.
The Post reports that Rice is walking backwards from the supposed tough line that Wilkinson fed to the American media over the weekend. The New York Times says that Rice is having a tough time convincing the Europeans of anything …
Well, at least Rummy is being clear: he has no plans to retire, even if the White House wants his ass gone for Joe Lieberman.
NATO spokesman James Appathurai said Rice led off a long discussion on the issue of CIA-run prisons and treatment of prisoners in the war on terrorism at the dinner.
The Dutch foreign minister Bernhard Bot also said Rice spoke convincingly about the U.S. commitment to human rights at the dinner.
«« click on pic for NATO story
US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice speaks during a North Atlantic Treaty Organization foreign ministers council in Brussels. Rice wrapped up a European trip having reassured her European counterparts about the secret CIA prison row but failing to convince much of the public AFP/BELGA/Etienne Ansotte
More to follow below the fold »»
At a dinner Wednesday for 32 foreign ministers and NATO representatives here, Rice said she decided to bring up the prisoner issue first, since it was on everyone’s mind. She later said she thought it “important that we have ample time to discuss and reassure.”
The conversation took more than an hour, with many questions. But at one point Philippe Douste-Blazy, the French foreign minister, spoke up: “Allow me to recall here, the United States, they are our friends and our allies.”
Other ministers offered only heavily veiled criticisms, leavened with praise for Rice, U.S. and foreign officials said.
Still, the controversy tied up a plan to increase the size and responsibilities of NATO forces in Afghanistan for a while. NATO planned to increase its force there by 6,000 servicemen who would take over security responsibilities in the south, where conditions are far more volatile than in the northern and western areas where NATO forces have operated until now.
Holland was to supply 1,200 of those troops, but refused to agree until it received assurances that any prisoners captured in Afghanistan would be treated humanely, a concern that arose after recent reports of mistreatment by Americans of prisoners, a Dutch official said. On Thursday, assurances were given that prisoners would be treated under the rules of the Geneva conventions, and NATO announced final approval of the deployment of 6,000 additional troops.
Profile of NATO SG Jaap de Hoop Scheffer.
THE HAGUE Nov. 24 — When CIA-prisons and detainee abuse in Europe is proven to be true, the Dutch will reconsider their participation in Enduring Freedom by its special forces in Afghanistan.
FM Bernhard Bot made this statement in parliament this morning. The State of the Netherlands has formally requested a clarification from the chargé d’affaires of the U.S. Embassy in The Hague earlier this week. A possible use of Schiphol Airport for the spook transport of prisoners by the CIA has been put forward for answers.
The ‘consequences’ FM Bot referred to, is possible suspension of Dutch Special Forces operation under U.S. Command in Afghanistan. Participation of an extension within NATO to the Afghan province of Uruzgan within the ISAF contingent, may also be at stake.
The Dutch right-wing partner in the coalition, VVD Liberal Conservatives, already criticized the suggestion by VP Dick Cheney to make an exception for torture by the CIA in Iraq or Afghanistan.
For the new ISAF-mission in Uruzgan, the United Kingdom and Canada have committed forces and Dutch troops are following special training assignments in preparation, and Minister of Defense Kamp has been an advocate for Dutch participation.
Minister Bernhard Bot as Foreign Minister has the possibility to veto the commitment when the U.S. cannot provide adequate information and when the peace and security mission of the Dutch forces under ISAF interferes with the military operation Enduring Freedom.
The Dutch cabinet has requested written promises of the Afghan government, that prisoners handed over by the Dutch will be treated in accordance with the Geneva Conventions, will not be tortured during interrogation and cannot receive a death sentence.
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
Judging by this morning’s press coverage of the NATO meeting, A lot of these FM’s must have a big poster on the walls of their offices that says “I WANT TO BELIEVE”.
On a slightly OT note: When the prospective ISAF mission is discussed in NL, does Srebenica ever get mentioned?
How often has the Bush administration given them the opportunity to be certain that the Bush admin ALWAYS LIES! There must be something under that table that Rice was passing out to cause them to take her WORD for it.
It is obvious that they know the US lies constantly.
Likely, Rice is offering an inside track to all of the Oil that is controlled by Iraq’s puppetmasters. OR something else along those (pipe)lines.
.
Just as Vietnam is part of an American nightmare, Srebrenica weighs heavily on each mission of the Dutch peacekeeping since July 1995. Motto of Dutch parliament for every mission: … today’s “peacekeepers” often need more flexible, robust mandates and rules of engagement and the combat capabilities necessary to enforce them.
PBS – Cry From the Grave
I found an excellent analysis of the Afghan ISAF mission from a Canadian source, Bill Graham, Minister of Defence —
Canadian Policy and Values in Action Vancouver Delivery
Failed and failing states are a major challenge to global peace and security in the first part of the 21st century. We must address them not only because of the geopolitical instability they generate as breeding grounds for terrorism and international crime (think of New York, London and Madrid), but also because the suffering and denial of human rights challenges basic Canadian values.
Few militaries in the world have this range of history and experience. This, in turn, has instilled in our military culture, and our people, a rich array of skills and attributes.
After all, our men and women in uniform embody Canadian values of tolerance and respect combined with a steely determination to defend our rights. These values are a result of our history as a bilingual and multicultural nation that has, over the years, become one of the world’s most successful models of embracing cultural differences among one of the world’s most diverse populations.
Moreover, the Government of Canada’s “3-D Approach”, which integrates defence, diplomacy and development assistance in our international operations, is tailor made to a policy emphasis on failed and failing states. This holistic and integrative approach gives Canada comparative strength in achieving objectives on the ground, whether that is security and stabilization, humanitarian relief, institution building or economic development.
[…]
General Romeo Dallaire distinguishes between the previous classic peacekeeping missions and the more complex multinational operations of the last decade or so. But in so doing, he does not abandon peacekeeping, rather he updates it to fit modern realities. He and other experts rightly point out that to be effective and successful, today’s “peacekeepers” often need more flexible, robust mandates and rules of engagement and the combat capabilities necessary to enforce them. And if you have doubts about the need to be ready for combat, ask the Dutch about Srebrenica in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
UN DRC Mission Major-General Patrick Cammaert
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
Good find Oui… and it is telling that our “battle song” is by Stompin’ Tom Connors (think country and western meets folk music) & it is called “We are the Blue Berets”.
.
SG Jaap de Hoop Scheffer ::
Belgium Foreign Minister De Gucht hosted the Transatlantic dinner–NATO ministers, EU Foreign Ministers–and as you might have heard there was a very good discussion on a question [secret detention centers and CIA flights – Oui] which has been in discussion very much over the past weeks.
Also yesterday evening, as you will have heard, we discussed at length the situation in the Balkans. I made a few remarks on Afghanistan, but I’ll come back to that subject as far as our meetings are today are concerned.
It is good to tell you that this morning, over a working breakfast, NATO ministers had a broad-ranging and frank discussion, informal discussion at the security situation in the broader Middle East. Secretary Rice kicked off a discussion followed by French Minister Douste-Blazy, Minister Gül and many others. And there was a frank exchange of views on the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, Syria, Lebanon, Iran. It was a good discussion. Also, I think, underpinning NATO’s outreach in the region in the framework of the Mediterranean Dialogue and the so-called Istanbul Cooperation Initiative.
It is not a discussion to give NATO, of course, a direct role in the peace process, or a direct role in what’s happening in the talks between the EU-3 supported by the United States. But it is important that we have this political Trans-Atlantic debate.
Q & A Session
As such, you will not see this discussion continue in the NATO framework, because I say again, it is not a NATO issue as such. We have our own detention policy.
About Afghanistan and the Dutch participation, it goes without saying that after all the important work which has been done in this NATO building and elsewhere I preparing for ISAF expansion, it is my strong hope that all the potential contributors to this expansion will indeed participate. I also know, perhaps better than anybody that Dutch participation awaits a cabinet decision and a parliamentary decision because the Parliament in the Netherlands, as you and I know, plays the decisive role in the process of participating in such a mission.
If you ask me, do you hope that the Dutch will participate? My answer is clearly, of course I do, because I think this expansion is very important indeed, and we need as many allies as we can get.
Final Communiqué
Press Conference Condoleezza Rice – MP3
In a New York Times editorial entitled “Torturing the facts“, Maureen Dowd cited Rice as saying “The United States government does not authorize or condone torture of detainees”. Dowd commented sarcastically: “It all depends what you mean by ‘authorize,’ ‘condone,’ ‘torture,’ and ‘detainees.'”
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
Lieberman takes a post in the Bush administration and a repub is appointed in his place that the dems are reduced therefore. But with a wolf in sheep’s clothing are they not reduced even more by the thought that OCCASIONALLY Lieberman is a FRIEND???
“The Daily Show” did a skit on Condi showing how the US diplomacy in Europe has come down since the late President Kennedy’s trumphant visit to Berlin. Imagine Condi going around Europe on the defensive against her country’s human rights abuses?! First she said flatly that the US does not torture, or rendition detainees to other countries, later she said that those that are renditioned are not tortured. Rice for dinner, anyone?
Doesn’t anyone in the international community, apparently besides the dutch, have the courage to tell this empress that she’s wearing no clothes?
.
Would love to have been the fly during dinner.
It’s my estimate the Condi Hour was well spent in speaking one’s mind in a frank and clear manner not to be misinterpreted or misunderstood. It’s the style of SG Jaap de Hoop Scheffer and his diplomatic experience to set guidelines to follow up with a constructive discussion on today’s problems in NATO and the decisions to be made.
His terminology to clear the air should be read as a lot of harsh words were needed before the real Atlantic Alliance debate could go forward.
Angela Merkel Not Happy with Condi Rice
The Dutch will participate with 1,100 troops in the NATO led ISAF mission to Afghan province of Uruzgan. The U.S. forces will end Operation Enduring Freedom early 2006 when NATO takes over to install a Provincial Reconstruction Team (PRT).
The Dutch forces have received a guarantee from the U.S. Central Command for support in case of extreme violence or urgent medical assistance be needed. With the government of President Karzai in Kabul a Memorandum of Understanding was signed to transfer prisoners within 96 hours to Afghan authority and not to the Americans.
A top Council of Europe official said the body had been granted permission to look at images in the archives of the European Union’s main satellite center, as well as log books held by the EU’s air safety organization.
Rene van der Linden, chairman of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, also said America’s war on terror was not a real war.
“There is … a difference of opinion between Condoleezza Rice and the Council of Europe, because the law of war doesn’t exist. We have international conventions. We are fully in favor of fight against terrorism, but we have to be aware that certain cases can not be accepted,” van der Linden said.
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
I would guess that the visual that accompanies the comment is so horrifying no one wants to contemplate it….
Does Rice EVER look like anything other than some sort of demonically destructive sociopath? She’s so far beyond “bitch goddess” that it’s almost an insult to make the comparison (and I know and love several…)
.
Put your questions on Iraq and the War on Terror to Noam Chomsky in this week’s forum.
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
How are you doing..?
.
Appreciate your recommend and reply to my query.
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
looks like that reply was from M.
He’s about broke now.
This is a great diary.
.
We Can Have Both
By Andrew Sullivan
The Sunday Times Nov. 13, 2005 — In a telegram on November 21, 1943, Winston Churchill defined a fundamental difference between the Anglo-American way of war and that of our enemies.
Churchill wrote:
“The power of the Executive to cast a man into prison without formulating any charge known to the law, and particularly to deny him the judgement of his peers, is in the highest degree odious and is the foundation of all totalitarian government whether Nazi or Communist.”
Perhaps Tony Blair and George W. Bush regard Winston Churchill as a bleeding heart lefty. But what Churchill’s view represents is an old, very basic principle of Anglo-American warfare and justice: fight war with ferocity, but never lose your democratic soul. Meet the enemy on the battlefield with force, but always treat prisoners humanely in captivity. This is never an easy balance, of course. In the numbing smog of conflict, we make mistakes.
Executives invariably over-reach in prosecuting wars, and have done so in both Britain and America in the past. But our system – of habeas corpus, executive powers subject to legislative and judicial checks, and free speech to air the issues – is specifically designed to correct such errors. That’s its beauty – and its strength in wartime. It gives us a flexibility in war that dictators lack.
Continued …
Winston Churchill – Statesman
LEAVE Iraq to the Iraqis
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
Oui, you are soooooooooo good at what you do…..my heavens, you have so much great information to share with us. I do wonder how condi is goona make it the next 2 years with her constant carrying of the water of lies for the bush adm. Seems as tho the other countries do not have to take her at her word for she is just one of the liars out of washington. I think they all know this and just do is give her courtesy is all.