Fourteen years ago I left the US on a one way ticket. For fourteen years I have ranted and fumed at the US and its foreign policies. For the last 20 years I have been “Bush-Bashing.” When I left the US I had no intentions of returning. It was not the country I had known, and not the country I wanted to know.
America, Love It Or Leave It. Those were the days, my friends.
America: I loved it, I left it. I loved it too deeply to suffer shame over it.
As my friend said to me recently, “You never recovered from the Kennedy assassination.” That’s right… although I remember a few rousing good times during the Nixon impeachment hearings. He’s right, my friend, but it goes further back from that… I never recovered from Sacco and Vanzetti, Ethel and Julius Rosenburg and the House on Un-American Activities. I never recovered from Vietnam. No, I never recovered from a lot of things.
I had an extraordinary interview with a member of the US State Department this morning. I had made myself a persona non gratis and I was in a difficult position. My two closest friends and I stayed up till one last night rehearsing what my expected interrogation would be like and how I might answer some strategic questions.
But today turned out to be one of the most wonderful and moving experiences of my life. I had forms to fill out that said who I was, where I was born and who my parents were. Three times the official asked me “Did you fill out these forms yourself?” Three times I said yes I did. I looked into the steady gaze of a steady young man. He asked me where my mother was born. London. He asked me where my father was born. Boston.
“What did your father do for a living?” asked the man from the US State Department.
“My father was a Company Commander in the US Army,” I said with some great pride.
Again he asked me, “What did your father do for a living?” “He was a salesman in a company south of Boston.” The man from the State Department seemed to want to move on from there, so I had to speak up for another great person who lived her life in honorable service to her country. “My mother was a teacher,” I said. “Both my parents have passed away.” “I’m sorry to hear that,” said the man from the US State Department. “No, that’s all right,” I said. “They were both really wonderful people.” I said.
The man from the US State Department asked me to raise my right hand and to swear what I had told him was the truth. But what I swore to him was that I love my country, that I love my parents, and that I am proud to claim that my father served with distinction in the Second World War.
So the interrogation I was prepared for never happened. What happened was an honorable ritual… a right of passage. I love my country and look forward to returning to try to give some part of my life in its service. On Sunday I will land in California, a state I haven’t seen for 24 years.
- The first thing I’m going to do is register to vote.
- I think I’ll take a course in American citizenship, like those for immigrants who want to become American citizens.
- I think I’ll introduce myself to Barbara Boxer.
- I think for the next six months I’d like to work on voter registration. That’s what I want to do.
You are all welcome to celebrate with me at my US Passport Party. Champagne’s on the house!
Congrats! Mazel tov! Party on!
And welcome back to the U.S. We are happy to have you back and there only thing we could wish for is that were more just like you.
Congratulations, suskind! And welcome home.
I love you.
M. Suskind
Welcome back…
Glad to have you on board the good ship USA. We sometimes sail in rough waters, but she’s a seaworthy vessel and we appreciate good hands.
All hands on deck !! All able bodied front and center !! Time to find all those not registered to vote and get them to take their proper place in US govt. THOSE CLOWNS WORK FOR US !!!
M. Suskind
Well, welcome home, from a ex-pat (kind of).
1st I want to knw who in your family got the CMH??!!
Now HUGs my dear friend..I welcome you home, Brother. God, I am so glad you decided to come back. We do need you here! Many hugs again…
did that cmh belong to your father?
I have not yet recovered my father’s medals. He was very good with languages. Among other things, he was an interrogator.
Great news (and great story) suskind! Welcome back… I think the first thing you should do though, considering where you are moving from and moving to is… buy sunscreen!
Have a safe trip 🙂
Good for you Suskind and as a Californian, let me welcome you back to the state, which I dearly love. Where will you be living?
As an immigration lawyer, I found that to be a great essay. I was surprised–from your beginning, I thought you were going to tell about how you had gone to formally RENOUNCE your U.S. citizenship, which is actually rather difficult to do these days.
I don’t understand one key sentence. You say you had made yourself a persona non gratis and were in a difficult position. What exactly does that mean? Had you renounced citizenship before?
I look forward to having a confidential conversation with you about my very interesting experiences of the last 14 years. Where do you practice?
persona non gratis means a person without rights, eh what? c’est vrai, mon ami.
Hmm. After getting various death threats some years ago from unreconstructed wingnuts, I’ve been pretty systematic about maintaining anonymity on general blogs. But it’s hard to close the door on someone who wants to talk about interesting legal situations. U.S. immigration law is ridiculously and unreasonably complicated; I’m an expert in two areas, but not particularly in citizenship law. But I’d be happy to communicate, and rest assured that any contacts with a reputable lawyer are completely confidential. If you wish, please find my email address at www.h*a*k*e.com/p*c (remove asterisks).
But will you please tell me WHERE do you practice?
Oh great. I try to obscure it a little bit with asterisks and I end up making my name light up like a pinball machine. What a maroon I am sometimes. . . . I’m in central Maryland, suskind.
I like maroons, but I don’t like to be marooned. Maryland is a lovely state, and quite near DC. Wow. What a day I had !!
Arminius,
Since this is your field…
what IS the procedure if one wants to emigrate and seek citizenship in another country, at this point? Does US citizenship terminate automatically when a citizen becomes naturalized in a different country?
It’s a thing I’ve been thinking about for some years, quite independent of the political situation here at the moment. (I’m far from certain I wish to do so, in part due to the political situation here, in part to the situation THERE, and in part just because, love it or hate it, the US is STILL the biggest gorilla on the block and membership in that club isn’t a thing to throw away lightly.)
No, U.S. citizenship most certainly does not terminate upon obtaining permanent resident status, or citizenship, in another country. The United States, like most countries, does not like dual citizenship. However, the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled clearly and quite emphatically that a person must specifically intend to renounce U.S. citizenship. It does not happen automatically upon acquisition of a foreign citizenship. And the government’s burden of proof to show intent is very high. (Of course, this current U.S. government is capable of literally anything.)
For what it’s worth, my wife and I almost moved to Canada after the Republicans stole the 2004 election. We actually had a contract on a house in Nova Scotia, which fell through for complicated reasons. I doublechecked this issue of maintaining U.S. citizenship carefully. My family came originally to North America in the 1600s. I have two ancestors who were officers in the Continental Army in the Revolutionary War. I was born in Washington, D.C. I’m not going to be lightly deprived of my birthright citizenship. My American roots are much deeper than the damn Bushes!
Incidentally, if one wishes to expatriate, U.S. citizenship can be a terrible curse. The United States is one of the few countries in the world that taxes all citizens on worldwide income, regardless of place of residence and regardless of the source of the income. And even if you renounce U.S. citizenship and acquire a foreign citizenship, the Treasury regulations presume that you did that for the purpose of avoiding taxes, and they will STILL stick you with the taxes. It is almost impossible to overcome that. That means, in effect, that a U.S. citizen who renounces citizenship and moves to a foreign country can never return to his native land–or he will be arrested and prosecuted for tax evasion.
By the way, maybe you’d be interested to learn more about those State Department consular officers. (Incidentally, may I ask which embassy you were interviewed at?)
U.S. consular officers are unique among federal officers. The consular corps actually predates the United States; it was established originally under the Article of Confederation in the 1780s. After the Constitution was ratified, one of the earliest U.S. federal statutes reconstituted the already existing consular corps, establishing a chain of command that goes directly from an individual consular officer right to the President of the United States.
There is no other official in the U.S. executive hierarchy that has anything like the raw, unreviewable power possessed by junior consular officers, many of whom are still recruited from the Ivy League schools.
Only the President himself can countermand a decision of a junior consular officer. Even the Secretary of State has no statutory authority to do so. (Although, of course, the Secretary, and high officials in the State Department’s Bureau of Consular Affairs/Visa Office do of course exercise considerable practical influence over junior officers.)
Therefore, consular officers have almost godlike power.
Nonetheless, under the law, they do not have power to take U.S. citizenship away and they do not have power to grant U.S. citizenship. Although they may think they do.
Screw the champagne, let’s have a jolt of Irish Mist. I must tell you Arminius you are one of my most favorite people of the day.
I was in a unique and interesting situation. I would love to share it with you, and ask you some more questions about a topic I find fascinating. But I can’t comfortably do that here. Where do you practice?
May I come for the Mist? That is the only whiskey I like..I am sure I would enjoy the conversation as well…:o)
You sound so excited and welcome home!! We are so happy to have you back fighting in this country for what we are all fighting for. Big welcoming hugs for you!
As an aside, does anyone know when/if that chip thing in US passports will be/has been implemented? I need to get a passport, never had one, but may have opportunity to travel abroad yet, but may more definitively in the semi-near future. I’d like to get mine before the chip thing… I don’t think it’s been started yet, so if I need to move faster on this that would be good to know. And if it’s already been started, fuck it, I’m still going to have a way out of here if I need to.
Thanks in advance! 🙂
From the State Dept passport website:
I just got my passport (renewed) in the mail today. (Yippee!) If it has a chip in the cover, it’s well hidden – I can’t see or feel anything there. I think they’re implementing this gradually this year, but it’s already started. I’d say boogie on your application and maybe yours won’t have one if you hurry.
And – Welcome home, suskind!
Thanks JS! I’ll be boogeying then!
I am extremely pleased…welcome home.
Peace
I love you.
M. Suskind
I think you mentioned Sacramento in a recent Cafe; if you’re ever thinking of making a trip down to SF, or even as far as the Silly Con Valley (though God/Goddess/FSM knows why anyone would specifically visit here), I’d love to have a chance to buy you a shot of Irish Mist… 😉
Oh, and there is a little get-together of West Coast Tribbers in the works for the end of March…alohaleezy had a diary about a week and a half ago… 🙂
Welcome home Suskind :o)
Your enthusiasm is infectious and sorely needed.
I second Cali Scribe’s invitation to the West Coast meetup in March. I’ll be making the trip across from New York. I wouldn’t miss it for the world.
Peace
First of all congratulations!
Something I don’t understand, though. Did you revoke your US citizenship and then become a citizen of another country? If that’s the case, just out of curiosity, how does one go about that?
I’m not going to completely crash this party, and will start off with a hearty congrats! and best of luck to you, but will nevertheless tell you what I’m really thinking….which is, boyohboy, hope this person knows what he’s getting himself into.
I was an expat for nearly ten years (84-93). When I returned to post-Reagan/Bush I America–even though I knew it was going to be bad, I had no idea what I was getting myself into and there was nothing that could have prepared me for the culture shock I encountered on my return.
By the time 2000 rolled around, I’d almost learned to live with it. Almost. Then came BushCo. Now, it’s like I’ve got this constant ticker-tape running in my head….”just when you thought it was safe to go back in the water….”
If I were you, I’d keep my options open–just in case.
OPTIONS OPEN. STOP. WORKING WITH GREAT COLLEAGUES AND FRIENDS. STOP. TAKES COURAGE, GUTS, TENACITY, INGENUITY AND FOCUS TO STAY ON THE BEAM. STOP. FEAR LEVEL NIL. STOP. THIS IS A GREAT TIME IN US HISTORY. STOP.
ps, Suskind, This “love it or leave it” business. Doubt there’s anyone who’s actually left in any real way who doesn’t think about that phrase….
My take, upon return, was:
Love it or leave it?
Yeah, I do love it, I have left it, now I’m back, and if you don’t like it, well, then it’s time for YOU to leave!
(and that’s not altogether flip–personally think at least a one-yr stay abroad ought to be MANDATORY for anyone graduating from an American university or running for public office in this country. Best way to understand your own country is to leave it–really leave it, and live somewhere else, not just on “vacation”).
I’ve always been partial to the other version:
“America: Change It or Lose It”
We’re already well on the road to losing it…
I dunno, Cali, judging from the “broken treaty” in my file drawer, my family “lost” this country sometime around 1871.
Since then, we’ve been trying desperately to salvage something from what we lost.
Sovereignty (and eventual secession?) for Native nations is the only solution I see as viable to my interests and concerns.
When I think in terms of “love it or leave it”–it’s about the LAND, exclusively so (and a select few of its people), not about the US government, which I still (and always will) consider an occupying force.
I love you. Alot.
Someone on EuroTrib asked me why I decided to return. Two reasons:
TWO ANSWERS TO THE SAME QUESTION:
1. Such will be the days of mourning for Coretta Scott King, who not only stood by her husband but also by her country, by which she meant what it might yet be.
(By Paul Greenberg: Sacramento Bee; January 31, 2006; Paul Greenberg is the Pulitzer Prize-winning editorial page editor of the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette.)
Reason Two:
THE PATRIOT GAME
Come all you young rebels and list while I sing,
For the love of one’s country is a terrible thing.
It banishes fear with the speed of a flame,
And it makes us all part of The Patriot Game.
My name is O’Hanlon and I’m just gone sixteen.
My home is in Monahan, ’twas there I was weaned.
I learned all my life cruel England to blame,
And so I’m a part of The Patriot Game.
It’s nearly two years now since I wandered away
With a local battalion of the bold I.R.A..
I’d read of our heroes and I wanted the same;
To play out my part in The Patriot Game.
I read how poor Conley was shot in the chair.
All his wounds from the battle, all bleeding and bare.
His fine body twisted, all battered and lame;
They soon made him part of The Patriot Game.
This Ireland of ours has for long been half free;
Six counties are under John Bull’s tyranny
And it’s always the leaders who are mostly to blame
For shirkin’ their part in The Patriot Game.
And now as I lie here, my body all holes,
I think of those traitors who bargained and sold.
I wish that my rifle had given the same
To the quislings who sold out The Patriot Game.
Will meet you at the BooTrib Tribal in California, I hope.
M. Suskind
TELEGRAM CONT’D. WAR IN IRAQ. STOP. DEGREDATION OF US CONSTITUTION. STOP. ABROGATION OF HUMAN & CIVIL RIGHTS. STOP. DISHONOR BORN BY US MILITARY DUE TO ABU GHRAIB AND CIA PRISONS. STOP.
THAT’S THE OBVIOUS STUFF. STOP. IT’S THE NITTY-GRITTY EVERYDAY THAT MAY DRIVE YOU NUTS.
STOP.
STOP.
STOP.
YES, don’t we all wish it would just STOP STOP STOP.
Anyway, still haven’t quite figured out whether I came back to go down with the ship or what, but it’s not like I couldn’t have left again either….in fact, it’s not like I couldn’t hop on a plane tomorrow and be gone, gone, gone….but I’m still here, still fighting….so come on back, just be advised…she ain’t what she used to be.
Whoohoo Suskind! Congrats! As others have mentioned we are having a SoCal meetup March 31st and we all would surely love to meet the great Suskind! You can find more info Here. Welcome Home!!!
I am so thrilled for you. But California – (sigh) guess I’ll just have to carry on loving you from afar.
Hate to miss a party too – I’ll be there in spirit.
There’s always a corny song for me:
“In the chilly hours and minutes
Of uncertainty
I want to be
In the warm hold of your loving mind.
To feel you all around me
And to take your hand
Along the sand
Ah, but I may as well try and catch the wind.”
Welcome home, dear.
I love you.
M. Suskind
Congratulations, Suskind! Welcome home!
I love you.
M. Suskind
The old saying is “home is where, when you have to go there, they have to take you in.”
Well, that’s just wrong.
You are home, and we don’t have to take you in because you were already here in words.
And now we are just delighted to be able to see you here on home turf, as some the folk in CA and elsewhere, surely will be so fortunate.
I love you.
M. Suskind