This diary was just posted at TPM Cafe
Josh Marshall intros it and links to it at his primary web site, Talking Point Memo
“LARRY JOHNSON IS a retired CIA officer who was a classmate of Valerie Plame’s when both entered the CIA in the mid-1980s. Johnson just did a guest post over at TPMCafe in which he explains the damage that was done when administration officials revealed Plame’s identity, who’s lying and who’s not.”
THE BIG LIE ABOUT VALERIE PLAME
By Larry Johnson Jul 13, 2005 — 12:47:20 AM EST
From: TPMCafe Special Guests
EXCERPTS (REVISED)
The misinformation being spread in the media about the Plame affair is alarming and damaging to the longterm security interests of the United States. Republicans’ talking points are trying to savage Joe Wilson and, by implication, his wife, Valerie Plame as liars. That is the truly big lie.
For starters, Valerie Plame was an undercover operations officer until outed in the press by Robert Novak…
Valerie Plame was a classmate of mine from the day she started with the CIA…in September 1985. All of my classmates were undercoverwas a get out of jail free card.
A few of my classmates, and Valerie was one of these, became a non-official cover officer. That meant she agreed to operate overseas without the protection of a diplomatic passport. If caught in that status she would have been executed.
The lies by people like Victoria Toensing, Representative Peter King, and P. J. O’Rourke insist that Valerie was nothing, just a desk jockey. Yet, until Robert Novak betrayed her she was still undercover and the company that was her front was still a secret to the world. When Novak outed Valerie he also compromised her company and every individual overseas who had been in contact with that company and with her.
…”I don’t know if a man made law was broken but an ethical and moral code was breached. For the first time a group of partisan political operatives publically identified a CIA NOC…
They try to hide behind the specious claim that Joe Wilson “lied”. Although Joe did not lie…Joe Wilson…tried to prevent the needless death of Americans and the loss of American prestige in the world.
But don’t take my word for it, read the biased Senate intelligence committee report. Even though it was slanted to try to portray Joe in the worst possible light this fact emerges on page 52 of the report: According to the US Ambassador to Niger (who was commenting on Joe’s visit in February 2002), “Ambassador Wilson reached the same conclusion that the Embassy has reached that it was highly unlikely that anything between Iraq and Niger was going on.” Joe’s findings were consistent with those of the Deputy Commander of the European Command, Major General Fulford.
The Republicans insist on the lie that Val got her husband the job. She did not…the decision to send Joe Wilson on this mission was made by her bosses.
…Shame on those who continue to slander Joe Wilson while giving Bush and his pack of liars a pass. That’s the true outrage.
Newsday Provided strong support for the above post on July 22, 2003, a mere eight days after Robert Novak exposed Valerie Plame’s identity:
…Intelligence officials confirmed to Newsday yesterday that Valerie Plame, wife of retired Ambassador Joseph Wilson, works at the agency on weapons of mass destruction issues in an undercover capacity – at least she was undercover until last week when she was named by columnist Robert Novak.
…A current intelligence official said that blowing the cover of an undercover officer could affect the officer’s future assignments and put them and everyone they dealt with overseas in the past at risk.
…Novak, in an interview, said his sources had come to him with the information. “I didn’t dig it out, it was given to me,” he said. “They thought it was significant, they gave me the name and I used it.”
Novak reported that his “two senior administration officials” told him that it was Plame who suggested sending her husband, Wilson, to Niger.
A senior intelligence official confirmed that Plame was a Directorate of Operations undercover officer who worked “alongside” the operations officers who asked her husband to travel to Niger.
But he said she did not recommend her husband to undertake the Niger assignment. “They [the officers who did ask Wilson to check the uranium story] were aware of who she was married to, which is not surprising,” he said. “There are people elsewhere in government who are trying to make her look like she was the one who was cooking this up, for some reason,” he said. “I can’t figure out what it could be.”
“We paid his [Wilson’s] air fare. But to go to Niger is not exactly a benefit. Most people you’d have to pay big bucks to go there,” the senior intelligence official said. Wilson said he was reimbursed only for expenses.
Yes
They will continue to use the big Lie texhnique until our Media wakes up and starts calling them on it.
Sadly, I don’t see that happeniung anytine soon, because they like the copntroversy of he said she said too much.
This was written before my first coffe of the day …
Obviously.
God.
COFFEE!!!!!!
Too bad the FBC has not opened yet..
I’ve had it up to hear with the lying liars and the lies they tell. They’re out in force, working double time to smear Wilson to save Rove, Cheney and Bush. The “Rove was just trying to get the story right” makes me puke, especially with what we now know from the DSM.
It’s time for push back because this smear campaign seeks to not only discredit Plame and Wilson, but to re-write the history on fixed intel. Please join me in my letter writing campaign to every media outlet that lets this turd float. Media Matters is following the coverage and has press contact details.
The main thrust of my letter writing has been to say that the media has been AWOL on matters of national security and the war in Iraq. Thousands have died while they’ve ignored their responsibility to the public that comes with their first amendment rights. They owe it to their profession, to the public and to their country to report the facts, and not allow the media to be used for propaganda, distortion and manipulation.
No “guest” should be allowed to tic through their talking points unchallenged. There is a public record to fact check and the public deserves the basic standards of journalism. Here’s what the much touted Senate Intelligence Committee actually says:
Some CPD [CIA’s Directorate of Operations, Counterproliferation Division] officials could not recall how the office decided to contact the former ambassador, however, interviews and documents provided to the committee indicate that his wife, a former CPD employee, suggested his name for the trip. The CPD reports officer told Committee staff that the former ambassador’s wife “offered up his name” and a memorandum to the Deputy Chief of CPD on February 12, 2002, from the former ambassador’s wife says, “my husband has good relations with both the PM [prime minister] and the former Minister of Mines (not to mention lots of French contacts), both of whom could possibly shed light on this sort of activity.” This was just one day before CPD sent a cable [blacked out] requesting concurrence with CPD’s idea to send the former ambassador to Niger and requesting any additional information from the foreign government service on their uranium reports. [p. 39; PDF p. 49]
No where in the Senate Intelligence Committee report (which has refused to tackle the larger and looming question on how the “facts and intelligence were fixed around the policy”) does it state that Valerie Plame arranged or approved her husband’s trip. To take the issue further, three Republicans — Roberts and Sens. Orrin Hatch of Utah and Kit Bond of Missouri — wrote additional views appended to the report, concluding that “the plan to send the former ambassador to Niger was suggested” by Plame. Three members of the same Senate Intelligence Committee that refused to endorse the conclusion that Plame even suggested Wilson’s trip to Niger.
Joe Wilson was right. The 16 words WERE BULLSHIT as even the Administration was forced to admit. Don’t let a whole new record of lies re-write history.
doesn’t this just make one sick? I am so sick of this administration and its operatives everywhere including congress. I really wished that this investigation was over and done with so we could all see the liars for what they really are.
I love your posts. You always get to the heart of the matter.
I strongly feel betrayed by this administration and the lengths they will go to to discredit anyone that disagrees with them or points out the lies. The media is complicit in this. Once again I will say the meme should be about connecting the dots. The DSMs, Bolton records being with held, Plame investigation are all connected. They are trying to coverup the biggest lie of all. Why we went to Iraq. I believe(cannot prove but someone can)that those records that the senate have not been able to get their hands on will prove that Bolton is the one that was looking for Plame’s identity to start this leak and smear campaign. The “Rove was only trying to make sure the story was right” talking point is coming out of every conservative pundit and mouthpiece we hear. We must not stop in our pursuit of truth and justice. These people are not only criminals they are criminally insane and dangerous. Look at the numbers of dead not just in Iraq but elsewhere that they are responsible for.
Great post, great points. These stories are connected – not sure we’ll ever prove the Bolton angle but does give pause.
Can’t let them get away with lies this big. We need to reintroduce the DSMs into the media discussion…we need to push this hard.
Heard this on NPR today – Daniel Schorr does some dot connecting…not perfect but a good start. This is a little over 4 minutes.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4752466
The dirty bastards who are pumping this lie into the airwaves should all be tried for treason. Why are so many conservatives sociopathic liars? They don’t REALLY give a rat’s ass about WMD, the war on terror or the security of our country. They care about power and money and their own asses. The American people aren’t even on the list. It reminds me of some lyrics by Frank Zappa singing about American politics:
“They’re looking out for number one…
and Number One just ain’t you…
you ain’t even number two”
You could post this diary every day for a month and it wouldn’t be too many reminders, imo. It’s sickening how they dare to call themselves “patriots.”
And Juan Cole wrote yesterday:
“When Rove blew her cover to the US press, everyone who had ever been seen with her in Africa or Asia was put in extreme danger. It is said that some of her contacts may have been killed. Imagine the setback to the US struggle against weapons of mass destruction proliferation that this represents.”
Who’s the terrorist here?
Isn’t that horrible? And it’s even creepier in that we can’t KNOW.
I wonder if Valerie Plame knows about some of her former connections, and what might have happened to them.
Can you imagine how she’s haunted by that?
I can see why Joe Wilson has gotten tears in his eyes when he’s talked about the betrayal of his wife.
I agree it is time to push back and the best way to do this is to stay on message. The message is: Karl Rove outed a covert CIA agent, thereby commiting treason according to the law. His current claim — that he was just “correcting” a story — is no excuse for what he did. There is no excuse for what he did.
I don’t think the left should get too bogged down in trying to argue about Wilson being right, or refuting point by point the GOP talking points. Anytime somone brings up Wilson, we should just say, this is not about Wilsons behavior, it is about Rove’s behavior and move on to talking about Rove.
I was watching Scarborough Country last night and it was just appaling. They spent the whole time talking about how Wilson was a “liar,” and Rove’s misdeeds were completely glossed over. Unfortunately there was no Democrat on the show to even counter the Republican representatives bullshit — I think it was Pete King of NY. But in any situation where Dems have a chance to be on one of these discussions, they must stay on message. Rove commited treason, plain and simple.
The spin machine is going full force, and every one is working off of Mehlman’s Talking points. Those Talking Points are nothing but a pack of lies. I am working on a point-by-point factual rebuttal. I also have an interesting theory about who outed Rove. More on that later.
According to Ed Schultz on AA a little bit ago…Joe Wilson to be on The Today Show tomorrow morning.Set your alarm clocks new York. This is one we don’t want to miss.
I really really hope that against all odds the media is finally gonna call these lying traitors on their blatently disrespectful aversion to the plain truth.
A good lie could pass for truth. They don’t even bother anymore — there’s no need. Might as well have Cheney running around saying “Go fuck yourselves”. Even that’d be a step more honest than a Scott McClellan lie-and-deny fest.
But, if the pattern holds and they get away with all of these lies too, never fear.
We’ll see how to counteract them…
…as soon as somone on our side tries to get away with this crud, and gets publicly crushed by the Republican Machine.
… controlling the media: priceless