Acting like a sleazy, tin-pot dictator of a third-rate banana republic, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld this week refused to allow UN human rights investigators access to detainees at Gitmo. The UN personnel are concerned about reports of widespread hunger strikes and numerous suicide attempts. Rumsfeld prefers instead to restrict access to the International Red Cross because its findings are kept confidential.
According to the Reuters article, the military claims that only 27 detainees are currently involved in hunger strikes. The detainees lawyers estimate that number is closer to 200. Rumsfeld claims it’s all a publicity stunt.
He added, “There are a number of people who go on a diet where they don’t eat for a period and then go off of it at some point. And then they rotate and other people do that.”
Sloughing off responsibility for what’s happening under his watch, he said:
Rumsfeld appeared to distance himself from the decision to force-feed detainees.
“I’m not a doctor and I’m not the kind of a person who would be in a position to approve or disapprove. It seems to me, looking at it from this distance, is that the responsible people are the combatant commanders. And the Army is the executive agent for detainees,” Rumsfeld said.
Last week, it was revealed that the Pentagon has further violated detainee rights by force feeding them without advising their lawyers. A US District Court ordered that the lawyers be notified beforehand. Force feeding hunger strikers is discouraged by an international declaration:
”The ICRC backs a 1975 Tokyo declaration by the World Medical Association [WMA] stating that doctors should not participate in force-feeding but keep prisoners informed of the sometimes irreversible consequences of their hunger strike, [ICRC chief spokeswoman Antonella Notari] added”.
While there is no international law against force-feeding, the WMA declaration “sets guidelines for doctors involved in hunger strikes and says they should not participate in force-feeding.” The American Medical Association endorsed the declaration.
As we already know, the Bush administration has virtually no regard for international treaties or declarations that get in the way of their flagrant disregard for human rights.
In addition to the hunger strikes, numerous detainees have attempted suicide. The military views these actions as purely manipulative on the part of the prisoners. One detainee’s lawyer actually witnessed such an attempt while visiting one of his clients, Jumah al-Dossari:
On October 15th in the afternoon, I was meeting with him when he needed to use the bathroom, and without describing in elaborate detail the procedures at Guantanamo, that requires my calling M.P.s to come and move him from our meeting area to a small adjacent cell where there’s a toilet. The M.P.s arrived. I left the room. Several minutes later, the M.P.s came out after having moved Jumah into the cell. After a few moments, I decided that I should check and see whether he was finished, so that I could come in and speak with him again.
I opened the door to the room that houses both the meeting area and the cell. The first thing I saw was a pool of blood on the floor, and strangely in that first moment, my initial thought was that he had made himself vomit blood because this is a symptom that he has complained about, and I had the strange thought that maybe he was trying to convince me that it was a genuine symptom and not something that he had made up. A second later, I looked towards the area of the cell, however, and saw Jumah hanging by his neck from the top of a mesh metal wall that encloses the cell. He also had what appeared to be a very serious gash on the inside of his right arm, which was causing him to bleed on himself and also on the floor.
I immediately yelled for M.P.s, who arrived quickly. I called Jumah’s name several times, but he did not respond, and as best I could tell, appeared to be unconscious. The M.P.s arrived, cut him down from the noose that was holding him and put him on the floor. Still didn’t seem that he was conscious, and I also didn’t see him bleeding at all. Within a moment or so, I was asked to leave the room, or ordered to leave the room might be more accurate, and as I did I saw Jumah seeming to gasp, which at least struck me as a good sign.
The lawyer, Mr Colangelo-Bryan, was not allowed to see Mr al-Dossari later that day or since then. You can read or listen to his interview with Democracy Now’s Amy Goodman here.
As a WaPo editorial declares today:
No wonder Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld has denied permission to U.N. human rights investigators to meet with detainees at Guantanamo: Their accounts would surely add to the discredit the United States has earned for its lawless treatment of foreign prisoners.
That editorial goes on to chastise Democrats over their handling of the issues of detainee rights:
There is no more important issue before the country or Congress. Yet the advocates of decency and common sense seem to have meager support from the Democratic Party. Senate Democrats staged a legislative stunt on Tuesday intended to reopen — once again — the debate on prewar intelligence about Iraq. They have taken no such dramatic stand against the CIA’s abuses of foreign prisoners; on a conference committee considering Mr. McCain’s amendment, Democratic support has been faltering. While Democrats grandstand about a war debate that took place three years ago, the Bush administration’s champions of torture are quietly working to preserve policies whose reversal ought to be an urgent priority.
While Republican senator John McCain (who will be on CNN’s Larry King Live show Thursday nite) has surely taken on the difficult task of condemning his party’s leaders on the issue of torture, it cannot be said that the entire Republican party – which holds all of the power in Washington these days – is exempt from the type of criticism that this WaPo editorialist is flinging at the Democrats. It’s time for the Republicans to stand up and demand action – to make that “dramatic stand” themselves – because they are the only ones at this point who can actually do anything about the abuses.
Embarrassed by Wednesday’s revelations about secret CIA prisons and with the EU now set to investigate those which may exist in its member states and while Scotland has declared it will investigate US torture flights, the pressure is on the Bush administration to come clean and change its policies. Considering the arrogance and blatant disregard of Bush’s cabal towards human rights, it seems likely that the only way anything will happen is to oust the obstructionist Republicans from the US government so the Democrats can move in and clean house.
Publicity stunt?
Of course the hunger strike is a publicity stunt. The detainees need publicity.
Thanks for the diary.
Err… unless it’s just a “publicity stunt.”
If it is, then, THANKS EVEN MORE!
Democrats coming in and “cleaning house” is just as likely as the Gitmo “investigations” turningup any wrongdoing.
As the editorial points out, Democrats aren’t willing to go that extra mile, or even foot, to stand up to the bullshit that is going on with the detainees — I am ready for some intervetion, but you can be assured, that it will not come from within.
I’m not letting the Dems off the hook but it’s irresponsible of that WaPo editorial writer to not place the responsibility squarely on the Republicans’ shoulders.
Really! Why is this now a dem problem? Almost every amendment they have tried to get passed has been voted down. I am not saying they should not be right out front screaming bloody torture but why do the republicans not get called out as they are the ones that keep voting for the party line, not in the best interest of the country’s national security or for human rights.
But brin is right, too. Bush will go to hell for starting this, Republicans in general deserve to be hanged for trying to make it settled procedure.
But it is the Democrats to whom we can in theory apply pressure. And each day that Democrats can sit there in the august halls of power and discuss anything other than why we are torturing and killing people in secret for a war that the President lied about is another day their souls shrink, and we all suffer.
I agreed with that absolutely. I said they should be right out front screaming bloody torture didn’t I. So we are all in agreement there…right?
For the same reason it is a “rep problem” or an ANYone problem.
I sit here in my humble abode and do all I can, and have lost hope that ANYone who has the power to stop this madness will.
It is all well and good that there are people in congress who will write letters and put things on the record, hell, even call a closed session to draw media attention. But excuse me while I continue to be cynical as hell that any of them ACTUALLY are about changing a thing OVER their re-election — I just do not see it.
Even if I were a congressperson from Podunk, Middle of Nowhere, I could get media coverage if I stood up and shouted from the rooftops about this, especailly if I stood with my fellow Americans while doing it. It doesn’t take courage, it just takes conviction — and I don’t see that any of these folks have it enough.
I agree Brinn. ALL Americans, repub, dems representatives, ordinary citizens should be outraged. I think part of the problem for me at least is that I don’t know if I really have any outrage left. Know what I mean?
Maybe I’m just tired, but what fries me right now is that yesterday’s revelations of probable CIA gulags in Eastern Europe washed over me with the same effect that the news of DeLay’s Democratic judge being dismissed did. I got to a certain level of outrage in both cases, but one is partisan political crap, and the other is about humans being tortured and killed, while destroying whatever credibility my country had left.
So I’m outraged by my lack of commensurate outrage.
I often wonder how much I’ve shortened my life by stressing so much about what’s going on, apparently to the point where my stress circuits fail to deliver peak output. Then I tell myself a longer life won’t be worth living if we can’t somehow put a halt to all this.
That is why my friend, as much as it pains me to say, I need to take breaks from news, blogs, tv and internet stories from time to time. If I don’t I am so afraid of becoming immune to all these atrocities. When I come back from a breather I have more room for the outrage I should feel. Let’s stay outraged together and support each other when we see that hope fading. That is why the blogs, especially Booman are so great. The support is always there.
Lee, damn, I do know what you mean. I am getting to the point where the politics of “I don’t give a flying rat’s ass” is looking more and more attractive. (and this is the second time today I’ve said that…)
I look at my kiddos and think about others’ and grandkiddos and these motherfuckers in Washington become more and more and more irrelevant……EXCEPT they have all the power to be doing all of these hideous things.
I feel like every day of consciousness consists of banging my head against a wall that not only softens my brain but actively sucks all semblance of sanity out of it.
And now, I am crying because all that has happened these past five years makes me so damn sad and angry and scared for the kids’ futures. I do not recognise myu country anymore. I never in my wildest imagination dreamed anything like this could happen in my lifetime. I so want to go hide under a rock somewhere and wait to come out until this madness ends but I know me and I know that is impossible. But I am tired and want it all to go away. I know I am rambling…sorry folks.
I remember your kind consideration of me, when you siad that in times of stress it is often hard to have a stranger in your house, and I said, you aren’t a stranger, and I wnat you here.
I remember seeing your face at my door and you apologizing for crying — please don’t apologize. You are a passionate, empathetic person, as am I and I wish we hadn’t butted head so hard of late, but I would much rather be banging me head against yours than against the infuriating madhouse the larger reality of our country has become. And I know, and think you do, that it only happens because we care.
As to the future for our kids/grandkids (my oldest is only a year younger than your granddaughter), they’ll have each other (and all of the other wonderful kiddos being raised ’round here) if nothing else — and they’ll find each other just as we did.
Can I crawl onto your lap and help you cry now?
I am sorry too that we have butted heads too, really sorry. I think we are all so damn outraged and frustrated that for me anyway, all it takes is one more little thing to send me into a rant and I just do not want to live that way. SO peace/truce? I sure hope so. God knows we have enough enemies we don’t need to go after one another huh? Thank you so much for responding. I was hopeful we would eventually if we just gave it a little time.
And Lil, we need you gal so hang in there and know that we love you and we WILL get through this together. Namiste gals, namiste! Now, lets go punch somebody…lol! Calling Karl, Karl you are needed here.
peace/truce, of course. I’m sorry (hah, BooMan, guess you shoulda placed a bet on that “I WILL NOT APOLOGIZE spew I wrote, eh? lol).
Some days I don’t know what to do with the outrage/rage and it gets sent all ’round and hits in all the wrong places…yes, I insisted that you come here because I wanted to see you and hug you and I won’t ever regret that I did, neither, I think, will Scott — have you heard from him at all? I am thinking about sending him an email, just to say hi…
I have a bunch of not-so-happy crap going on in RL right now, and it is mostly my fault for avoiding and procrastinating and basically, not dealing with it. Just a reason, not an excuse.
As far as the whole “the world sucks and the handbasket to hell is full”, I take heart in what my mom told me when I was considering my choices when I was [regnant with eldest (single, unable to identify the father, etc.) and said to her “But the biggest worry I have, is how could anyone bring a baby into this fucked up world!?!” and she said, “Well, I don’t know, but we’ve been doing it for centuries. When I was pregant with you (mid-60s), we had duck and cover and the fear of being anihilated by the instant breakdown of the ssecurity MAD (mutually assured destruction) at any moment, and yet, here you are, and I don’t regret it….”
We humans are a very very curious species — at once wonderful and awe-inspiring and beautiful and horrific and brutal and agaonizing — if I know what to amke of us before I pass on, I will truly be amazed.
PS You have my number too — call any time you like.
(((((alohaleezy))))
right now…..yeesh.
Right back at you girl. I haven’t heard from Scott but would love to email him. I got sick that hot day in Crawford as you know and never got a chance to say good bye. I would love his email if you have it. I will email you tonight. AND I hope you know how much I wanted to meet you too and how very very grateful I was for all that you did for me and that you “insisited’ <snark> that I come to your house. I will never forget that day as long as I live. See Boo, we can be grown ups when we want to. Teehee!
Wow. Who knew that my posting of this diary would bring you two back together? I’m stunned.
Life works in mysterious ways…
Damn, now I’m crying.
More and more often lately I find myself wishing it was all a dream. Then I think about people in other countries trying to survive under extremely harsh conditions, whether natural or political or both (as in Pakistan right now), and I’m ashamed of myself. God I’m tired too.
Fantastic post catnip, you managed to sum up all of the atrocities in a cogent manner.
I agree Catnip your an excellent writer. I saw Jimmy Carter last night talking about this and other subjects. Scum sucking Chris Mathews asks him twice about some far fetched scenario about stopping a 9/11 by catching someone and torturing information out of them. Extremely far fetched and maybe the reason we have false terror alerts all the time anyway. I wouldn’t doubt a lot of the chatter we hear about is only the chattering teeth of people who have had the living fuck beaten out of them. Anyway carter was a little peeved the second time he had to tell dim bulb Mathews that torture doesn’t yield accurate information.
.
Libby and Niger Forgeries – Italian SISMI Investigation
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
I heard that interview and it was heart wrenching. Also,not to sound cynical but if my client cracked a joke, went off with a couple mps and was next found hanging and bleeding my first thought wouldn’t be suicide attempt but a homicide attempt. That said, we have to stop this somehow, it’s too horrible for words.