Like some of you, I am an adult child of a combat veteran. My combat-veteran father has severe, debilitating PTSD. His war devastated him, and subsequently, our family. His experience in Vietnam nearly forty years ago, when I was nary a twinkle in his eye, helped shape the person I am today, and for a long time, I have wanted to know and feel the things that did this to him, and to me. I had gathered bits of puzzling information here and there over the years, but as I got older and achieved a truer understanding of the impact of his war on him and our family, I realized that I needed to hear his story in its entirety, that I needed to hear the unmentioned details that would meld the story into a complete whole.
One night, a few months ago, my dad was at my house. We were speaking of politics and current events, and I realized that I had a perfect opportunity to ask him about his experience. The asking was difficult, because I knew that should he choose to recount his story, it was likely that he would suffer even more disturbed sleep than usual and more than a few troubled days. My need to know prevailed, however, and I timidly asked him a very basic, child-like question – “What happened to you?” He seemed startled by my inquisitiveness, and I told him that if it made him feel bad to tell me, he didn’t have to. He then said something that surprised me – he told me that I had caught him off guard, that he was pleased that I wanted to know, that he thought I should know, and that no one in the family had ever asked him like that before. And so began his tale.
He and I stayed up through the night talking, and then continued our discussion through another night a few weeks later. He was forthright and honest, and the vividness with which he remembered things was startling. He shared with me truths about war that no father is anxious to share with his daughter – truths about existing in a state of sustained fear, the horror of invoking death, what a person is capable of doing in order to preserve one’s life and the lives of others – all truths that set the course of his life, and mine, forever. It’s a detailed and convoluted story, horrible and ugly, and more than anything, infuriating to the core.
All of the details of his experience are too much to share in this forum, but I can tell you this: my dad was sent to Vietnam in 1967. He was nineteen years old. Six months into his tour, my teen-aged father, ill-equipped to handle killing and dying, snapped, in the field, and was sent for psychological evaluation. Three days later, he was back with his unit and forced back into combat. Nine months into his tour, he snapped again, this time for good, and he left Vietnam, medicated into submission and wearing a straightjacket, headed for the psychiatric ward at Yokosuka Naval Hospital. After two months there, he did a few months in the psychiatric ward of Bethesda Naval Hospital, and for many years after that, he was on his own. No follow up, no disability, no help. Nothing.
What else did I learn from our discussions? Well, I learned that, in war, my father was disposable; that my father was valued only as a killing machine; that living daily in an environment that all but guaranteed his eventual death threatened, and yes, even compromised, my father’s moral center. I learned that the first time my father was forced to kill, he threw up, and that the vomiting continued until, after only three months in, he had lost fifty pounds. I learned that my mother (who was only sixteen years old at the time) visited my father at Bethesda Naval Hospital, and met a man she had never seen before, a man whose eyes were glazed over, a man who was so medicated that he was incoherent and drooling. I learned that when my father was finally discharged and returned home, he met my mother at the airport with as much excitement as his still-medicated body could muster, while at the same time looking around the airport and telling his now twenty-year-old self, “I’m fucked.”
I also learned why my father had twenty-seven jobs in twenty-two years, and why a loud noise or an unexpected tap on the shoulder could send him into a whirlwind of rage and chaos. I learned why going out in public was so difficult for him, and why, when we went to a restaurant, he had to have his back to the wall and his eyes on the door, and why, if such positioning was impossible to achieve, we left. I learned why my mom once found him wandering our neighborhood in the middle of the night, wearing only his underwear, and why I knew intuitively as a child to never, EVER, startle him when he was sleeping. I learned what drove him to attempt suicide, not once, not twice, but three times, with the third (pills, vodka, pistol) maiming him forever, and I learned that all three of those attempts occurred on or near the same day in the same month that he first snapped in Vietnam. I learned why my father sought out volatile situations from which he would be forced to extract himself, and how constant hyperawareness and subsequent adrenaline dumps damaged his organs. I learned why my father never had more than three uninterrupted hours of sleep per night in thirty-plus years, why he would be awake for days at a time, and how devastating the effects of perpetual sleeplessness can be on a body and mind. I learned why my hyper-vigilant father stopped driving the family car with us in it, and eventually just stopped going pretty much anywhere. I learned that when my father finally received his disability, twenty-three years after the fact, he saw the money as “blood money” and wanted nothing to do with it. I learned how he hated even endorsing the checks, and how relieved he was when the government implemented direct deposit, for that meant he would never have to touch those checks again.
The most important thing I learned, however, is that we who have not experienced it cannot effectively imagine the horrors of war. It is impossible to imagine or understand the power of the sounds, the smells, the sights, the fear, and the devastation of war. We can never really know the full impact of such trauma on one’s mind and the havoc it can create, nor can we ever completely comprehend the soul-destroying things that war might make one do. Though we would like to believe that we are above such things, that our morals and good, solid upbringing would act as shiny beacons leading us away from such depravity, the truth is, we just don’t know how we might act or what we might do if emboldened by fear, anger, and the desire to stay alive in a war zone, and we should consider ourselves lucky that we will likely never know.
Though such things may disgust, sadden and enrage me, I have learned that I can never be so presumptuous as to judge the actions of a lowly grunt in the field. I must leave that to others, for if I do not, I would find myself forced to pass judgment on my father, and, knowing what I know of him, that is something I would never do. Those unfortunate enough to experience the unthinkable in war don’t need my condemnation, for theirs has been created for them.
Very powerful.
It’s too bad the people who MAKE the decisions that send people like your father and my uncle into such soul-destroying situations never seem to have to live with the consequences of them.
Thanks for sharing.
It’s my first diary, and I thank you for taking the time to read it.
Sometimes we get the fuckers to the Hague!
for sharing this.
Perhaps if Bush, Cheney, and all the others responsible for what has transpired in Iraq had actually served in Vietnam, they wouldn’t have been so quick to go to war in the first place.
How many more diaries like this are we going to see 30-40 years from now?
Blessings and peace to you and to your father…
There’s a family going through, or headed for, the same sort of trauma as we speak, and it just sickens me. Thank you for taking the time to read my story.
Thank you for writing this loving diary. It must have been a relief to your dad for somebody to finally ask him, and then for him to get to talk while you listened so carefully and lovingly. I hope he finds some peace in his life.
those moments with my father were extremely powerful and brought us both to tears at times.
.
Thanks for sharing your life’s story and forcing others to never forget what war is all about. Your diary was also posted at Big Orange. See General Frank’s remarks from this weekend.
Study and treatment of PTSD in the Netherland from World War II suffering and the precautions for today’s soldiers.
Resistance workers and war-affected people
In short, Center 1945 treats the psychological complaints of participants in the resistance movement, the persecuted and civil war victims from the period of the German and Japanese occupation. This concerns people with psychological problems who during the Second World War …
Learning To Be Safe
No shame
Towards the end of a mission each soldier has an individual talk with a professional; two months after the mission this is repeated and, after six months, both the soldiers and their spouses or partners receive a questionnaire to fill in. Colonel Wil Martens points out that the time is long past when soldiers were ashamed to show their feelings of fear or even their inability to go into combat in front of their comrades:
“Feelings of shock are normal reactions to abnormal situations”
Even the tough guys in the Commando Corps are keen to take part in the one-to-one talks and follow-up care. Before and during the mission, assistance is also available for the families, in the form of meetings, special phone lines, organised mutual support and suchlike.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
for the links, and for stopping to read and post. I am often impressed by the openness exhibited in other countries’ PTSD treatment programs, especially when it relates to the impact on families. When I first starting researching online, it seemed like every good link that came up was Australian.
And at the moment we have a government that hides the coffins, cuts the benefits, never goes to funerals, grinds people down in endless rotations and stop-loss orders–and still manages to manipulate symbols so well that much of the military enthusiastically supports them.
Beautifully written diary.
thank you. Their manipulation is breathtaking, brilliantly effective, and disgusting beyond words.
War is immoral by definition.
Those who order young people into wars based on lies are the most immoral.
Thank you for your diary and for the even more difficult effort on the part of you and your father to relive that horror.
I was prompted to write this diary when I saw critical comments in other threads that seemed to oversimplify one’s ability to be moral in an environment that, by virtue of its very existence, is immoral.
My uncle served in WW2 in the Battle of the Bulge. He suffered what we would call PTSD today but which was then described as “battle fatigue.” He was in combat for about 2 months before he was relieved and sent back to Britain. Only recently has he begun to talk abouit it at the urging of my Aunt.
My uncle was in the 589th Field Artillery
Battalion attached to the 424th Infantry Regiment of the 106th Division. The other two regiments of this division were surrounded during the opeing days of the Battle of the Bulge and captured en masse. My unlce speaks of the fighting being so close that they were using their howitzers as if they were shotguns. He came back with “battle fatigue” and a constant ringing in his ears that lasted until the day he died. When I turned twenty one, I went on one of his benders with him. Being drunk was the only thing that stopped the ringing. He was embarrassed that I had learned how he dealt with the after effects of America’s Heroic Battle but I pretty much learned about his whole war experience that day. The hangover was worth it.
His are stories we should all hear. I hope that it is therapeutic for him and for your aunt.
My brother-in-law has been waiting to receive his PTSD disability money for several years. He has appealed the first ruling that denied the benefits, (almost routine he was told) and evidently his request is now (successfully) nearing the end of the process.
No one should be made to suffer what these people went through, and are struggling against every day. When he was finally diagnosed with PTSD, thirty-some years after the fact, he immediately applied for benefits. Now, some years later, he is still waiting for the money, trying to support his wife (my husband’s sister) and her married son and family. It’s an emotional and financial struggle that we, the extended family, are dealing with.
Our government is quick to use young men and women in the armed forces, but terribly slow at healing and helping them once their usefulness has passed.
Thank you for your diary. Best wishes and healing to your father.
Our government is so unwilling to pay for the sacrifices soldiers and their families make. Were it up to me, your brother-in-law and his family would be taken care of until death, since war likely robbed them of much of their lives. The last thing a PTSD family needs to worry about is finances. I am sorry that your family is going through this, and I hope that all of you get the relief you so richly deserve. It is amazing how deeply PTSD can affect an entire family, immediate and extended. Best wishes to you all.
to the many men and women who’ve been treated at the White River Junction VA, most of them Vietnam Vets. They helped put PTSD on the books as a real entity, and pointed the way to much of what we know now about PTSD.
My great uncle came back from WWI shell-shocked, in time to see his young wife and daughter die of the flu. He was ever after silent, more comfortable in the woods with his dogs than with people. My dad came back from WWII with PTSD. He did not suffer as badly as many persons, but he left his “mark” on the 5 children he had in the years that followed. Anxiety, depression, suicide, failures of confidence, agonizing procrastination, self-loathing, and terrible fear.
I’ve seen children come to this country with PTSD, having seen their parents killed, their houses destroyed, all in front of their eyes. Memories etched in as strong as words cut in stone by diamonds, without adult understanding to temper the cuts – if there is such a thing.
And one poor soul – for he was that – sent me an anonymous letter, chastising me for daring to say to a reporter, that children whose parents went off to war, could also be hurt, and suffer trauma. He had lost his dad in WWII, he said, and had not suffered whatsoever in the long run, Indeed, he went on, his life was a model of good adjustment. Including, I’m certain, that he felt the need to send angry letters anonymously.
I am so tired of seeing children suffer. Of young adult lives snuffed out, or with bodies torn apart, with souls damaged or removed. With ordinary life made an unthinkable, impossible goal.
Just tired, damnably tired.
I can add nothing to such a poignant response. Thank you.
Woldoog – Thank you for writing about your Dad. You have described so well the reality of what is academic for some. Your words provide us with insights and an opportunity to empathize and to understand.
I have typed and deleted over and over. I decided I needed to address something you posted in a comment here:
I was prompted to write this diary when I saw critical comments in other threads that seemed to oversimplify one’s ability to be moral in an environment that, by virtue of its very existence, is immoral.
This subject of our military is so volatile. What I heard others attempting to do was to do the same thing as you – provide us with insights and an opportunity to empathize and to understand. The perspective they offer us is from the other side.
We might easily slip into the boots of the American soldier and imagine as best we can the nightmare from his or her perspective. What those who write from the other side are providing us with a chance to slip into their shoes. To imagine the nightmare through their eyes.
What is it like to have soldiers burst into your house and order you around in a language you do not understand? What was it like to hear gun bursts in another room where your father is praying? What was it like for the woman and her three year old as they positioned themselves on the floor, as if in prayer?
What is it like to be the neighbors of those killed in Haditha? What goes through one’s mind when food needs to be purchased – who do you send to the market when death may be waiting? What do we call it when there is daily, ongoing, never ending “traumatic stress,” one that never even gets to a “post” stage?
Even more difficult to think about is the matter of right and wrong in this nightmare.
A few years ago there was a woman who drowned her three children. I believe it was in Texas. What she did was wrong.
In reading about her, wondering how she could come to this, we discover she was a member of a very fundamentalist church. We find out she was depressed and mentally ill, perhaps suffering from sleep deprivation – an internal war. We learn she was the primary caretaker without much respite from the demands of three young children.
Some of us might be able to empathize and understand how a person might find themselves driven by depression, despair, and even the “voice of God” to see drowning one’s children as the right thing to do.
But it was wrong.
Now a concerned community might use this woman’s story to make some changes, so another woman might not end up in the same horrible position. But our society doesn’t seem to do that, at least not now. Instead, many condemn her and shake their heads saying, “How could she?” or “What kind of monster is she?” Some might look at this woman with sorrow, wanting to comfort her, knowing that if she is ever brought out of her mental illness she will be faced with what she has done.
What she did was wrong.
Woldoog, you wrote:
We can never really know the full impact of such trauma on one’s mind and the havoc it can create, nor can we ever completely comprehend the soul-destroying things that war might make one do.
I cannot agree with you more.
What the soldiers did in Haditha was wrong. And if I was there and joined them for whatever reason – then what I did would be wrong too.
Your dad has judged himself more harshly than anyone else could – a lifetime term of suffering. I would not wish that on anyone. He is fortunate to have you asking and listening. Again, many thanks for bringing his and your story to us.
Tampopo,
I too wrote, then deleted, several times. But chose not to write in the end. Because the last thing I would ever want to convey to a child of a veteran, or the veterans themselves, would be that I would have done things differently than they did. Nor could I feel very comfortable at all making a judgement about actions taken in the hell of war. But you are right. And thank you for writing what i could not. What happened in Haditha was wrong. It was more than wrong. In no way do I mean to make a connection between those soldiers in Haditha, and Woldoog’s Father. But it must be pointed out, repeatedly, that there will never be any justification for the murder of a three year old child, let alone that child’s entire family.
Woldoog, thank you for telling your Father’s story here. It is heartbreaking.
Be well.
Please know that I understand and respect your perspective. This is a very emotional issue, and I thank you for taking the time to read my story and comment.
Thank you for such a thoughtful reply. Perhaps I should have done more to specify the types of comments to which I was referring, for I did not mean those that tried to describe the horror of war from the perspective of an innocent civilian. I would never want to diminish their perspective, not only because it would be immoral for me to dismiss it as less than a soldier’s, but also because it is their perspective, their experiences and often their very existence that so often play an integral role in the conflict that is PTSD.
I think that for many combat veterans, true conflict arises because they, unlike us, do witness the horrors of war from both sides, but they do it simultaneously, and both sides cannot be reconciled in their minds. How does a soldier come to terms with the fact that he or she has orders to run over any child that crosses the path of the humvee he or she is driving, because that child may be being used as a decoy for an ambush? Killing a child is horrifyingly wrong, but it is also wrong for you to allow your friends to be killed in an ambush. A child runs into the road, and in a split second, your moral center is compromised. The people whose comments I was referring to would have responded to such a situation by saying, well, you’re a monster if you don’t stop, or, you should just drive around them, or you shouldn’t be there in the first place. That’s the kind of oversimplification to which I was referring.
I linked to the Haditha article because I think it perfectly illustrates the most incomprehensible thing we as civilians could ever imagine, and I think it offers us the opportunity to ask ourselves “What would drive a soldier to do this?” I truly understand the wrongness of their actions, and I would never dismiss the deaths of those helpless people. I simply propose the idea that in a troubled mind, that atrocity is not as black and white and simple as we would like to make it.
In writing this diary, I only wanted to emphasize how clashing emotions often cause right and wrong to be quickly blurred in such a volatile environment, in ways we can never imagine; how emotional decisions are made rashly without thinking of inevitable consequences until said consequences are upon you; and how living in a state of sustained fear can cause one’s moral compass to go haywire. Thank you again for your thoughtful comment, tampopo – you forced me to re-examine my thinking, and I thank you for taking the time to read my story.
Oh woldoog – I am ever so grateful that you understood what I was trying to say.
I have enjoyed talking with you. This was a difficult diary to write, and talking about it is no easier. I am grateful for the opportunity to share my thoughts in a forum such as this – everyone here has been kind, respectful, and understanding. I am more than delighted by the responses I have received.
You bring a powerful perspective to this discussion tampopo. Makes me think about the writing of Sister Helen Prejean and her story of “Dead Man Walking.” We do have to embrace the complexity that human beings are capable of evil – especially when they have been subjected to evil – but NEVER cease being human beings. Those who have been able to embrace that complexity, such as Sister Helen, are my heros.
In my work with teens who have been involved in criminal activity – I always want to point out that they were not born that way. They have to be held accountable for their choices, but as the adults in their lives, we have to be held accountable as well for failing them. Its not an either/or situation.
And finally, I want to join with others Woldog, in thanking you for sharing this story. I am so sad that we are repeating history today in this country rather than learning from it. I only hope that you and your father find some peace in the story’s telling.
Iraq has brought my father’s war to the forefront for me, especially in recent months. I have been itching to tell my father’s story, and I am grateful that you took the time to read it.
Powerful diary.
I wish healing for you and your Dad and your family.
In reading your vivd and poingnant description of your Dad’s pain, I was struck with an incredible sense of irony.
Your father’s empathy and humanity, left him mentally ill. Yet, I have to wonder about the true mental health of those who are seemingly “all right” after being exposed to and participating in the horrors of war.
I was thinking something along the same lines. The only people I could think of who might be able to soldier without being harmed are sociopaths. But we consider them to be mentally ill, locking them up when we discover them.
Apparently when we discover some sociopaths we don’t lock them up, we elect them to high office. ; )
Thank you for noticing that. His morality is what destroyed him.
I also wanted to say that I, too, wonder about the true mental health of those who seem “all right”, but I also wonder if some people are just somehow better-equipped than others to handle trauma. Perhaps through upbringing, or more of a good chemical in the brain, or just dumb luck, some people have the tools to witness and/or do horrible things, but are then able to move forward as kind, gentle, healthy, compassionate, well-adjusted people.
Thanks for posting this, Woldoog. It broke my heart because I (your father’s age) never asked my own father about his experience in war, though it was obviously important to him. I can only hope that he eventually forgave my lack of interest, and my youthful ignorance and willingness to judge.
You have achieved a level of kindness and understanding that I’ve spent those forty years working toward.
I am so sorry! I can’t tell you how much I wish that we never had to ponder these things. Your kind words mean a lot to me – thank you.
Haditha, they will go to prison over it no doubt about it. I don’t think they were much older than your father was or my Uncle was in Vietnam. Considering that we slow maturing humans don’t even get our frontal lobes in until around twenty three years of age and that is what enables us to make better decisions and mellows our teenage impulsiveness……your father, my uncle, and the young Marines in Haditha were at a severe disadvantage in the middle of a bloody war. I do condemn the officers though….I can’t help it, I have to, my husband is one of them. I know what they are fully capable of (well, at least him). I also know what internal motives they can pack around inside of them and I know how their own career agendas can affect the lives of every single person around them! My husband was a mission pilot in command for missions in Iraq. He effectively stalled a planned attack on a target in Iraq because he could as the mission pilot in command. It just didn’t feel right to him and the targets weren’t acting like they were about to rob a bank! It turned out that the target he was told to take out was what was left of some of the original Iraqi police who were legitimately attempting to guard their own local bank. If he had not stalled that attack though, those guys would have been body parts and the story in the press would have been that an Iraqi bank robbery had been foiled thanks to wonderful freedom bringing coalition forces. It was pretty early in war so maybe we could have even had a parade over that one! Hey, my husband maybe could have even received a combat award for that too. He is the best man in the world though. Nobody died that day. A whole bunch of fuel was burned up in Apaches waiting to fire…..then they went home….no big headlines, NO AMERICAN HEROS THAT DAY! I know what hasty war decisions bring and I know all about counting and calling every body of a dead adult male Iraqi an “insurgent”. Dead men tell no tales! It happens every day over there. I can’t stand to read about the number of “insurgents” that the DOD claims to have killed a day. A lot of it is bullshit. Just like the whole IED blowing up and destroying a bus in Haditha was all bullshit! If you are in the line of fire and then dead and you are tall enough and you aren’t part of the American/Iraqi forces and you have a penis, you are listed as a dead insurgent for the appeasement of the American people. I Hate This War! I Hate What it is doing to our soldiers, and those soldiers will come home and move next door to you and and me, someday they might snap too…..we are as much responsible for their welfare as they are for ours when they are in uniform. They are Americans….they are being internally and externally shredded to pieces though right now and they will bring it home. They will bring it home and we will all see what we reap from what we have sown again.
Kos and someone had left a link to this video there. I would like to put it up here because it seems to pertain to your diary subject. I have only been watching it for about four minutes now though. If you do not want it linked to though please just say and Booman can remove it. I seems to be a very very brutally honest video from an Iraq War Vet. LINK
Jessie MacBeth, who appears in the video at the above link that was in my Kos diary from yesterday. I am taking great pains lately to make sure that I stick to facts and check them where ever I am able. I know that as more pressure is applied to the administration it is likely they will attempt to make us all out to be loony lefties and the more loony lefty I appear to be the less serious anyone will take me. Dahr Jamail expresses some reservations about Jessie MacBeth and IVAW had no knowledge of the video being made and are investigating Jessie MacBeth’s story. They aren’t saying that he is lying, he does portray himself as a member of IVAW though and IVAW logos are in the video. IVAW has fought a long long hard battle from a couple of Iraq Vets wanting to do something about the Iraq War to being an honest credible organization working their tails off every single day. After meeting a few of the IVAW soldiers I can say first hand that they will protect the credibility of IVAW first because without the truth and their credibility they have nothing. All they can fight this war with that will stop it is the truth. I believe that Dahr Jamail, though I do not know him, is cut from the same cloth.
I can’t get the link to work, is it bad or is it me? 🙂
.
Cache link is also inactive
This video is currently not available.
Please try again later.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
Tracy,
This comment will be difficult for me because of how I feel about you, and the friendship that I believe we have. But I am really struggling with with the fact that no where in your comment to Woldoog is there any mention of the three year old girl who’s brain was splatered by a bullet fired point blank into the back of her head while her mother, who was also murdered, held her while kneeling on the floor. They, and the rest of their murdered family are the real victims in this specific incident. And while it could be proven that the Marines who carried out this act were suffering from the brutality of the war they are involved in, and are undoubtedly suffering from the most horrific forms of PTSD, the reality, for me, is that at the moment they began putting bullets into women and children who were kneeling on the floor in terror, they were no longer victims, but murderers. And when all the shooting and dying was finished, they had the presence of mind to concoct a coverup story. Which can only mean that they knew what they had done was wrong. At least wrong in the eyes of those who might find out. Why was it not wrong when their fingers began pulling those triggers?
will ever be able to unweave everything that happened in Haditha and be able to lay blame and find justice where it is due. What is worse is that Haditha was just the time they got so obviously caught! I have heard so many “braggings” of out of their fucking mind soldiers who have returned from Iraq! People still don’t want to believe it all though. It is huge gray area for me, a gray area that comes with a lot of depression for me. I don’t even know what happened to the children that my Uncle offed himself over in front of the VA last year. I don’t know if he killed them in cold blood or if other Marines killed them and he helped cover it up, and that his suicide letter said that he had lost his honor and his VA records have sketchy blurry writings in them about him suffering trauma over children that were killed in Vietnam. I have no idea what happened. I only know he did his best to lead a life of beauty after that and shot himself in the heart last year in the VA parking lot with an enlarged photo of Vietnamese children sitting in the seat next to him. I have no answers friend. Only tears and sometimes depression about it all and fight. I have a ferocious fight in my heart to end this fucking hell!
.
When frontlines are blurred and the battle runs in civilian suburbs, the Pentagon and US Military should have a tough discipline in command structure to avoid killing of innocent civilians.
There was never the intention to show this kind of leadership going into this illegal war, nor once the U.S. and British forces got bogged down, to stop the abuse, torture and indiscriminate killings of suspects. The Coalition is the agressor by invading a sovereign nation and evolved into an occupier. The primary goal is to avoid casualties of their own in the short run. However by inflicting suffering on the civilian population, the blowback in the long run will be “terror” for years to come.
Get out now and make a true effort for peace between Israel and its Arab neighbors. Not by stopping humanitarian and medical aid to the Palestinian people in the occupied territories.
Bush promised a two-state solution by the end of … 2005!
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
Your husband sounds like a great man, and I commend him for having the ability and courage to make what could be construed as an “unpopular” decision. Your story is remarkable. Thank you for such a passionate comment, and for reading my diary.
This is a painfully beautiful diary.
I am nearly 60, and it seemed at the time as if ALL my male friends went to Viet Nam.
They were youngsters who had been brainwashed to believe the American myth of masculinity. They thought that a Real Man can do anything without emotion. Their notion that gentleness, empathy and sensitivity are weak, feminine traits were reinforced by Basic Training. Then they went to war.
These men suffered not only the trauma of war and the guilt of comitting or witnessing unconscionable acts, but they lost their sense of self as well. They weren’t supposed to vomit and wet their pants in fear and horror, even though it is human to do so. They weren’t supposed to shake and cry, although only a psychopath could endure war and be unmoved.
A very few came back better than they went in, filled with insight and an understanding of human nature bought at great cost. Most just came home shattered and badly mended, plagued with nightmares, guilt, self doubt, and a lifetime of fear that they are unworthy of anybody’s love, that someone might see them for who they really are, and be disgusted.
All because they couldn’t measure up to a ridiculous myth.
Maybe if that sick, destructive myth didn’t exist, most young men wouldn’t go to war in the first place.
And what a myth it is. Might I relate a quick story? My father’s tale began with his boot camp experience. Boot camp, from what I’ve heard, was much different in those days, more violent and abusive than today. My father told me of much abuse he himself experienced, of being beaten and punched and the like. He also told me of how there was a boy in his platoon who couldn’t seem to “hack” it. He was overweight, and not doing well for a number of reasons. One day during training, they were outside running, and this boy collapsed and died. My dad’s drill instructor forced my father and the other boys to run OVER this boy’s dead body. Again and again. Even being DEAD was construed as weakness and not worthy of respect. Sickening. There was eventually an investigation; my father and the others were interviewed, and the DI was removed. My dad doesn’t know if he was punished. Can you imagine?
I thank you for taking time to read my diary and comment.
I cannot imagine how horrible it is to be trapped in an environment with such sick “values”. If my workplace promotes cruelty (as many of us women who entered previously all male jobs experienced), we can quit; we risk poverty, even homelessness to do it, but it’s an option. Your father had no such choice. The treatment of that poor, dead boy was an object lesson. Cutting out the most vulnerable and using him/her as a showpiece is a deliberate technique used to jerk everybody else into line. It is the heart of fascism.
I cried for your father when I read your diary, and for my old friends, dead, maimed, disabled, addicted and broken hearted.
For thousands of years, war has shuffled territory among a handful of powerful leaders who use fear and myth to con the masses into dying for a new design on the flag. For most of the poor everywhere, who wins a war makes no difference; it just kills millions of them. “We must preserve our way of life,” the rich yell. Translation: “THEY are coming to take our stuff, and we want YOU to die to preserve and expand our power.”
I’m getting way too angry to be typing this from work. Thank you, woldoog, for opening a window to the realities of war. We can’t end it if we don’t stop glorifying it.