“You’ll feel better…” My friend Other Lisa wrote that above her e-mail with Digby’s, “It Is The Only Way We Can Live” post below.
I’m less pissy about the cloture vote yesterday. I turned off the computer early last night, and watched Amy Goodman’s marvelous interview of the lifelong fighter, Harry Belafonte, who’s never given up. Never given up. And he won’t give up. That means something. Especially to us today. He’s personally felt what we fear today: His conversations with Martin Luther King were wiretapped by the FBI in the 1960s. His closing words for Amy, and us, yesterday:
I cannot believe that that which we have achieved in this country, nothing could have been darker than the time of slavery. We extricated ourselves from that. Nothing could be darker than a century of apartheid and oppression. We extricated ourselves from that. The Second World War was not winnable by the onslaught of the German forces. We won that. I think in the final analysis, the people are the true frontier, and I think people will save this nation. But it is only people who can do it.
This morning, I read Nag‘s stirring, hilarious “let-me-pump-you-up!” prose:
Yup, you’re right, Susan… now it’s on to the next battle. When the shit hits the fan from 5 different directions, you put on your mental slicker, hose off and learn how to duck. Hopefully, you also learn how to fling a little poo of your own. I’ll live to fling another day, and that makes me realize that life is pretty good.
Then there are the thanks we owe to these Senators for voting against cloture. Let’s all write them today:
Those who voted for filibuster:
Bayh, Ind.; Biden, Del.; Boxer, Calif.; Clinton, N.Y.; Dayton, Minn.; Dodd, Conn.; Durbin, Ill.; Feingold, Wis.; Feinstein, Calif.; Kennedy, Mass.; Kerry, Mass.; Lautenberg, N.J.; Leahy, Vt.; Levin, Mich.; Menendez, N.J.; Mikulski, Md.; Murray, Wash.; Obama, Ill.; Reed, R.I.; Reid, Nev.; Sarbanes, Md.; Schumer, N.Y.; Stabenow, Mich.; Wyden, Ore. And Jim Jeffords, Vermont (thanks to Karen Backman of Democracy for Washington! for e-mailing the list)
And, yes, Alito was just confirmed but only by 58 to 42 … but we have many people ON OUR SIDE who are stirring us with their words today …
A snippet of Digby, who also quotes Kevin Drum’s fine comments:
by digby
So we only got 25 Senators to vote for a filibuster of a Supreme Court
nominee who, if defeated, would be replaced by someone just as bad by a
president in the pocket of his radical right wing. Well.
Do you know how many votes the Republicans managed to get when uber
wingnut Antonin Scalia was confirmed? 98. And Democrats had a majority.
We didn’t have to even think about a filibuster. We couldn’t defeat
Clarence Thomas and we had a majority, a huge push from women’s groups
and a very dramatic set of hearings that went into the wee hours of the
morning. It is very, very tough to do.
<P.
Kevin Drum says:
The lefty blogosphere has spent the last week trying to fire up
support for a filibuster of Samuel Alito. This campaign was never
likely to succeed, and today it failed as expected. But that’s not all:
it failed by the embarrassingly lopsided margin of 72-25.
I’m glad the filibuster took place, because even in failure it puts
a marker down for future court fights. Still, even given the amateurish
way that Senate Dems handled it, I expected it to get more than 25
votes. So here’s today’s assignment: In 5,000 words or less, what does
this say about the influence of the lefty blogosphere?
I didn’t expect it to get more than 25 votes and I’m frankly stunned
that we did as well as we did. Indeed, something very interesting
happened that I haven’t seen in more than a decade.
When it became clear that the vote was going against the filibuster,
Diane Feinstein, a puddle of lukewarm water if there ever was one,
decided to backtrack and play to the base instead of the right wing.
That’s new folks. Given an opportunity to make an easy vote, until now
she and others like her (who are legion) would always default to the
right to prove their “centrist” bonafides. That’s the DLC model. When
you have a free vote always use it to show that you aren’t liberal.
That’s why she was against it originally — a reflexive nod to being
“reasonable.”
Obama had to choke out his support for a filibuster, but he did it. A
calculation was made that he needed to play to the base instead of the
punditocrisy who believe that being “bold” is voting with the
Republicans. Don’t underestimate how much pressure there is to do that,
especially for a guy like Obama who is running for King of the Purple.
The whole presidential club, including Biden joined the chorus.
The last time we had a serious outpouring from the grassroots was the
Iraq War resolution. … read it all
Oh sure. There’s the usual tripe from the Dana Milbanks of the netherworld:
“Tasting Victory, Liberals Instead Have a Food Fight.” Fuck him. Fuck the Washington Post (except E.J. Dionne (he’s on fire (!) about the budget today!) and — bless his heart — Dan Froomkin).
Oh, but surely didn’t this make Alan and Andrea and Cokie and Steve titter over their morning coffee and dry toast this morning?
Right on cue, liberal activists including Cindy Sheehan and Ramsey Clark gathered yesterday at the Busboys & Poets restaurant and bookshop at 14th and V streets NW for what they billed as a forum on “The Impeachment of President George W. Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney.” But the participants, while charging the administration with “crimes against humanity,” a “war of aggression” and even “the supreme international crime,” inevitably turned their wrath on congressional Democrats, whom they regarded as a bunch of wimps. …
Fuck Milbank. Oh, I said that already.
Let’s hear it from the man, Meteor Blades:
For now, I’m laying off the recriminations. Instead, the first thing I’m doing as soon as this is written is to call my two Senators – Boxer and Feinstein – to tell them I appreciated their “No” votes. And I urge others to do so as well. But, more important, I urge others to put their energy into a new fight. Because the Alito nomination is all over but the final vote, and we need to invest the next week into making something useful out of next Monday’s Senate Judiciary Committee’s hearings on “Wartime Executive Power and the NSA’s Surveillance Authority.”
Given what an atrocious job most of the Democrats on the committee did in querying Samuel Alito, particularly bad when it came to follow-up questions, and in framing the issues of concern raised by Alito’s extensive judicial record, it is incumbent upon us to try to ensure that Democrats ask tough questions at these hearings. We need to push the Dems away from playing enabler for what is sure to be Attorney General Gonzales’s efforts to make the hearings nothing more than a forum for the idea that the Administration’s evasion of FISA is being done to protect us from the bad guys. … READ ALL!
He ends with this:
… The war against Big Brotherization is as crucial as that for abolition, for women’s suffrage, for civil rights.
In every case, the warriors in those wars suffered immense setbacks, repeatedly so, and found it hard to get the politicians to speak up and stand up for them. Eventually, however, because they refused to surrender, and because they took the fight beyond the electoral arena, they won.
We will, too.
WE WILL! Or we’ll die trying … we have to. For the sake of future generations. We have to.
I like the WaPo’s William Arkin too…and Froomkin, of course, even though they won’t claim him!
Thanks! I’d gone blank on Froomkin’s name … he’s added NOW! 🙂
I dont know Arkin.
I wish we could get a print version of the WaPo in the hinterlands … I’d love to hold it in my hands to read it instead of on the ‘net.
Does National Security/Foreign Policy. He’s good. Check him out.
I remind myself that we have been through MUCH worse in this country. So, we muster our dignity and grace and thank those that have helped us… But then we target one of those that voted for cloture but no on confirmation – oh, Liberman comes to mind – and target just a LITTLE retribution in his direction – enough to get his attention anyway.
Then we don’t have to waste a lot of energy fighting all the battles, but we still get our point across.
I’ll just lay here and quietly bleed to death within my own chest cavity now!
You’ll do it, MT. You’ve got more fire and fight in you than 10 people.
And — besides — we HAVE TO DO IT for our kids! And their kids! We have to!
I’d never forgive myself if they looked back on us at the beginning of the 21st century and thought we’d done nothing.
gushing into Senator Menendez’s voicemail box, with profuse thanks and promises to work my (sadly considerable) ass off for him in his campaign this fall.
Lock up your daughters, people, the feces is about to hit the whirling blades.Oh yeah,and stock up on BC pills for our new underground RR. SHIT.
Both staffers I spoke to were really nice. At Boxer’s I said, I figured she would do the right thing because she always does, but it’s great that she keeps doing it, and the staffer said, I totally understand. At Feinstein’s, they are very efficient, as I think I’ve mentioned, and always ask for zip codes. This time I said that though I was more progressive than the Senator, she had my support (I’m basing this also on her “no” vote against Gonzales, another bottom-line issue for me), and they wanted my name. Interesting…
Oh, btw, on the humongous John Kerry diary over at Kos, someone put together a chart of how often various Democrats voted “Republican” on a bunch of issues. John Kerry was the only one in his list who voted “Zero.” I’m sure there are others (like Kennedy), but it was still interesting. Down towards the bottom of some 1000 comments, if you feel like scanning it.
Lisa, I don’t think my BABY MAC can open a 1000-comment diary.
(I wish Kerry’s aide had posted a #2 diary.)
If you have any time, could you repost that info here?
Make it a new diary! It deserves to be on the recommended reading list .. even if you just quote the comment / i.e., no original text required.
(Glad about Feinstein … and, you know, I think I need to write to Maria. She really helped me when we were trying to save the life of that woman in Yemen! She even called the State Dept. and made them write me a personal letter that I got via the USPO, and have saved — so astonished I was to get a real, personal letter from the State Dept. Oh dear .. I forgot all about that in my anger yesterday. And she voted NO on Gonzales too — really adding to the floor debate with her great speech on his Enron connections.)
Ok.
That part is over.
Now what can “I” do, from within the circle of this single life, that will make a difference, over time?
For one thing, I can get it through my thick head once and for all, that this democracy no longer works as intended and this mess probably cannot be fixed from the top down.
(Not when the top layers are only accessible to those with enough money to purchase a slot there, who even with money, can’t get there without selling their souls to the company store along the way.) That’s just how it looks to me.
I can wrap my head around the fact that democracy cannot be sustained when it’s elected leaders are corrupted by greed, self interest and special interests. The people cannot elect better leaders when cut off from objective information by a power controlled media, and manipulated election processes. Ethical leaders already elected are hamstrung by majority controlled manipulation of congressional procedures. Again, that’s just how it looks to me.
Then I can decide where to put my available energy. Am I going to spend it continuing to battle it from the top down, expecting one corrupt party to unseat another corrupt party, when every evidence in front of me says that’s not working.(and how much better off would we really if it did?!) Knowing that while I’m spending all my energy doing that, people all around me are paying a price the wealthy and powerful will never acknowlege, much less ever have to pay themselves?
Well, this is one old gal thats done spending all my energy beating what looks to me like a dead horse.
The rest of my time here is going to be spent planting seeds around my own feet, right where I am standing. At the family/friends level by continuing to email news summaries to those who have little time or inclination to keep current. At the neighborhood level by doing the newsletter I leave laying around for people to see. By getting myself more educated and involved in local politics and electing ethical people on the foundational level. By making sure my actions in my own life mirror my own principles, not over consuming,living simply, and refusing to support corporations that exploit human beings like so many disposable widgets.
Far from giving up, this has reenergized me to do my part with even more enthusiasm, from within my own circle of influence, where it has an effect I can actually see.
I leave it to the rest of you to carry on the bigger, more visible battles with this sicko structure, and will continue to cheer you all on. Just remember, and take heart, from knowing there are many many people like me, who are working very hard with you, from down here in the rootbeds.
Democrats who voted YEA for Alito.
Byrd
Conrad
Johnson
Nelson
Who are these people?
(Sen. Byrd, we forgave you big-time, once already.)
Byrd.
I’ll be blunt. He is 88 years old. He needs to go.
But he needs to do it himself … he needs to find a young, strappin’ Democrat in West Virginia and promote him all the way … with Byrd endorsing the candidat (and with Byrd’s ahem control of the media in W. Virginia), he should win.
I wish he had the wisdom to do this. He is too old to run again. It shows when he speaks on the floor. And that he ran scared on Alito leaves me speechless … some people never know when to quit.
Yes, Susan. I had a list of “people who should retire” topped off with the late pope, Queen Elisabeth, etc.
Time for the old Byrd to go sit by the fire, meditate, and make way for the youth. He can still give advice from his rocking chair.
may not be what we want right now, but I think Belafonte’s list of victories was more instructive than he may have intended. All were achieved by electoral politics only when violence or the threat of revolutionary disorder put the fear of loss into the ruling class. Same goes for the other greatest US achievements, starting with the American Revolution. The Civil Rights Act, the New Deal, the Great Society, the rise of labor unions, the end of the Vietnam War — these are just a few of the needed correctives that came to be only because the power of the corporate/military state was threatened by popular disaffection and disobedience.
It’s time to think seriously about whether simply focusing on getting a Democrat majority is worth anything at all.