I received this today from Julie Smith, a well-known mystery writer from New Orleans and a long-time friend of mine. She has given me permission to share it with you. I’ll let Julie talk now.
Dear Friends: We’re in a panic down here, the second in three months. (You know what the first one was.) Somehow or other–I really can’t think how–aid to Louisiana, rebuilding our levees, treating us like any Americans in trouble has become a political issue. It shouldn’t be. Some of us are Democrats and some are Republicans, and we’re all in it together. I’ve just learned the right-wing political pundits have begun taking us on–Rush Limbaugh in particular–with a ton of misinformation and vitriol. On the other side, there was 60 Minutes, with its shocking one-source documentary.Where all that’s coming from I really have no idea. I honestly can’t believe anyone could question of whether to appropriate money to rebuild our levees (and the rest of the city). We’re an American city. We deserve to be treated as such.What makes us different from any other one? Crooked politicians? We’ve had them in the past, but we don’t particularly now. So has your city, whatever it is. If this is what it’s about, it’s a smokescreen. Oversight can be built in to any spending plan, and it should be. What responsible legislative body wouldn’t include it? Or is it about the concern that we just shouldn’t have built a city here? Tulsa was flooded and it recovered. Anchorage had an earthquake and it was rebuilt. If The Big One hit San Francisco, there’s no doubt in my mind anyone would debate rebuilding. The Times-Picayune wrote “they act as if we wore our skirts too short and invited trouble.” That about sums it up. What’s happening here? I’ve never been so bewildered.
The point of this letter is that we need you to write to your Congressmen (and women) to get us help. I’d also like to clear up a little misinformation I understand is circulating. Here are things I keep hearing:
1. New Orleans is a toxic waste dump. It isn’t. Some chemicals have been found in some of the soil, but there are no alarming reports.
2. There are plenty of jobs, but no one wants to do them. This one is particularly galling–there’s no place for anyone to live! Workers are camping in the parks and living in RV’s. Not everyone can do that, and anyway, it’s illegal. This is a huge problem, and it’s not going to get solved without a lot of help from all branches of government.
3. The state misspent money that was supposed to go to levee repair. But the Corps of Engineers is a federal agency! One variation has it that the money was spent on casinos. The only reason we have casinos is to bring in tax revenue. We don’t spend money on casinos–we depend on them for money.
4. Our public officials are so stupid we deserve to be deserted. You know, they’re really not–and we don’t. They’re not Rudy Giuliani, (and don’t we wish we had him!)–they’re just ordinary people of slightly -above average intelligence from a backwater state, who never in a million years thought they’d be called upon to do this kind of a job. They’re overwhelmed. It’s too big for them. Would yours be any better? Would Giuliani? Consider this–9/11 knocked out 16 acres. Katrina and Rita together devastated 23,000 square miles. 9/11 was over–even the searching–in the amount of time the government took to even get some rescue units in here. Three months later, we’re still a shell of a city. New York didn’t lose 80 per cent of its land mass and 85 per cent of its population. Giuliani never had to evacuate an entire city. Who knows if even he would look good in our circumstances. And if you don’t personally like our mayor and governor, since when do we punish citizens for making poor choices, anyhow? (Besides, you should have seen the other guys.)
5. Things are not getting back to normal here. Actually, the situation is quite dire. Things aren’t bad for us personally, but we still don’t have mail service or a landline phone. Try living that way. We don’t mind because it’s little enough, considering. Most– not a little, but MOST of the city still has no electricity and no gas. Families are split, there’s no place to live, schools haven’t reopened. Hardly; anyone’s come home because they can’t–they have no homes, not even FEMA trailers. and no faith that the levees will be rebuilt,
Please, please take a minute to write your Congressmen and senators. If you can, even send the letter below out to your mailing lists, and ask other people to do it. Your help would be so much appreciated. What follows is a “friends and family letter” (as you can see, I wrote my own.), a letter for lawmakers, and a list of addresses. Many thanks for any help you can offer. Julie Smith
Friends & Family Letter
Dear Friends and Family,
I am asking for your help. New Orleans cannot rebuild unless congress supports levee protection that will not fail when a storm comes. New Orleans is an important American city. Would people say to give up on San Francisco or Chicago or Miami or Anchorage or New York because it was just too expensive to protect? Well that is what I am hearing from the media across the country and from individuals in congress. The fate of greater New Orleans’ levees lies with the committees and lawmakers below. Please contact them in some way and let them know that New Orleans matters. However you communicate, use your own words, and speak from the heart. Please share this email with as many people as you can. Maybe in this way congress will hear that America really does care about New Orleans. If, by chance, you know any legislator personally, please contact them.
Letter to Lawmakers Here is a sample message. Feel free to just copy, paste and send it to all of these listed below.
Dear Sir;
I write to implore you to support legislation solely involving the re-securing and re-building of New Orleans. It is imperative that appropriate and immediate funding for the proper and timely construction of the levee system around the Greater New Orleans Metropolitan area be approved.
New Orleans plays an important part in the economic welfare not only of the area but for the entire country! North, South, East and West depend on the vital traffic of goods and services that New Orleans and its people have always provided through its port.
Thank you
SENATE MAJORITY LEADER
Sen. Bill Frist, R-Tenn.; 509 Hart Senate Office Building, Washington, D.C.
20510; (202) 224-3344; Web site: <http://www.frist.senate.gov>
www.frist.senate.gov.
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Sen. Thad Cochran, R-Miss, chairman; 113 Dirksen Senate Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20510; (202) 224-5054; e-mail address:
<http://us.f312.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=senator@cochran.senate.gov>
senator@cochran.senate.gov.
Sen. Robert Byrd, D-W.Va., ranking member; 311 Hart Senate Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20510; (202) 224-3954; e-mail address:
<http://us.f312.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=senator_byrd@byrd.senate.gov>
senator_byrd@byrd.senate.gov
Sen. Ted Stevens, R-Alaska; 522 Hart Senate Office Building, Washington,
D.C. 20510; (202) 224-3004; Web site: <http://www.stevens.senate.gov>
www.stevens.senate.gov
SENATE BUDGET COMMITTEE
Sen. Judd Gregg, R-N.H., chairman; 393 Russell Senate Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20510; (202) 224-3324; Web site:
<http://www.gregg.senate.gov> www.gregg.senate.gov
Sen. Kent Conrad, D-N.D., ranking member; 530 Hart Senate Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20510; (202) 224-2043; Web site:
<http://www.conrad.senate.gov> www.conrad.senate.gov
SENATE ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla., chairman; 453 Russell Senate Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20510; (202) 224-4721; Web site:
<http://www.inhofe.senate.gov> www.inhofe.senate.gov
Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., ranking member; 511 Hart Senate Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20510; (202) 224-2651; e-mail address:
<http://us.f312.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=max@baucus.senate.gov>
max@baucus.senate.gov
SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE
Rep. Dennis Hastert, R-Ill.; 235 Cannon House Office Building, Washington,
D.C. 20515; (202) 225-2976; Web site: <http://www.house.gov/hastert>
www.house.gov/hastert
HOUSE MAJORITY LEADER
Rep. Roy Blunt, R-Mo.; 217 Cannon House Office Building; Washington, D.C.
20515; (202) 225-6536; Web site: <http://www.blunt.house.gov>
www.blunt.house.gov
HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Rep. Jerry Lewis, R-Calif., chairman; 2112 Rayburn House Office Building;
Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-5861; Web site:
<http://www.house.gov/jerrylewis> www.house.gov/jerrylewis
Rep. David Obey, D-Wis., ranking member; 2314 Rayburn House Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-3365; Web site:
<http://www.obey.house.gov> www.obey.house.gov
HOUSE BUDGET COMMITTEE
Rep. Jim Nussle, R-Iowa, chairman; 303 Cannon House Office Building;
Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-2911; e-mail:
<http://us.f312.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=nussleia@mail.house.gov>
nussleia@mail.house.gov
Rep. John Spratt, D-S.C., ranking member; 1401 Longworth House Office
Building, Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-5501; Web site:
<http://www.house.gov/spratt> www.house.gov/spratt
HOUSE RESOURCES COMMITTEE
Rep. Richard Pombo, R-Calif., chairman; 2411 Rayburn House Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-1947; e-mail:
<http://us.f312.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=rpombo@mail.house.gov>
rpombo@mail.house.gov
Rep. Nick J. Rahall II, D-W.Va., ranking member; 2307 Rayburn House Office
Building, Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-3452; e-mail:
<http://us.f312.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=nrahall@mail.house.gov>
nrahall@mail.house.gov
HOUSE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Rep. Don Young, R-Alaska, chairman; 2111 Rayburn House Office Building,
Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-5765; Web site:
<http://www.donyoung.house.gov> www.donyoung.house.gov
Rep. James Oberstar, D-Minn, ranking member; 2365 Rayburn House Office
Building, Washington, D.C. 20515; (202) 225-6211; Web site:
<http://www.oberstar.house.gov> www.oberstar.house.gov
If any of you want to copy this to another blog, feel free. The idea is to get as much help as possible.
Everybody who has followed blksista’s diaries knows how dire things are for so many people.
this with us, kansas. I have posted an entry at my blog and will forward to the Az Bloggers Network.
That’s great, ManE. I’ll let Julie know of your efforts and I know she’ll be grateful.
I should have mentioned duranta’s diaries, too. Here’s the latest:
LINK: duranta.
I can’t believe that we’re even debating whether to rebuild NOLA and I can’t imagine what it’s like to be a citizen just wanting to get your old life back and having to beg and borrow and enlist the help of strangers to do so. We have such a short attention span as a nation. Katrina was a good story for about 3 weeks, and then it was just business as usual when there were no more bodies floating around for the camera. When we see news accounts of how Bourbon street is coming back to life it’s tempting to think that the whole city is coming back. It’s not. Bourbon street and the casinos are not the heart of New Orleans. The heart of New Orleans are the people who have lived there for generations, and many of them have nothing to come back to.
Let’s get to work and call these people, or inundate their inboxes.
http://www.congress.org/congressorg/home/ This gives you access to finding address/phone numbers etc to Congress and also your state and local officials.
I keep reading and saving so many articles on what is happening in NO and it really is unbelievable how almost nothing is being done in the way of help. And it’s not really just NO but the other Gulf states aren’t getting the help they need either from FEMA or other agencies nor are many of the states that had big influxes of people from NO.
I don’t think that any help is going to be forthcoming to any of the states and particularly to NO unless many many more people start sending letters/emails and get this issue into the public consciousness. Bushco is going to everything possible to continue to NOT do a damn thing.
I know one link I put up in one of blksista’s diaries was about the fact of medical attention…for gods sake doctors/nurses are working still in tents-tents mind you in NO-that’s beyond unbelievable.
So much depends on the levees.
That’s something else that is so incomprehensible to me that after some 4 months that a new plan for rebuilding the levees isn’t in place and already begun work on. By that I mean of course a new and innovative plan for the levees and repairing the land also that is sinking. What’s the point of trying to rebuild the city if that isn’t done?(as others have mentioned also) Then on to getting clean up done fast and safely for all workers with all electricity already back on so people could start moving back and have that electricity on-including as I’ve mentioned hospitals or temporary hospitals able to operate to help adequately care for people who are coming back.
Last I knew also there are still people in some of the other states living in tents with their kids-like this is a third world country.
A plan for the levees, etc to protect the city should have workers working round the clock to make sure when hurricane season comes around in just another 6 months or so the city won’t be wiped out again. This is just so scary that nothing is being done.
nola will be rebuilt
as soon as they figure out how to rebuild it for the rich people only
if you think they are going to build affordable housing that all the poor people can come back to you must stop drinking now
FWIW. Sent an e-mail to Brian Williams (think he might be interested) asking him to read this story. I am appalled at the lack of action in N.O. What happened to all the money (50 Billion or so) that Congress approved in Sept for emergency aid???
Maybe it was just transferred to Halliburton??
But, I’ve got this hangup: I hate the condescending letters politicians always send me in reply to something heartfelt I’ve sent them.
The dismissive pat on the head.
It especially bothers me when it comes from my democratic congressman — because then I bad mouth him instead of offering my full-on support.
I’ll do it though, if you think it really would make a difference with our guys. What do you think?
I know what you mean – try having John (boxturtle) Cornyn and KayBee (bops staffers on the head with 3-ring binders) Hutchinson for Senators and Lamar (DeLay clone/sycophant) Smith as Representative. Yuck. Yuck. and Yuck. If they reply at all, it’s sickening spin/propaganda/talking points.
But we really need to do something to keep the fate of New Orleanians from being lost to public consciousness. Letters to lawmakers can’t hurt. And they might help. Better to do something, even when I’m not sure it will do any good, is how I look at it.
My next comment is going to be a link to my blog, where I’ve made all the addresses into clickable links so it’ll be easier to send letters if you do it from there.
I think that is wonderful of you Janet — but for me, I use web-email not outlook or other application. So it’s all manual. I think.
I just told kansas that I’m going to do it.
Dennis Moore and all the other are just going to have to show me what he’s made of!
Most of the links to the Reps are to web sites – they don’t list actual email addresses – you have to go to their web sites and fill out an email form. The links from my blog might help you get to their web sites more easily.
I love you!
😉 Ball o’ yarn coming your way – and see note below.
There are a lot of people we can write besides our own reps – committee chairs and such. Julie included their addresses in her letter. Those are the ones I’ve made links to.
I’ve posted this at Jackie Strange (my rarely updated blog).
I made all of the addresses into clickable links if you want to use those for your letters. And if you want to use that formatting on your blog or in an email to your friends (if your email does html formatting) I think you can do the “View source” and just cut and paste.
[btw, kansas, Julie Smith has long been one of my favorite writers. I also used to work as an editor – hence the compulsion to add more paragraph breaks and make clickable links in her letter. Couldn’t help myself. And now I can say I’ve “edited Julie Smith”! Can’t wait to tell my friends.
Someday I’ll have to “edit” one of your comments so I can add you to my resume, too 😉 ]
That’s all great, Janet. And Julie will so laugh when she sees your comment. You’d love her. GREAT sense of humor. As for my comments, oh man! Could I ever use an editor!! 🙂
Well she sure has I nice website! I think anyone with such a nice website has to be a good author.
Don’t you?
Can anybody tell that katiebird is doing my website? 🙂
Seriously, her website is like a party — it looks very exciting and like you can never read it all.
And I’m more like dreaming of working on your website as long as I’m stuck on this emergency computer. I’m barely functioning.
Actually, I think the Republican Congress might hesitate to rebuilt SF if we had the Big One right now.
But will try to get Pelosi on the case.
Thank you, on behalf of.
Great diary!
I think some of this message needs entirely different targets than Congress, though.
I am in Dallas, and evidently there was a sort of “evacuee town hall meeting” on rebuilding. Local media coverage (Dallas Morning News, local news on our NPR affiliate)sahred comments from participants in their coverage. Things along the line of
‘where I am now is so clean – no papers, bottles, trash in the streets’ (she’s in a nice white-bread/white people suburb)
and “the first thing we need is not money, it’s for you (the N.O. leadership) to stop stealing the money we have”
and “now we have seen how good cities can be run/how low crime can be/what excellent public education looks like” (Yeah – fellow Texans and Dallasites – have a good laugh about all that!!)
Maybe these statements reflect the views of most N.O. evacuees, or just those who were at the meeting, or just the few who gave our local media some soundbites to pat our local selves on the back with. Whatever.
Before impacting Congress there needs to be a strong voice from NOLA rebuilders and an effort to get media coverage. Why would my Texas Cong-critters give any weight to the suggested letter if they, and many of their constituents, are getting this Babs Bush style message that the evacuees are better off than ever, and happier than they could have imagined, in their new communities?
Or wait another 3 months until the shine wears off on the charitable impulses of the locals; combined with the evacuees “nice place to visit, but…”
The comments you heard on the TV interviews are pretty much the same as I’ve been hearing from Katrina evacuees living here in Austin now, off camera. One thing I hear over and over is about the schools – how much better the schools are here. Which – given that you and I and the vast majority of our fellow Texans think our schools are (generally – there are exceptions, of course) appalling – really says something to me.
But I suspect that everything about this is more complicated than it first appears. EVERYWHERE in America, as far as I can see, we tolerate (WHY the HELL do we tolerate this?!!!) great inequities in educational quality in our public schools. (Sorry to shout, but this really pushes my buttons.) “Good,” well-to-do neighborhoods/districts have good schools, poor neighborhoods and towns have crappy schools.
Could it be that the evacuees have ended up in “nicer” neighborhoods as they’ve settled in here? Would the schools their kids are attending be just as bad as the ones they left behind in NOLA if they had been given housing in poor neighborhoods?
And, yes, most of the folks I know do not intend to go back to NOLA, say they’ll never return. But I wonder if that will change as their relief at being rescued and brought to a place that was clean and dry and filled with an outpouring of love and help gives way to homesickness for the NOLA they knew, for the family and friends now scattered. Who might bit by bit realize that if they are all going to be together again, they will have to, one by one, whenever and however they can, return to New Orleans.
There will be people living there. Besides the people who go back because they simply miss New Orleans too much, a port at the mouth of the Mississippi and all those oil platforms are going to make it inevitable that there will be people living in the path of the next Katrina. That’s the reason we need to be raising holy hell (or at least writing those letters) so we aren’t, as Mike Tidwell says, luring people back into a death trap.
I work with a young black man who grew up in NO. He came to MN on a college basketball scholarship long before Katrina. He says that when he looked around at what was happening to his friends, he KNEW he could never survive if he stayed in NO, that his only hope was to get out. Now he’s working with urban middle school kids (mostly black) here in St. Paul trying to help them succeed in school.
I keep thinking about what he said about not being able to survive in NO. Its like being a refugee in your own country. And I wonder what that must feel like to a young person. Its just so sad that we let that happen here in our urban areas.
I suspect that NO’s major error was in having voted Dem. No joke, those dreadful BushCo people are just that small and nasty and petty. Not to mention utterly incompetent.
This link came to me via a writers’ loop at the end of August, listing various writers affected. Julie Smith is on it, and others. There are also updates included and some links of places you can send some help if you’re so inclined.
p.s. Kansas: Like Janet Strange, I’ve been a professional editor. Your subject line had too many characters, so I edited it. Nyah, nyah, Janet, I got to edit Kansas! 😉
lol! Who knew editors were so funny? Nyuk nyuk.
Everyone acts like I’m too cynical for saying this, but I’ll keep it saying until I’m convinced otherwise: it strikes me as odd the administration began worrying about the cost of reconstruction when it came under attack for patronage and no-bid contracts. I understand that there are legitimate concerns about the national debt, but didn’t “Reagan prove that deficits don’t matter?”
Also, I think Jeff Bingaman’s name needs to be added to that list. I have no idea where he stands on reconstruction financing; he’s probably supportive. However, as ranking member of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, he’s been adamently opposed to a fairer offshore revenue deal for La. La. gets less than 1% of the offshore revenue collected by the federal government, with onshore revenue states get 50%. That would be an average of $2.5B every year for La. Bingaman has some valid reasons, but if he’s going to oppose a deal that would let La. finance everything by itself, he should be out front on Reconstruction and Coastal Restoration financing. At least as vocal as he is on offshore revenue sharing. senator_bingaman@bingaman.senate.gov
I just visited your blog, MOLDY CITY/ moisie cité, cité pleine de rêves, and I am impressed as hell. I try to keep up with the New Orleans news, but there is a lot of information there that I haven’t seen elsewhere. And your commentary is right on – your knowledge of New Orleans and your insight adds a crucial component to the understanding of people like me who didn’t know much about NO before Katrina and now are trying to make sense of how a large American city can simply be abandoned. For example, the info in your comment above about Bingaman and the offshore oil revenues is something I would never have known without your input.
(Not to mention that anyone who includes Pharyngula on their blog roll is a man after my own heart.)
Would you consider cross-posting your blog entries here at BooTrib as diaries? Please, please, please.
wow, thanks for the compliment, but is it kosher for a new blogger to cross-post his own entries as diaries? I should add that Bingaman does have some legitimate reasons for his position, I just feel that anyone who takes that position so strongly has an obligation to get behind reconstruction spending just as forcefully. Of course, Bush fudges on both. Another La. blogger has a petition up as well as more frquent updates: http://joefromla.blogspot.com You might have to scroll down a little to find the petition. Thanks again
Absolutely kosher, and encouraged. Scroll down to the bottom of the page in the FAQ’s. And you can put a link to your blog in your sig line, too if you like, so that people can go there easily. I only found it because I went to your info page.
There are a number of us here who are looking for more info about New Orleans in the aftermath of Katrina. I loved your post about Plan B and also the one about Foghorn Leghorn Republicans. They’d fit right in here. Also, I noticed the coverage of Blanco’s release of documents and what different papers were emphasizing. Contrast the WaPo story with the one in the NYTimes. Interesting to see that a New Orleanian was as frustrated as I was about that. Again, media, and its spin, is of interest to a lot of us.