Shameful, shameful! How shameless can one be, declaring Hitler only wanted to evict the Jews and putting blame on Mufti Haj Amin al-Husseini and today’s Palestinians ar the root cause for the extinction of Jews. How morally corrupt must one be to publicly make these statements in a speech in 2015! Netanyahu is not a leader, he has always been competing with his brother Yonathan. Bibi just destroyed his own legacy as Prime Minister of Israel. This should lead to his political downfall and a pariah statesman in the world … unless that world is just as corrupt and morally void as Israel has become.
The Zionist spirit of socialism and kibbutz movement has turned the corner to settler violence and the ways of Meir Kahane in political discourse in the US, Canada and Europe. The spirit of pioneers and communal service has evaporated into hatred, superiority and criminal occupation of the Palestinian land and oppression of its people for over six decades. The world watches as the United Stated condones and gives necessary military support for the crimes to continue.
Israel does not need Benyamin Netanyahu, he should be voted out of office the sooner rather than later.
in the face of the criticism Netanyahu is doubling down on his contention that Palestinians incited the holocaust. Here is what he said today before leaving to Berlin:
My intention was not to absolve Hitler of his responsibility, but rather to show that the forefathers of the Palestinian nation, without a country and without the so-called ‘occupation’, without land and without settlements, even then aspired to systematic incitement to exterminate the Jews.
Meanwhile, Germany says it has no idea what Netanyahu is talking about. [Video Chancellor Merkel]
Here is the speech to the World Zionist Organization, in which Netanyahu relates the ten biggest lies told about Israel. One lie is that Israel intends to destroy the Al-Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem. He says this lie has a long pedigree, going back to the mufti. The relevant portion begins at 2:55.
Why Holocaust historians decry analogies by Netanyahu | Christian Science Monitor |
Although al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem at the time, was a Nazi sympathizer who supported the Final Solution, and fought unsuccessfully throughout his life to prevent a Jewish homeland in the Middle East, historians strongly rebutted Netanyahu’s claim, saying evidence of the Third Reich’s genocidal intent was in place well before Hitler met with al-Husseini.
Tel Aviv University professor Meir Litvak, for instance, told Israel’s Ynetnews that plans for the Holocaust were put in place by 1939. Al-Husseini “was an abominable person,” Dr. Litvak said, “but this must not minimize the scale of Hitler’s guilt.”
“We know that responsibility for this crime against humanity is German and very much our own,” a spokesman for German Chancellor Angela Merkel told Ynet’s Ahiya Raved.
It’s not the first time Netanyahu has come under attack for using questionable Holocaust references. In 2012, he drew controversial parallels between the threats posed by Iran’s nuclear program and Nazi Germany’s concentration camps.
When the Israeli Knesset was debating a bill to limit the use of the word “Nazi” in non-historical or educational contexts, hoping to cut down on “trivializing” political and popular usages alike, a column by former CIA analyst Paul Pillar wryly noted that the Prime Minister himself “is one of the worst abusers.”
Outrage on Twitter over Netanyahu’s Holocaust remarks | Deutsche Welle |
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Adolf Hitler had wanted to expel Jews from Europe at first, not kill them, until a conversation with Jerusalem Mufti Hajj Amin Al-Husseini changed his mind. That speech was met with outrage across Israel and the Jewish world, with many people calling for him to backtrack from these claims.
Opposition leader Yitzhak Herzog posted a message on his facebook page calling the speech a “distortion of history,” and added that it could be used by Holocaust deniers. Meretz party leader Zehava Galon wrote that her own family members had been persecuted and killed in Lithuania and said she was “ashamed” for Netanyahu.
Palestinians in particular were quite angry.
Many Israelis, too, took to social media to mock their prime minister’s remarks, while others expressed their anger, with many criticizing Netanyahu for using the memory of the Holocaust as a political tool. Other users, like the popular parody account God, found more comfort in humor.
Netanyahu under fire after linking Palestinian leader to Holocaust
○ In Mufti Speech, Netanyahu Showed His Obsessive Hatred of the Palestinians
○ Israeli PM accused of trivialising the Holocaust | The Guardian |
○ Israeli Jewish Mob Lynches Eritrean, Mistaking Him for Terrorist
○ Jerusalem Descends Into Blood Lust
○ Jordan king warns Israel over Jerusalem holy site violence
○ Palestinian toddler burned to death in ‘settler’ arson attack | Digital Journal – July 31, 2015 |
In spite of their bitterness at the brutality of the British suppression of their rebellion [the Arab Revolt, 1936-39], about nine thousand Palestinians volunteered during WW2 for service in the British forces against the Axis powers. Some of these volunteers are seen here on parade in Nablus in May 1941.
— Walid Khalidi, “Before Their Diaspora: A Photographic History of the Palestinians 1876-1948”.
○ Palestinian Volunteers Against the Axis | Palestine Studies |
Thanks, I didn’t know that was online. I could have saved myself a lot of frustration this morning when I was trying to get my stupid scanner to work so I could upload from the book.
1. Future Israeli Prime Minister, Yitzhak Shamir (second left), spent WW2 in Palestine as a leader of the Zionist militant group, Lohamei Herut Israel (Lehi). Unlike the Haganah, the Lehi declined to suspend its armed campaign against British rule for the duration of the war against Hitler. In 1940, the Lehi sought an alliance with Mussolini’s Fascist regime in Italy. In January 1941, it offered “to actively take part in the war on Germany’s side”. Throughout the war, the Lehi carried out armed attacks against British property and personnel, and against fellow Jews who continued to employ or trade with their Palestinian Arab neighbors, or who declined to pay protection money. In November 1944, Shamir was one of the three Lehi leaders who ordered the assassination of Walter Guinness (Lord Moyne), Britain’s Minister of State in the Middle East.
(After the war, in September 1948, Shamir was again one of the three Lehi leaders who ordered the assassination of Count Folke Bernadotte, the U.N. mediator in the Middle East conflict. As a Swedish diplomat in WW2, Bernadotte had facilitated the release of at least 20,000 inmates -including thousands of European Jews – from Nazi concentration camps, and their evacuation to Sweden.)
2. Future Israeli Prime Minister, Menachem Begin (left), was initially a member of the free Polish forces commanded by Gen. Wladyslaw Anders. In May 1942, when the war against Hitler was far from won, Begin deserted from his unit while it was in transit from the Soviet Union to fight the Nazis on the western front, in order to fight against the British in Palestine instead. He joined the Zionist militant group the Irgun (whose leader he soon became), and opened its terrorist campaign against British forces in Palestine in February 1944.
In October 1944, Britain’s Middle East commander in chief said that Jewish terrorists in Palestine were “directly impeding the war effort of Great Britain” and “assisting the enemy”.
In Europe, people who deserted allied armies, offered their military services to the Third Reich, and spent WW2 carrying out armed attacks against allied personnel faced trial and possibly execution as collaborators with the Nazis once the war was won. In Israel, people who deserted allied armies, offered their military services to the Third Reich, and spent WW2 carrying out armed attacks against allied personnel became prime minister.
And their successors have the gall to blame Palestinians for the Holocaust.
Where did you take this information from?
The attempted alliance with Mussolini is from Wikipedia’s entry on the Lehi; the offer to fight for Nazi Germany is from Lenni Brenner’s Zionism in the Age of the Dictators (hardcopy) though the document in which the offer was made is called “Fundamental Features of the Proposal of the National Military Organization in Palestine (Irgun Zvai Leumi) Concerning the Solution of the Jewish Question in Europe and the Participation of the NMO in the War on the Side of Germany” and can be found in numerous places online; the killing of Count Bernadotte is from the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs (linked); Begin’s history with the free Polish forces and the British C-in-C’s comment about assisting the enemy are from Walid Khalidi’s Before their Diaspora (hardcopy); the wanted posters and descriptions of terrorist activity in Palestine are from the The Encyclopedia of Palestine (hardcopy), with the information in that encyclopedia about British personnel killed by Zionist militants during WW2 verified at the Palestine Police Roll of Honour, here, and in the archives of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, e.g. here; Lord Moyne assassination info from Hansard, the daily record of proceedings in the British Parliament, online here.
Excellent work! I lifted just a small paragraph from the comprehensive article …
○ All you ever need to know about Israel by shergald | Feb. 28, 2007 |
○ Sharon Readies Plan for Total West Bank Pullout by ’08 by Oui| Nov. 28, 2005 |
More about Ariel Sharon:
○ Ariel Sharon in interview admits role in Qibya massacre in 1953
○ His finest hours: On Sharon’s murderous legacy | +972 |
I don’t visit Daily Kos so I hadn’t seen that diary, but it is really impressive. I can’t imagine how long it takes to write something like that.
Thanks.
Mondoweiss Netanyahu’s having a better week in the Democratic Party than Hillary Clinton!
Something else Clinton supporters can take pride in. Along with her recommitment to the death penalty. (Too bad she’s not a governor of a state with a mentally handicapped AA prisoner that she could rush back to and sign the death warrant for the man’s execution. That would give her another poll bounce.)