{Update1} See video of John Kerry press conference in Ankara.
Fits precisely the mold I put forward in my series of six diaries – US Will Be Ousted by Saudi King Abdullah in Middle-East. The US doesn’t understand the differences in strands of Islam. Where on the one hand, the French are fighting Islamist extremists in Mali coming from the Maghreb states plus Algeria, Tunisia and Libya. Recently there was an uproar in the Western world for anti-Semitic remarks by Egypt’s President Morsi. The news item had a life-span of a few days and has been forgotten. This week another ally in the overthrow of Assad’s regime in Syria has shown it’s blatant view of hate towards the state of Israel by the following remarks …
Erdogan at UN forum: Zionism is ‘crime against humanity’ [VIDEO]
(JTA) – Amid rampant hate speech against Jews published in newspapers in Turkey, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan said at a United Nations meeting that anti-Semitism, Zionism and Islamophobia were all “crimes against humanity.”
Speaking Wednesday at the “Fifth Alliance of Civilizations Forum” [Start video at 8:00 min] in Vienna’s Hofburg Palace, Erdogan said: “Just like Zionism, anti-Semitism and fascism, it becomes unavoidable that Islamophobia must be regarded as a crime against humanity,” Anatolia News Agency and other Turkish media reported.
The event was a United Nations summit for tolerance.
Kerry to ‘express concerns’ to Turkish PM over Zionism remarks
ANKARA, Turkey (Hürriyet) – “We put out a statement from Washington making clear that the statement was both offensive and wrong and I am sure the secretary will be able to convey that to the prime minister directly this afternoon,” the official said.
Netanyahu slams Erdoğan’s comments on anti-Semitism as ‘dark and libelous’
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu criticized Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s comments on Zionism and anti-Semitism on Feb. 28, describing them as a “crime against humanity.”
“I strongly condemn the comparison that the Turkish prime minister drew between Zionism and Nazism. I had thought that such dark and libelous comments were a thing of the past,” Netanyahu said in a statement issued by the Prime Minister’s Office, according to daily Jerusalem Post.
Iraq to Mali: The changing calculus of war
Netanyahu:
Erdogan:
Always interesting to see someone condemning someone for something she/he didn’t say — particularly when she/he spoke carefully enough not to be misinterpreted.
Erdogan is in a tough spot both domestically and regionally. Puppets of the west aren’t faring well of late. So that limits the options for himself and his country.
In my diary I added the link of the citation in context of his full speech. At first I thought Erdogan gave a fine speech, however later it became one-sided from his point of world view. The Muslims were victim of Islamophobia as immigrants in the (Christian) world. Never spoke of persecution of Christians in Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Sudan or Egypt. He spoke in vague terms, avoided specifics and didn’t name the countries where multi-culturalism as a strength and could be seen as an example. Similar to Netanyahu portraying the Jewish state as victim of anti-semitism and the Holocaust.
He’s competing for relevance and power in his part of the world and not the world. A region that for the past decade has been actively under the bombs and geopolitical manipulation of powers that make use Islamophobia at home to keep the war machines operating. (The people of Turkey are also sensitive to the times when they were subjected to direct attacks by Christians.) The ordinary people in his region have more objective evidence that they are under attack because of their religion than Americans have cause to feel that the “Muslims are coming, …” And like ignorant people bound to their religions across the globe and across time, they act out their fears against their perceived enemy in their midst. That there are currently more cooler heads in the US — no large rampages against Muslims only small isolated incidences and the quashing of a Muslim center in NYC — may be more of a reflection of the tiny population of Muslims in this country and not what’s in our hearts and minds. Plus so much of our anti-Muslim bloodlust is satisfied with our wars.
It’s too easy to tell foreign leaders/governments /people to hold up a mirror to themselves when we don’t do the same. US Congresscritters keep trying to pass an Armenian Genocide Resolution without recognizing the genocide of Native Peoples and slaves brought here from Africa. While we ignore the millions we slaughtered for no reason in Vietnam and the untold number killed/maimed/displaced by us in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Given the world leaders on the stage these days, “enlightened” is not an adjective that comes to mind. Even economically competent is in short supply — but Erdogan seems to have managed that much unlike a few others that could be named. The toppling of the Assad regime wasn’t on his agenda but his country is paying a large price because it was on the Saudi/US/Israel agenda; so, maybe he should be cut some slack.
I do hope John Kerry is fired up about the peace issue in the broader Middle-East. What I read between the lines during his first week of travels, Kerry is much more the diplomat than “rock-star” Hillary Clinton. I don’t want to see a PR show of meetings between leaders, the negotiations should be behind closed doors. The same is needed for a break-through in the Syrian Civil War and the diplomacy between Obama and Putin for a political solution to end the bloodshed.