I don’t want to be racist, but I am.
I don’t want to be classist, but I am.
It is time for me to admit to both.
I have done my level best to rid myself of the deeply imbedded effects of racist attitudes that were instilled in me during six decades of living in the white culture. With painful honesty, I must admit that I have not been succeesful.
How can I tell? One small example is because to this day, I have trouble remembering the names of my black neighbors in this senior apartment building: my eyes just cannot seem to remember the different facial characteristics of black faces, as well as they can remember white faces.
I had the same trouble with Native American faces, and Mexican American faces too, until life afforded me the opportunity to actually live within each of these cultures long enough for this to go away, and for each face to come into clear and unique focus in my mind. Only then, could my eyes easily see the full uniqueness of each non white face, and remembering names became easier.
So deep does racism exists within me, that even though I have tended to feel more at home with cultures other than my own, this subconscious effect is STILL operational in me. How deep does culturally imbedded racism really go? How far down inside do its tap roots lie? I still cannot answer that for myself because I have yet to get to them. I wonder if I ever can?
And now I have to confess to even more blatant racism, that seems to be growing fast within me, as I’ve watched with growing horror, what my own white culture has managed to do to the America I was (rightfully or wrongfully) once so proud of.
How hard it is to see how this white culture of mine has twisted and mutilated basic values and principles so dear to me, and turned them all inside out and upside down, to make them all about power over others, and rampant materialism. How hard it is to know how my own white culture has overridden basic principles like honesty, integrity, fairness, justice, collaboration, and concern for the common good of all, and trrumped all of these with a me-first kind of unrestrained, insatiable greed and need for power over others.
So now, here I am, even more of a racist that I was, for not only am I still dealing with remnants of my own old racist programming toward people of color, but a much stronger fear and distain, and distrust for the WHITE culture that I am technically a part OF.
Not only that, the older I get, the more “classist” I become! Although I honestly do not know how this can be avoided, by those of us who always lived in the mid to lower “class” of white America. How can you NOT feel this, after a lifetime of living the proof of it every single day? How was I suppose to NOT see the differences in the opportunities open to me as a woman born in 1940 in a bible belt Midwest blue collar culture, and the rich white people (mostly men) of my time? How am I supposed to ignore a lifetime of being treated as less worthy, as a low income person, than someone with money is treated? How can I ignore the reality that the riches of this land are flowing faster than ever to the very elite top layer of American society, while the rest of us grow poorer every day?
And now that I have totally fallen out of the still (somewhat worthy) class of productive, tax paying American citizens, and fallen all the way to the bottom of the pile into a category called “Old, Poor and Disabled,” I am REALLY getting an in my face 24/7 view of how little my wonderful “white culture” values the “least among us”.
No, I cannot deny my classism or my racism. I can never rid myself of them either. They are alive and well and growing fatter every day for the richness of evidence all around me that is feeding all of it. And now it is all flowing out of me towards my own white culture.
There is one comfort I have and cling to, and that is the fact that I have always known, since childhood, that I was a “misfit” in my own white culture. I was never able to swallow everything I was told, without tasting it first, and spitting out the parts that tasted bad. For a time, yes, I got worn down and did do my level best to conform to it all, and all that accomplished was to win me a near terminal case of alcoholism.
I am, and always have been since my birth, a person without a culture of my own.
When I lived with the Native Americans and watched them celebrate the richness and wonder of their shared spirituality and culture, while welcomed to share it, I knew I was on the outside looking in.
In Laredo, observing the Mexican American people celebrating their incredibly rich cultural legacy, again, while welcomed warmly, I was on the outside looking in.
And now as I come to the last part of this life span, I am really grieving this loss. I have never known, nor will I ever know in this lifetime: what it feels like to have the strength and comfort of a cultural heritage of my very own to lean on for strength and comfort.
So I am immensely grateful to All my Relations who have been graciously willing to allow me to share their rich cultural heritage over the years. And to all the “Other-Americans” I’ve met and grown close to over the years, who have always felt as disenfranchised in the white world as I have, and have been down a long path similar to my own. Without you all, as hard as you were for me to find, I don’t know if I’d have survived intact.
And to the younger “Other-Americans” there are now, please, please find a way to honor who you are fully enough to create your own genuine culture, based on who you are in your authentic selves.
Create your own celebrations and cultural rituals, so you have something of comfort and value to hand down to your own descendents, based on your own core values.
But most of all, no matter what you are told, or how you may be penalized and punished for non- conforming with what this American culture has become, know in your deepest heart there is NOTHING wrong with you, at all. Nothing. And do not allow anyone or anything convince you there is.
Because right now, perhaps more so than ever, there is a need for Americans to focus inward, and find out for sure who we each really are in our own deepest selves: that center core where none of the propaganda or current “programming” of who we `should be” has penetrated yet. Please.
Take enough time off from everything going on, to dig deep enough to get to that core place, and then listen to the soft and pleading voice you will find, that may have been drowned out for so long.
That is the voice of the center core of our very being. It has access to wisdoms the mind alone can never reach by itself. When we can truly hear it, it will give us all the answers and direction we could ever need, to create the richest lifetime we could ever ask for and, I believe fully, the one intended for us to have. Not alone, but together.
I believe with everything in me, that those “core voices” will not tell us to fear each other, or build walls against each other, or fight and kill each other but to see and embrace each other. I believe they will tell us how to share and accept and to CELEBRATE our differences in ways that strengthen all and broaden everyone’s horizons.
And I believe this: that when enough of us can hear our own “core voices”, and those of others around us, those voices will come together slowly, and create a harmonious hum that will start softly at first, and build in volume, until it can not be ignored by anyone. I can already hear this soft and deep hum.
It will gather strength, and be such a joyous, hopeful sound, that others will want to join the chorus and will, until it is the common song we have all sought forever, called peace.
The search for this peace begins right here, inside of me.
And right there, inside of you.
And you and you and you,
and all of us.
I will be at the polls next week to cast my vote.
Then I will sit nearby awhile, and listen very closely, for the soft, quiet hum I know I will hear.
(Crossposted from http://www.maneegee.blogspot.com/)
Great essay, scribe. Let me know if you have any more trouble logging into Blogger – it’s been a mess lately.
The quiet hum, the core voice, is something that I’m finding a hard time locating in the chaos of the world. I used to be able to quiet myself amidst chaos and find that Peace – but either due to the elections, family turmoil, or who knows what, I find I’ve had to physically place myself in quiet to be able to listen to me.
Thanks for the reminder of hope that you and NL are sharing with your diaries. It’s much needed, imo.
Then it is my sincere hope that you, and all the young like you, will continue to physcially place yourselves in as much quiet as you need, to always be able to hear your own voice loud and clear over any external roar.
Because you, my friend, your generation and all those to follow, ARE America’s hope now.
Which means you need to start as young as possible, doing most of it differently that we did.
I know you can, and that you will. You are the hum I can hear now.
Who amongst us is without some imperfection of spirit? There is something unsavory in each of us. Look deeply into a mirror and you will find it, as you have done.
The beauty of that mirror, deeply, is that it allows us to identify the good and the bad, and to work to make improvements over time.
I identify with your non-identity and your willingness to question the prevailing culture in our country and its origins and associations. I have lived life as a misfit here in Mississippi. Too many illnesses of spirit are too widespread and too deeply ingrained here for me to feel that I belong in any particular cultural grouping, whether it be based on race or class.
I have spent many an hour pondering whether society was crazy or whether I was crazy, but fortunately I was able to come to the conclusion at a relatively young age that I am not alone, that many “misfits” exist, and that we are the better for our non-conformities. One of my personal favorite sayings is “Show me ‘normal’ and I’ll show you boring.”
Viva la difference!
Like Man Eegee has commented, I’ve had some difficulty lately in achieving that sense of peace that I have known, and finding the voice inside. Thank you both for gently pointing me back towards it today. I fear that we misfits will sorely need that place of peace in days to come.
So true, blueneck, there are many of us, and we really do need to stay connected with each other as well in touch with with our core selves. People here have so often reached out through this screen and dragged me back up from whatever pothole of dispair I’ve fallen into, to remind me that no no no, I am NOT alone!
I agree. And I thank you for keeping intouch here. This place and the liberal blogosphere has helped me stay somewhat sane these past few years. I’ve also really enjoyed being a part of two BT meetups now. There really are people out there who care about the same things we do. That’s sometimes hard for me to remember, otherwise.
Great stuff Scribe!!
I went through a period in my life where my family/cultural history of racism and colonialism debilitated me with guilt to the point that I was depressed for a few months.
Eventually I spent a few years exploring anything I could piece together about what our Western European culture was before our pagan roots were destroyed by the combination of the Roman Empire and Christianity. There’s not much left of that culture, but a few hints are here and there. I’m not sure it makes sense for me to try and re-create those customs and rituals today, it did help me embrace my ancestors.
I don’t however, feel that I can embrace one part of all that history and reject the other. Its all there in me – with alot of work yet to do. Thank goodness though, it gives me plenty to keep busy with for the next 30-40 years (hopefully).
It really is a heck of an adventurem isn’t it? 🙂
I appreciate your diary a great deal, scribe. For those whose lives are little troubled, I think it is hard to feel how different things are for them compared to people who know – or come to know, most painfully, that the step outside of the “mainstream” is shorter than expected, and closer than it appears.
“Objects in the mirror are closer than they appear” – when I see this, I think about how the public culture presents a homogeneous face to us, with a tiny tiny dollop of “ethnic” spice here and there.
In contrast, I think about the class I taught yesterday. I have about 150 students in that course, about 1/3 who appear to be minority – based entirely on appearance, mostly of skin color. But the reality is that skin color isn’t much of a good guide (there’s a lesson there, for another day). There are among those 150, students whose families come from 25 different countries. 17 different languages were their own first languages, though most learned English very early. For these students, there is no singular “white” culture. All but 7 or 8 are U.S. citizens, I should add, the others being from Canada.
I have to say, I love teaching them. It’s like facing a full spice cabinet every morning. Most of the content that the text provides comes from just a couple of different cultural groups, taken mostly as white middle class in contrast with some other group. What fits? What is really important? What speaks to the experiences and the lives of all these varied young persons (and some not so young)?
Much of my life outside of teaching is not pleasant, full of community values that I resist or think warped or truly horrible. The community I live in is the still disintegrating remnant left from decades of terrible racism. My religious faith of former years is almost entirely gone. However, being with these students is the anti-entropy medicine for what ails me. It won’t solve those ongoing difficulties, but I can see in the students a lot of hope for the future. For them, I am certain, there will not be a history within a single, monolithic culture. They don’t expect other people to be like them, and they seem to enjoy a degree of oddness and variety that I haven’t seen in more homogeneous places. Frankly, it’s a great privilege to get to know them, and to teach them. They teach me, too, and that is sometimes the best part.
Thank you so much for sharing some of your anti entoopy medicine with us, kidspeak. I ate it up it like a starving person and in a way I am: I miss being able to be out in the midst of diversity, to see more of this for myself. And what a fascinating challenge for you, to seek to teach what fits, what’s important, etc for kids from such varied backgrounds. Wish I could sit in on that class!
I think there are really some young people that are “getting it” these days. I volunteer with a group that sponsors year long foreign exchanges for high school students. Last year I was the groups stateside contact for a young woman who went to Brazil. Here’s an excerpt from an email I got from her after a gathering of exchange students from all over the world. Brought tears of joy and hope to my eyes.
OK, now, that made me cry. I mean REALLY cry, hard. If only we could make this happen for more and more of our kids…
Thanks so much for sharing this…
Wow! The diary and the comments have completely filled me with overflowing emotions.
You know me, and what a comforting thing it is to say that, I have mostly viewed myself as a “not from this planet” person all of my life, so I certainly relate to the feelings of “outside looking in.”
These past few years I have been deeply feeling the loss of not having lived in a far more diverse cultural and racial community. I intend to rectify that situation as soon as possible, but until then it is a great hunger I have for all those who look differently, who speak differently, who have far different views and understandings of things, than I do or have. It is not a new feeling, but it has intensified greatly these past 4 or 5 years.
Thank each of you for feeding parts of my soul that hunger for these experiences. As the student so eloquently expressed. . .I just need and want to listen to these views and stories, not so much anything I have to say, but a great deal that I want to hear.
Loves and Hugs,
Shirl
I’ve long wondered if some of us, no matter where we are born, come INTO life on this planet with an identity geared more toward world citizenship, than one geared being a loyal citizen of any one place ON it. (And yes, Shirl, and of other assorted places in the cosmos too!)
I was never fully successful in seeing America as such an absolutely astoundingly exeptional ” better-in-all-ways-than-any-other country-that-has-ever-existed” sort of place, as they tried to teach me it was. It just made no sense to me, to think that way.
How could we even KNOW this with such total certainty, if this is the only country we’ve ever lived in and when actually know very little, (most of us anyway,) about how life feels and is in any other?