Here’s how things look from inside the State Department:
“This is probably what it felt like to be a British foreign service officer after World War II, when you realize, no, the sun actually does set on your empire,” said the mid-level officer. “America is over. And being part of that, when it’s happening for no reason, is traumatic.”
Do you want another perspective?
“I used to love my job,” she said. “Now, it feels like coming to the hospital to take care of a terminally ill family member. You come in every day, you bring flowers, you brush their hair, paint their nails, even though you know there’s no point. But you do it out of love.”
Those quotes come from an excellent piece Julia Ioffe just had published at The Atlantic.
You can probably detect a wee bit of a morale problem developing in Foggy Bottom. Ioffe does a nice job of documenting the atrocities, and you’ve probably caught wind of some of the major issues, like the lack of any Deputy or Assistant Secretary of State. It appears that things are considerably worse than most people realize, however. The place is half-empty, people are coming in late and leaving early because they have no work to do. There’s no guidance on anything. They haven’t held a daily press briefing since the inauguration. The Secretary, Rex Tillerson, it isolated and tightly controlled.
The space on Mahogany Row, the line of wood-paneled offices including that of the secretary of state, is now a mysterious construction zone behind blue tarp…
…Tillerson’s chief of staff is not his own, but is, according to the Washington Post, a Trump transition alum named Margaret Peterlin. “Tillerson is surrounded by a bunch of rather mysterious Trumpistas,” said the senior State official who recently left. “How the hell is he supposed to do his job when even his right hand is not his own person?” One State Department employee told me that Peterlin has instructed staff that all communications with Tillerson have to go through her, and even scolded someone for answering a question Tillerson asked directly, in a meeting.
This all calls to my mind what Hunter S. Thompson said in the fall of 1972 when he realized that George McGovern wasn’t just going to lose to Nixon, but be utterly destroyed by him:
“America… just a nation of two hundred million used car salesmen with all the money we need to buy guns and no qualms about killing anybody else in the world who tries to make us uncomfortable.”
Set against that somewhat unfair characterization of our great nation has always been another impulse. The State Department, at its best, is where our better angels reside. It’s where people not only believe in human rights and diplomacy and leading by a positive example, but where idealistic and morally principled people work long hours every day in the furtherance of those goals.
And if those people are interpreting current events as America being over, that really means that our better angels are being destroyed. If going to work at the State Department feels like painting the toe nails on your terminally ill mother, who am I to argue?
These people want to fight for an America that is more virtuous, and the simple fact that they do this work makes our country more virtuous. Now they say their work is a pointless act of love for an incurably ill nation.
What answer do we have for that?
Well, these State diplomats are certainly not alone. What do we imagine is the state of “morale” at EPA? Or Education? Or Interior? Or Fish and Wildlife? Or NASA? Or Labor? Or NLRB? etc. etc. ad infinitum.
At least State diplomats can come in late and leave work early in Prague, Paris, Rome, and a hundred other wonderful locales. Things could be worse. And if they quit, there are about 4000 applicants for each of their positions—inexperienced, overconfident and callow, but that’s the mantra of TrumpAmerica!
Anyway, this is the morale that Team Conservative and its imbecile voters WANT in the employees of the non-“defense” agencies of the federal government. The notion that these departments and agencies are illegitimate is a “conservative” article of faith. So Repubs love reading articles like this—another sign of that Der Trumper is “shakin’ it up!!” He’s “stirrin’ the shit!” Waaahoooo!
Apre Trump les deluge?
Think if I scrubbed my internet history I could get an ambassadorship? I’m not white but maybe. If that state is going down gotta protect myself.
Think if I scrubbed my internet history I could get an ambassadorship?
You’re not a big donor to Trump, so no.
When Trump signed the intial EO halting admission of refugees and prioritizing Christians, I commented on social media that we were watching the end of America’s run as a world leader. That there are some things you just can’t take back.
This post and the linked piece by Julia Ioffe make me feel that even more. Things like this aren’t fixable no matter how many resources might be poured in later. This damage is permanent.
While I have certainly had my own criticisms of the American empire, I have never thought that a full scale deconstruction was the right answer.
This does not make us, or anyone else, safer.
I’m sure we can agree that an America in any way virtuous is like a square circle.
Since when, Booman?
Since John Foster Dulles? Whose brother actually set up the CIA system that now essentially rules the whole goddamned country?
Dean Rusk?
Henry Kissinger!!!!!!!????????
Al “I am in control” Haig?
Frank “Enron” Wisner? the son of the CISA guy who established Operation Mockingbird as the essential media control mechanism that persists to this day?
Condoleeza Rice? The Secretary of the Exxon State?
Hillary “The Deplorables!!!” Clinton?
John “Don’t tase me, ‘bro!!!” Kerry?
Please!!!
You know better…
AG
P.S. And don’t tell me about all of the good-hearted, selfless State Dept. workers. I’ve been to the visiting artist receptions in Egypt, in Venezuela, in South Africa and Columbia, among other places not so…bullet-prone…in western Europe. I can smell spooks and undercover military security a mile away. Probably about 1/4 to 1/3 of them are CIA cover stories, and the rest are scared shitless of doing anything to mess with their pensions.
Give me a break!!!
You left out a few other winners.
“We think it [half a million deaths] was worth it” Albright.
“there can be no doubt that Saddam Hussein has biological weapons and the capability to rapidly produce more, many more.” Powell.
Too many villains…
AG
Uh, no, in the Latin it’s “tu quoque”. You mispronounced it.
So the mostly Jewish family of which I am a member would like to remind everyone of the longstanding anti- semiticism that has characterized much of State Department history.
I do think Booman is trying to suggest the foreign service – as opposed to the political appointees – which is very smart and dedicated – plays a vital function.
I think he has a point.
There are other examples of State losing influence to the White House – not that surprising.
But it isn’t a good thing.
Half my salary is now paid by the State Dept through the Office of Foreign Disaster Assistance. That’s one agency I suspect Trump would consider worthless.
Yeah, I feel pretty confident that Booman was writing about State Dept career professionals. That seemed glaringly obvious. Nonetheless some commenters.chose to ignore this and go on the attack.
OFDA is actually part of USAID, which gets a direct appropriation from Congress.
I have no idea what the Tillerson-Trump revamped State Dept will look like — and expect that it will be no damn good — but not going to shed tears for the Dulles State Dept.
Sorry — I shouldn’t have lumped Cyrus Vance in with the other sorry-asses from Dulles forward. Of course Carter informally shit-canned Vance in favor of Z-Big, making it easy to forget that Vance was ever there.
No kidding. Not shedding any crocodile tears for all the NeoCons who’ve been running the State Dept. for decades.
Can’t imagine that Tillerson’s State Dept will be any better, and possibly could get worse. But nope, not sad at all. Let them eat cake.
Pffft. That Thompson quote has never been more appropriate.
Unfortunately…at least within living memory it has also never been much less appropriate.
Sigh…
AG
Now I had to go back and read the quote again, this time without the ellipses. HST; “This may be the year when we finally come face to face with ourselves; finally just lay back and say it-that we are really just a nation of 220 million used car salesmen with all the money we need to by guns, and no qualms at all about killing anybody else in the world who tries to make us uncomfortable.”
Personally, I like this quote better. HST: “McGovern made some stupid mistakes, but in context they seem almost frivolous compared to the things Richard Nixon does every day of his life, on purpose…”
I still think both are appropriate. Not sure I understand why it would be less appropriate, but you jazz men operate on a whole other level.
In the face of Bush and now Trump I just don’t… Nixon seemed like so much more of a mixed bag. But then I was over a decade away from being born in the era of Nixon.
The GOP was somewhat of a mixed bag then. Nixon not so much. But the GOP had yet to discover the fundies; so, Nixon and his cronies retrospectively appear to have been more moderate than they were. With the racists and fundies fully on board, defections were few and much fewer than their acquisitions.
Can’t tip for the usual reason.
But you’re correct on this. Thompson wasn’t covering a presidential campaign similar to Clinton vs. Trump. It was more like Cruz vs. a young Sanders.
No. The amount of criminal shit Nixon had pulled prior to the 72 election far exceeds anything Cruz has done. Sure, both are/were sleazy dickheads, but Cruz hasn’t done anything remotely approaching Nixon’s chicanery. Dolt45 on the other hand…
You need to work harder at putting all the pieces in the same historical time-frame. Nixon’s level of criminality wasn’t known by election day 1972. Even those who readily perceived Nixon’s hand in the Watergate break-in, knew little or nothing beyond that.
Analogies are rarely perfect — and a younger Sanders would never have been running against a sitting President Cruz. However, as characters in their own time, Cruz does resemble Nixon.
You wrote:
“That Thompson quote has never been more appropriate.”
My comment (“Unfortunately…at least within living memory it has also never been much less appropriate.”) was meant to say…in fact, does say…that said particular Thompson quote has been “appropriate” for most of the Secretaries of State within living memory.
AG
Damn. Thanks. Language. How does it work? (referring to myself here if that isn’t clear).
My syntax is admittedly somewhat too dense sometimes.
Sorry.
I do keep trying…
I understand it, and it is usually right on point once you figure it out.
That doesn’t mean it’s necessarlily “good,” at least in terms of other people understanding it.
That’s the story of my life, both as a musician and as a writer.
Like I said…I do keep trying.
Sigh…
AG
All empires end someday.
Please don’t troll rate anyone when they comment on a post of mine. If they are talking to me, I want to have the conversation.
FWIW: I don’t believe ASG to be a troll, just a cranky NYer whom I seldom agree with.
Having served in the Department for many years, i am appalled at the viciousness about it displayed by some of the commenters. You expose your ignorance and small-mindedness with every word. Learn something about those who dedicate their lives to maintaining our position in the world before you dare to talk about them.
Part of that learning process might include visiting the main lobby at the Department, which is described in Julia Ioffe’s piece. On both sides of that lobby are huge plaques bearing the names of hundreds of diplomatic staff who have given their lives for our country. These plaques are the counterparts of the CIA’s famous “wall of stars.” Every one of those people was a better human being, and contributed more to the United States, than some of the commenters on this article.
And by the way, most State Department staff don’t work in elegant locations with a great nightlife. In my time with the Department, I was assigned to only one post where it was possible safely to drink the local water. And over 1,000 Department positions overseas are so dangerous family members are precluded from joining those assigned there.
As Confucius reportedly put it, “If what one has to say is not better than silence, then one should keep silence.”
You have to consider that a majority, or at least a strong plurality, of commenters here consider the American state to be an evil per se.
Sometimes this is because it is a nation-state, and that’s the problem — the world would be better off should there be no nation-states.
Sometimes it is because it’s the American state, which functions as the primary source of evil in the world in this, the early 21st. century.
Based on those priors, people who work for State in particular, or the federal government in general, are ipso facto complicit in something terrible.
Actually, it’s mainly because they are republicans. And the main goal of republicans is to disseminate and propagate hate.
Myopic and simple minded.
.
By putting it into words you’ve already given it more thought than any of that crew ever have.
Some people only have one idea in their head, and everything has to conform to that one idea.
.
Vicious, yes, and despicable, to celebrate the trashing and demoralizing of people who serve this country — in other words par for the course for a certain subset around here.
And exactly what I was expecting when I read Booman’s piece.
I know half a dozen career professionals, ie. Foreign Service Officers, at State. Five of them voted for Trump, one for Clinton. The Foreign Service exam does screen for a certain type of person, hence why most people I know now are Repubs and most 20+ years ago when I would interact with them overseas in my previous life.
None of them are dumb people. They knew better than your average ‘Murka FUCK YEAH! voter about what they were voting in and yet…
I won’t deny that they work in crappy places and as a rule are a committed group of professionals but it reminds me of the What’s The Matter With Kansas effect.
My observations are purely anecdotal. I know one of these Trump voting FS officers who was home over the holidays and obviously before Twitler took over. She made it clear that everyone around her in DC was stunned and scared to death. Why she wasn’t, well, I assume the cognitive dissonance that’s part and parcel of most Republican voters, no matter how smart and educated they might be, is strong in her.
As for The Usual Suspects here who castigate everything done by Dems and the feds as you allude to, again, as has been said here before, when you have an axe than needs sharpening, everything looks like a grindstone. The Our Progressive Betters clique here won’t let anything get in the way of getting to that grindstone.
I have to question just how much less-bad would the state department be with Elliot Abrams back in power again?