[From the diaries by susanhu. Another must-read by StreetKid.]
Senate Democrats told stories Thursday of weeping older people who were unable to get their medicine as Congress opened hearings into problems with Medicare’s new drug benefit.
Sen. Blanche Lincoln, D-Ark., said pharmacists in her state have had to take out loans because they could not get reimbursed quickly enough for drugs dispensed to customers who had no means to pay them. Sens. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y., and Bill Nelson, D-Fla., said they met older people who were in tears when they talked about problems filling prescriptions.
“I for one believe we should scrap this and start over,” Clinton said.
Some republicans admitted to Mark McClellan that they have heard of similar situations, but feel that Medicare D should be fixed, not scrapped.
According to Elzabeth Dole,
“It is nearly impossible to avoid startup challenges, but we now we must identify those individuals who are vulnerable and make certain that their needs are met.”
How about people with disabilities, Liz?
According to Mark McClellan the government makes
“no excuses for the problems. They are important, they are ours to solve and we are finding and fixing them.”
So why haven’t you?
Continued below:
McClellan also stated that Medicare D is working for most people, and that the competition between private insurers re: the cost of the plans was driving prices down. Example: Premiums will average about $25 a month, as opposed to the $37. McClellan and his agency have now lowered the estimated start-up costs to $678 billion over 10 years opposed to $730 billion.
And, gwb, in his infinte wisdom, has decided to ask private insurers to supply senior citizens with another 60 day supply of their rx’s, in the hope that an alternative treatment would be medically appropriate!
Now from Health and Human Services Secretary Mike Leavitt,
“We’re seeing the cost of drugs come down in a rapid way because of an organized, competitive marketplace.”
Uh, Mike, do you recall this from Sen. Charles Schumer?
“He (Leavitt) seemed incredulous when I told him, but said he wasn’t really aware of the problems…I was surprised by that.”
And, Mark, how about this?
Robert Hayes, president of the Medicare Rights Center, states that he had a discussion with Mark McClellan, (Administrator of the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services) EARLY LAST YEAR:
“I was sitting in McClellan’s office and I said, ‘Look, even if you get this transition 99 percent right for the people losing Medicaid coverage, you’re still going to have 64,000 people without drug coverage come Jan. 1.’ And [McClellan] said ‘No, we have everything under control.’
Here’s another opinion from a pharmacist
Pharmacists are trying to make this plan work even though it takes money out of their pockets. The plan is costing patients and the states more, too.
The blame should be placed where it really belongs: on insurance companies and their partners who can manipulate drug prices.
McClellan also said that the agency was trying to make the program
“even easier”
for a person to understand.
Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., asked:
“Even easier? It’s bedlam out there.”
The most serious concerns about the benefit center on the 6 million low-income people who had obtained drug coverage through Medicaid. In the transition to Medicare, a few hundred thousand may have had trouble because of data errors and because they switched plans late in the year, McClellan said.
Michael Donato of Mayfield, Ohio, told senators that his pharmacy tried to charge him $700 when he first tried to get his prescriptions filled.
“But what about the seniors?…What happens to people who don’t have the help I had? I hope that you will give them the assistance they need.”
What about others with disabilites who are unable to have the assistance necessary to figure out Medicare D(isater)?
xposted at dkos
and mlw–and now I don’t know wtf is going on at dkos, taking forever to load???
What about them indeed! I would suggest they have an advocate, (if they have one) contact the office of their Representative to the Congress. I have been assured by a staffer for mine, that they have “a counselor (not counselors) available to walk folks through the process if they are having trouble.” That is what they said, I am not making this up. Of course, if they do not have an advocate….well you can complete that thought as easily as I can.
to assist a person thru Medicare D. I received so many different answers from so many different people and, was told to call so-and-so, who told me to call so-and-so, and on, and on, and on, and I was eventually referred to the person that I started with.
Know how I managed to figure some of this crap out? Raised hell and told everyone that I talked to, if I didn’t get an answer NOW, I was calling the paper and the networks! So far, it looks like I’m ok, but I really don’t know…
Oh and get this–sent an email to Rogers office re: my oppostion to the invasion of Iraq, it ended with, (paraphasing) If there is anything I can do for you, please don’t hesitate to call. And, it was written on letterhead!
Like it would really do any good!
I hope you are OK too StreetKid. Our guy has a way of getting my blood pressure to rise when I don’t want it to. I have a few “form letter” responses from him that have little to do with my e-mail to him. I sometimes feel as though he thinks I am supposed to treasure the “autograph”.
BTW, did you see this
or this one?
Will the senators be looking to claw back the drug industry’s Medicare D windfall of $2 billion extra profits this year and up tp $40 billion over the next 10 years?
Obscene.
“Windfall for drug industry raises questions”
http://www.realcities.com/mld/krwashington/13777959.htm
Not just obscene. Criminal.
OMG! I’ve got to go thru all the stuff I have saved!!!
Thanks!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I really caused Street Kid some major stress tonight. I was front-paging her story and my mouse cursor slipped, and I hit the Archive button.
Well, no biggie, I thought … but I couldn’t un-archive it! Turns out there’s no function to allow us front-pagers to do that!
I called BooMan and Andy. Andy did a lot of work, but finally restored StreetKid’s terrific diary.
All the way through, StreetKid was nothing but NICE and REASONABLE about it all.
And I’ll be a broken record until we get the Story Delete and Archive buttons so that we have to click twice — for confirm — before they actually do their functions.
Street Kid’s work on this is HUGELY important. She’s doing the best, most clear, most BRIEF (brief is a great feature of her work), and most consistent research and investigation.
She is our hero.
Thanks susanhu!
Most Republicans don’t care about people who fall through the cracks.
If seniors have to wait as long as the Katrina survivors for this inept bunch to “fix” this, many may be psychotic, hopeless, or dead, in addition to being betrayed.
What. a. mess.
Understatement of the year!
here
“”My understanding is that some cancer medication was seized that requires refrigeration,” he adds.”
Leukeran, an oral treatment for leukemia, requires being kept at 40°. I know because when I have to pick up my Mother’s prescription, I drive to the pharmacy and then straight home so as to keep it cold enough. I suspect that there are other cancer drugs that require similar care in handling. At $127 for 50 pills, a 25 day supply, I can see why some seniors would try to get it from Canada. The price jumped about $12 just before the first of the year and our pharmacist said that many drug prices were going up in anticipation of Plan D going into effect. The drug companies are also getting very stingy with their samples according to Mom’s doctor.
Rubber stamp Prez (zero vetoes)….Lobbyists and aides write legislation.All paperwork is done by recipients via the web.
Never mind that seniors HATE computers(and Elvis), and most can’t afford the one-time hardware cost, not to mention another monthly bill.
…Lobbyists write legislation, aides get a free lunch.
T.A.C.P. 2/5 1st Mar. Div. An Hoa 9/68 – 9/69
here
Have you ever seen an angry 90 year old woman? It’s nothing to take lightly. An acquaintance who is himself past 60 is taking care of his 90 year old mother, and with several advanced degrees between them, neither can figure out this plan.
There are a lot of angry seniors out there, and a lot of baby boomers taking care of them just a few years shy of their eligibility. Don’t make the mistake of thinking that this affects only the poor. Fixed incomes may be fixed fairly high, but some prescription drugs can make a fortune disappear. This is one of those stealth issues to a lot of people who post here. But old people vote in higher proportion, and they read newspapers and follow the news more than younger people on average.
The Bushites did to Medicare what they’ve done to the Army, Iraq, Katrina relief, everything: they’ve given it to their corporate buddies to loot. But this one will come back to haunt them in November.
Yeah Cap – Nothing against corporate buddies, IF they’re competent, you want your team.
These clowns can’t run a cheerleading team.
To put the lobbyists in control (who supposedly knows the particular industry better?) is just beyond cronyism.
Not only that, with the K Street Project, lobbyists don’t even have to be knowledgeable, just Republican.
It just makes for more mistakes and some rich asshole “learning on the fly”
Again, nothing wrong with hiring your team – IF your team is COMPETENT!
My standard response as far as gov’t goes: Don’t help me, help the BEAR!
That is: If you see me fighting a bear…..
HELP THE FUCKING BEAR!
I won’t accept government help, but I find this admin. UNABLE to help our seniors or poor.
They simply don’t have the job skills.
Cronyism at it’s worst, and all it implies.
This admin does not WANT to help seniors or the poor.
Maybe Mark McClellan will bring brother Scott to answer questions for him on the issue.
Trying to ‘fix’ this fiasco will never work -no matter how many issues they try to fix another one will crop up because the whole Plan D is rotten to the core.
And as someone upthread pointed out people who are waiting for these ‘fixes’…if they have to wait as long as the Katrina mess than more and more people will die/end up hurting themselves or other due to not being able to get their medications for mental problems. I really wonder how many people already have been severely effected..probably something will never know for sure.
Democrats like Clinton who say this plan should be scrapped is fine but if she and other Dems don’t get out and actively try to get this Plan overturned than they are part of the problem and just mouthing platitudes.
It’s also patently untrue for HHS director Levitt to say the price of drugs are coming down due to competitive market..that’s just pure bullshit..prices are going up.
link
New intro paragraph:
Practically the same damn article as the one in this diary!