Anyone that is a sports fan is familiar with the following scenario. There is a team that is ahead in the standings on the last day of season and all they need to make it into the playoffs is for some other team to lose. Their fate lies in someone else’s hands. So they sit around in their locker room or someone’s living room, watching some other teams play, with the champagne on ice. That’s not the situation that Obama faces today, but it has some similarities. The polls will close in Kentucky and Team Obama will be watching the returns come in on television. At some point it will become obvious that, although he has lost the contest badly, he has gained enough delegates to make it to the next level. This is called ‘backing your way into playoffs’.
Under ordinary circumstances, Team Obama would be justified, just as sports teams are, in popping the corks and spraying champagne all over each other in some kind of Dionysian ritual of ecstasy. But that is not going to happen for two reasons. First, they want to be mindful of Team Clinton’s feelings:
[Obama’s] aides insist that he is mindful of doing nothing to suggest impatience with Clinton or to signal that she should end her candidacy before she is ready…
…Obama is favored to win the Oregon primary today, and Clinton is an even stronger favorite to win the Kentucky contest. But Obama will not celebrate primary night in either of those states. Instead, he has chosen to be in Iowa, where his victory in the caucuses in January turned the Democratic race upside down. There, at a rally in Des Moines, he is expected to declare that he has secured a majority of the pledged delegates currently eligible to attend August’s Democratic convention in Denver.
Obama and his advisers insist the event will stop short of a declaration that he has won the nomination. But it will be seen as another signal to superdelegates to climb aboard his bandwagon as quickly as possible.
The celebration, however, has rankled the Clinton campaign and the candidate herself. They see it as a highhanded effort to embarrass her and to generate renewed calls from others in the party for her to quit the race before anyone has achieved a genuine majority of pledged delegates and superdelegates.
So, the first reason Team Obama will not be popping corks is that Team Clinton doesn’t want to be embarrassed. You could call this ‘sportsmanship’, I guess. The second reason for the subdued celebration is that the nominating rules are different from the rules for sports teams looking to make the playoffs.
It’s as if the Chicago White Sox beat out the Cleveland Indians for the American League Central Division crown by winning several more games during the regular season. But then they had to rely on a bunch of baseball and television executives to ratify their victory before they would be allowed into the playoffs. Maybe the Indians have a Cy Young Award winning pitcher and the Home Run champion, and they are assured of bringing in better ratings than the scrappy bunch of underdogs on the White Sox squad that win by playing together as a team.
That’s the type of situation Obama faces tonight. Even before the polls close in Oregon, Obama will have won the most pledged delegates. In other words, in the part of the contest where voters vote (games are played), he will have won according to the rules. All that will remain to be seen is if the rules will be changed after the season and/or if the executives will simply toss out the results in the interest of potentially better ratings (poll numbers).
The Clintons and their supporters have been making all kinds of arguments about how unfair the process has been. But let’s focus on how unfair it would be for the Cleveland Indians to go to the playoffs despite losing their division to the Chicago White Sox, on the mere theory that the Indians would get better ratings. Imagine the scene where the White Sox are forced to tone down their season ending celebration because they’re worried that too much celebration would be presumptuous given the executives’ prerogative to strip them of their accomplishments and deny them the fruits of the victory.
Even further, imagine if the Indians and their fans were making the following argument:
‘We would have won if not for the games we had to play against National League teams. If you don’t count those games, and let’s face it, interleague play is stupid and undemocratic, and you add our spring training games to the standings, then we would be ahead if you don’t count that game in August against the Yankees where we only lost because of a bad call by the third-base umpire.’
That’s pretty much the level of idiocy the Clintons are using to insult our intelligence. And they are claiming it’s all in the interest of fairness and democracy, which is enough to make one’s head explode.
So, here’s to the South Side of Chicago and Barack Obama. Go White Sox!! I know they’ll sweep those Arizona Diamondbacks in 4 games. That is, if no one steps in and fudges with the rules.
The celebration, however, has rankled the Clinton campaign and the candidate herself. They see it as a highhanded effort to embarrass her and to generate renewed calls from others in the party for her to quit the race before anyone has achieved a genuine majority of pledged delegates and superdelegates.
Oh, waaaaah. As one of our greatest modern heroes used to say, “You knew the job was dangerous when you took it.”
Thank god you linked him to the White Sox.
And not the Chicago team that manages to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.
Well, the White Sox are Obama’s team. He’s said so, coming from the South Side himself. I’d go find the link if I wasn’t supposed to be busy doing other stuff. 🙂
I’m waiting for Second Nature to discover that in BooMan’s analogy Hillary is the Indians. I’m gonna lay low.
A better analogy would be deciding the winner of the playoffs. Central division vs. Eastern division. Hillary does resemble the Yankees.
and we don’t want a repeat of 2001, if that’s the case…
l dunno manny, that was one hell of a series…even for a rockies fan…:{)
it was one for the books. I’m still kicking myself for passing on a ticket to game 7 – the reasons were solid, but still…
That was one of the best world series ever. I watched it at Disney World.
Yeah, but still, I would have preferred that the Diamondbacks face off against the Mariners. Talk about disappointments . . . 116 wins in the regular season, then struggling to beat the Indians 3-2 in the ALDS before being unceremoniously dumped by You Know Who, 4-1.
Disney World, huh? As it turns out the only game of the ALCS I saw was about two innings of the Mariners’ only win, and I was at the Rain Forest Cafe in Downtown Disney at the time (the huge money vacuum that exists between Disneyland and California Adventure).
Well, we all would have preferred the Mariners over the Yankees 🙂
The whole thing was an odd experience. I was at Disney World with my sisters and my mom — it was a girls trip that had been planned for a long time. Then 9/11 happened and lots of people canceled all their travel plans … but we didn’t. It was like we had all of Disney World to ourselves. It was, in fact, a little bit creepy.
My mom and I were sitting in the hotel bar watching the world series – just us and the bartender.
Yeah, that is weird. We had a night like that once in Disneyland when they closed the part early, except for those of us who paid an extra $10 to stay after early closing. I think there were probably about 5000 people there that night, which for Disneyland is nothin’.
I have to wonder how big a hit places like Disneyland will take as gas prices rise. I suppose the locals will still be spending money there, and they account for a pretty significant piece of the pie, but tourists are probably going to slow way down.
Foreigners.
The exchange rate means that people from all over the world will find it cheap to vacation in the US – and they will go to Disneyland and Disney World.
And gas prices in the US are cheap compared to Europe.
You’re right, hadn’t thought of that.
You didn’t think their defeat of the Yankees last year could go unpunished, did you? 🙂
ah yes…the cubbies
the late, great steve goodman
Lordy-lordy, he was the best. We had a couple dozen filker friends over to our house on Saturday, and part of the fun was a mini-tribute to Steve Goodman. Someone sang “Lincoln Park Pirates,” I followed it up with “City of New Orleans,” and another friend finished it with “Looking For Trouble.” Steve wrote some great, great songs.
Cognitive dissonance from a DBacks fan…
Yeah, I’m offended that the National League is the Republicans in this story.
in other words, Boo – you‘re not going to be able to win with a thread like this 😉
hey, it’s not my fault your senator(s) is a weasel.
not my fault either! i didn’t vote for them.
i’ll have to look up the stats, but i don’t think baja arizona gave either weasels a majority in the past.
By that I mean the little game that he plays that I call Poor Beleaguered Brotha Bob. When there’s something that he wants–say for example, estate tax repeal, he is acting on only the very, very bestest behalf of brothas and sistas everywhere.
When he is asked, implored, begged not to be a video pimp (scroll for the “tribute video”), then his responsibilities are to his shareholders only.
That’s the game she’s playing right now. She can’t get what she wants? Suddenly, she speaks for all womankind. I am really just disgusted by this put-upon act, and frankly just astonished at how gullible her worshippers/fan girls (‘cuz hey, Obama has “fan boys” remember?) are. They think this is about them? She becomes president so they all benefit? Please! This is about herself. Just like Bob Johnson–what he does benefits himself, not the community.
But you’d never know it when he goes into Poor Beleaguered Brotha Bob mode. Could the very blessings of Dr. King himself be behind?
(Snark alert if you didn’t catch it.)
Her pity party needs to end–five minutes ago.
Hillary Clinton (P-NY).
This game finished awhile ago, and Obama won. He is now playing a new game in a new series – the one against McCain. The only game left in the Democratic town is how best to re-unite the party and bring the Hilary supporters back on board, and if that takes a little diplomacy and consideration for the feelings of those who lost, then so be it.
Most romances follow a certain ritual and we don’t want this to be a one night stand. So let Hilary and her supporters play this one out. Almost no-one is watching anymore, and the new game has begun. But that’s ok – Obama’s credentials as a fighter and a uniter will have been enhanced by the process. Let Hilary have her last dance into the sunset – even if she doesn’t yet quite realise that the music has changed, and she is still waltzing whilst Obama raps.
I’ve been wondering all day how the Ted Kennedy news will effect Obama’s Iowa celebration.
Can’t possibly not mention it.
Hard to celebrate with that news on the table
Doesn’t want to say he will continue the Ted Kennedy legacy (JFK maybe), because that will brand himself the “ultra liberal” that gives energy to McCain.
Tough call.
One more reason to keep it subdued and tasteful, while Hillary whoops it up that she’s got the momentum even though she’s further behind than ever. She’s a fighter!
I think a better sports* analogy might have been figure skating or gymnastics – you nailed every element of the routine perfectly but you don’t want to hand the judges an excuse to give the top prize to that other competitor who didn’t perform as well.
* Figure skaters and gymnasts are some of the best-conditioned athletes in the world, but I really consider their “sports” to be just a hair above professional wrestling.