I’ve heard the jokes, you’ve heard the jokes: is it too late to let the red states secede? (Or as Janeane Garofalo refers to ’em: “the cracker belt.”)
But link to the below maps to see the chilling correlation between the slave vs. free states of the Civil War and the red state/blue state breakdown of 2004.
(Thanks to ourword.org, a great feminist blog: http://ourword.org/node?from=10&PHPSESSID=a1ea9ac9f0cac3ce01d6c65cce906564 and then scroll down half a page.)
Matsu of Media Girl provides a telling analysis of how the former slave states have knuckle-dragged and resisted moral and civil rights fights for over 150 years: including being the bastions of Jim Crowe laws and voting against the ERA.
And what is needed now to turn the red states blue, based on a history lesson or two:
“As long as the Republicans have deadlock on the South, they need to pick up a few swing states and the Neo-Confederacy – the successors of the Kansas-Nebraska Act – to hold the White House and with sparsely populated states having two senators a piece even the senate itself was not out of reach.
They key thing is the message.
So back to 1964 and what caused me to leave the Republicans, and so this is a sort of oral history at this point.
As I said, in 1964 the conservative wing of the Republican party was largely discredited and were called “extremists.” Many were “closet” John Birch Society members and if not out-and-out Birchers, as they were called, they at least felt kinship. The Birchers saw Communist infiltration and agitation everywhere. The Democrats were seen as “soft” on Communism – and that included John F. Kennedy – and many Birchers went so far as to suggest President Eisenhower was a Communist.
Well, needless to say, this was too much for most people to swallow.”
A fascinating piece, read more at: http://mediagirl.org/2004/12/irrepressible-conflict
I’ll come from the other side and tell you how not to turn them blue:
I’m not attacking you personally, you’re diary just fell at the end of a few weeks of this kind of thing (not here at Booman but elsewhere). And I’m really wondering why I bother.
I HEAR you!! As a Texas resident, this is one of the things that I battle almost daily, well, until I stopped.
Amid all of the stereotypes and “root of all evil is Texas” BS that float about, the fact remains that this state is the size of a European country, has 32 electoral votes and as diverse a population as you will ever find, and I say that from my experience travesing the state for business and pleasure, not form a little blue bubble in Austin.
Where are you LP? You have a non-deaf ear here!
I hate when I write something and don’t check before hitting post!!
that would be “traversing” and FROM a little blue bubble…
I’m in Orlando, Florida. All the places I’ve lived since I was born:
Guantanamo Bay, Cuba (born there)
Arlington, VA
Charleston, SC
Norfolk, VA
Millington, TN
Orlando, FL
I spent part of my last vacation visiting a friend in Alabama last year. Kept joking with her about how insane it was for someone to go to Alabama from Orlando for vacation.
And did you see the errors in my first post. Shameful.
Wow. Born in Guantanamo, eh? That’s the title of a besselling novel/book if I ever saw one!!
Mine are:
Born: Ithica, New York
Hartford, Connecticut (until 4)
Germany, three places (until 9)
Columbia, MD (6 months)
Sierra Vista, AZ (10 and 11)
Tuscon, AZ (11, 12 and 13)
Fairfax, VA (13 – 17)
Blacksburg, VA (17-25)
Koriyama, Japan (6 months)
Toyama, Japan (25-26)
Seoul, Korea (8 months)
Caldwell, TX (4 months)
Roanoke, VA (8 months)
Kingsville, TX (3 years)
Austin, TX (since 1997)
That sort of felt good…sorry if it was waaay OT!
No, I didn’t notice ANY of your typos or spelling errors… I only do that to myself! 😉
As we continue our descent into OT-land, that is a pretty impressive list you have.
As for Gitmo, we left when I was an infant so I have no memories of it (all my mom remembers is a hurricane and scorpions in the closet). It had until recently been a place hardly anyone knew about. So much so that when registering for school they would ask my mom for my citizenship papers. Recently it led to confusion at the Driver License office as they didn’t know what state to list me under.
Thanks, it’s taught me a lot — guess I shouldn’t further hijack the thread, eh?
Let’s talk more about this elsewhere…not tonight tho, gotta sleep!
Yeesh….
I noted this in “the other place” but just saw this diary here.
The original author appears to have forgotten a few states in her “slave states=red states” analysis: those north of the Mason-Dixon line:
Northern Slavery
That’s the trouble with attempts to make historical claims without actually knowing the history you’re trying to use in your analogy. The only meaningful distinction that can be made, accurately at least, is the distinction between those states who gave up slavery through economic payoff and attrition relating to the War of Independence and those who gave it up involuntarily because of the Civil War. That’s pretty much it.