Sisyphus…I mean, BooMan…just posted a diary titled Can’t Win For Trying that bemoans the left’s constant position as losers in its Sisyphean ordeal of uphill rock rolling against an almost constantly winning right.
I think that it is time to DROP that rock like a hot potato.
It is a fiction.
A fixation.
A fixation on “Doing things right. The AMERICAN way.”
It does not exist.
There IS no more “American Way”, and if there ever is to be one again, we must reinvent it out of whole cloth.
Read on for more:
Oh BooMan.
Sometimes I am just so sorry for you and your compatriots.
Really.
I like you guys.
Your hearts are in the right place, I think.
But…do you actually believe that the Ford and Reagan eras DID “end”?
No, BooMan. They just took a little unexpected electoral detour or two. Nothing that can’t be ironed out over the long term. Just a little glitch…
Remember…43 years since JFK’s assassination.
12 years of Democrats in the White House (I do not count LBJ, because I believe that he was at least passively complicit in the assassination[s].), 36 years (by the time Bush II is over) of Republicans.
That’s a score of 36 to 12. If this were a football game it would be considered a rout. A laugher.
And then you write:
“It amazes me that all our work has failed to prevent this. But I don’t know what else to do but roll up my sleeves, like Sisyphus, shrug, and start pushing this damn rock back up this damn hill.”
43 years of constant failure. And there you go, pushing the same damned rock back up the same damned hill.
WHEN ARE YOU PEOPLE GOING TO GET IT, BOOMAN???
Sisyphus was CONDEMNED FOR HIS SINS…primarily the sin of hubris, because he tried to cheat death not once but twice…to roll that rock.
The only “sin” the left has committed is the venial one of credulity. Of innocence. It has believed the official story. It has accepted the story around which the fix has been spun.
The “America The Great” story.
The “America: The Constitutional Democracy Story.”
‘Tain’t so, BooMan.
Not since 1963.
The fall of 1963.
The FALL of 1963.
And not EVER for the poor. The permanently disenfranchised by dint of their skin color or sex.
Not EVER.
Stop rolling that rock.
It ain’t going NOWHERE.
Except back down the hill.
A sane man…an unhypnotized, un-mediaized man…would see that.
Eventually.
You would think.
Wouldn’t you?
Say when the candidate for the losing side went skiing in Gstaad while the evidence of the fix in Ohio was being assembled and wrote an OH so nice letter to his fellow Democrats about how for the good of the country we should now all rally ’round the winner and go fight the bad guys who wear rags on their heads and murder innocent American wimmins an’ chil’rens an’ such.
Like GOOD little sheeple.
And then some of you get incensed when I suggest that you wake the fuck up?
Rolling a Sisyphean rock again and again up Capitol Hill while your weak-livered, Humpty Hump Hump politicians sell you down the river at every turn is the ACT of a sleeping people. A sleeping people who NEED a good wake-the-fuck-up call.
So far, only Russell Feinstein and George Galloway have stood up in public, taken off their kid gloves and said “OK, motherfuckers. You want a fight? I got yer fight right HERE!!!”
I was watching a prizefight last night…an overweight, too old James Toney (One of my favorite characters of all time in sports, a natural middleweight who put on the pounds in order to get some of that heavyweight money) against a plodding journeyman heavyweight. I didn’t even watch it to the end but I think Toney lost simply by being too small, too old and too fat…the other guy was TERRIBLE and Toney is a master.
Anyway, in true HBO fashion they did a little feature on the fighters, and in Toney’s feature it was noted that he is an truly obstreperous trash talker and actor-out in the gym, and that he acted out once by throwing a chair though the wall of a gym owned by the fine trainer and ex-lightweight boxer Freddie Roach. Now usually people just let Toney get away with his act, but Roach…who is ten years older and about 60 lbs lighter than Toney…got in his face.
Toney said some shit about how he would “Wipe the floor with you, white boy” and in his own words (with a smile and a little twinkle in his eye), Roach answered “Well…maybe you will. But you’ll know you’ve been in a fight.” The exact same idea my Irish grandfather (The REAL “Arthur Gilroy”) taught me when I had to learn how to deal with bullies.
It works, too.
Toney backed down, and the little South Boston Irish banty rooster prizefighter is now Toney’s trainer. Calls him “son” in the corner.
America. Ain’t it great?
Welll…I think it’s great anyway. And I think that the Dems could do worse than listen to little Freddie Roach.
Stop pushing that Sisyphean political rock up the neverending down staircase of the Ratpub hustle.
Step back, ball your fists and say “OK. You want a fight? I got yer fight RIGHT HERE!!!”
You write:
“I don’t know how we lost the battle. I don’t know how we got back here from there.”
BooMan…WE NEVER LEFT “THERE”.
The deal has been crooked from the Grassy Knoll right on through to the cooked books and the fixed elections.
BOTH sides.
Time for something new.
Time for THE NEW PARTY!!!
Yes.
Impeach BOTH sides.
Send the Liebermans down the river WITH their Ratpub boys.
Clean house.
It’s time.
Later…
AG
P.S. And…awww…YOU know.
WAKE THE FUCK UP!!!
Isn’t that rock getting just a little…heavy, BooMan?
You’d think so.
Wouldn’t you…???
Wakeup recommendations?
Anybody?
Anybody up out there?
AG
Ahhh. You obviously either disagree with Camus, or you don’t get the reference. Whether you choose to push the rock for the Democratic Party or a Third Party, the only naivete lies in giving up on pushing the rock, or in believing that it matters whether it rolls back down again.
What happens when one realizes that one has been pushing the rock up the wrong hill?
OR;
Pushing the wrong rock up the correct hill?
Thanx
The man of survival is man ground up by the machinery of hierarchical power, caught in a mass of interferences, a tangle of oppressive techniques whose rationalization only awaits the patient programming of programmed minds.
The Revolution of Everyday Life
by Raoul Vaneigem
Y’know, BooMan…when I read Sartre…and when I reread such deep thinkers as yourself as well…I am often reminded of a lesson I learned from a great jazz musician.
Houston Person.
Never heard of him?
You ain’t been listening with them GOOD ears.
Not a famous intellectual figure even in the jazz world…just a true player. A black tenor player with real southern roots who is now probably well into his 70s and who for 50 years has made a steady living playing…the blues.
The JAZZ blues, which is harmonically and rhythmically a whole ‘nother level beyond simpler blues forms.
Sophisticated music that has not lost its common sense.
Its soul.
Its connection with working peolpe.
So here we are…a fine big band of NY jazz players, rehearsing for a concert celebrating the sophisticated (and decidedly NON-bluesy, in its original intent) music of Harold Arlen. (Over the Rainbow, It’s Only A Paper Moon, Stormy Weather, I’ve Got the World on A String…YOU know. STANDARD standards.)
With Houston Person as the featured soloist.
Now Houston doesn’t talk a lot.
He’s a big man…wide receiver, NBA shooting guard big..and he looks and sounds as if he’s leaning against an invisible wall while he’s playing. Every note reaxed, from the heart and true. And the arrangements and band were fine as well. So we were just sailing along, getting the cues straight, etc. About an hour and a half into the rehearsal, however, we ran into a little roadblock. The bass player, who although VERY good is also somewhat renowned for being a little…fussy (A little too thinky, not enough feely sometimes)…stops the band on this one chart and starts a discussion about how the rhythm section should be approaching the time feel. Should it be straighter eighth notes, more or less of a shuffle feel, etc. This goes on for about 5 minutes, the arranger/conductor trying to reason w/the rhythm section (to little effect) and Houston just leaning back against his invisible wall up there in front of the band.
Waiting.
Until finally he straightened up a little, turned around to face the band, and said quite clearly and slowly “HEY man. It’s JUST the blues!!! Let’s take it from the top. ” And he counted it off. “2-3-4.”
You can intellecualize about Sisyphus all you want. I’ll bet HE did some heavy thinking around the 27th millenium of his endless task as well.
But it’s just the blues, BooMan..
It’s just the blues.
It’s REAL simple.
You…and almost the entire REST of the left…continue pushing the wrong rock up the wrong hill.
You’re a rock junkie. And you use intellecualization as a denial tool.
“ME??? I’M not a rock junkie!!! I’M a deep thinker!!! This rock rolling is just what I do to get my exercise whilst I’m a’thinkin’.”
Bullshit.
Kick cold turkey or die like a dog.
It really IS that simple.
Do it or not.
“Take it from the top….2-3-4.”
One more time.
Please.
Roll that ol’ rock on down the hill and never EVER go back to push it up again.
It’s ONLY the blues!!!
Go on out and play it.
It’s only a new set of dues.
Go on out and pay them.
Your union has proven itself to be incompetent and useless over the last 50 years.
Go out and join a better one.
Or start your own if you have to.
In the end…you be bettah off.
Bet on it.
Later…
AG
that’s a lot of talk for someone who still totally misses the point.
To counter Camus by insisting the struggle is absurd is mind-blowingingly inept on your part.
Not the struggle. BooMan.
Just the form.
When you run one play over and over and over and over again…when you bet on one losing team repeatedly despite all evidence to the contrary…
You just hooked on losing.
Papo down on the corner of 148th and Lex could tell you THAT.
If you’d just put down your books and ask him.
“You just hooked on losing.”
Yup.
That’s what HE’D tell you.
And he’d be right.
(A renownedly nasty jones, by the way, Boo. Got old man Freud’s shorts all in a bunch, too. Bet on it.)
AG
P.S. Now a diary.
BooMan: It’s ONLY the BLUES!!! (Houston Person, 2003)
AG
You clearly haven’t understood a word of the diary that inspired your two diaries.
The point of Camus’s essay is that life is unavoidable tragic and our actions are inescapably vain. We are condemned to push the rock up the hill only to see it roll back down.
You can’t push the wrong rock, in fact, you have no choice in the matter.
If you gain one level of awareness, such as yours, you will discover that vanity, but not the inescapability of the vanity. Therefore, you may latch onto some panacea that might put an end to the absurdity.
Like a Madman in the Marketplace, you may hold up a lantern and ask people to wake up and see that all is vanity. Or you may come up with some “manual of happiness” including a Newstrike or a third party.
That shows your awareness has only made a first step. There are no panaceas. There is only the struggle. And the struggle, when it becomes conscious, is tragic.
The next step is not to care that it is tragic. And to choose joy in defiance of the Gods.
You promote apathy. You do not show the way to joy.
Lastly, the Democratic Party is my vehicle for change precisely because I recognize the impossibility of perfection as well as the futility of dividing an already neutered left.
BushCo. is not more of the same. They are the worst administration in our modern history. I’m not willing to play games with third parties to teach the wrong party a lesson.
As you wish.
MY take on it is that it is a NEGATION of effort.
You CAN push the wrong rock; you DO have a choice in the matter, and there is NO joy in Mudville when Mighty Casey habitually strikes out.
Sorry, BooMan.
One reason that the left has so badly lost here is JUST this attitude.
It the the attitude of thjose who have lost faith in evolution.
HUMAN evolution.
Or who at the very least think that evolution will continue without their conscious efforts to change things.
So just go push ANY rock. It’s the effort hat coiunts.
No.
Not in MY neighborhood.
If you practice the wrong scales all of your life you simply will never play like Charlie Parker.
And playing on that level IS desireable.
Else…why bother?
In the service of the Inscrutable All?
I think not.
SCRUTABLE all that!!!
It’s JUST the blues, BooMan.
Once you really understand that fact things get much…simpler.
And more efficient too.
bet on it.
If this note doesn’t work so well…repeatedly…then TRY ANOTHER NOTE!!!
Or…from the undermind of America as exporessed in vaudeville comedy:
Silly patient: “Doc!!! It hoits when I do DIS!!!” (Raing his arm above his head.
Silly doctor: “Don’t DO dat!!!”
Yup.
Duh.
If it’s called common sense…how come it’s so goddamned rare?
AG
if you don’t understand the analogy then don’t pontificate.
I might as well attack your diary by saying that you are wearing the wrong colored shirt.
Your whole argument is just argumentative. It is not a rebuttal of anything I said. It is only a rebuttal of what you think I said because you don’t understand the references.
It’s tiresome, AG.
You cannot push the wrong rock. Sisyphus is all of us. You don’t get to opt out of being Sisyphus. You can’t get rid of the rock by turning off the television.
It’s boring to engage in this kind of conversation with someone that can’t get the point.
Bored?
Oh.
OK.
Stop.
(You can always turn on the TV and get ALL het up again, though. That’s what it’s THERE for.)
AG
If you would listen instead of making nitpicking your permanent vocation, you might have noted the lyrics (both included and only available thru the link) to Stella Blue, and then you might have seen how it is an Existentialist anthem through the eyes of a touring musician. It might have spoken to you about a number of things, including: your identifition of evel and the necessity to fight it without expectation of prevailing, your interpretation of history from Dealey Plaze until now, and your need to believe that there is still a way forward despite all evidence to the contrary.
But you aren’t listening.
I reference Charlie Parker, a genius on the Mozart level, and you reference Jerry Garcia, who was an execrable poet who couldn’t even tune his own guitar.
He wasn’t a touring musician…he was a touring faker.
That about sums it up, Boo.
And you think you understand Camus and Sartre.
You don’t even understand middle Bb yet.
PLUS…unless it’s just bad syntax…you statement about my “need to believe that there is still a way forward despite all evidence to the contrary” seems somehow disapproving.
BooMan…the entire history of the universe as far as we know it strongly suggests that there is indeed a “way forward”. And you, sir are as lost as a babe in the woods if you cannot see that one simple truth.
Every tree past which you walk deep in painful thought about how to roll your goddamned rock up the hill one more goddamned time and what a drag it is to have to do so bears mute witness the the way forward as it lifts its braches to the divine sky above.
And you can’t see it.
Nor can you hear how bad thge grateful dead really were. And are.
Becuase you are…
TAH DAH!!!
Fast asleep.
I am through trying to reach you.
You are too deep into it.
Sweet dreams.
Jerry Garcia!!!
Sweet JESUS!!!
I’m outta here.
AG
Robert Hunter. Not JG.
Same lame scene, BooMan.
Same lame scene.
AG
Hunter’s note in Box of Rain says “This lyric is a requiem for King Faisal of Saudi Arabia, a progressive and democratically inclined ruler [and, incidentally, a fan of the Grateful Dead] whose assassination in 1975 shocked us personally.”
Listen, BooMan…all the words “a fan of the Grtaeful Dead” mean to me is someone who was not given the tools to recognize amateurish bullshit from art by his education and does not have enough native intelligence to figure it out for himself.
” Tonality is a natural force, like gravity. Indeed, when we consider that the root of a chord, because of its most favorable vibration-ratio to the other tones, and the lowest tone of a chord, because of the actually greater dimension and weight of its wave, have greater importance than the other tones, we recognize at once that it is gravitation itself that draws the tones towards their roots and towards the bass line, and that relates a multiplicity of chords to the strongest among them.” Paul Hindemith
Can’t HAVE “tonality” if you are too ignorant to be able to tune your fucking guitar.
Just bullshit and posing.
Bad time, bad notes, bad tuning, laughably primitive attempts at “improvisation”…lame like a motherfucker. And anyone who involved himself in that scene is EQUALLY lame and woudn’t recognize “Allah” if he showed up in the room and started dictating verses of the Koran to him in Brooklyn-accented English.
Just another acid casualty, as far as I am concerned.
Go read Rumi or Shakespeare if you want verse.
Go listen to Bird or Mozart if you want music.
Go listen to Chano Pozo or Art fucking Blakey or Frank Sinatra or James brown if you want groove.
But DON’T hand me that Grateful Dead shit.
Lame like a MOTHERFUCKER!!!
Over and out.
AG
Your conceit is amusing. You dismiss a lot when you dismiss so totally. Dylan said it one way, Hunter said it another. Open your mind, and you’ll see Hunter was saying the same thing you are trying to say.
P.S. Go read some Bob Dylan, you want poetry.
AG
BooMan says: The point of Camus’s essay is that life is unavoidable tragic and our actions are inescapably vain. We are condemned to push the rock up the hill only to see it roll back down.
Say’s Camus. Why should I believe him?
How do you know Camus is correct here? Is it from your own experiences before reading Camus or after? After all it (Camus’s essay) is only one of many, many such essays expounding on the Meaning of The Struggle, whatever that may be. Is ALL of life tragic? Are all of our actions vain? Personally, my life has had some tragic moments, and many of my actions were quite fun. How ’bout your’s?
pax
P.S. From one who just wrote a diary bemoaning the fact that he seems stuck with pushing a Sisyphean rock yet one more exhausting time up a seemingly endless hill, the words “You clearly haven’t understood a word” regarding ANYBODY else ring more than a little…unseemly, BooMan.
Hollow, even.
“Fatigue makes cowards of us all.” Vince Lombardi
Yup.
“Fools, too.” Arthur Gilroy
Yup
AG
Thank ypou, Ed.
Rock rollin’ is (unfortunately) here to stay.
So it rolls…
AG