Let’s count the ways that Molly Ball dehumanizes the youth vote.
1. They line up for hours to see Sanders, snow accumulating on their puffy jackets and knit caps and uncombed hair.
2. They gather in little knots as they wait for him to appear, engaging in impromptu rap sessions about pot legalization and campaign-finance reform.
3. [The New Left] is obsessed…with policing its own adherents for their violations of its norms.
4. At a rally against police violence at Dartmouth in November, a protester screamed at a frightened girl, “Fuck your white tears!”
5. “Socialism shouldn’t be a dirty word,” Phillip Moran, a green-eyed aspiring glassblower with a black beard and blue bandana on his head, told me.
6. The kids want legal marijuana.
7. They want rights for gay people and trans people and people in between genders.
8. “I work for our sexual-assault prevention program, educating people about seeking and receiving consent,” said Sami Cola, a women’s studies major at the University of New Hampshire with a blond topknot and ripped black jeans.
9. “I know I enjoy white privilege,” said Russel Evans, a 20-year-old history major at the University of Vermont with shoulder-length dirty-blond hair.
10. The kids are earnest and well-meaning and sweet. They come to see Sanders in couples, leaning on each other’s shoulder, wearing matching pot-themed T-shirts (“KEEP CALM AND BERN ONE”).
11. “I try to get people to recycle, because I care about what happens to the earth,” said Nicole Rode, a junior biology major, who wishes she could stop having political arguments on Facebook but can’t help herself.
12. Emily Ratajkowski, the swimsuit model best known as the girl in the the “Blurred Lines” video, emceed the event and began with a fiery repudiation of Gloria Steinem, who had implied that young women only supported Sanders because they wanted to meet boys.
13. The students around him all sat down, too, and he urged them to put their arms around each other. It had the feel of an old-school love-in. He led them in an a cappella rendition of “Lean on Me.”
In case you miss the point, these are kids who complain about income inequality even though they have ski lift tickets on their puffy jackets. They want free tuition, legal pot, and they can’t be bothered to comb their hair. They’re obsessed with rape culture and white privilege and use incomprehensible words like ‘cis’ and ‘intersectional,’ and they don’t like patriarchy. They have no use for religion or other imaginary things, and they dress in rags and don’t shave. They’re as likely to tsk-tsk you for saying something racist or failing to recycle as they are to worry about people who are “in between genders.’ They major is useless things like English, Women’s Studies, History, and sustainable-agriculture. Or, maybe they don’t even bother with college and merely aspire to be a hippified glassblower.
I like most of Molly Ball’s reporting, and this piece is probably a broadly accurate portrayal of the people she’s encountered in New Hampshire. But it’s needlessly snarky and dismissive. These young adults’ opinions aren’t less valid because they wear ripped jeans, argue obsessively on Facebook or believe in sustainable agriculture.
And, as Nancy pointed out earlier, it may be a bit premature to expect that the youth vote in places like South Carolina and Georgia will be as pro-Sanders as it is in Iowa and New Hampshire. This is an assumption that crept into the Matt Yglesias piece I cited in my last article.
To my way of thinking, Ball’s piece is flawed on both counts. It’s condescending and it’s presenting facts not yet in evidence.
Let the kids’ words speak for themselves, and let’s see how they vote before we tell everyone what they think.
Rich pundits always hippy punch. Always.
PJ O’Rourke wrote some similarly stupid bullshit that I read on the BBC website last night. Oh yeah, O’Rourke also had something about Bernie Sanders being on the other side of the Iron Curtain. Juvenile stuff.
Yeah, quite a haystack he assembled, wasn’t it?
He’s been doing that shit for decades.
It’s a shame because he was such a talent at National Lampoon during its Second Renaissance. But he’s been an absolute shithead ever since.
O’Rourke was humorous for about fifteen minutes, forty years ago. Now he’s Hip Conservative shtick is just sad.
“His” not “he’s” … jesus
Spiffy MBAs are why we are in the fix we are in, not DFHs.
Know them well. Couldn’t avoid working with them and they never understood why I refused to join their club.
Completely familiar to older and old DFHs. And my cognitive and emotional response to the DFH punchers hasn’t changed one whit even though the DFH punchers are of a different generation and of my own and younger. They are as loathsome, self-centered, and visionless as ever.
Is there something wrong with me? That doesn’t seem derogatory at all. They sound like great people. Wild hair has been in for 10 years and ripped jeans for 30.
It’s not about what you don’t like. It’s about what the author and her readers are tacitly agreeing about.
(I’m on your side! They sound great — I wish I’d been there.)
When I read the piece earlier today, I suppose I should have put more critical thinking glasses on, because all those insinuations went over my head. I can’t tell if that’s because that’s because it’s losing its punch as a successful line of attack, I’m just not used to reading those things into it (think of anyone’s “feminist transformation” when all of the sudden you see the patriarchy you didn’t previously see), or a combination of both.
You can say that again.
It is amazing how some love to judge a book by it’s cover so to speak. The one thing that is clear. If they are waiting to vote then these young people are doing far more then the other of the too numerous amounts of Americans. That are sitting on their butts at home complaining about the country.
And if The Atlantic went out of business anytime soon, Molly Ball would wonder why, when the answer is staring her and her ilk straight in the face.
They had a very good article the other day on faith in regulation vs monopoly busting. Very fair minded.
Gawker — This Is How Hillary Clinton Gets the Coverage She Wants
Must say millenials are smarter than the boomers. They can identify the culprits.
As Thomas Frank put it: [Young people] have every right in the world to be furious, OK? I’m quite serious about that. And it’s a refreshing thing to see them flocking to Bernie. But it’s not idealism, per se… At the end of the day, these people are screwed, and they know it. And they’re reaching out to someone who promises to unscrew them.
Goddamn long hair dope smoking hippy freaks
Crap, here’s some more …
None of these people will amount to anything.
worse yet, some of those guys are dropouts…
You write:
Further…and this is where it could get very interesting…let’s see how many non-so called milliennials…non-hipsters, non-college students, non-enititlement gifted yupsters…agree with them.
Given a straight vote count tonight…and my extensive personal experience in the towns and cities of Maine, NH and Vermont leads me to believe that those people are neither easily fooled nor particularly compliant when hustled…we’ll know more in the morning.
My own take…colored by a fervent wish to be right in this case, granted…is that Bernie is going to come out on top.
Substantially.
We shall see by morning.
Let us pray.
Or be preyed upon.
Later…
AG
P.S. Some fine, 8-year-old Piedmont red wine is going to help me get through the night. Bet on it. See y’all tomorrow.
They all sound like very nice people to me. I’d far rather talk to them than the dicks who show up to Trump rallies. What a country we’ve got
Molly Ball is a republican, one who made her bones working the Republican beat in past election cycles. Any “analysis” from her end has to be considered with those caveats in mind.
Stupidest headline since “Dewey Defeats Truman” — HuffPo –
A Racist, Sexist Demagogue Just Won The New Hampshire Primary
First, it should read “Just Won The GOP New Hampshire Primary”
Second it could have been written months ago because the only thing on offer from the GOP as a “racist, sexist, demagogue” even if a couple of them aren’t as blatant about their racism and sexism as Trump, Cruz, Rubio.
True, that.
Also lots of women going to hell tonight. Lol. We are looking at potentially 20%+ with Clinton finishing below 40%.
The expansion plans for hell have just been ordered.
Meanwhile, lots of attention on the three page (single spaced) Clinton “how I will win” manifesto is being absorbed by the MSM. Notice the speed with which team Clinton has attempted to grab the spotlight from Sanders.
Not sure what’s up with reports of Clinton withdrawing staff from NV and downplaying her SC “firewall.” Possibly lowering expectations — and the better to trumpet herself as “the comeback kid” should she win.
Not hard to grab the media spotlight. They are in the bag for her anyway. That’s what makes it so hard to change. Not convincing the public. Left and Right, they are DEMANDING change (not necessarily the same kind). It is the corporate media that is the enemy, maybe more than the banks.
Trump says we have 40% unemployment, you would think something like that would have made the news
You would?
Why?
Have you gotten any real truth…unforced truth…from the Obama administration about surveillance? About the deal in Syria? About the Ukraine? About the extent and accuracy of drone strikes? The only “truths” that we have heard for 8+ years have been from people like Snowden and Assange.
Grow up.
AG
Snowden is a traitor and high employment like that would be felt far into the economy.
Grow up and maybe move into the real world for a while it’s not that bad.
This government is the traitor. Snowden was just telling the truth about it.
AG
maybe you should move into the woods somewhere and join a militia, you’d fit right in
Yeah, right. I’ll go there and start talking about how much I want a Sanders/Warren ticket and then await getting my ass kicked by a bunch of ex-marines.
Please. Wise up. The “patriots” are the ones who are trying to uncover the truth about this system as it now stands. It is run by and for the 1%, enforced by covert means of all kinds including the mass media, and it is truly vicious in its war against all who actively disagree with this state of affairs.
But you can relax. Apparently you have no problem with this system.
Congrats…
AG
Some of us don’t consider buying into propaganda or PR of, by, and for the elites a sign of maturity. It’s actually rather children as kids about the age of three on can be made to believe in almost anything.
You’re speaking like the dicks from a few decades ago that claimed Daniel Ellsberg was a traitor. iirc included in the list of dicks was the POTUS — or maybe he just ordered a break-in of Ellsberg’s psychiatrist office in an effort to label him crazy.
Molly Ball is scared of these young adults and their newfangled language which supports their fights for inclusion, fairness and equality. She comes off awfully foolish here, a child of Tom Wolfe in an era when Wolfe’s shtick has become as outdated as Soupy Sales.
Soupy Sales!!! Now there is a name I haven’t heard in forever!! I’m old enough to remember when he used to do the 10am to 3pm shift at WNBC radio. And who followed him at 3pm? Howard Stern!! God, I feel old!
And like she’s totally going to cancel the next thirty odd large dollar fundraisers that she has scheduled and toss out the e-Rolodex of her campaign contributors that she’s spent the past twenty-four years putting together.
This new version of Hillary should do wonders to increase her trustworthy rating up from 5%. Or maybe she cut it in half.
And there it is again. Another Hillary right on schedule. Fake anyone?
Karma Chameleon
The money secret to her that is.
Talk is cheap
I bet she ain’t a rushin’ out to hand back the wall street and corporate donations she is holding.
12. Emily Ratajkowski, the swimsuit model best known as the girl in the the “Blurred Lines” video, emceed the event and began with a fiery repudiation of Gloria Steinem, who had implied that young women only supported Sanders because they wanted to meet boys.
That’s classic. I wonder if Ratajkowski will do any more events for Sanders. It can only help him.
Linking appearance, social attitudes, and voting behavior and ignoring political philosophy and policy positions or using the superficial to marginalize those is the surest way to train people not to vote. The attempt is to say that their views don’t matter at all — to anyone. It is the same media failing from the 1950s and 1960s. It is just another form of making Maynard G. Krebs out of more serious social critics.
In fact, the kids are all right. Even the non-standard “alright” becomes a trope in this attack. Cutesy muck, slipping in the MoDo direction.
truly awful, they’re kids fer fsm’s sake. they’re motivated, energetic and want to build a future instead of tearing things down. the dem “establishment” is pitiful