I think most of us have smelled that “natural gas” smell at some point. Of course, it isn’t the gas we’re smelling, it’s the chemical methyl mercaptan which is added so that we can detect if gas is leaking.
Now imagine waking up and finding your whole city smells like that, or worse, the city to your immediate north, as those in New Jersey found this morning.
I heard Mayor Bloomberg assure citizens this morning that there does not appear to be any danger. If there was a leak of gas, it disperses so rapidly there is no danger of combustion.
But as I listened, I thought, as I often do when I listen to the news, what if this is not what it seems? What if this is like the Army’s biological warfare test conducted on the citizens of San Francisco in 1950?
As the San Francisco Chronicle reported a couple of years ago:
For six days in late September 1950, a small military vessel near San Francisco sprayed a huge cloud of serratia particles into the air while the weather favored dispersal.
Then the Army went looking to find out where it landed. Serratia is known for forming bright red colonies when a soil or water sample is streaked on a culture medium — a property that made it ideal for the bio-warfare experiment.
Army tests showed that the bacterial cloud had exposed hundreds of thousands of people in a broad swath of Bay Area communities including Sausalito, Albany, Berkeley, Oakland, San Leandro, San Francisco, Daly City and Colma, according to reports that later were declassified. Soon after the spraying, 11 people came down with hard-to-treat infections at the old Stanford University Hospital in San Francisco. By November, one man had died. Edward Nevin, 75, a retired Pacific Gas and Electric Co. worker recovering from a prostate operation, had succumbed to an infection with Serratia marcescens that attacked his heart valves.
The outbreak was so unusual that the Stanford doctors wrote it up for a medical journal. But the medics and Nevin’s relatives didn’t find out about the Army experiment for nearly 26 years, when a series of secret military experiments came to light. [Emphasis added.]
So I’m thinking, what if this is more than a bizarre ‘accident?’ While gas was not detected at the city’s air monitors, the smell of mercaptan was omnipresent for hours. What if the government added mercapsan to some other substance and sprayed it one way or another in New York City?
The obvious motive that comes to mind is that the government wants to see what might happen were a biological agent to be released in the city. Simple reports of the smell would tell the experimenters all they’d need to know regarding how far the substance spread.
Whatever the case, despite assurances from Mayor Bloomberg that there is nothing to fear and no danger to citizens, Reuters is reporting that 19 people have so far been hospitalized:
NEW YORK (Reuters) – A powerful, mysterious smell of gas wafted through much of Manhattan and parts of New Jersey on Monday, forcing building evacuations and a temporary suspension of commuter train service before dissipating by mid-afternoon.
Officials were quick to stress that the natural gas-like odor was not dangerous, but at least 19 people went to hospital suffering minor complaints and its wide extent provoked jitters in a city that is constantly reminded of the September 11 attacks.
Twelve people were taken by ambulance to New York hospitals by emergency workers responding to calls from people complaining of upset stomachs, dizziness or difficulty breathing, a Fire Department spokesman said.
…Seven people went to the hospital seeking treatment in New Jersey, … although New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg said the odor was not dangerous and no unusual gas leaks had been found.
…”The city’s air sensors do not report any elevated level of natural gas,” he said.
…A U.S. Department of Homeland Security spokesman said there was no indication of a terrorism connection.
…Four schools in Manhattan were briefly evacuated, and the smell chased people out of landmarks such as the Rockefeller Center and Macy’s department store.
“It was really, really bad then, so bad it gave me a headache,” said Kate Browne, who lives in the West Village neighborhood and said she could smell the gas when she took her daughter to school.
This is my problem with the news. Fifty-six years ago, the people in San Francisco were told nothing was wrong, either, even though the results became one for the record books.
I hope and pray that the people of New York are safe, and that if this is some secret experiment, it will not cause any permanent damage to citizens and visitors to that great city. I also hope and pray it will not take us another 26 years to find out what really happened there.
More experiments:
Source: http://www.mindfully.org/Reform/Military-Germs-US-Cities.htm
Hope you didn’t miss this part:
Can you please give a citation to your quote from George Seldes? I have no doubt that he thought that. But I can’t substantiate that he ever said it.
I actually wanted to put a large segment of that book online, as it’s excellent.
It’s from a large (8 1/2×11″) paperback published by his own imprint, In Fact, Inc. The book is called “The Facts Are… : A Guide to Falsehood and Propaganda in the Press and Radio” — I have the fourth printing, from April 1943. It was first published in 1942. I love the inscription:
Its Winter Soldiers
And its more than 100,000 Subscribers
Remember – most of the world’s published material is NOT online. A Google search won’t cut it when it comes to material like this. I’m a collector. I can’t walk past a used bookstore without poking around for hidden gold. I think, if memory serves, I got this at a place that sold primarily labor literature in San Francisco. I could have stayed there for hours!!! I wanted to find an original campaign brochure from Upton Sinclair’s run for Governor in California. His “End Poverty In California” (EPIC) plan was a radical socialist vision that was breathtaking!
Btw – my favorite quote in the book? It’s on page 108, in the chapter called “How to Read the Editorial Page.” His one-word advice: “Don’t.” 😀
The quote from which my sig is taken falls on page 71, as he concludes his “How to Detect Propaganda” chapter.
My second favorite quote (not counting the one I’m using) is on the same page:
One of these days I plan to type in his section on how to recognize propaganda. He quotes from a pamphlet put out by the Institute for Propaganda Analysis. Very interesting, and useful. One of these days… one of these days….
That is one of the all-time great answers! Thank you.
I’ve done a lot of programming, plus some doctoral work in information theory. I’m well aware that virtually all of human knowledge is still not digitized. But you’re quite right–when I said I could not substantiate it, I meant I could not find it in five minutes of googling, trusting myself at being pretty good at that.
But we don’t have a way to search obscure books without legwork and expense.
I still keep a fat paperback of Seldes’ Great Quotations at my desk. Your collection is cool.
“Much is published, but little printed.”
Thanks. I love to talk about Seldes. That book was just fantastic – I wish it was still in print, or that I had the means to put the whole thing online. It’s just incredible!
pass the “smell test“, does it.
the same thought crossed my mind when I read about it…what if?
Cute re the ‘smell test’ – wish I’d thought of that!
Reminds me of that rare pathogen that was picked up by DC monitoring units at the time of the 9/24/04 march on Washington. Some sort of rodent based virus or bacterium as I recall that had been employed in research by government supported scientists for its biowarfare implications. The suspicion at the time was that these were also releases made as a biowar test, (there had been other similar incidents in California and Houston involving the same pathogen( though the story sort of died and never got much mainstream media coverage. I remember writing a diary about it at the time.
This is our surely own side gaming biowar on our own people.
Why?
Just two from an endless array of possibilities:
Why now?
I think 2007 is going to be a very intense year.
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/news/stories/local/01/09/9deadbirds.html?COXnetJSessionIDbuild
4a=4fzTFjvQZ1dnWwhT5Pgf5ySr0br5lXp47yDXy1hXdf8gnKgSQlwx!564231953&UrAuth=%60N%60NUOcN]UbTTUWUXUVUZT[U]UWU^U^UZUUcUcTYWVVZV&urcm=y
Not sure if that link will stay valid, but here’s the article title & first paragraph at least:
Maybe it’ll turn out to have a simple, believable explanation, but who knows?
The humorous side – scroll down and read some of the comments..!
http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/01/08/manhattan-smells-like-mercaptan/
So apparently the insertion of humor in your thread is acceptable when you deem it so, but not when others do. Fascinating.
I was also concerned yesterday when you had dead birds in Austin, The NYC stink and the truck in Sugarland emitting an ammonia vapor. All in the same day? Only I went to Bush/Rove distractions immediately or what if these were all “faked” terrorist attacks gone wrong. I don’t trust these whackjobs. But I guess that is pretty obvious. I have to tell you, I was surprised this didn’t get more coverage yesterday on the blogs.
There have been dying bird incidents all over the world in the past few months – just search Google. I don’t know about the truck to which you refer, either.
But the New York thing was all over the TV, and it sounded so simple – like a gas leak. But on TV, when I heard that air monitoring units were registering no gas at all, indicating something else was ‘leaking’ or being put into the air, I had to wonder. And when I remembered the past tests, it seemed to fit.
I certainly do not KNOW what happened. But here is a scenario that would fit the known facts, and that’s more than the press gave us.
I’m not surprised this wasn’t in the blogs – most people don’t know about the Army’s testing on American civilians. There were even more horrific radiation experiments. And then there were the CIA’s tests of mind control and biowarfare, BOTH of which were grouped under the umbrella project term MKULTRA. The media doesn’t talk about such things, DK doesn’t talk about such things, so where are people supposed to get this information?
Had I not read a bunch of books on the subject years ago, it wouldn’t have occurred to me either. But I had, and it did, and I’d sure like to know what exactly New Yorkers were subjected to yesterday.
Check it out…
http://www.watchermagazine.com/?p=7853
More news on this this morning:
(Source: http://www.silive.com/news/advance/index.ssf?/base/news/1168347649133070.xml&coll=1)
Come on, Mayor Bloomberg. If you don’t know what it is, you can’t be certain it is safe.
And what about that “noxious cloud” or sweet smell from before? Were those biowarfare experiments?
this is the first thought that crossed my mind, as well.
There is a strong temptation to attempt to link this to the Chicago UFO. And the large group of birds that died in Texas.
I don’t feel any such temptation. Why would you?
because he’s a sarcastic joker perhaps? :oP
Thanks, SS.
Lisa,
did you intend to give Boran a 2 or was it a mistake? It was obviously a joke. Most of us here know of his tongue in cheek and friendly sarcastic sense of humor.
Btw, like StevenD above, this diary immediately reminded me of the reports of high levels of some kind of rodent or rabbit virus right after the march in DC in September last year. Did you hear anything about that?
It was a mistake – I tried changing it to “none” but it wouldn’t let me! I must have flipped it passing through!
Is there a way to change that?
Just change it to a 4. Simple as that :o)
I don’t want to give it a four because I don’t want some future person to use that against me and say I agreed with that – which I don’t. Believe me, I do have people follow me around the net and bring up stuff like that.
Why can’t I change it to none?
Try it. But I don’t think it works that way. Don’t ask why. I’m a strictly all or none person as far as ratings goes. Or leave the 2. Then we can follow you around the net asking you why you rated that way ;o)
People would hold it against you if you gave a 4 to some snark? I think not, but do what you believe is best. It is more likely that this diary, based purely upon your suspicions arising from another long ago event, would bring these people to you and not a 4 rating.
In any event, in the future I will refrain from commenting upon your diaries.
By the way, Lisa, directly below is a link to the bird story from another commenter. Just my advice, I wouldn’t take it as a “cutdown” and give that person a “2”.
It was indeed snark, RHL. Thanks for the 2. This is the second time recently that a silly comment of mine has yielded a strange reaction from you. Here’s something that’s worth keeping in mind. Mand does not live on bread alone, and blogs aren’t always about serious inquiry and analysis. Sometimes a brief injection of levity is appreciated.
As to the odor, I suspect that if there was something more involved here, those involved would have done soemthing somewhat more sophisticated without an obvious odor, the recent imcompetence of our government nothwithstanding. It’s not that our government wouldn’t have done something like this, it’s just that this probably has some other explanation.
Kindly disregard my many typos. So much for the vaunted compact laptop.
See now, I got the humor in THAT comment! ;-D
Lisa,
I’m pretty certain that Boran was making a joke. He has a dry and sarcastically friendly sense of humor that might have led you to think it was a cutdown. I can assure you it wasn’t.
Sorry for the double post. I like Boran, but I’m not a psychophant :oP
No – I didn’t think it was a cutdown, although I did feel it was out of place. But I didn’t mean to rate it a 2 and would like to know how to undo should I slip again, as I most assuredly will!