I don’t have any profound points to make about the massacre at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, CT this morning. No one can when faced with a horror such as this one. But I cannot remain silent merely because I do not know the best words to use to express myself.
Since the massacre at Columbine, I’ve feared for my children at school. After the Virginia Tech massacre, I feared for my son when he went to college. My daughter – no, make that my lovely and precious daughter – is seventeen and a senior in high school and I still feel afraid for her. Tonight she’s out on a double date with her boyfriend, and with her best friend and her boyfriend. They’re going bowling, and I know this isn’t rational, but I’m worried about her going there, being out in public, exposed to the whims of my fellow armed citizens.
However, my fear is not entirely irrational. Because, if we have learned anything, it is that no place in our country is safe from gun violence. Not a church or a temple. Not a shopping mall or a supermarket parking lot. Not a movie theater and probably not a bowling alley. For many Americans, not even walking down the street is safe. This is the country we have allowed to come into existence. This is our America in 2012. Like a bad movie it just keeps repeating itself.
Many of us have allowed our love of guns to trump our good common sense. Many others, out of fear for their political careers, or an unwillingness to speak up and rock the boat, or maybe just sheer indifference, allowed the National Rifle Association, an organization once primarily dedicated to promoting gun safety for hunters, to become a political monster in our midst. A monster that kills without any remorse for its victims.
The NRA now pushes guns on people like drug dealers push heroin. They tell us that more guns in more places is the solution to our national problem with deadly gun violence. They, with their allies at the Koch brothers funded conservative political organization, ALEC, have seen to it that laws have been passed that promote gun use, such as the “Stand Your Ground” laws. The same type of law such as the one in in Florida, which has been shown to reduce the number of cases prosecutors bring for homicide and resulted in defendants going free in 70% of the cases where that law was raised as a defense.
In Arizona, gun laws there allowed protesters to openly brandish loaded weapons, handguns and rifles, at political rallies, a form of political terrorism and intimidation. In Michigan, the lame duck Republican controlled Legislature just rammed through a bill that will permit people with concealed carry permits to bring handguns into Michigan churches, schools and daycare centers. Other states have passed laws allowing guns to be brought into bars and restaurants where liquor is imbibed. Supporters of such laws tell me these laws will make us safer. For the life of me I do not see how.
I may not know much, but I do know the more guns you bring to a fight, or a dispute, or any place where judgment and reason is impaired, the more likely they are to be used. Used to maim and kill. How many times
have you read news stories about verbal disputes, whether in someone’s home, or in public, which escalated into violence? How many have you read where the introduction of guns led that violence to end in the shooting of those guns and the deaths of people? Too many times for me. Ask a police officer if he feels safer because all the other cops are armed when a shootout with an armed suspect breaks out. Better yet, ask a cop who was shot and killed in a “situation” where the non-police officer was armed. Yes, forgive me. I know, that’s impossible. Sorry for even suggesting it.
My point, perhaps the only one I have, is that adding more guns to our ever growing personal arsenals, and permitting more of them in more places, is not the answer to gun violence, it only makes incidents of gun violence more likely and more deadly. There are a plethora of “reasons” why many people in America turn guns on themselves or on others, and then pull the triggers of those guns, letting loose bursts of small metal objects traveling at great speeds that take the lives of other human beings. But the core thing they all have in common is the ready availability of firearms in this country. Let me explain by telling you about an incident of violence against children where guns were not involved.
Oddly enough, today in Chengping China, a deranged man attacked a group of school children with a knife. He wounded 22 of them. A heinous crime. Obviously, crazy people in other countries will find ways to commit violence against innocents, even small children, much like the children of Sandy Hook, even when they do not have the same ease of access to firearms as we do in America.
But here’s the difference. Read it for yourself from this USA Today article:
A knife-wielding man injured 22 children and one adult outside a primary school in central China as students were arriving for classes Friday, police said, the latest in a series of periodic rampage attacks at Chinese schools and kindergartens. […]
A Guangshan county hospital administrator said the man first attacked an elderly woman, then students, before being subdued by security guards who have been posted across China following a spate of school attacks in recent years. He said there were no deaths among the nine students admitted, although two badly injured children had been transferred to better-equipped hospitals outside the county.
A doctor at Guangshan’s hospital of traditional Chinese medicine said that seven students had been admitted, but that none were seriously injured.
You see, this madman did not have the ability to obtain two handguns and a rifle, as did the killer of six adults and 20 children at Sandy Hook Elementary School. He still found a way to attack them though — with a knife. However, the result could not be more different. That man with the knife in China probably wanted to kill a lot of people, including children, at the elementary school in Chengping, just as the man with the three guns in Newtown, CT wanted to kill adults and children at Sandy Hook. Only one succeeded, however, in murdering anyone. The man with the guns.
It is a well established fact that guns kill more people than knives, and far more easily, when both are available. A gun allows a person to shoot others from a safe distance, that is, a safe distance for the shooter. I often hear supporters of guns claim that just as many murders would happen in America if we had no guns. People would simply use knives. I don’t believe that statement. Do you?
I do believe that we will continue to live in fear of gun violence, no matter how many guns we buy, or how many more places exist where we can lawfully take them, or how many more laws permit us to use them when we could otherwise run or drive away from dangerous situations where we feel threatened with harm or injury. And the longer we do not face up to this truth, as a nation, the longer we do not seek to change our insane gun culture, in which guns are glorified, fetishized and idolized, and their use against fellow human beings is seen as acceptable, the worse this fear will become. It will consume us. Indeed, one could argue that it already has. And through the miasma of our collective fear, distrust, anger and paranoia more people will be tempted to use guns to “resolve” their problems, and more innocent people will suffer and die.
Just as the adult teachers and young school children died today at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, CT – in a hail of bullets.
The news report that I saw at DKos says he killed his brother, his mother, and his mother’s pupils. This sounds very Freudian to me. I’m saying we need to understand how this mental conditions are formed, how to spot them, and how to treat them. There is a much better chance of that than a fruitless quixotic campaign to rid the country of guns which isn’t going to happen.
MOrons ask Why. To paraphrase Checkov, every insane person is insane in a different way. You cannot predict violence. I have a Ph.D. IN quant psych. No one can predict violence.
You can answer HOW. HOW could he shoot 100 bullets in 20 min? With a high-cap magazine.
These need to be banned, and we need to confiscate them.
Look, I realize this is an emotional issue but the high-capacity mag issue isn’t going to solve much. It takes a matter of seconds to change out a magazine. His rate of fire is not very high for 20 minutes of shooting. I don’t care if these are banned but don’t fool yourself.
Camel’s nose.
Geezus, a gunsuck. Yes, eliminating high cap mags will solve a number of problems. No mag should be larger than 6 rounds. It should take a screwdriver to change mags.
Get a grip. I own no guns but I know enough not to talk out of my ass about something I know very little about.
If you want to say eliminating high cap mags is part of a comprehensive plan for gun safety then I’m all for it. But know that any mag can be changed out in as little as 2 seconds even ones that only hold 6 rounds. For that matter, 6 dead is still a mass shooting.
A screwdriver to change mags.. yes that’s going to happen. Clown.
OK. So you can’t predict who will get violent, but you can see from demographic studies that someone will get violent. Adam Lanza killed 26 people in about five minutes. There is no possibility that anyone could have done that without firearms and probably firearms with high capacity magazines.
Just because we cannot predict the incidents and the individuals with any reliability does not mean we need to ignore what we are also doing to enable the crazies to kill more people much faster.
I can also tell you that changing magazines during action requires training and constant practice. There is also no – absolutely zero – need for high capacity magazines in legitimate hunting. They are tools for killing people and symbols of such killing. That’s all they are. Ban ’em. Get rid of them. All the high capacity magazines in the civilian world together are not worth a single life and especially not the lives of 20 elementary school children.
Engineers ask HOW. Scientists ask WHY. I would not call scientists morons.
I hear you. However, in many states the legislation doesn’t exist to allow concerned family members to get help for a loved one who is showing signs that are concerning. If it’s a co-worker or friend, forget about it. The mental health safety net that was in place years ago is now gone. In Michigan we have a different name for severely mentally ill people……homeless.
When You Tie Shootings to Mental Illness
^^Good read.
Thanks. It was a good read.
I just can’t believe that anyone could actually do what this young man just did. He just caused so much pain. And I just can’t imagine being capable of carrying it out.
I don’t understand the why. And he’ll never explain it now that he is dead, too. But the capability? He had access to three guns and ammo.
I could not harm a hair on a five year old’s head.
All I know is that I’ve been getting angrier and angrier all day about this. People arguing for more guns or that “people kill people” just makes it worse.
It’s never going to change. Too many people don’t want to lose their “rights” to guns and as many guns as they could possibly ever want. The hell with the consequences.
It seems like there isn’t a day that goes by lately where I’m not disgusted and disappointed with what’s happening in this country.
As a country we should be ashamed, I know I am.
Anyone surprised that NRO’s The Corner ignored the shooting all day and then posted a clip of Krauthammer saying the only issue is the psychology of the killer?
I guess they couldn’t upset a donor.
This is another negative example of American exceptionalism. Not only that, the NRA represents the gun makers, not the gun owners. Since the branches of out Federal and state governments don’t want to deal with gun violence, I fear we will see more of these incidents. Evidently Denver and Madison weren’t enough to convince people.
Five Lies The Gun Lobby Tells You
I’ll tell you what if your a parent today was a nightmare in real life. I’m flashing back all day to my son’s childhood. I cannot imagine the terror these poor sweet children went through and the pain their parents will forever carry. Something has to be done to limit the number of guns in this society. Its out of control.
A nation wide ban on gun sales at “gun shows” would be one step toward sane gun policy. I’m sick of the whining about personal liberty in the context of firearms there are people dying here. Lets get sane.
.
I’m glad you wrote your heart out. I’m here to offer home buys to all distressed sellers. Let me know if you may be interested.