Vladimir Putin would obviously like to know who the sources are who talked to Christopher Steele. For example, the first thing we see in the Steele Dossier is an account of comments Source A (“a senior Russian foreign ministry officer”) made in confidence to Source B (“a former top level Russian intelligence officer still active inside the Kremlin”). It was Source B who supplied Steele with the information that the Russians had been cultivating Trump for five years and it was source A that said Putin had personally approved a plan to supply Trump with information on his opponents, including Hillary Clinton.
Now, some people already know the identity of these sources. The first thing the FBI wanted to know from Steele after they saw his earliest memos was how reliable his information was, and Steele supplied his sources to them in an effort the get them to take his intelligence seriously. There’s someone else who claims to know the sources, and that’s a man named David Kramer who works as a senior fellow at the McCain Institute for International Leadership at Arizona State University.
Kramer traveled to London in late-Novemeber 2016 to meet with Steele in person. He took a copy of the dossier back to the United States where he handed it off to Sen. John McCain. McCain, in turn, gave the dossier directly to FBI Director James Comey. But, of course, the FBI had been receiving Steele’s dispatches since July so they didn’t need McCain’s package.
Kramer testified on December 19th before the House Intelligence Committee. He asserted that he knew Steele’s sources, but he refused to provide their identities. As a result, House Intelligence chairman Devin Nunes has slapped a subpoena on Prof. Kramer in the hope that he will spill what he knows.
Chairman Nunes supposedly recused himself from the Russia investigation but he’s still issuing subpoenas. That’s a concern, but it’s more troubling that he’s asking for information that would help Putin liquidate the people who talked to Steele.
This is lost on Byron York who is much more concerned with running interference for the president and his congressional enablers than he is in getting to the truth:
Knowing Steele’s sources is a critical part of the congressional dossier investigation, for both sides. If one argues the document is unverified and never will be, it is critical to learn the identity of the sources to support that conclusion. If one argues the document is the whole truth, or largely true, knowing sources is equally critical.
That argument is 151 proof bullshit. Devin Nunes cannot estimate the quality of intelligence provided by Source A or Source B by knowing their identities. He can perhaps prove or disprove some of what they alleged, but that wouldn’t involve knowing their names. What Devin Nunes can do is leak their names and get them killed.
The Kremlin seems to think that FSB Officer Major Gen. Dmitry Dokuchayev was a source to the Americans, and they’ve arrested him for treason. There’s a Russian hacker in prison over there who says he worked for Dokuchayev and that together they’re responsible for the hacking of the Democratic National Committee’s servers. The Americans want Dokuchayev, too. Along with folks like fellow FSB officer Igor Sushchin and Alexsey Belan, he’s been indicted for hacking into Yahoo’s servers and stealing passwords and committing other identity thefts.
Here’s a fun fact. Igor Sushchin worked undercover for the FSB as the security director for Mikhail Prokhorov’s Renaissance Capital. He was fired the day after he was indicted. Mr. Prokhorov owns the Brooklyn Nets and the Barclay Center they call home. He also owns an island in the Seychelles which served as a convenient place for former Blackwater CEO Erik Prince to meet an emissary from Vladimir Putin named Kirill Dmitriev.
In any case, it’s interesting that there’s a hacker in Russian custody who is saying that he was ordered to break into the DNC headquarters by Dmitry Dokuchayev. Mr. Dokuchayev served under Sergei Mikhailov, who was the deputy chief of the FSB security agency’s Centre for Information Security. Mr. Mikhailov has been arrested for treason, too.
Two of Moscow’s top cybersecurity officials are facing treason charges for cooperating with the CIA, according to a Russian news report.
The accusations add further intrigue to a mysterious scandal that has had the Moscow rumour mill working in overdrive for the past week, and come not long after US intelligence accused Russia of interfering in the US election and hacking the Democratic party’s servers.
Sergei Mikhailov was deputy head of the FSB security agency’s Centre for Information Security. His arrest was reported in a series of leaks over the past week, along with that of his deputy and several civilians, but Tuesday’s news went much further.
“Sergei Mikhailov and his deputy, Dmitry Dokuchayev, are accused of betraying their oath and working with the CIA,” Interfax said, quoting a source familiar with the investigation.
If this all seems like a hopeless web of criminality and espionage, perhaps there is still hope for getting to the bottom of it.
In written answers from jail made public Wednesday by RAIN TV, a Moscow-based independent TV station that has repeatedly run afoul of the Kremlin, [Konstantin] Kozlovsky said he feared his minders might turn on him and planted a “poison pill” during the DNC hack. He placed a string of numbers that are his Russian passport number and the number of his visa to visit the Caribbean island of St. Martin in a hidden .dat file, which is a generic data file.
That allegation is difficult to prove, partly because of the limited universe of people who have seen the details of the hack. The DNC initially did not share information with the FBI, instead hiring a tech firm called CrowdStrike, run by a former FBI cyber leader. That company has said it discovered the Russian hand in the hacking, but had no immediate comment on the claim by Kozlovsky that he planted an identifier.
Maybe Devin Nunes could run down that lead. It’s a better use of his time than trying to out Steele’s sources and it won’t obviously get anyone killed or help Putin and Trump cover their tracks.
Conservative Republican Teabaggers have put party before country and money above all for many decades.
It’s in the DNA for the cult members now.
Devin Antonovich is starting to smell bad even on the internet.
In a functioning government, Nunes would not even be a legislator now, let alone chairman of the House Select Intelligence Committee.
Emphatically agreed.
It’s part of the whole Republican “philosophy” of being so viscerally opposed to government on even the most abstract, conceptual levels, that they believe the best thing to do is to put people in each position who are not just unqualified but are ideologically opposed to even the concept of the department they’re heading and are personally engaged in a lifelong struggle against it. This is how we get John Bolton, a U. N. Ambassador who’s publicly opposed to the entire existence of the U. N., or a series of EPA chiefs who come from the oil industry. It’s disgusting and stupid.
It also appears that conservative ideology is more of an excuse than a reason for their opposition to government. Government and governing stands in the way of their real agenda, which is in service to wealth and oligarchy.
Put a climate change denier in charge of the EPA, because the EPA’s mission of doing something about climate change costs their benefactors money.
Install a bankster/mortgage cheat as head of Treasury, because he has direct knowledge of what tax rules and regulations need to be ignored or voided to give them unfettered access to the public wealth.
Replace the nuclear physicist heading the Dept of Energy with a know-nothing moron, thus guaranteeing safety regulations won’t get in the way of the nuclear, oil and coal barons drive to to extract natural resources and gain even more profits since he knows absolutely nothing.
If anyone still believes this is a worst case of cynicism, they all but said it themselves:
“In a candid moment last week, Rep. Chris Collins conveyed out loud what many members have been thinking for months. ‘My donors are basically saying, Get it done or don’t ever call me again,’ the New York Republican told The Hill.”
“Sen. Lindsey Graham, a Republican from South Carolina, also warned that the ‘financial contributions will stop’ if the GOP failed on tax reform.”
Passing unpopular bills, protecting malfeasance of a republican president, and working as a party to obstruct an investigation into one of their own, it would not be uncalled for to describe the GOP as less a political party as it is really a criminal racketeering organizations, openly existing on bribes and lawlessness. Harsh, but not unfair.
Booman writes:
Or…If this all seems like a hopeless web of criminality and espionage, perhaps it is. I believe none of it, myself. It is the product of several groups of professional liars. Nothing more and nothing less. They are good at what they do. That’s why they have climbed to the heights of service in their various imperial governments. The only thing that is absolutely certain is that something has happened, and said “something” is that…sigh…several groups of professional liars have sufficiently muddied the info waters that they are now able to absolutely ensure that no one privy to truly top secret information really has a clue to what is going on. Other than, of course….that several groups of professional liars have sufficiently muddied the waters that they are now able to absolutely ensure that no one privy to truly top secret information really has a clue to what is going on.
It is an almost infinite loop, Booman.
Meanwhile, back at the ranch…
Clickbait suppositions are being flailed about by the very media (at huge profit…we can be sure of that, at least) which are being used to…sigh twice…sufficiently muddy the waters to be able to ensure that no one privy to truly top secret information really has a clue to what is going on.
Do you really believe that we have the final truth about…oh, say (just for starters):
The Assassination years?
Watergate?
The intelligence career and connections of George Bush I?
9/11?
Trump’s finances and his real financial backers?
The Clintons’ rise to power and their own financial backers and maneuverings?
Really?
If you do, I’ll be driving over the Brooklyn Bridge New Year’s Day to play a gig. I’ll stop off and ask if it’s still for sale.
C’mon, Booman. You know that I know better than to believe that you totally believe this whole pile of intelligence-promulgated horseshit. I’ve been here too long…I remember your long-ago takes on the previous intel loads of horseshit.
‘Fess up.
Thank you and…Happy New Year.
AG
P.S. I personally will be walking into the number one terrorist target of the real world…Times Square, New Year’s Eve…(unencumbered by any kind of protection other than my own Guardian Angel)…with my heart in my throat and my instrument on my back. To do what? To earn maybe a week’s pay playing superannuated jazz styles…my own musical roots, so to speak, and proud to say it… for a bunch of upper middle class twits.
Courage, brother.
It’s gonna get worse before it gets better.
Bet on it.
Hug your loved ones; say a prayer and then hunker down.
Shit’s gonna hit the fan eventually, and it won’t just be intel horseshit.
Bet on that as well.
It’s gone too far, and now it’s too far gone. Gonna have some kind of real, constitutional crisis before this lovely 2018 year is up. Even a “nearly infinite loop” has to have an ending. The “nearly” word is the kicker.
Watch.
Later…
AG
Arthur shows such special courage by going to Times Square on New Years’ Eve. Only a couple of million people manage to display such bravery each year.
Asking people he views with contempt to enjoy his music and supplement his income really marks Arthur as an admirable and interesting person.
. . . “I’ve been summoned.”
I play plenty of gigs for people who I do not view with contempt. They don’t pay enough to live. So it goes.
This holiday season alone I will have played five. Average pay? Oh…I guess maybe $20 per gig. Enough to maybe cover travel. I consider it pro bono work. The others? Like a good lawyer…I do my job. That approach has allowed me to continue to grow as a musician…a craftsman and artist…in this wonderful NYC jazz and latin scene for almost 50 years.
Take it or leave it: I’m gonna do it anyway, and do it as well as if I was playing for group of real aficionados.
In a sense, my position in gigs like that is the same as my position on this blog. I continue to “play” as well and as truthfully as I can, no matter what the percentage of blockheads in the audience. This band on New Year’s Eve? It is really good, playing the mainstream music of the late swing era…say the late ’40s through the early ’60s in NYC…with real commitment and passion. It is full of the same kinds of players as am I…dedicated American-style musicians who have spent their entire lives mastering the many disparate American jazz idioms.
The only difference between this blog and those gigs?
Really?
The ones who do not like this music and this commitment don’t pay to come in, thus there aren’t that many complaints. They don’t really understand the music…except for a few really good dancers who truly understand it on a physical and emotional level…but it brings them back to when they were young and impressionable. And…it pays the bills.
We get the occasional sour old grouch, of course. I remember one nasty-sounding older lady who sashayed up the band one night and shouted in a perfect Wicked Witch of the West voice “Can’t you stop swinging???!!!” Come to think of it, she reminds me a great deal of you and your little downrater compadres.
We paid her no mind.
As do I with you.
Happy New Year, square. I’m gonna keep swinging no matter how much it bothers you.
Deal wid it.
AG
Tell us more.
This is solid work, Martin. Investigative journalism and the analysis thereof is what will save the Republic when it is saved. The truth will out.
“Maybe Devin Nunes could run down that lead”
I find it very difficult to conceive of any constructive role for Mr. Nunes in this matter.