Perhaps you’ve heard the story of Jay Bennish, a geography teacher in a Colorado high school. One of his students secretly taped his class discussion without asking permission from Mr. Bennish. In that class discussion Bennish compared Bush’s justifications for his pre-emptive war policy in Iraq to similar tactics employed by Hitler.
Not surprisingly, Mr. Bennish’s penchant for apt comparisons caused an uproar among the character assassins of the right, one of whom sent an email to the school which led to Bennish’s suspension [Note: The student who had taped the class and his father had not bothered to inform the school or the teacher in an attempt to resolve their concerns. Instead they simply went public on the internet with their outrage, which is why the school, and Mr. Bennish did not learn of the issue until the email was received.]
That wasn’t enough for the rabid right, however. Bennish soon became a cause celebre on numerous right wing talk shows, and across the wingnut blogosphere, all because he dared to suggest that President Bush’s war policies. However, while 150 student supporters of Bennish peacefully protested his suspension, Bennish opponents employed a different tactic to make their point:
DENVER – The father of a Colorado teacher who compared President Bush’s State of the Union address to speeches made by Adolf Hitler said he and his family have received at least 12 death threats.
More on the flip . . .
Jay Bennish is on paid leave from Overland High School in suburban Aurora while Cherry Creek School District investigates whether his Feb. 1 lecture violated a policy requiring that balancing viewpoints be presented in classes.
Bennish’s father, John Bennish of Beverly Hills, Mich., told The Detroit News in Wednesday’s editions that people have called his house threatening to kill him or his family.
“This has been totally lopsided and one-sided,” Bennish’s father said of the news coverage of his son’s lecture.
Jay Bennish has defended the lecture, saying he was trying to encourage his students to teach. he told NBC’s “Today Show” Tuesday that excerpts of a recording made by one of his students were unrepresentative of the full lecture.
“This is 20 minutes out of a 50-minute class. The rest of the class provides the balance,” he said.
Imagine for a moment that we are back in 1998, and a teacher just called President Bill Clinton a sex freak and serial rapist who deserved impeachment. Does anyone imagine that hypothetical teacher being subjected to the same levels of abuse that Jay Bennish and his family have had to endure? Does anyone believe that teacher would have been suspended for trying to stimulate class discussion on the propriety of the Clinton impeachment through the use of such provocative statements. Can anyone reasonably argue that such a teacher would have received death threats from angry Clinton supporters?
Clinton was a far more popular President than Bush, even at the worst of the Monicagate frenzy in the media and Congress. Yet, we are not surprised that Bush supporters would stoop to this despicable practice. Disappointed, concerned, angry? Yes. Surprised? Nothing surprises me about these creepy faux brownshirt cultists anymore.
I guess simply calling us traitors, and hoping we get killed by terrorists just doesn’t do it for them at this point.
You’re right – it is a cult. We are beyond politics at this point. Mr. Bennish saw that. School is no longer about teaching people to think for themselves. The poor teachers have to worry about protecting themselves.
Hopefully if we keep pointing out the suffering, people will begin to see it, and avoid it. I see that happening ever so slowly on many different levels. Look at the declining enlistment numbers.
Unfortunately, we have to go through an awful lot of hell to learn anything.
And these people pride themselves in being the advocates for law and order? Well when it comes down to it the law seems to be for everyone else but themselves. This is yet another example of how much the right value the principal of ethics.
against “terroristic threats” that pre-date 9/11. Are the police investigating these threats against the Bennish family? That’s what needs to happen — people need to be arrested for this kind of behavior.
And Bennish needs to sue the father and son for slander or libel, whichever applies. Make them pay for distorting his lecture, attempting to ruin his reputation, subjecting him to emotional distress, etc.
They not only need to be arrested they need to be convicted, sentenced, and jailed. Threats are not protected free speech.
How much does a high school history teacher make in Colorado? Probably not much more than $40,000 annually, if he has a masters degree. Suing would be way too expensive.
Most of this B/S is the fault of Karl Rove – who has divided this country more than since the Civil War according to historians-can’t find link at NPR. We need slander laws like England has so that it is easier to prove harm.
Rosee’s Diary yesterday, made mention the GOP are trying to do away with Hate laws. Could it be because these hateful, venom spewing people want to continue their vile behaviors, or even escalate, with no consequence for their behaviors? Or are they trying to demonize anyone who disagrees with Bush$co so that people accept many of us being hauled off to their new “immigration camps”?
I fear what may be coming.
would take this case pro bono, especially if the student’s father has money… and from Tracy’s description of the area, it sounds like he does.
Removing the Hate laws doesn’t invalidate other laws either. If you beat up someone for being gay, you’re still going to do time for assault. If you kill someone or burn down their church, you’re still going to do time whether you did it with hate or drunken indifference. And when you threaten to kill someone that’s still against the law whether you’re a Bush cultist or a jealous boyfriend.
Think of the 150 students who stood up for their teacher and don’t think your neighbors who know you would be so passive about seeing an old grandma hauled off by the Thought Police. With Bush at 37% and falling, I’m starting to have hope for America again.
I don’t see how these assholes do not perfectly fit any possible definition of terrorist. Time for a trip to Guantanamo or an undisclosed East European location.
That’s a good point.
Did you see and hear the 911 recordings of that guy in NC that ran into a crowd to avenge Muslim deaths by the US? Much of that didn’t seem right, there were no serious injuries and he’s facing 100+ years on terror laws.
Compare that to the 3 college kids and their 10 church burning ‘prank’ that ‘went too far’. I have yet to hear any mention of terrorism charges against them.
looking at 45 years EACH for their drunken sprees. Even with good behavior, they’ll be over 40 before they are released from a state prison. Terror charges are federal and federal prisons are much nicer than Alabama state facilities. So, all things considered, I’ll be satisfied if they do 20 years on a chain gang, won’t you?
I think we need to define the terms and elements used in the so called global war on terror.
interest. Cherry Creek is the area of wealth in Denver. The Cherry Creek school district is the wealthiest school district in Denver. Hmmmmmm, what’s gonna happen here everybody?
It’s also the town of Aurora
It might be a pre-planned experiment for research into threat behavior, social interaction and profile modeling.
Fascists have a tendency to bully and threaten. Seems that Mr. Bennish has hit a nerve.
protesting for him…….these are the wealthiest kids and families in Denver. I think this could be regionally a very important issue and I think that the outcome is important to Denver politically. I think it would be very very cool if Cherry Creek became the next Boulder!
I seem to remember another person who received death threats – the soldier who was so disgusted by Abu Ghraib torture that he sent videos to his superiors. It got so bad, his family couldn’t leave the house in their own hometown.
Ironic, isn’t it? The same folks outraged at a teacher using Nazi analogies to describe Bushco, are using Nazi tactics to suppress his (and others’ who might stay silent after watching this treatment) ability to criticize this administration. Like the host on AAR said this morning, we’ve turned into a country of sneaky narcs. How sweet.
A sad, sad state of affairs indeed.
Have these people nothing better to do with their lives? Time is short, after all — theirs no less than mine, or yours. What type of serious personal deficiencies compel people to live their short time on earth writhing with venom?
It’s pathetic.
to start a civil war here…
go get a gun and wave it around instead. Which fully defines the American Right and the Republican Party. Any bets on whether these killerboy wannabes are “pro life”?
Of course no one is anonymous online, not for law enforcement and for sys admins or literate people who are good at computers.
But the minute your political views get plastered in a place any Bush clown can see things can get nasty…
he and his family have received at least 12 death threats
I’m sure the kid and his parents didn’t mean to get the teacher’s family threated with death, but by publishing the teacher’s views in a widespread manner that is what they caused.
Thank heavens the two doofus who published my friend’s address online at Kos stopped. I’m quite sure my friends views would yield the same attention.
And that is why publishishing a fellow lib’s address online, no matter what the reason is, is the lowest of the low.
But it is a moot point anyway. It is now law: Annoy someone online and you are forced to publish your info.
This case unfortunately is not even unusual in America anymore. It’s good that it is getting publicity, but for something like this there are many more that few people hear about outside the localities where they occur.
And they happen for things like controversies over zoning, or local environmental regulations. That’s where our political life is now. Death threats, or at least telephone threats of bodily harm, threats to family, etc. are COMMON.
That’s why I am uncomfortable with people pumping up anger to fuel political activism. But it’s partly a product of extreme times—when someone like Bush who is legitimately compared to Hitler (Kurt Vonnegut did it recently at Ohio State–he said the only difference between Bush and Hitler is that Hitler was elected), then the gates seem to open on inflamatory rhetoric and ultimate anger at all levels, so that environmentalists are called enviro-Nazis.
But in fact this has been brewing for a long time from the right. I first starting hearing about death threats to local officials in PA during the Clinton years.
That said, anytime is a good time to become aware of this and use the law to try to stop it. It is an offense to the rights of us all as well as to democracy.