I’ll be honest with you. It has often difficult for me to come to this site, or any political blog these days. Has been for some time now. Everywhere you look, there is bad news out there. I know, I’ve written about a lot of it. Political corruption. Endless wars, whether the War on Terror or the War on Drugs or Class War. Politicians who failed us and continue to fail us again and again because the only way they can remain in power is to accept the bribes of major corporations and industries. The same powers whose concern for most human beings is equivalent to that of gangsters and con artists.
Gangsters who shear us like sheep and slaughter us like lambs. Gangsters who steal what little we have to enrich themselves beyond all reason (Wall Street, Insurance Companies), who kill us slowly with their toxic products (Big Oil, Big Ag, Big Coal), who “sell” products and services that literally kill people or torture them (Defense contractors, Mercenaries like Blackwater/Xe, Taser International) and gangsters in the form of religious fanatics who prey on the weak, the fearful and those whose anger and frustration at their lot in life can be fashioned into hatred, fanatics who want to turn America into a Fundamentalist Christian version of Iran where freedom is but a word for total and complete obedience to their will.
Most tragically I have borne witness to ruination of the hopes and dreams of our children — dreams of a better lives than the ones their parents and grandparents have lived — through the devastation of the environment in which they live, the ruination of the economy they were led to believe would provide them jobs if they worked hard enough, and the concerted effort to poison their minds with the lies and propaganda of those who hold the reins of power.
Yes, boys and girls, I’m depressed as hell, and I haven’t even scratched the surface of all that is wrong with our world. Yet, this is a diary I entitled Hope. At this point you must be wondering why. Let this depressed, disabled, 55 year-old man try to explain.
We were sold hope in 2008 and many of us believed that one man could reinvigorate our nation, like some super-hero who would rescue us from all the evil villains and save the world. Many of us found hope in the promises of Democratic officials who, like the cavalry in some John Ford Western, would ride into Congress, blowing their bugles to save the day, bringing truth and justice in one fell swoop. We were deluded, of course. Hope cannot be manufactured, nor can it given to you by someone else, as a gift. At least not the kind of hope that lasts, the gives you the strength to raise yourself out of bed each morning despite all the troubles, calamities and suffering that besets you, and allows you to believe that the future shall be better than the past.
We are creatures who are genetically wired to strive for power and status, or to follow the lead of those who possess a will greater than our own. That is what the scientists tell us. That is what our history books tell us, which revel in stories of great men and women who accomplished great deeds and led others to the promised land. We, as a species like the easy narrative, and the symbolic function that heroic myths provide. We love to hear of golden ages and past generations that were greater than our own. We love to worship greatness in others as if by doing so, some of their magic dust will fall from their shoulders and sprinkle us with their glory, and thus spark in ourselves the some small measure of hope and success. Or so it seems. But lately I have begun to question the entire idea that hope and inspiration is a commodity that only some possess, and that that only some can generate in others.
We all have myths that we look to in times of despair, and never more so than in America, where we venerate heroes and elevate them to the status of demigods who were simply people like ourselves, often more better or worse. The founding fathers who defeated the greatest power in the world and established the first true democracy in modern times. Or Abraham Lincoln, who preserved the union. Or Franklin Roosevelt who saved the country from economic disaster and led our nation to victory in WWII, helped by the “Greatest Generation.” Or Martin Luther King, the leader of the Civil Rights Movement. Or for some Ronald Reagan, the man who tore down that wall and defeated Communism. Men and women supposedly greater in spirit than those of us who live now in this so-called era of decadent decline.
Yet, if you look closer, you find that the truth never matches the myth. America’s founding Fathers were often greedy and rapacious men, men who lost more battles than they won, whose revolution was secured more by the weariness of the British and the intervention of a doomed French King than any actions for which they themselves deserve credit. These were the same “founders” who failed to resolve the single greatest issue facing them, the divide between slave states and non-slave states, a failure that resounds to our nation’s discredit and dismay to this day.
As for Lincoln, he made disastrous decision after decision as President, felt despair and guilt far more than hope, and was in large part lucky that the political leaders of the Confederacy were even more inept than he was. His reliance on corrupt financiers to fund the war led to decades of oligarchic rule by “robber barons,” numerous cycles of business panics and depressions until finally the country was almost destroyed by the Great Depression. FDR? He often operated by trial and error, and though he got much right he also made many mistakes. His greatest success was to bring America into WWII (the great economic stimulus that re-energised the economy and also defeated fascism), and even there he was lucky that his opponents, both “Foreign and Domestic” were either weak and despised, or stupid and despised.
Martin Luther King? Yes a great man, but a flawed man, and a man who often took his lead from those who first stood up for their rights, such a Rosa Parks. An inspiring speaker and tactician, yes, but he was not the sole reason that the Civil Rights Movement succeeded. As for Reagan, never has a President been more fortunate to come along at just the right time. A time when the Soviet Union, after its failed war in Afghanistan, had Gorbachev as its leader, a reformer whose actions accelerated the decline of the Soviet Union as a great power essentially allowing Reagan to stand by and through clever propaganda take credit for what would have happened sooner or later regardless of who was the “Leader of the Free World” in the 80’s.
You see, those who subscribe to the great leader theory have it all wrong. They see these “historical leaders” as the source of the hope that led to ultimate successes, when in truth these people were very much in the dark as to what course of action to take, very flawed human beings and often very fortunate that they appeared on the stage at the right time. I do not deny that they often have been inspiring figures, but if truth be told, they owe their accomplishments to the people that never get the credit. People like us.
People who found in themselves the humanity, the decency, the passion and yes, the hope that things could change. Where would Washington have been without an army of unknown, underfed, mostly lower class farmers and tradesmen who despite numerous defeats (often because of Washington’s poor generalship) and a Continental Congress that refused to pay them and ran like cowards whenever the British forces appeared close to victory? Where would Lincoln have been had the abolitionist movement not forced the issue of the immorality of slavery? An unknown Illinois lawyer and failed politician, one we would never have read about in the gazillions of biographies that have become a staple of the Publishing industry.
The same can be said of most so-called great leaders. I don’t wish to demean what they meant to many people during their moments of crisis, for they do stand as symbols, powerful symbols for what the the human spirit can accomplish. But that is mostly what they are: symbols. Symbols for the hope that they found in others and used.
No, the only hope that lasts is that which you can find in yourself and in those, who like you, have found that facing fear, rather than cowering before it, is the only way to live, the only way one can live. You think I am misguided? Well, let’s look at some definitions of hope, shall we:
Verb:
To wish for something with expectation of its fulfillment.
Noun:
… a feeling of desire for something and confidence in the possibility of its fulfillment
Not very helpful, but the fundamental nature of the word is apparent, Here, let me offer my own expanded definition. Hope is a desire, a wish, an expectation and the belief that this desire can be accomplished even in the face of opposition from those who would deny and ridicule and disparage that desire, and the people who seeks to fulfill that desire. Most importantly of all, is the fact the “hope” is limited by what others perceive as possible or practical or (to use a popular neologism) “do-able.”
Without that desire, and without that expectation that one day it can be achieved, hope does not exist. And what gives us belief that our desire can be fulfilled? Not one person, though each of us, to have hope must first have the desire to seek its fulfillment. Now we arrive at the crux of the matter: hope exists only if there also exists an expectation, or as I would call it belief, that it can be accomplished. And what gives us that belief? Some find it in themselves alone, I suppose, but most of us do not. We are social animals, and as such let me make the claim that hope is as much a societal process as an individual one. That is to say, we need others to act if we are to turn hope, that wish to see a desire fulfilled, into a force that can accomplish what others do not believe possible.
And where to I see hope today, amidst all the signs and portents of a civilization on the brink of collapse? I see it in the people who, with great courage, and with great desire, and with actions that will not be denied, despite the powers arrayed against them, have out of seemingly nothing but the desire to see injustice end, have put their bodies and hearts and minds into fashioning a movement that I, for one, feeling helpless and hopeless not so long ago, would not have believed possible.
I speak of course of Occupy Wall Street and all the other Occupy movements that have sprung up, certainly against the expectations of the oligarchs and power brokers and politicians. A movement begun with nothing but a sliver of hope. Yet, with each day that passes, we see that more and more people are finding that hope within themselves, and what is more acting upon it. Hope that grows even as the authorities (governmental and otherwise) seek to crush it under the heels, batons, pepper spray and other means of violence practiced by their paramilitary law enforcement agencies against those who have the courage to express their hope for a more just and fair society and to demand that it be fulfilled.
In a long life filled with many defeats, and Pyrrhic victories, never have I seen the power of hope and the fundamental courage that accompanies it on display as i do now. Others older than I may have memories from earlier times when the Civil Right movement also struggled and fought for justice, when hope was a profound force for good, but I was too young to remember those efforts. Those people who acted on their hope for a better future, a better society, back in the day, accomplished much, yet even they might agree it was not enough. For evil does not easily surrender to what is good as the last half century has shown. Always it lies low awaiting its opportunities.
So make no mistake, the hope of those in the Occupy Movement alone cannot lead to the change we desire. But without it, without the strength that the hopes of millions upon millions of people possess, no change is possible. Let me leave you with several quotes.
First, one by Gandhi:
“I claim to be an average man of less than average ability. I have not the shadow of a doubt that any man or woman can achieve what I have, if he or she would make the same effort and cultivate the same hope and faith.”
The second is by Oscar Wilde:
We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.”
The final one is a french proverb of unknown origin:
“Hope is the dream of a soul awake.”
I have been discouraged and I have despaired, but my soul is now awake thanks to the courageous people of the Occupy movement who have shown me hope is the better path, for nothing we want to change can be accomplished without it. Continue to cultivate your hope, and I will continue to cultivate mine. I am through feeling sorry for myself and for my country. Like you, I will look to the stars, with hope. Thank you.
Great diary Steven.
I watched ‘Capitalism: A Love Story’ for the first time a couple nights ago. It came out two years ago, but watching it now it was striking how much of it was a seed for the Occupy movement. I had forgotten about the Republic Windows and Doors strike of 2008. Note that even there they were using the word ‘Occupy’ to describe their movement. A lot of the chants heard in the protests that Moore shows in the movie are the same ones that you hear at the various Occupations across the country.
It made me think that this movement, despite common knowledge, did NOT just start one day in September. It has been building for a long time.
And knowing that gives me even more hope. People are starting to get it. And what we thought technological advances and people-powered media would bring years ago at the inception of the liberal blogosphere is finally starting to come to fruition.
I still read blogs a lot but I don’t engage anymore. It’s too easy to say something that someone will (willfully or not) misinterpret and totally take personally. I’ve decided that it’s more worth my while to read and stay informed and support a range of liberal blogs–and have conversations with my friends and family about issues instead of flamewars with people I’ll never meet anyway.
I’d rather live my life and do what I can or want to do about the world within my own life’s radius and circle of people. I don’t feel like that’s tuning out and dropping out though I’ve been told that it is–but I don’t care about other people’s judgments or misperceptions anymore.
Or so I tell myself after writing long comments.
For me the blogging world is more or less a manifestion of Orwell’s “Two Minutes Hate”. In his prescient 1984, everyone has to attend meetings where the people rage against “the enemy”, and then they trudge back to work.
The people participating in today’s bloggo world do the same: liberals/progressives rant about/ridicule the right, and right wing blogs rant about/ridicule the left.
BIG deal… it’s all sort of pointless in the end.
It’s interesting over at the orange site– more and more people are finally facing the political/economic reality I’ve been talking about for oh, six years now.
By the time “progressives” there, here and elsewhere finally admit we have a one corporate party oligarchy, it will be wayyyyyy too late to do anything about it.
Who’s this ‘we’, and this ‘us’? Anybody having that level of expectations shouldn’t be permitted the franchise, and have someone, somewhere, holding their power of attorney.
Every market eventually clears, at some price — even the price of magic beans.
Alternate diary titles: “The problem with hero worship”– and related, “The problem IS Congress”.
Backdrop: I’ve voted democratic all my life, born and raised in a union family. Former member of the UAW.
I voted for Obama. However, I had no allusions regarding prompt, massive change. Reason being: he is merely one guy, and he’s not in Congress.
Congress IS the problem, and they’ve been a problem for thirty years or so.
I’m not sure why this fact gets lost/overlooked amongst the fervid hand-wringing over Obama and the current disaster we’re in the middle of?
Ideas, anyone?
I think it’s because people are A:) Naive; they actually thought one guy was going to swoop in and solve large problems which have been building up over the previous thirty years,
and B:) People refuse to face the fact Congress is a massive problem, it’s going to take a massive effort to correct this– and we have very little time to get it done.
Good diary, but I don’t see the point of much discussion regarding “hope”.
What is needed is a PLAN of action(s).
Alternate quote for the end of your diary: Failure to plan is planning for failure.
What is needed is a PLAN of action(s).
More than a nodding acquaintance with the liberal & progressive blogospheres would reveal that the best possible plan is to go whoring after another panacea-candidate.
What I’ve learned from wasting time in bloggo world is many “progressives” can’t cut the cord with the so called “democratic” party– regardless of just how lame the party is and how often they join their fellow corporate lackeys across the aisle to kiss corporate ass.
I’m a bit (but not much) younger than Steven, meaning that I’ve been politically active since precisely the moment when Reagan began building momentum toward the presidency. In other words, at the macro level my experience of the political world is that with very few exceptions (e.g., LGBT rights) on most issues the US has been moving steadily backwards for my entire adult life. Some days I feel like the patron saint of lost causes.
But my activism has also brought me into contact with a whole lot of truly amazing people from all over the country (and world), and taught me that such people are doing important things every day in every community in our country. They may not be visible, they’re definitely not the majority, but they’re – we’re – out there. Many, many people who keep trying to make a difference and make the world a better place, even in the grimmest circumstances. They’re my heroes, and they – not any elected politician – are why I always have hope.
.
Great diary Steve D. and a pleasure to read. The sacrifice of a single person can be the spark of a movement based on the hope of many. Gandhi and India, Czech uprising in 1968, Poland in overthrow of communism, Tunesia and the Arab Spring. Many brave persons lost and lose their lives in a vain attempt for freedom under a totalitarian regime. The advance of human rights must be a building block of democracy. Since 9/11 the western world has offered too many civil liberties of its citizens in the endless and ugly war on terror.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
Jesus. This post, right after one titled “Leaving Iraq”? Am I the only one seeing irony here?
nope
unintended irony
it’s not that I plan what to write or when to write it based on Martin’s schedule. I post much less frequently now as you may know. That is one reason Martin went and got Geov and Steve B to post here.
Steven, I am truly sorry that you are feeling such despair.
My perspective is soooo different. I have been an organizer my whole adult life and the last 5 years have been some of the most productive I have experienced. I also am the child of organizers and so I lived through their work as well–starting with anti Vietnam war organizing. I say this to give you a sense of what informs my perspective.
I never felt as though I was “sold hope”. To me that cheapens the commitment that then candidate Barack Obama made. As someone who volunteered for his campaign in many states starting in early 2007, I understood directly from his words that we would work together to make change. He said repeatedly that it would be difficult, that we would disagree, and that this would just be our chance for change. I never stopped working as part of that “we” and I am proud of what we have accomplished so far. Have we achieved everything we set out to? No. The President never promised we would. It would be foolish to think that possible. As I go through the list of accomplishments, all the doors knocked, and phone calls made, all the advocacy we did to our Senators and Representatives–I am inspired and very pleased.
I remember working on the Clean Air Act and how intractable the auto industry was to any sort of pressure or regulation to improve safety, fuel efficiency, etc. If you had told me then that the American auto industry would be restructured and revamped to develop higher fuel efficiency vehicles, electric and hybrid motors,etc I would have thought you were insane. And yet it happened!
If you had told me in 2006 when I was struggling with my own never ending health crisis (made a crisis by my insurance company refusing necessary treatment) that we would finally create meaningful patient protections, reign in out of control health insurance industry profits and administrative costs, and insure 32 million more people especially considering how much more powerful and intertwined the insurance industry is in our economy since the last failed attempt–I would have thought you were completely crazy.
And I can’t tell you how grateful I am that my sons will not have to deal with the corrupt student loan lending situation that put me in such horrific debt. My oldest son is in his sophomore year of college and will not be burdened the way several generations of students were. And if you don’t know about the recent student loan repayment and forgiveness programs that are retroactive to help people who took out these loans before 2010–please do check them out.
As for Occupy, I mostly stay quiet on the issue. I admire the intentions of many of the participants but overall I am not impressed by the tactics, decision making processes, or the messaging. That our local Occupy was completely silent and unhelpful when we were dealing with voter disenfranchisement also sours my opinion. The most effective activity they have engaged in thus far, again in my opinion, was to close accounts en masse to protest fees, etc.
Steven:
As a wise man once said,”when hope is gone, the seeds of revolution have already been sewn.” Now, I’m way to old to be a revolutionary, (and too much of a pansy), so hope is what is left. I sincerely hope you are right.
I have a facile answer for this:
Maybe the consumer economy doesn’t survive. The question is how we change from being shoppers to something else and still meet our needs for survival.
Touche! BTW that IS the question of our time, isn’t it?
The last few days of Congressional action have been traumatic. I’ve been giving serious thought to how to get out of the country if the GOP wins (steals) the Presidency next year. Then I saw an amazing story that reminded me that things are sometimes much better than they seem. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/12/02/1041706/-Hang-in-there,-baby-One-story-for-2012?via=siderec
ent And I agree that the Occupy Movement is a good sign. We just have to hold onto each other, and keep moving forward.
Wow, Steven D, just Wow.
And now, what the dictionary doesn’t tell you about hope. It’s not a feeling. It’s a state of being that you are in or not; you can’t whomp it up.
When all illusion is gone, when there is no ground beneath your feet, you find you keep going despite your feelings and sometimes despite your will. You take that next chance knowing that the future is absolutely unknowable.
That is hope. And it brings with it new illusions and a new sense of there being ground beneath your feet. Which at some point disappear again.
We often mistake the illusions for the hope when we are looking back.