And so we see a lot of agitation within the Democratic Party, and its supporters, to ditch its traditional values and just go for market share. Like New Coke and Pepsi Free, we get Cherry Democrat and Republican Lite, two competing products from brand names who don’t care about anything but market share.
People have noted how politics get marketed to the public. But what’s increasingly clear is how the two major parties are bringing market-think into politics.
The logic may make sense in business. MTV started with music videos, but eventually transformed itself into a reality television network, all in an effort to boost ratings, and thus perfectly “valid” for the corporate bottom line. But is this the way to go in politics? Forget what people stand for, just elect the right gangbangers, no matter how awful they are?
Does it really make sense to advocate a political direction that deliberately abandons the people who’ve counted on the Democratic Party to stand up for them? How is this a winning strategy? I thought ends-justifying-the-means rationales were discredited centuries ago.
Alas, the temptation to give in to the dark side is too great.
Some people think environmentalism is too inconvenient politically, despite the evidence that environmental problems are much bigger than politics. Some people think that women’s equality and reproductive rights are too inconvenient politically, despite the horrors that are happing across this country. They think a party should change its politics as willy nilly as MTV changes its program offerings, as long as it might gain market share.
The thing is — and perhaps this represents a break-down in my analogy — not even Coke or Pepsi would be so cavalier towards their the formulae of core businesses.
So why should the Democrats?
Coke or Pepsi? Hmmmm, what if you think that is what I have to choose from, but the only thing I see in my district/state is a choice between Pepsi or Diet Pepsi?
If I really really really like Coke, and really really really want to drink a Coke but there is no Coke on the shelf for me to buy, and I like Diet Pepsi slightly better than syrupy Pepsi, what you have me do? Perhaps I should just die of dehydration while I lobby for a real Coke to come along.
There are PLENTY of other alternatives on the local level.
NONE of the ABOVE:
If the Democratic establishment is intent on destroying the base… then don’t expect them to put the noose around their own neck.
Demcrats should stay active and perhaps concentrate their efforts on the local and state level.
At this moment there is no point on the Federal level… as witness by the Dems capitualtion on Roberts…when this administration is at its weakest point ever… They are NOT going to fight and to add to their ranks MORE capitualing Democrats is suicide.
It is time for Democrats to “Just say No” and leave some ballots blank.
I don’t reccomend “not showing up” but to show up and fund and vote for progressives. It is a lose / lose proposition to vote for MORE Republicans like Salazar/Casey/LIEberman/Taylor.
Stay active, support progressive candidates on local level… that is better than getting these Republican Dems entrenched in office.
That’s my plan.
I can’t tell them apart.
That Democratic candidate for Governer of VA advocates “covenant marriage legislation” with a reduction of the marriage license tax for couples who undergo state-sanctioned counseling with a minister or counselor just blows my mind. Hello, Terri Schiavo?? Get the government out of my personal business!!
His “faith-based opposition to abortion” and “abstinence-focused education” rounds out the Democrat’s stubborn conversion to running fundy candidates in pro-choice states.
I can’t tell them apart. And, NO THANKS, I don’t want a “taste test”.
agreed. i hereby take the pledge to never vote straight democratic ticket again. from now on i will examine each candidate individually on the issues. for those in which no candidates measure up? no vote. money to individuals, no more contributions to state, or national party.
I think the most frustrating thing about the Dems capitulations are their pathetic attempts at trying to camoflage their actions.
The whiny call to action of “Well, they will vote for Majority leader” is now getting beyond embarrasing. The right have been fighting this “War” for forty years…they have only been able to make significant headway when Democrats decided “NOT” only to be an opposition party but a party that stands for nothing at all.
They started by taking over school boards. And now with 20/20 hindsight I know understand what happened to my school system in Massachusetts. A rightwing school board elected a wingnut Latino who systematically destroyed the school system and made it almost impossible for minorities to ever have the opportunity of getting a decent education by mean of tracking students to their failure.
I didn’t know then we were at war…I assumed as everyone else did, that everyone in the end has good intentions… now I know better. And there is not a chance in hell that someone like Casey, Salazar or Taylor will EVER do the right thing… they are on their side not ours…PERIOD.
So they can whine and whinged all they want… a lie, is a lie, is a lie. We will NOT be better off by “oppressing ourselves for the greater good”. That strategy has all the makings of another Jonestown Massacre…”Drink the Kool-aid and set yourself free”.
Only in the mixed up corporatly financed world of the DLC/NDN do Democrats openly “market” that the Democratic base should put the noose around our own necks…for the greater good… and if you believe that then “I gotta levy in NOLA for sale”“
stop selling out the working class. neoliberal economics (and pandering to credit card companies) are killing us.
Environmentalism = special interest?
Reproductive freedom = special interest?
The poor/proverty = special interest?
This is the kind of thinking that I just cannot understand! To my mind, a special interest is a group of bankers who lobby for a law so that they can buy real estate cheap, traders who want to tweak securities laws in their favor, etc. etc., these are SPECIAL interests because, though they eventually affect us all, they will do so in a destructive way, whereas combating poverty, maintaining freedom for government intrusion into personal decision and fucking keeping the environment livable, affect us all immediatley and are human survival issues….
New phrase? Survival interests?
I am just so sick, sick to death of professional politics. Time for some ametuers!!
Agreed, everything has been turned on its head. Black is white, etc. Special or narrow interests (various industries, religious fundamentalism) have been embraced by the Repugs becoming their main thrusts and Democrats have faltered, letting environmentalism (amongst other things) slip to the back burner. So, environmentalism, something that has a tremendous impact upon all of us has now become the provenance of “tree huggers” and not the party as a whole. Both parties, it seems, have given special/narrow interests far greater attention lately. Priorities need to be refocused.
Clear and concise and it just threw me to the floor! I am afraid to go look at how it did on Kos girl, but I know I will…..that’s entertainment.
Have been overall above-average for dK’s standards of late.
However, the poll results are quite different:
37 votes.
The Faust votes I confess both surpised me and didn’t surprise at all. Not surprising because that’s what they talk about every day with things like the Taylor gambit, yet surprising because they’re so forthright about what they’re doing. The random votes against the poor etc. could be gag votes. After all, boys just want to have fun, too. On dK, today is talk like a pirate day. No, seriously.
The orange of democracy. Thanks for all the comments!
It’s not just for breakfast anymore…
Oh, jeez – even they now have red and blue bottles.
Lately, whenever I think about this issue, I keep hearing this old 80s song by The Fixx in my head:
Crying parents tell their children
If you survive don’t do as we did
A son exclaims there’ll be nothing to do to
Her daughter says she’ll be dead with you
While foreign affairs are screwing us rotten
Line morale has hit rock bottom
Dying embers stand forgotten
Talks of peace were being trodden
Stand or fall
state your peace tonight
Stand or fall
state your peace tonight
Is this the value of our existence
Should we proclaim with such persistence
Our destiny relies on conscience
Red or blue what’s the difference
CHORUS
An empty face reflects extinction
Ugly scars divide the nation
Desecrate the population
There will be no exaltation
Its the euro theatre (3x)
CHORUS
Its the euro theatre (3x)
CHORUS
Media Girl, this is the issue that drove me away from a site that shall remain nameless, and which fills me with impotent rage. My family were Republicans until the 1960’s when it became clear that the Dixiecrat defection had reversed the Social Justice polarity of D and R, and the Party of Lincoln was now the official racist party. I was a teenager then, and I have voted in every election for forty years. I’ve always voted a party line Democratic ticket unless it was safe to vote Green, but I’m really a Socialist. I WILL NO LONGER support a party that has no principles but expediency. If the Dems won’t get up on their hind legs and howl against the disgraceful treatment of working people, the cynical exploitation of women, people of colour, and the poor, the castration of our labour unions, the epidemic of incest and domestic violence, the deliberate dumbing down of our citizenry, the destruction for profit of our world’s environment, our imperious foreign policy, the insanity of nuclear weapons,the Partiot Act’s terrifying assault on our civil liberites, and above all the co-opting of our representative government by corporate interests, I will fight Big Business Party Number Two as hard as I fight Big Business Party Number One.
Best poll ever.
<rant>
I realized something a couple of weeks ago: I want them ALL out. I want change. I want people in government who will do something to help this country, rather than spending all of their energy trying to stay in office. I don’t give a damn what their party is — I want them helping the people of this country every single day. If they can’t do that while they’re representing the people, they should be out of a job.
I want Paul Hackett to run in Ohio. I want a decent candidate for my US rep (esp. since the incumbent [R] has broken his term limits pledge). I want my state rep (a dem) OUT, because he’s been in office for a good 15 years, and that’s enough. I want my Dem governor to lose in a primary because he’s a crook.
I’ve had it. This system is broken, broken, broken. The people in office are broken, and their tired old policies (right, center, AND left) are broken. We need change.
</rant>
This is the time to forcefully advocate the most needed changes, and to make politicians and the public aware of what we still have that it is necessary to protect.
I don’t care what the bottle is called, I care about what it is in it.
We can worry about lesser of two evils or may the better candidate win later. We marshal our powers of persuasion, and apply them where we can. That may mean using our own voices. But it may also mean using them to move those whose voices are currently louder, in this culture of celebrity at every level.
hey, E, where’s my Cracker?
You know it don’t feel well…..