Whatever you think of Edward Snowden’s behavior, his decision to steal and leak troves of information about the activities of the National Security Agency (NSA) has already led private industry to massively ramp up their efforts to foil governmental and criminal snooping on their networks because real damage has been done to their reputations.
The tech industry’s response to revelations about NSA surveillance has grown far more pointed in recent weeks as it has become clear that the government was gathering information not only through court-approved channels in the United States — overseen by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court — but also through the massive data links overseas, where the NSA needs authority only from the president. That form of collection has been done surreptitiously by gaining access to fiber-optic connections on foreign soil.
[Brad] Smith, the Microsoft general counsel, hinted at the extent of the company’s growing encryption effort at a shareholders meeting last week. “We’re focused on engineering improvements that will further strengthen security,” he said, “including strengthening security against snooping by governments.”
They are also applying pressure on Congress to rein in the NSA.
Microsoft, Google and Yahoo also have joined other major tech firms, including Apple, Facebook and AOL, in calling for limits to the NSA’s surveillance powers. Most major U.S. tech companies are struggling to cope with a global backlash over U.S. snooping into Internet services.
As a result, pressure is building on Speaker Boehner to allow a vote on the USA Freedom Act, which has growing bipartisan support. The administration has already announced a change of leadership at the NSA and is debating splitting the leadership of the the NSA and the recently established U.S. Cyber Command.
At a White House meeting of senior national security officials last week, Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper Jr. said he was in favor of ending the current policy of having one official in charge of both the National Security Agency and U.S. Cyber Command, said the individuals, who spoke on the condition of anonymity.
Also, officials appear inclined to install a civilian as director of the NSA for the first time in the agency’s 61-year history.
Ideally, Congress would hold hearings aimed at getting to the truth about the breadth and effectiveness of the NSA’s programs, and use what they learn to craft sensible reforms, but I fear any such effort would become a partisan brawl, with Republicans running amok and Democrats circling the wagons in response.
Real reform is rarely possible without a degree of outrage from the American public, but even the exploitation of the porn habits of Muslim “radicalizers” has so far done little to raise the ire of most Americans. This particular story is rather bizarre. If some fiery imam likes to view pornography in between crafting jihadist incitements against the West, that information could indeed be used to discredit them among their followers. But we could just say that they like kiddie porn or sex with animals or pork sausage biscuits or anything else we might think up. The truth of the allegations is only preferable to lies if we can demonstrate their truth. And the NSA isn’t about to demonstrate to the world how they discovered the porn habits of the “radicalizers.” If they aren’t going to “show their work” then the whole process is pointless.
The truth is, however, that knowing about the personal sexual habits of our adversaries is useful for blackmailing them and recruiting them to work for our side. The same is true about their financial habits. A crude version of this type of spy craft was used in this season of Showtime’s Homeland, where a senior Iranian spy was recruited as a U.S. agent after the CIA discovered that he had stolen hundreds of millions of dollars from his own government.
The concern is that the government will use the same tactics to quiet domestic critics. Another concern is that the level of intrusiveness the NSA is pursuing is causing so much harm to our relationships with our allies that it is doing the opposite of keeping us safe. The desire for Total Information Awareness is understandable, but tapping the phones of foreign leaders’ of friendly countries isn’t likely to increase cooperation and intelligence sharing.
I know policy-makers want information when they ask for it and don’t want to be told that getting the information they seek is more trouble than it’s worth, but that really is the case sometimes. It would be easier for the NSA to say ‘no’ to some requests if Congress told them that they had to say ‘no.’
In any case, because the NSA couldn’t keep what they were doing secret, they lost the right to keep on doing it. These revelations harmed the tech industry that the NSA was obligated to protect. So, now the tech industry is at war with them on both the security and the legislative fronts.
People who like power seldom not use it. I would not be surprised if snooping on the internet for porn users’ habits has been going on a long time. And not just for radical Islamists over there. When you consider all the inane things the government has spied on its citizens for over the years. Wouldn’t you like to know what Boehner and Graham have for stroke material? No, well, the next time that the big appropriations bill comes up you can bet how lovely Lindsay will vote.
You a radical environmentalism? I’m sure that there’s something you looked at that can embarrass you. And I bet they’ve got ways of putting things on your hard drive.
Power.
The Talking Heads should reissue their 1980s classic and retitle it Life During Perpetual Wartime, now with renewed relevance.
We got computer, we’re tapping phone lines,
I know that ain’t allowed
.
.
Foreign Intelligence agencies were cooperating with the NSA to illegally tap international Internet trunk lines and forwarding or “selling” data in return to the NSA. Not only the British GCHQ, part of the five eyes, but also the French, Germans and the Dutch. European corporations and governments will avoid US services where data is stored on servers on US territory. US will lose several $ billions in traffic and Europe, Mexico and Brazil will cut-off US corporations from their Internet data storage. The privacy of citizens have been trampled and most of the snooping was done illegally.
The intelligence services have their own dynamic of deals, contracts and cooperation outside the civil authorities. About time the broom sweeps clean … for a while at least. Haha 😉
France and the UK were corrupt anyway but the Germans with Angela Merkel will get tough. The Israeli intelligence service had profited from all illegally gathered data from the NSA directly. Will the Obama administation halt this free-ride transaction too?
Personal privacy is over. Deal wid it. If there is something that you do that you find potentially embarrassing? Don’t do it!!! Duh. Trillion dollar organizations…private companies such as Google just as much as Fed groups like the NSA and probably better at it..are busily at work collecting every bit and byte of data that you commit to the internet or on phone lines of any sort. If you are truly targeted? Hell, man, drones and surveillance equipment the size of a fly egg are available for those w/real money and power. Bet on it. Use GPS? Best not if you do not want to be tracked, even years into the future. Don’t bring your cellphone, either, although a sudden alteration in your cellphone use might of course be a “dog that didn’t bark” sign to real surveillance people. “The cellphone that didn’t move or get used.” Yup. Get used to it. Where were you the night of November 17th, 2013? Betcha that info can be discovered by anyone w/a high enough security clearance and probably by any schmuck IT person working for your GPS provider as well. Probably by anyone working for your cell phone provider too, and more than likely anyone working for most of the apps on your phone. C’mon, man…Obama presided over the end to personal privacy. Get used to it, ‘cuz it ain’t gonna change. The only way that it will “change”…and don’t give me any rigamarole about so-called laws, because they now mean nothing except as a sort of set of general suggestions to the government and to private enterprise…the only way that this situation will change is if the whole internet is destroyed. This is a distinct possibility, of course. InfoWar is the newest military front and all hands are on deck trying to figure out how to InfoBomb the so-called enemy while protecting the so-called homeland. Bet on that as well.
The Borgness.
It’s what’s for dinner now.
Did he do it “on purpose?”
I hope not.
Just another mistake, more’n likely.
So it goes.
1984 came a little late this century, but it’s goddamned well here now.
The question is…whatchoo gonna do about it, Booman?
Help Hillary get elected?
Good luck wid dat shit!!!
Remember them “new glasses” she got when she fell on her head?
Are you familiar w/Google glasses?
Borgle glasses.
Bet on it.
Have a nice day.
I’m gonna.
Why? How? Because I don’t give rat’s ass what they think. Bet on that as well.
That’s why.
Wake up and fight, man.
Wake the fuck up and fight back!!!
Later…
AG
Stole? Maybe we need a new word because technically he copied documentation; the government still has full possession of all the original documentation.
Different story bubbling up at the Navy where information was used to steal money. Money that will never be retrieved.
The best report on the first case: Two Admirals Face Probe in Navy Bribery Scheme.
Now there’s another one concerning Inchcape Shipping Services. Reuters report The NYTimes report on this is more complete.
Inchcape is owned by the government of Dubai. (The same owner that caused a brief flurry of outrage in 2006 over its purchase of some US port operations. Dubai Ports World.) It’s been under investigation since 2010 and under subpoena to turn over documents since March 2011.
Time to watch Enemy of the State again? Other than appearing technologically slightly out of date, this fifteen year old movie holds up very well.
And does Jon Voight in the movie remind anyone else of a certain high level government face we’ve come to know this year?
Snowden released to the public information that they had paid for and was necessary to their understanding the abuses that were occurring at NSA.
I still maintain that unwinding these abuses and the legal system (PATRIOT Act, FISA Courts, secret budgets, secret laws) that support them is one of the huge challenges if the Obama administration intends to leave behind a functioning democracy.
Having all of the information that has come out has allow security experts to put pieces together that proved government assurances to be lies. The biggest worry now is over the effects of the StuxNet virus, which attacked the supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) system of Iranian centrifuges but has already leaked out and been found at a Chevron refinery. SCADA systems are standard control systems for controlling machinery, electrical equipment, and pumping equipment. The fact that the US Cyber Command in conjunction with Israel carried out this offensive cyberattack without considering the defensive consequences has industrial security people worried.
So the mindless nature of the intelligence community has destroyed markets for US cloud software (even called the whole idea of cloud computing into question) and presented a threat to US industrial operations. When I was arguing five months ago that this was I big deal, I was thinking about surveillance. But this mindless war footing is even bigger.
But Congress does not understand this yet because the Congressional intelligence agencies are still shielding the intelligence community instead of exerting oversight. And now, when oversight comes, it must be public because the public cannot trust the Congressional intelligence committees to faithfully do their jobs.
This is a huge issue that demands strong and decisive action that we have not yet seen.
Do we know if Stuxnet is robust enough to infect and do serious damage to water supply SCADA? Those systems are individually designed for the provider and as such, may have some protection.
.
○ SCADA and vulnerabilities to critical infrastructures
○ STUXNET US-Israel Cooperation Cyber Warfare on Iran
Well and good that the giant tech companies are exerting pressure to reduce access for NSA and its interests. But who is watching the giant tech companies to make sure they are not betraying customer confidence for their own commercial interests?
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/aug/14/google-gmail-users-privacy-email-lawsuit
<block quote>In any case, because the NSA couldn’t keep what they were doing secret . . . So, now the tech industry is at war with them on both the security and the legislative fronts.</block quote>
War is stronger than warranted. These data collectors have had their brands damaged because of NSA incompetence in indulging outsourcer greed. They are embarrassed that they have been outed, otherwise they don’t really give a shit. Now they are just looking for some remedy to put the genie back in the bottle and go back to business as usual with some fig leaf they can use to pretend they aren’t still providing the same access.
This is much more like a marriage where one spouse has disgraced the family by getting addicted and behaving badly. Not going to get a divorce, not going to destroy the family. A little rehab to get the habit under control and then they can get back to business pretending there’s nothing going on.
Make blockquote one word. Use the preview button to check. Not a criticism, I fail to heed my own advice too often.
Thanks! Will use the preview button.
They are doing good job!
blood borne pathogen training
Booman I am curious, just what behavior would constitute “Republicans running amok”?
Seems to me that’s what we have now.