The Body in Room 348 is a great article. It’s a compelling page-turning murder mystery. A middle aged oil and gas man is found dead in his Beaumont, Texas hotel room. It looks like a heart attack, but the medical examiner says that the man has massive internal injuries in his groin, his intestines, and his heart. It’s like someone dropped a safe on him, or he was in a high-speed accident.
I won’t spoil the whole story for you, but they eventually found the person who caused his death. It turned out that the medical examiner had missed an entry wound from a bullet. And when they tried to convince the District Attorney down there to charge the shooter with a felony, they got some attitude.
If he had come forward at any time prior to Brennan and Apple’s solving the mystery, which had taken about eight months, it is unlikely he would have been charged with manslaughter, much less have gone to jail. Mueller had gambled from the start that whatever connection he had to Greg’s death would never be discovered. The odds in his favor were good, too. As it was, even after the connection was made, the county district attorney’s office had been reluctant to prosecute the case as a felony.
Brennan had turned that idea around. When he found out that the prosecutor might opt for a plea deal, he flew to Beaumont and joined a meeting between Apple and Paul Noyola, an investigator for the D.A.’s office. Noyola explained that accidental gun discharges in Texas were not uncommon, and that juries and judges tended to understand them, and that … well, the whole issue of accidental deaths was a fairly gray area of the Texas criminal code. In other words, the whole thing was looking like more of a hassle than a slam dunk.
Guns go off all the time, and sometimes people get killed because of it, but, you know, it’s a gray area. Texans understand that this stuff is quite common, and so who are they to sit in judgment.
Again, I don’t want to spoil the fun of reading the article, but the idea that you can shoot and kill a person and not get charged with at least manslaughter is incredible to me. The only reason this guy got hard prison time is because he didn’t admit what he had done.
What kind of culture is that?
It’s America, fuck yeah. Simple answers to simple questions
It’s America, fuck yeah.
Speaking of which .. “Team America: World Police” was on IFC this weekend. In all its F-bomb glory.
What kind of culture is that? really? LOL http://linkapp.me/J8fTs
Do you feel that way about all accidental killings or only those involving guns?
Don’t get too radical just because guns piss you off, man.
I didn’t want to explain all the details of the case so that people could still somewhat enjoy the suspense of the article.
But part of the problem is with defining accident.
If I get drunk and drive my car, I know I am at risk of killing myself and others. If I use substandard construction materials, I know that I am endangering others. If I take a bribe to certify the safety of something, I know that someone could be harmed. And if I discharge a weapon in a hotel, likewise.
So, I am not picking on guns. I’m picking on a culture that is disinclined to hold anyone responsible when their gun kills someone unless they were aiming at them.
This wasn’t an “accidental killing”. The man was waving a gun around, his finger on the trigger and pulled the trigger.
I find nothing in that sequence to be ‘accidental’.
I mean there accidents and then there are accidents.
The idiot didn’t mean to kill anyone, but he was so careless that he nearly killed his friend.
It’s clearly no worse than manslaughter, but it’s also clearly manslaughter.
Good article. Thanks. I get really angry at the gunsucks.
You can follow a liveblog of the George Zimmerman trial here:
http://3chicspolitico.com/2013/07/08/state-of-florida-vs-george-zimmerman-trial-day-10/
One of the constant themes over the last 30 and more years for those opposing the capital punishment industry in Texas is how frequently shoddy the investigations, prosecutions, and trials are. And that’s in capital cases, which have far more resources and (supposed) safeguards devoted to them than other crimes do.
The sloppiness of the police investigation and initial ME examination, and the laziness of the prosecutor’s office, are no surprise to anyone who’s lived or been politically active there. It’s not just gun culture at work.
Thanks for the story link — what a great read.
And another excellent reason for why I will never own a gun: I would do something stupid with it.