Palin’s stunning performance BooMan observes – a performance that left him feeling stupid – but,
“Sarah Palin was propped up by written responses”
Can we have a debate without props or cheating?
Why was this allowed?
Thinkprogress provides this Video
Sarah Palin Read Her Answers in Last Night’s Debate
For Sarah Palin, last night’s debate was an open-book exam. She spent much of the evening methodically reading and rehearsing answers from “carefully scripted talking points.” Palin’s notes were largely hidden from plain view, resting behind the lectern where she stood.
Because the cable and network television stations did not show a split screen of the debate, most viewers could not see that, during Joe Biden’s answers, Palin spent almost all her time looking down and studiously reading her notes. But viewers did see that when Palin delivered her answers, she would repeatedly glance down to check her talking points.
ThinkProgress has compiled a video documenting some of the instances where it was clear to the audience that Palin was propped up by written responses. Watch a video compilation:
[.] Video at link at link above
Politico reports that “on at least ten occasions, Palin gave answers that were nonspecific, completely generic, pivoted away from the question at hand, or simply ignored it: on global warming, an Iraq exit strategy, Iran and Pakistan, Iranian diplomacy, Israel-Palestine (and a follow-up), the nuclear trigger, interventionism, Cheney’s vice presidency and her own greatest weakness.”
[.]
(highlights added)
Hey, all the propping won’t make her ready in the next four weeks or the next six months.
TPM: notes conservatives are raising the white flag “One thing to watch for: Prominent conservatives essentially conceding that the race is over.”
In Wapo –Krauthammer:
Krauthammer’s Hail Mary Rule: You get only two per game. John McCain, unfortunately, has already thrown three. The first was his bet on the surge, a deep pass to David Petraeus who miraculously ran it all the way into the end zone.
[.]
Then, seeking a game-changer after the Democratic convention, McCain threw blind into the end zone to a waiting Sarah Palin. She caught the ball. Her subsequent fumbles have taken the sheen off of that play, but she nonetheless invaluably solidifies his Republican base.
When the financial crisis hit, McCain went razzle-dazzle again, suspending his campaign and declaring that he’d stay away from the first presidential debate until the financial crisis was solved.
He tempted fate one time too many. After climbing up on his high horse, McCain had to climb down. The crisis unresolved, he showed up at the debate regardless, rather abjectly conceding Obama’s mocking retort that presidential candidates should be able to do “more than one thing at once.” (Although McCain might have pointed out that while he was trying to do two things, Obama was sitting on the sidelines doing one thing only: campaigning.)
[.]
In the primary campaign, Obama was cool as in hip. Now Obama is cool as in collected. He has the discipline to let slow and steady carry him to victory.
[.]
He’s been moderate in policy and temper ever since. His one goal: Pass the Reagan ’80 threshold. Be acceptable, be cool, be reassuring.
Part of reassurance is intellectual. Like Palin, he’s a rookie, but in his 19 months on the national stage he has achieved fluency in areas in which he has no experience. In the foreign policy debate with McCain, as in his July news conference with French President Nicolas Sarkozy, Obama held his own — fluid, familiar and therefore plausibly presidential.
Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. famously said of Franklin Roosevelt that he had a “second-class intellect, but a first-class temperament.” Obama has shown that he is a man of limited experience, questionable convictions, deeply troubling associations (Jeremiah Wright, William Ayers, Tony Rezko) and an alarming lack of self-definition — do you really know who he is and what he believes? Nonetheless, he’s got both a first-class intellect and a first-class temperament. That will likely be enough to make him president.
One of the few times I agree with Krauthammer. With what’s ahead, we’ll need an FDR…not a McBushCheney or a “Bush in a skirt”
the race is over
My straw poll –
Maybe. I just ran an errand and came close to wrecking my car…
A sign of the times. Rural VT where its solid, Solid GOP country. Don’t look for Dem signs whether the election is local, state or national.
In the next block over, a Republican house has a sign up for the incumbent Republican Governor Davis (R-VT) and a sign for Obama.
Now over the last 4 years, Governor Davis has distanced himself from Bush. And by distancing, he has sued the BushCheney administration on EPA, and SCIP.
without identifying details, but to show the contrast.. wow.. that totally rocks!!
Thanks for the linked video, hope Olbermann picks it up.
curly and I watched last night and to us it was obvious that she was reading and sorting through notes.
BooMan has a post in defense of Lowry’s reaction to Palin’s stunning performance;
I’ll just drop in here this Sullivan’s reader’s reaction to Lowry and other men who, uum, had their pecker up:
God Bless America. We’re in a financial disaster but we’ll still hang on to the bright and shiny empty bags.
Was it her eye wear or the hair style?
He’s a family man. In every picture with Michele he STILL looks like the cat who got the cream, all pleased with himself to have married up so merrily. And his interactions with his kids, he’s motivated to do legwork to make the world a better place for them. And he stays connected to them, taking the effort to make video conference calls to see the girls off to bed every night.
Biden… another family man. Check his swear-in ceremony, where he didn’t want to leave his hurt kid’s side, and his team of fellow politicans worked with him. Team spirit, and dedication. Fantastic role model, including the human flaws like rage against the world when he was struggling with the loss of his wife and daughter. Conflict, effort, triumph.
What sort of role model does McCain provide? Ditch your “broken” first wife (who doesn’t look different from any soccer mom I know in this post-accident picture) .. to sneak around with a new wife that you later call a cunt, in public!? Yah, role model. Or those creepy ads that were all the rage before Palin-pick? Where we see John McCain from THIRTY YEARS AGO waving at us? I had no idea that was him, for the longest time. Then, when I knew, it was like.. why in hell is he using a picture that looks absolutely nothing like him today? Twisted, out of touch with reality vanity? Keep him the HELL away from me and mine.
And how Palin holds her baby, when she even does .. something leaves me feeling creeped out by her detachment from her own family, much less her genuine concern for people unlike herself. Like, the family knows they better make her look good, but she totally comes off as a Dolores Umbridge, the evil “proper” lady out of Harry Potter. (hat tip to some dKossack, who noted that spiritual resemblance). Again, no role model I care to point out at good to follow, and possibly also caught up in weird vanity issues.
So, family men who are motivated to improve life for self and others, dedicated to work and balancing that with connecting with family?
Or a deeply sleazey creep and a lady willing to sleaze the wink & “drill baby drill” talk that has already garnered her a Larry Flint fake-Palin porn flick?
Family men for me & mine, thanks! Team sleaze can exit stage left.
And how Palin holds her baby, when she even does .. something leaves me feeling creeped out by her detachment from her own family,
Its 10pm CST and she is parading the poor baby around at a post debate rally. There is something wrong with that picture. You sense that family is all about Sarah and Todd first.