So this is what the country is now supposed to be scared of? House Majority Leader Nancy Pelosi, riding back into DC with her “San Francisco Values” slung over her shoulder – just waiting to infect the rest of `Murka. Now that the failed conservative house of cards has officially come crashing down, all that remains in talking meatstick land is the tried and true tired and old “evil scary liberal” meme. Of course, this comes from the same terrorist sympathizer who would love to see Al Qaeda blow up the entire city.
And before you think this won’t take hold in freeperland or right wingnutistan (yes, they are not the same, although they reside very close to each other), I have had conversations over the past week or so where this very issue came up – not just in passing either. The crux was how Nancy Pelosi and the liberal congress is going to let the terrorists win and run our armed forces into the ground. Funny enough, I think that I heard that somewhere else recently, but it wasn’t about Pelosi or any liberals though…
Besides the complete asininity (and yes, I reserve the right to make up words if I need to) of this, was anyone talking about the southern values of lynching, segregation, discrimination and hate crimes when Congress was being run by Tom DeLay and Bill Frist? Plus, I think that those who are afraid of, or who mock the “San Francisco values” should probably not only take a good hard look at what those values are, but also probably would benefit from rolling up a nice fatty chock full of those values and inhaling deeply.
Now, I don’t live in SF, and never have. But I have family members who live there, very close friends who have (and still) lived there, and it is one of my very favorite US cities. My guess is that I have only been there around 10 times, tops, but each time is better than the last (and the first one was largely spent at Dead shows at Shoreline Ampitheater, which as Bob Weir says, “must be heaven”).
So, what are these spooky “San Francisco values” that we should cower in fear from?
Since its days as a port of entry for the Gold Rush, San Francisco has been an epicenter of Western-style individualism. Yet given the city’s high cost of living and role as an international tourist destination, alternative lifestyles coexist with cutting-edge businesses and a monied class that thrives on fine dining and the arts.
—snip—
More recently, the region’s early embrace of gay rights, medical marijuana and anti-war rallies cemented the stereotype of contrarian peace-nicks out of synch with American values.
That’s ironic, said Richard DeLeon, professor emeritus of political science at San Francisco State University.
“The values of the American creed – individuality, liberty, free speech, democracy and at least the aspiration of equality – can be expressed and experienced in San Francisco to an extent that’s hard to find elsewhere,” said DeLeon, who first came here during the 1967 Summer of Love. “San Francisco isn’t un-American. America has become less American, with a retreat from civil liberties and, in the White House, suppressive policies and pre-emptive war.”
Hmmmmm. It seems to me that the whole anti-war, civil rights, gay rights, free speech, democracy and liberty thing are pretty much in line with what America is all about. Not only that, but a number of those words appear in the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence or other major movements in America’s history (ok, so you have to read the fine print in the Constitution to find the words “gay rights”, but they are there. Trust me).
Also, the demographics are a pretty solid model with one of the lowest poverty rates (under 8%), a relatively high median income, and a somewhat average level of crime for a large city. Not to mention the economic environment, which is very friendly to small businesses, large businesses, and venture capital. I don’t think that the republicans’ best friend, “the almighty dollar”, would argue with the San Francisco values.
I would think that education is a value that people would respect as well – and the city was ranked 2nd in the country as far as cities with the highest concentration of college degrees. The educational system (public schools) is on the leading edge for major cities and the system (citywide) has improved greatly over the past few years.
And what about keeping our families healthy? Well, those crazy evil bastards out in SF are looking towards a system of universal health care for its residents. How un-American that is – to try and make sure that people can afford to get treatment or medical help when they need it.
Yeah, education, tolerance, health care, free speech, a solid economy, an eye towards business, keeping military recruiters out of high schools (and really, how small is the percentage of people who (1) are for this and (2) would actually want their own children to be recruited?) – what horrific and scary things.
And that whole “anti-war, hippie” thing that makes the terrorists salivate – well, I guess that the 60%+ of the US who are against the illegal and immoral invasion and occupation of Iraq (and voted the republicans’ sorry asses out) – they must have those same “San Francisco values” too.
If House Speaker Pelosi does bring those values to Congress – then man, we would be able to get this country headed back in the right direction.
also in orange
Right on Clammy. I wrote on just this thing this morning. I moved to SF 15 years ago and I will never look back. It is hands down one of the sanest cities I have ever lived in or visited.
Granted, SF will sometimes pass some pretty bizarre laws, but all in all, it is a city that does its very best to look out for its people. It has art and culture, diversity and tradition, and great weather to boot.
I am proud to be a member of the Bay Area and one of the last bastions of liberalism in America. I wouldn’t trade it for anything. I think America would be far better off trading in their mysoginistic, homophobic and racist family values for SF’s realy family values.
True, true. I lived in S.F. many years and have hovered in the Bay Area ever since. I wondered about that “liberal” moniker. If Pelosi were from another beautiful area beloved by tourists (Hawaii, for example) would she be called “liberal?” Of course, not.
I think “liberal” comes from two things: (1) Haight-Ashbury, which has changed a lot since the 70’s, but the rep hasn’t died; and (2) gay rights, including the mayor’s authorizing gay marriages.
Eons ago my son, away at school with an awful lot of Southerners, bet on the 49ers for the Super Bowl. Most of his teenaged schoolmates bet on the Florida team, on the basis that the 49ers were from San Francisco and therefore must be sissies because S.F. had such a large gay population. He collected a lot.
Haight-Ashbury has changed so much, that on the corner of Haight and Ashbury now is a GAP and I believe a Starbucks as well.
Although I haven’t been there in a year or so…..
I agree that “San Francisco values” is code for gay, but also notably they are firmly Democratic values. I was so proud of my town today when I read this:
sorry, source this morning’s S.F. Chronicle
And which city, pray tell, was ranked #1? Hmmm? Hmmm? Let’s hear it.
It’s hardly surprising. Seattle is basically San Francisco farther north, without the notoreity or the good baseball teams.
yes, but those beloved Seahawks!!!!
They better get their guys back soon, but they do have a soft schedule down the stretch.
Can’t wait to break out my Hasselbeck jersey once again!!!
It was sure nice to see the Hawks knock off Oakland on Monday. From what I’ve heard they’re hoping Shawn Alexander will be back this Sunday and then Matt Hasselbeck the week after, so hopefully things will pick up from here on out.
I’m really not a big football fan but it’s hard not to get caught up in the hoopla.
jeez, I hope so – I heard the other day that Alexander was now pushed back one more week. Hasselbeck should be back in a week as well.
If they win on Sunday, then I think they have a near lock on the division.
I saw the following comment by yowsa on The Poor Man yesterday. Since I’m too stupid to have my own thoughts at this hour in the morning, I’ll reproduce the whole thing.
Yes!!!!!!
I love that comment, thanks Chris. It is right on. All my life I’ve had to be resigned that the way I live is almost never represented in the media. Why don’t we see liberals on television who aren’t laughingstocks? We have the real American values, thank you very much.
Gimme those San Francisco values
Gimme those San Francisco values
If they’re good enough for ‘Frisco
They’re good enough for me!
–from one of the bluest counties in Maryland,
right on! 🙂
Insomnia had a good post on this:
http://insomnia.livejournal.com/715159.html