Despite being mentioned in a congressional hearing, one aspect of Medicare D(isaster) that has been overlooked by many is the impact that it has been having on independent pharmacies. According to Sen. Blanche Lincoln, D-Ark.,
pharmacists in her state have had to take out loans because they could not get reimbursed quickly enough for drugs dispensed to customers who had no means to pay them.
This is not limited to Arkansas, though. In Mississippi,it has been reported that pharmacy owner Bob Lomenick has dispensed
$200,000 worth of drugs but has received only a $25,000 in payments from insurers.
In Wisconsin,Jeff Seabloom, owner of the Elcho Pharmacy stated
“We are handing out tablets to these people out of our own pocket, not knowing when we are going to get reimbursed. We are kind of subsidizing the program right now.”
continued below
And in California
Beatle Tran now keeps his West Sacramento pharmacy open an extra day each week. He has to. He’s trying to make up for what he says the federal government’s new Medicare drug plan is costing him.
chantedor’s diary, stated that
Many of the insurance companies have not been paying the pharmacies for the drugs they’ve provided–even though the insurance companies approved these people’s prescriptions and have been collecting payments from the insured.
At least one pharmacy has already become so far in the hole because of this nonpayment that it has been forced to shut its doors. Others are owed tens of thousands of dollars, some over $100,000, and they have no idea when they will ever get paid by the insurers for prescriptions they have dispensed.
Some of them, especially the smaller local pharmacies, are worried that they won’t be able to stay open much longer.
In Ohio, pharmacist John Coler is concerned that his business may go bankrupt, as his expenses are, in addition to overhead, a bank payment, a loan payment, and a wholesaler bill every 2 weeks. Coler’s opinion of Medicare D(isaster)is that it
“has created an environment where you can’t practice pharmacy. We spend so much time being insurance representatives that it’s taking away from patient counseling…The questions we’re asked are not 5- to 10-second responses. We can spend 10 to 20 minutes per patient…I have had patients tell me to keep [the medication] because they can’t afford it“
Another pharmacist, Randy Shrivers stated,
“The federal government and pharmacy benefit managers [PBMs] weren’t set for January 1. We’re not in the business to put insurance plans into place.”
He further describes the cash flow problem that many independent pharmacies are facing.
“We’re not getting paid by these people [insurance companies and PBMs]. For some reason, the federal government and legislature think pharmacies are plush with money. As a result, there’s going to be pharmacies that go out of business.”
Another cause for concern is the Medicaid cuts. The House of Representatives voted on February 1, 2006, to cut $3.6 billion from Medicaid for generic drugs.
A 2005 University of Texas study found that the current average state Medicaid pharmacist dispensing fee is $4.15, whereas the average cost for a pharmacist to dispense a prescription is $9.62.
The difficulties of maintaining a small business/pharmacy have not been limited to the pharmacies in the states metioned above. According to the National Community Pharmacist Association (NCPA)
“Implementation of Medicare Part D has been beset with serious problems, including incomplete or unavailable eligibility information and significant challenges with claims processing. Although the source of these problems comes from many elements of this complex new benefit program, it is the nation’s community pharmacists who are bearing the brunt, along with their patients.”
Yet the actual impact of Medcare D(isaster) on small businesses has not been adequately addressed. Another fact worth noting,
The nation’s independent pharmacies, independent pharmacy franchises, and independent chains represent an $84 billion marketplace, dispensing nearly half of the nation’s retail prescription medicines.
This concern was about the maintaining a business and providing good customer service re: rx’s was echoed by Bob Lomenick, when discussing what the future may hold.
“I may have to shut it down completely…You’re going to have an access problem. The Wal-Marts and Walgreens of the world aren’t going to put a pharmacy in Potts Camp, Mississippi.”
The pharmacy that I get my rx’s filled is a local/regional one. But, the concerns in this diary/these articles have been echoed by my pharmacist.
Also xposted at dkos and MLW
And a thank you to chantedor and blueneck!
Thank you, Street Kid. Your series on Medisaster have been one of the best I’ve seen. You are doing a real service by making this info available and presenting it in a readable and accessible format.
You’re welcome and thank you.
I’ll echo what blueneck said(and everyone else). Part of the power of your diaries is that you have managed to pull all this information together and not make it sound dull/dry but as stated very readable and easy to understand. That’s over half the battle in getting people to read anything..good writing.
I have to go pick up my 7 prescriptions today..and we’ll see what this month brings..Jan. they charged me 20 dollars..last month 8 dollars for the exact same thing and who knows what this month will be? Pharmacy here is so swamped that you have to take your meds in at least 3 days before you need them as it takes that long to get them filled(and that’s for simple refills)…if you have a new prescription that you need right away you are literally out of luck. And the one other pharmacy in this town isn’t any better.
Thanks chocolate ink, but you have posted some great links. Some of these wouldn’t have been written w/o them!
I hope things go well for you at the pharmacy. Like I said, my pharmacy is an independent/regional, and the people who work there have really been bending over backwords, trying to understand Medicare D(isaster) so a person can get their rx’s.
Being on a tight budget as we both are, we are really hurting due to Medicare D(isaster). I’m really hoping that things go ok re: your rx’s. That is one of the things that people don’t realize–what seems like a small increase in a copay to the rest of the world is a good sized amount of $ to us.
Come to think of it, that is how all this bs gets justified.
I don’t usually pile on with me-too comments, but just wanted to chime in to say that your series on this issue has simply been outstanding! Many thanks.
Your welcome. And I am really enjoying writing/researching about an issue that impacts so many.
Call me an idealist, but, I really hope this series is the beginning of some real change in the health care system, as opposed to empty promises.
Thanks again.
of adjectives with which to praise your work on this, and that is no small feat.
I believe I mentioned in a previous comment on this subject, that these obstructionists pharmacists who have engaged in unauthorizedly extended lives, in defiance of corporate policies, will nevertheless have the satisfaction of knowing that Wal-Mart will accept their applications and accord them the same consideration as all others, when they magnanimously step in to fill the drugstore void in these communities.
I remember you saying that! But, as stated in the diary, there are still small towns that are dependent on an independent pharmacy. And the people who live in such towns also need their rx’s. The fact of the matter is that Medicare D(isaster) is actually really dangerous legislation. If the scenario that you have described does come to pass (God forbid!), those who are unable to get rx’s will end up getting sicker and dying. And, if that happens, the death toll will be higher than that of Katrina.
This isn’t exactly about the way that small pharmacies are being hurt by Plan D[isaster], but it’s too good a story to not submit a link:
It’s not seniors who benefit most from plan
Sounds like a typical Repug boondoggle.
Thanks, Denim Blue, that’s a good link for my collection.
Everything about this impacts on something else…
I’m no economist, but I can see wnats going on. The corporate world has been slowly swallowing up the health care system up for years. It is a captive market: people have no choice about this "product" we all must have it.
Then the big guys eat up the little guys, and form monopolies, so they get the whole pie, while buying off polticians to them from any consequence of ther actions amd keep the skids well greased so they can do whatever they wish. Since"price control" is a dirty word in a "free market"…it’s a no holds barred deal: you can exploit the life/death needs of a captive market till hell freezes over and who can stop you?
I stood gaping in disbelief at a "Mini Clinic" in a local Target store the other day; you can sign up, they give you a beeper to carry around while you wait your turn, so you can SHOP while waiting for your teensy bit of health care services, from which you wil emerge with yet another prescrption you can fill at their corporate pharmacy a few aisles down. Convenient? Hell, yes. "Efficient, Of course.
Genuine health care? Bull.
Street Kid, I applaud your mission. You’ve dound your own strong, couragweouos voice and are using it magnificently!
I had to read your description of the “health care” that is sold as a commodity at the Target a few times before it fully sunk in. And that is disgusting. Want to bet they bill as an emergency room as well–I believe that reimbursements for different insurances are higher. That’s nuts!
And thanks. I really hope that all of the writing that I do will wake more than a few people up so things will be changed.
Yea, Street Kid. You deserve tons of kudos.
Readers may want to be alerted for what’s due May 15th. In “The $80 billion Medicare Sellout” Jeff Cruz, over at Tom Paine, writes that’s when the “doughnut hole” kicks in.
Thanks so much, idredit, the article that you linked to is beautiful!!!! Having known of some of the organizations that would benefit by going single payer, it is also good to know that more are actively stepping up in oppostion to Medicare D(isaster). Thanks again!!
There have been reports that because of the way prescription drugs are paid for by insurance plans pharmacies don’t really make much money from filling the orders. It is as if the pharmacy part of a “drug store” is now just a loss leader to get people into the store.
Non-prescription drugs, cosmetics and other beauty products can be sold at a much higher markup and this is where the real money is. If online pharmacies get more efficient the neighborhood druggist may vanish altogether. Whether this is a good development or not remains to be seen.
I don’t think that an online pharmacy would be at all beneficial. The lack of computer/internet literacy is a serious problem for the populations that Medicare D(isaser) was supposed to serve.
And,
So it seems to me that is not a viable option for many. But, many do take computer/internet use for granted, as witnessed by the repeated insistence of those who manned the 800 number to go online and compare plans. At that time, my computer was down and I was pretty sick (pneumonia) and had no way of doing so. I really had to throw a fit to get signed up for a plan. It was a rough situation, don’t ask me how I managed to do it!
Perhaps I should have said online/mail order prescription filling. My latest insurance plan came with an envelope to enroll for automatic refills if I wished from a mail order company. The incentive was one would only have to pay one co-pay for several month’s worth of pills.
The plan doesn’t work well for one-off prescriptions or those needed in a hurry. Although if there were better communication between doctors and these remote services most people could get what they need overnight.
This is as fast as the local pharmacy sometimes is able to fill prescriptions for uncommon items.
I don’t trust mail order rx’s. When I need a refill for rx’s, I want to know that I have it in my hand. Bet there are a lot of other people who feel the same way.
And, as you said, for rx’s needed in a hurry, that won’t work at all. When I had pneumonia, I needed rx’s filled fast. And there are times when people do run out of rx’s and need a refill fast.
I don’t really see the benefit of mail order, except for cost, i.e., ordering rx’s from Canada. Come to thinkof it, wonder where the mail order rx’s are coming from? (I mihgt be getting a bit too cynical now.(
Thanks again for this excellent work Street Kid.
See this front page article from today’s The Forum (Fargo) on the problems our pharmacists are having with Medicare D.
Benefit drains druggists, Patrick Springer, The Forum Thursday, March 02, 2006 [note: subscription is free if requested]
Pharmacists have been to Washington, DC to testify and are continuing to work with our Congressional delegation to get some legislation to remedy the problems.
Here’s some results of a survey of the state’s pharmacists that was done Feb 24 by the North Dakota Association of Pharmacists.
I can’t begin to imagine the frustration of being on hold at an insurance “help” line for some 30 minutes let alone 6 hours, WTF sort of insanity is this anyway?
Thanks! That ties in beautifully w/others. Am writing now.