Promoted by Steven D. Way to go ilona!
I’ve been out of it a bit since having the flu last week; have I woken up from its haze in an alternate universe or something?
Tom DeLay shuts his campaign down, Chris Matthews covers posttraumatic stress disorder [PTSD] on Hardball, and FOX News delivers a great piece of reporting on PTSD — currently the featured story on their Politics page. As if that weren’t enough, FOX News cites and links back to my PTSD Combat blog (taking notes AP?) and the PTSD Timeline at ePluribus Media.
I want to thank reporter Kelley Beaucar Vlahos for her efforts in presenting PTSD to the FOX News audience. She wrote a solid piece any veterans health advocate should be glad to be associated with. And she eased my worries (this was the first time I was approached for an interview on the subject). Now, I can’t say my experience with FOX News is anything at all like the deserved crush John Gibson has on Maryscott O’Connor; but, I’m really happy to see that every now and again FOX News surprises us.
More below the fold…
So, let’s jump right into the article (first, the intro):
Blaming what they say is a shortsighted, under-funded system that does not learn from past mistakes, some advocacy groups say they are concerned that the federal government is unprepared to help the wave of troops returning from Iraq seeking mental health care.
“We should have been ready for this,” said Steve Robinson, director of the National Gulf War Resource Center, a veterans advocacy organization. “It’s simple math: If there is an increase in demand, and there is not an equal increase in dollars to hire new people to buy more equipment or provide more services, the person who suffers is the returning veteran.”
Vlahos goes on to share some veteran mental health stats that come from a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in March.
She refreshingly included my main criticism I have with the data: you simply can’t use these statistics (which are from the first year of the war) to reliably conclude what the current mental state of our soldiers is. As ground-breaking as this study was (and it honestly deserved the credit and attention it received), today’s Iraq battlefield is entirely different than the one that existed in 2003 — and that difference has a direct bearing on the number and intensity of PTSD cases we’re seeing today.
The numbers were based on screening and follow-ups of more than 300,000 troops returning from Iraq, Afghanistan and Bosnia from May 2003 to April 2004, leading many to surmise that the number with mental health problems has increased since then, since the rate of battlefield casualties among U.S. service members has also risen.
“[The study] is only marginally relevant to what condition our troops currently find themselves in,” said [the] editor of PTSD Combat: Winning the War Within. “A lot has changed since that time, including increased number of troop deployments … and an escalation in [improvised explosive device] attacks.”
She’d asked me if I believed that the nation is prepared to deal with the needs of our returning veterans coping with PTSD. I was glad to see that she included my response:
[A]n alarming rate of violent incidents, suicide, homelessness and unemployment among recent veterans has been documented, but the issue has not garnered much national attention. “We simply have not been the beneficiaries of that type of substantial coverage by the media these past three years,” she said. “So, how exactly would the public be expected to be prepared for what’s to come — in fact, what is already here?“
Vlahos moves on to include a response by the VA, listing some of their efforts in providing the best health care possible to our returning veterans: the record-setting $80 billion set aside in Bush’s 2007 VA budget is mentioned as is the addition of PTSD specialists in every VA facility.
Republican Sen. Larry Craig of Idaho, chairman of the Senate Veterans Affairs Committee, said the government is already meeting the new demands. “The president has always made it clear that military veterans are among his highest priorities, and this budget demonstrates his dedication to all who have worked in uniform,” he said.
In any case, advocates … say they hope the government will stick to its promises. “How loudly we cheered them onward as they laced up their boots has no relevance once they’ve done their job. It’s how well we took care of them when they return that really defines our true moral character.“
[Rubbing eyes…] Whoa! Hold everything.
That was my quote Ms. Vlahos and FOX News decided to end this piece on?! OK, someone just try to get me to believe I’m not still in my flu-induced haze of an alternate universe. Go ahead and try… :o)
Although I’m having a bit of fun here, and beaming a bit at having been given the chance to advocate on behalf of our vets coping with PTSD, this article would have received a recommend from me even if I wasn’t fortunate enough to have been a part of it.
I’m beaming tonight to see this issue dealt with in a serious manner on a media outlet we often consider to be broken. Although this one article is but a grain of sand in a sandstorm of spin, I welcome it (and I’ll keep fingers crossed for more of its kind). Bit by bit, hopefully people of all political stripes can come together on this of all issues. Can we all agree that our soldiers should be taken care of — for their own good, as well as that of the society at large?
Again, I’d like to personally thank Ms. Vlahos for writing this piece.
It personally gives me much to be hopeful for: the plight of our soldiers and Marines weighed down by PTSD is reaching a wider audience, one that probably doesn’t hear enough about this issue. Or, what it hears of the issue falls more along the lines of what’s found in a recent Oliver North column — that the mere public discussion of PTSD seems to be causing the high unemployment rates of our returning troops:
According to the U.S. Department of Labor, the national unemployment rate is hovering around 4.8 percent. But for veterans of the Global War on Terror (GWOT), the unemployment rate is more than three times higher — 15.6 percent. Why?
Part of the answer is found in the fact that so few corporate executives and personnel managers are veterans themselves. Couple that with a drumbeat of adverse publicity about the war, a mainstream media fixation on military “atrocities” and the constant harping about post-traumatic stress disorder — PTSD — and one has to wonder how any war veteran gets hired. On a recent flight to Texas, my seatmate, a corporate CEO, asked if “all the troops coming back from ‘over there’ were ‘screwed up.'” He cited a study alleging that, “more than a third of those who served in Iraq and Afghanistan needed psychological treatment.” The actual number — according to the American Medical Association — is 35 percent — a figure compiled by psychiatrists who have made diagnosing PTSD a self-employment program.
Um, Ollie: 35% actually equals “more than a third” the last time I checked. And the last time I checked, an organization that goes by the name of the Veterans Administration has an entire website devoted to combat-related PTSD. An entire website! Is the VA also merely trying to stay in business with its PTSD conspiracy ploy?
So, I applaud Ms. Vlahos’ solid reporting. A larger cross-section of people are learning more about combat-related PTSD tonight — and, hopefully, a few more will rally around the cause as we have here. As great as it is for us to talk amongst ourselves, sometimes it’s even better to have the opportunity to reach a wider audience — and Ms. Vlahos’ excellent piece allows us that opportunity.
And so, please:
– Read the entire article.
– Email it to those friends and family members who only believe things they hear from FOX News.
– And thank FOX News (yes!) for this effort to educate their readers.
And, finally, an ever greater heartfelt thanks goes out to you guys. You know who you are. I personally never would have been approached by FOX News, never would have started up a PTSD blog, never would have stuck with this issue without the awesome support of everyone at ePluribus Media, My Left Wing, Political Cortex, Daily Kos, Soap Blox/Chicago, and most recently Booman Tribune. Thank you all for taking on this issue and spreading the news far and wide.
We’re making a difference. You can count on it.
I’m still new to the community here, and have been so swamped that I haven’t spent as much time as I’d like to get to know one and all; but, I wanted say thanks to everyone here for the support this issue has gotten in the few diaries that I’ve cross-posted.
Every effort on our part(s) makes a bigger difference than any one of us might even know.
Congrats on making the recommended list at DKos.
Aw shucks, thanks Steven. I’m exhausted from the Rec List action, what with the required tending to the Big Orange log, etc. Later, I stepped away from the computer for a bit (what the heck was I thinking!?)…
Now I’ve dived back in, and settled in your mighty fine pond for a spell and notice that you FP’ed the darn thing! Always late to the party, am I. I’m sorry my replies are delayed in coming; sincerity hasn’t dimmed, though, with the passage of time (my mind is another matter entirely…early to bed tonight will help with that, I hope). Thanks, everyone for the great help on broadcasting this. You guys do most assuredly rock!
Geez, what the heck am I going to do tomorrow to top this? Yikes. :o)
As a vet I want to personally thank you for working tirelessly on this issue, and FOX for turning it’s usually blind eye to a real story AND for not sugar-coating it with a healthy dose of spin.
One gripe: Didn’t the bush admin make a large CUT the VA’s budget before they added a bit back for PTSD?
…and I do mean that. Can’t imagine the unique rollercoaster ride every former (and current) veteran must be going through these past 5 years as we headed down the war’s road once more.
You’re right about wondering about the budget’s cut before this year’s budget addition. Although the President’s $2.77 trillion budget (VA portion: $80.6 billion) would add about $3 billion in real appropriations for veterans health care over that of last year’s, it “relies on $1.1 billion in cost-saving ‘efficiencies’ — the subject of a Government Accountability Office report released in February which criticized past VA health-care projections from the president’s Office of Management and Budget.” And that’s not all! There’s more (you knew there wasn’t didn’t you, CM1?)
With his 2007 budget, the President wishes to:
If I didn’t know better, I’d think they were trying to take care of our veterans on the cheap. That’s not what this War President is planning to do, now, is it?
Thank you, Ilona for persistently tackling PTSD. There is a lot to learn. The first time I read that women are more susceptible to suffering from PTSD, I was floored. What about those military families where both parents are gone to Iraq? There are so many issues and angles about PTSD, the media should have covered this from day one.
There are many veterans issues that the MSM dutifully ignores. To see coverage on FoxNews about PTSD is a real accomplishment. Toots to you… keep it up!
Now there you go, making me blush. THANK you, too…we’re all in this together.
I know, no one wants to touch Fox News with a ten-meter pole, but it would be a nice thing to write to them and tell them how much we appreciate the story. Positive reinforcement is an important part of the carrot-and-stick approach, and when they do things right, we should say so.
No, thank you Ilona for your dedication to this very important topic. If one feels they support the troops, it is more when they come home and really need us that we have to make sure we and most importantly the GD government is there for them. After my experience with Scott, an Iraqi Vet Against the War in Crawford, I know first hand how badly they will need us. Great work!!
Solid!
A Vietnam Veteran this post triggered another flashback of sadness. We weren’t Rambo but innocents turned into losers. Screwed by leaders who knew better.
Ollie North rings true. Modern corporate American will only hire illegal aliens or squeaky clean multi-taskers. Today’s grunts are screwed by delusional leaders and the lack of good jobs.
Iraqi vets may not just act out and build a wall of remembrance. They could trigger the Cultural Revolution that ends the American Empire.
I don’t know how to add anything, other than to say I’m sorry that this madness is happening all over again for you guys to have to wade through once more. Thanks for your service, Jim; I’m so sorry that we have just not been able as a do right by all of you’ve who’ve worn the uniform. It hurts me to hear how deeply we’ve let you all down…
already over at: Pluribus Media
The below article came in my Veterans For Common Sense Newsletter. Thought you might find it interesting.
Coping with combat
SCOTT HADLY
Santa Barbara Newspress {This is a subscription site}
The following I have passed around and use it occasionally as a signature, the site that is, but for those who hadn’t seen this, and Especially know any Military Personal who might use the site:
U.S. Military Has New Online Mental Health Resource
Forbes
ilona, this keeps popping up in the VCS Newsletter, the study, with link back to Political Cortex, and highlighting a response on the message board. There are only some 10 responses, but below is the one they Highlight and have a few times. Thought I’d pass it on if you hadn’t seen the Site.
PTSD Breakdown: We’re Failing the American Military Family
Political Cortex, NY
Veterans For Common Sense Message Board:
Also, right now, I’m streaming AA and listening to Randy Rhodes Talkin about PTSD, playing clips from Hardball and relating a few cases of Suicides and Those suffering from!!
~~~~~~~~
This Country also better be Prepared for what may come from the Children Now Actually Living those Tragic Experiances, in Iraq and Afganistan!!
For we waged War, and are Fighting, against many who were the Kids of the 1st Gulf War, the bombings, the highway of death, the loss of family members and others…………..!
And in Todays World will they Lash Out as have some Leading Up To This, think about it, along with callers giving first hand responses!!!!!!!!!!!!
“along with callers giving first hand responses”
should have been at the end of the Rhodes info, not my sig,Whoops!!!
Jim, you are a one-man dynamo and are absolutely irreplaceable. Thanks for passing these links on…will check ’em out tomorrow after dinner and a solid night’s sleep — and then I’ll send them on to others.
“you are a one-man dynamo”
Wish that were true, although since 2000 and saying “It Was Getting Colder”, to friends, pertaining to the so called Cold War, and stating than we were heading towards a Conflict somewhere, and fast, All That’s Happened Since Has Made My Life Busier Than Ever!!
I only get a few hours a day online, after work, of which I’m ussually extremely tired, work construction. I use 4 differant E-mails, somewhat set up to receive certain types and send postings to a few boards from only one, cuts the spam. I never could type and it’s even harder now as on my left hand I’m missing half of my index and a third of my middle finger and had sliced the palm to the bone in a workrelated accident some 14yrs, ago, after 35 in the business.
I get a number, adding them constantly, of NewsLetters, which have become my News, along with these few boards. It’s all I need in these times of No More Real Investigative Reporters, or very few.
A few reasons I don’t comment much are: Too Tired and the Typing Thingy, also not much of a writer, but I do Read an awful lot of the postings and there are some Great Writers/Thinkers which is a Hopeful Sign for this Country and World!!